#polyam!ghostface x reader

You’re in the kitchen, occasionally stirring the big pot of macaroni on the stove. Stu comes up behind you, wrapping his long arms and lean frame around you. He nips at your neck, leaving tiny kisses as you giggle and try to escape him. "Not now, babe."

You can hear Stu whining in return. "C'mon, dinner can wait a bit. Haven't seen you all day," he murmurs against your neck.

You hum in return, trying again to push him off. "Dinner will be done in a minute, you think you can wait that long?"

You look at him, and he's giving you the biggest puppy-eyed look you've ever seen. "Fine. We can cuddle up on the couch later, drag Billy into it too- maybe watch some Elm Street?"

Stu excitedly nods, going back to peppering you with kisses and sucking at your neck.

"Fuck off, Stu," you giggle as he finally let's go.

"Aw, you're no fun, Y/n,” he says, dramatically sticking his tongue at you. He slips away to open the fridge, grabbing a beer, and silently offering one for you. You shake your head, giving the macaroni two gentle stirs.

He takes a few sips then sets it down next to the stove. You look up towards him curiously and he gives you a mischievous smirk. He takes you by surprise, gently dragging a finger along your jawline, directing your face up towards his. It had been much longer than you’d care to admit that you’d had a good, proper kiss like this. Between work and classes and the boys’ murder gig. You melt into him, cherishing how nice it feels this close to each other. His lips are soft and warm against your own, and you can taste his beer as he deepens the kiss. 

Your sweet moment with Stu stops mid-way, interrupted by the front door slamming open then shut. Billy tosses his mask to the kitchen counter, landing with an angry slap- blood splattering against the tiled surface. You spot him trying to slip his Ghostface garments over his head, struggling as he makes his way to the bedroom.

"Should someone check on him?" Stu mumbles, feeling nervous.

You sigh, "I've got it, babe. Just keep an eye on the macaroni, it should only be a few minutes longer- and don't burn it like last time, okay?"

He chuckles, "I won't, I won't."

You roll your eyes, feeling unsure and worried about the decision to leave Stu in charge of dinner- but eventually settling on the feeling that it was for the best. Billy needed you.

Usually Billy did the caring- not to say that the rest of the relationship didn’t- but Stu and yourself were far more expressive of your own feelings than he would ever be- he would ever let himself be. He wasn’t much of a talker like Stu- but had an equally calming aura when he needed to be there for his loves. Aside from the physical comfort he’d provide, his attempts for comfort were subtle (unless it involved maiming a new victim…). 

When it came to the few times Billy found himself struck with harsh emotions that he never quite learned how to deal with- it was tricky for Y/n and Stu to help him. It was different every time. Finding the right balance between treating him as normal and stepping into new territory- and depending on what set him off, it could always be easier said than done. 

The bedroom door is left ajar, and you carefully move it further open- wincing as it makes a painful creak. Billy doesn’t seem to mind much- or hear it- as you find him sitting stock still on the bed, hunched into himself. His ghostface robes clutched in his grasp, dried blood packed into his nails and caking his hand- in parts they still shine as if freshly drained from his victim, 

You let out a sigh, eyeing him carefully. His knife is placed hazardously on a towel next to him- if he moved the wrong way it could knick his skin. You move across the room, and tentatively entering Billy’s space you grab the knife- the handle is sticky and wet. You set it on the ground, not caring about whether it stained the carpet or not. You could deal with it later- all that mattered was making sure he was okay, that he was safe. 

"Here," you motion towards the pile of clothes in Billy's hands. His eyes appear glossy as he clings onto them harder. You sit down next to him, putting a cautious hand on his back and the other smoothes down his hair. "Is this alright?"

He shrugs.

You sigh, "Can I take these? I'll put them in the laundry room, I'll wash them after dinner."

His grip on them loosens, and you get up, plucking them from his grasp. You press a gentle kiss to his forehead, scurrying off to do as you had promised. You clean your hands off, before grabbing Billy some fresh clothes from the dryer that had yet to be put away yet.

When you come back, he's dutifully wiping the blood off his knife. You smile at him, leaning against the doorframe, "I'm gonna go check on Stu and dinner, you need anything?"

Billy stares up at you, smiling- it's something devilish but sincere. "Come here."

You raise an eyebrow at him, but do as told. Billy sets his knife down on the floor, slowly slipping his arms around your waist and pulling you down into his lap. He gives a contented sigh, nuzzling his head into the crook of your neck.  

