pairing: jennifer check!sephira street x fem!needy lesnicki!reader
cw: no smut, this is based on jennifers body, reader is referred to as Needy, brief mention of stabbing, ithink thats all.
a/n: baby's 2nd fic... is this good idk..oo i dont rewlly like this. this for @puppygirlchessa cuz we r needifer
sephira street, or sephi to you, was perfect, everyone knew this. she was perfect and popular and adored. her hair was smooth and straight and shiny and her teeth were white and perfect. she was everything. which is why when people saw the two of you standing beside each other in the halls, they did a double take nearly everytime without fail.
you were.... well, the opposite of that. you weren't popular or perfect or adored. it didn't make sense to anyone why you two would be as close as you were, but that didn't matter. it made sense to the two of you, you guys had been bestfriends since childhood. one day you two just became friends and never stopped. everyone thought sephi must be doing some kind of charity being friends with you, that she didn't actually like you. which wasn't the case at all, sephi adored you, more than you knew. sandbox love never dies.
but as of late.... things had been so so so incredibly weird between you and sephi. ever since this bar burnt down in your town and sephi left with low shoulder, boys have been going missing, no one knew who or what was doing this, police had no leads. and sephi had been acting weird, like not just sephi-weird, genuinely odd. she'd always been a little resentful towards your boyfriend, Nate, but now it was weird... almost hostile?
tonight, she was supposed to be doing something with Hollis, this emo kid from school, you knew him, you two were chill. that's honestly the whole reason sephi even agreed to go in the first place. you had been with Nate, but then... things got really weird, not because of anything he did, but you started seeing the creepiest stuff. so you ran out and went home.
the second you clicked your bedroom light on, cautious, you jumped, letting out a blood curdling scream. sephi sat on your bed wearing one of your shirts, laughing at your reaction, getting up to cover your mouth
"needy, shhh. my god, you are so loud, it's just me" she finally took her hand off your mouth, snickering, clearly unfazed by the horror on your face.
"what the fuck!? you can't just come in here when I'm not home and- is that my shirt?" you furrowed your brows, whispering-yelling at the brunette, she shrugged, seemingly amused at your reaction, "yeah it's your shirt... we always shade clothes at sleepovers, remember? i didnt think itd be a big deal" she stood up on her knees on the bed, moving your hair to one shoulder and twirling it, biting her lip as she looked at you.she ran her thumb over your bottom lip, slowly leaning in, pressing her lips against yours.
you reciprocated the kiss briefly, until you shoved her away, "what the hell is happening!?" you screamed, and sephi laughed at you again, "calm down, needy... what's up with you?" sephi stared at you, she said this as if you were the weird one, as if you'd been acting weird for so long, as if you showed up on her bed without warning in the middle of the night in one of her shirts,
"what's up with me? sephi, what's up with you? you've been acting weird for weeks and it's starting to creep me out." sephi narrowed her eyes at your words but ultimately softened, sitting cross-legged on your bed and patting the spot next to her for you to sit. reluctantly, you obeyed, sitting down beside her,
"what do you want from me?" you asked, glancing over at her"nothing, i just wanna explain some things to you. besides, we're best friends, we aren't supposed to keep secrets" she cleared her throat, hopefully preparing to explain what's been going on with her lately,
"so... on the night of the fire, i got super messed up. and those guys in that band, they're so evil. they're technically like cult members but with guyliner." she paused briefly, as if trying to recall the events,
"what did-" you started but she cut you off, "im not done, they drove me out to the falls. and like, i couldn't find a way to escape because it's super dark out there. and they kept talking about some ritual and sacrifices and the moon... it was really scary. and.. the lead singer kept stabbing me and stabbing me and they were singing this song while they did it.." she trailed off, taking in your teary eyes,
"they killed you."
sephi shook her head, smiling "im still here, right? they did go all benihana on me with that knife, and it should've killed me but.... it didn't"
you furrowed your eyebrows, staring at her, then you shook your head once, "maybe it did" sephi ignored your response, but something changed in her expression "anyway, i dont remember much of anything after that. all i know is that i woke up and found my way back to you.." she whispered, a small smile on her face
you nodded, "i remember"
"i didn't wanna hurt you, but i was just so hungry. uh- i ran into that foreign exchange student and as soon as i saw him, i knew exactly what id been craving... and ever since i just knew what i had to do to stay strong, to stay me, to stay full."
that last part made you pause, something twisted in your gut, "sephi... what do you mean when you're full?" she didn't answer you, which only confirmed your suspicions
you angrily stood up, pointing at your bedroom door, "leave, get out" you looked at her, the girl sitting on your bed may have looked like your best friend, but she wasn't acting like it.
"needy, let me stay the night, c'mon. we can play boyfriend and girlfriend like we used too." she looked at you for a minute until she realized you were serious, and with that she got off your bed, pulling her pants on, the ones she discarded before you even got there and started to climb out of your window, muttering a "see you at school" and then she was just gone, like that.
it was as if she had never been there
















