Ok, @saraminia, here ya go. I did NOT include any of his covers (including all the Tillerson album songs). I also didn't include People Hold On, because honestly I haven't listened to it nearly as much as his albums and I think that's unfair ;) I'm fairly confident about my top 10, as I've thought that over on more than one occasion. I also feel good about my bottom 10 or so. The middle? A bit muddled. Honestly, it might depend on the day or my mood where they rank and how much I want to give them a listen. I usually don't skip those though.

Anyone else want to play? Or have opinions about my list lol?

Another game of mental gymnastics that I like to do is this: If you could only listen to one of his albums for the rest of your life and couldn't listen to the other two, what would you choose? It's so hard for me because my top 10 are a solid mix of all three albums!

Anyway, here's my list:

Hold On (I know this is not a popular opinion, but I've attached this song to something personal in my life and I think it will forever be my #1)

Apollo

Mostly to Yourself

Rivers Underground

Statue’s in the Stone

Left Behind

Runaway

Jacob’s Dream

Underwater

 American Roads

Heroes and Ghosts

 Road Again

 Honesty 

 Everything’s Fine

 False Alarms

Tiff Song

 Never Gonna Get My Love

 Neverending December

 I Guess I’ll Just Lie Here

 Another Fuckin’ Condo

 Still Don’t Know

 Got You

 I Miss Writing Songs

 Everyday

 Hate this Town

 Villain

 Angels and Demons

 Michigan

 Minneapolis

I grabbed a signed SFABC too. Looks like they sold out right after that as well. Good for him.