Of Whistling Piece and a Letter
I find it really confusing and amusing that some people deem romance as high import and significant in validating a character. Iāve read some posts about the lack of S-Supports and romance, the invalidation of a certain main character (Shez) in the castsā stories and lives because they didnāt achieve anything romantic with anyone, and, of course, the comparison of two main characters (the current and previous one) regarding their access in S-Supports. Does romance really matter that much? Does it have to happen just to evaluate and validate a characterās story and development in the plot? Does it help speak more about the charactersā relationship towards one another? I have thought of these questions after playing almost 200 hours on Three Hopes, and to my growing contentment, it came to me that Three Hopes did a spectacular job as a Fire Emblem game in explicitly showing the earnest relationship that Shez developed and harbored with everyone without any semblance of romance. And if they did, it seemed pretty vague at best; almost an implication and up for interpretation and debate.
Because, really, one of the problems that I see with the Fire Emblem fandom is its fixation and stickler for romance and S-Supports that it undervalued the game and the charactersā underlying issues and stories as a whole. So focused with its romantic notion they completely missed the point. This is, of course, my opinion, because who am I to negate what people enjoyed? Even I love seeing the charactersā blooming relationship and how this relationship becomes something more. I just really donāt mind romance that much.
I just sincerely think Three Hopes did wonderfully despite the lack of romance in Shezās side. In fact, I think itās much better that the S-Support option didnāt make it through in the game, notwithstanding the interview of the devs. Shez didnāt need a romantic partner. As much as I can glean from my playthroughs, I did not see them showing any interest in being in a relationship. They see the whole cast as their comradesāfriends that they didnāt have before but now they do. They care for their friends and would go to such extremities and lengths just to keep them safe, but they would also not hesitate to keep them in their toes. And this friendship is deep, almost spiritual, bordering much more than the planes of just being plain friends. Almost like Studio-Ghibli friendships/relationships (at least, for me that is). The Merc Whistle and the letter in the finale proved that.
Donāt get me wrong though. I love an S-Support (I did hope prior the released date). I want to see the growing relationship of each character and how they inspire each other in becoming better (the romance is just a bonus for me), but after playing this game for a while, it just came to me that I donāt need an S-Support. The Merc Whistle and the letter in the end is good enough to represent Shezās sincere and unique friendship with the sender of the letter, and that is more than enough for me. The Merc Whistle feature, in particular, is even unique because it symbolizes a deep bond, a mutual understanding beyond human comprehension, a whistling piece and a part of Shez that they willingly gave to the person they (you, a player) found a friend in, someone they knew they could trust in the depths of this world. When you think about it this way, it could also serve as an S-Support, just not in the instant-romance-kind-of-way. And that's what I love in this game, because it gives us more space and leisure and liberty on how we want to proceed with Shez's relationship with the character we have chosen. It's all on usāon our interpretation whether they remained as steadfast friends or something moreāand I say that's a pretty big win. (Although I may be speaking for this in behalf of my demisexuality lol)
But I digress, of course everyone would not agree with me in this, and thatās fine! I just think that Three Hopes did really well as a Fire Emblem game that doesnāt need a romantic option just to explicitly show the earnest relationship that Shez (and the casts) developed and harbored with everyone. Shez is a wonderfully written character who has a different personality, story, flaws, and identity. They are their own separate person, and they donāt need romance for some validation to be declared as a character.