I had a thought recently, while listening to the birds in the park outside. Birds can make many, many different kinds of noises and calls, even mimic other sounds around them. Do we know how they do that, anatomically? And would it be possible to find fossil hints wether dinosaurs had a similar range of calls?
you have questions and i have answers!
Iâm going to be focusing on passerines, or songbirds, since they have the most well known and well developed calls and songs of Aves. also the most likely to be heard in the park!
>>>Do we know how they do that, anatomically?
yes, we do! i could go super in depth, but iâll stick to being relatively simple for now: basically, birds have a bony structure called the syrinx at the bottom of their trachea. the syrinx interacts with membranes around it as the bird forces air through. birds can control the pitch and volume depending on the exhalation force/tension on the membranes. a cool thing about bird vocalization is some birds can control each side of the trachea independently, forming 2 different sounds at the same time. (X)
>>>And would it be possible to find fossil hints wether dinosaurs had a similar range of calls?
well, sort of. syrinxes donât fossilize, but structures (like airsacs) around the syrinx do have some fossil evidence (like in Aerosteon and Buitreraptor), so theyâre possible in extinct dinosaurs! syrinxes allow for pretty complex noises, but in general theyâre more of a recent development for dinosaurs, found only in certain groups of birds. so the likelihood of non-avian dinosaurs having  syrinxes, and thus being able to make complex duo-tones and songs, is low.
however, birds also have a larynx, which other archosauromorphs, mammals, and other animals have, so you could say theyre âmore primitiveâ than syrinxes - more animals share them, more evidence for common ancestry. animals with larynxes are all typically very loud, and since extinct dinosaurs most likely had them, it can be assumed theyâd be pretty loud animals too.Â
what kind of sounds they made, we canât be super sure. (animals like hadrosaurs, including Parasaurolophus could have used their crests to make almost trumpetlike noises, like wind instruments, but theyâre the less birdlike dinosaurs). and of course, some birds arenât that advanced in their sounds, so they couldâve made sounds like non-avian dinosaurs did as well. turkey vultures donât have syrinxes, and they make weird hiss-growl sounds, so non-avian dinosaurs couldâve sounded something like that.
here are a few good resources relating to this!Â
if any paleoblogs/animal blogs want to add to this, feel free!
@spinosaurus-the-fisher @a-dinosaur-a-day @fezraptor @biologizeable @whoever else i didnt tag