“You two just can’t keep your hands off me, can you?”

You can hear him murmuring something, but it’s muffled by him being pressed so close to you. 

Usually when Billy was sad or overwhelmed and didn’t know what to do, he’d push those close to him away. There was a comfort in being alone- feeling like you deserved it, that this was how things were meant to be. It was rare that Billy accepted your care without a fight- so graciously, so calm. You begin to gently rub your fingertips in soothing patterns against his hands.

Every once in a while subtly asking him if it was alright, and receiving nothing more than a few mumbled words and grunts.

Stu shows up a while later, poking his head in the doorway. “It’s done.”

You glance at him, “You drain the water out before you put the packet in?”

He looks away.

Your face falls in mock anger, voice stern as you call to him-“Stu?”

He lets out a big laugh, grinning at you, “Yes, I did.”

You roll your eyes, presenting him with an exasperated look but gentle smile. “Why don’t you bring it in here, not sure if he’ll let go of me yet.”

“Totally!”

He comes back a moment later, setting the bowls of warm macaroni on the nightstand. You give a smile of appreciation towards him, and he takes that as his invitation to join the two of you. He lays down long ways on the bed, close enough to pull his arms around the cuddled mess of his lovers. He rests his head nudged against Billy’s backside. A bit of an awkward position? Maybe, but then again- that was Stu for you.

After a moment of allowing the quiet to overtake the room, you can’t help but laugh at the way the three of you had situated yourselves. You twist in Billy’s grasp, and he hesitantly moves his head upright. “Hey, Billy,” you whisper, “Mind letting go of me for a minute?”

The only response you get is him nudging you back to your position, and hiding his face in your neck again. He holds on tighter. 

“C’mon, we’re gonna cuddle up with Stu. You’re gonna be more comfortable, babe.”

His grip tightens uncomfortably. 

“Billy.” Your voice seems to startle him, and he lets go. His arms fall limply against his side.  You sigh, gently removing yourself from him- his head seems to almost hang in shame as you part. 

Stu moves himself up, so he’s sitting behind Billy.  

Your voice comes out soft, as you try to assure him that “It’s okay.” You offer your hand out to guide Billy to a more comfortable spot on the bed. The three of you find yourselves laying down with Billy situated safely in the middle. Stu’s behind him, arms wrapped around his torso, hands tucked gently around his waist. You’re in front of him, giving him a gentle smile and very softly petting you hand against his head. He yearns to lean into your touch, but he doesn’t deserve it. He doesn’t deserve this.

Billy feels small and angry, trying to shy away from Stu’s hold by slowly curling into himself. He’s got his back hunched and his legs awkwardly pulled up towards himself. He’s tired and he hates the two of you seeing him like this- but he knows it will be worse if you and Stu leave. He lets out an awful whine, clutching your shirt in his grasp. He ducks his head, so he’s staring down at your shirt twisting in his bloodied hands. He shouldn’t be doing this, he shouldn’t be doing this. 

You spare a glance towards him, his sudden noise worrying you. You catch the sight of his eyes glossing over again, and him trying to blink away any possible tears. You want so badly to pull him into a hug and tell him it’s okay to cry, to let it out. But you can imagine his reaction to it vividly, him pulling away, an angry look on his face. And letting out some terrible, defensive noise. Him pushing you away for the rest of the night- and perhaps it would spill into the following days. It was safe to say that Billy wasn’t good with most comfort, and definitely not his emotions. You’re still surprised he’s let the two of you coddle him like this for so long.

So you don’t hug him. And you don’t tell him it’s okay. You lean in closer, pressing your forehead close to his. You start your fingers through his hair, you try to be gentle with it, but your fingers keep getting caught in little snarls and dried blood. You move your head to press a small kiss to his forehead, then move back and continue trying to sooth him. 

“I love you, Billy,” you whisper. 

Stu makes a muffled agreement and then, in an attempted whisper, he says almost too loud, “Me too!” He chuckles out an apology, and nuzzles his head into the back of Billy’s neck. Billy doesn’t say anything, but he likes the warmth radiating off of his boyfriend. It feels...safe.

It’s a while before Billy does anything again. His voice is much smaller than usual when he speaks- and it sounds like he’s holding something back. Trying not to let out teary, loud sobs. 

“I don’t want you to go,” he mutters, pulling your shirt tighter in his fists.

“We’re not going anywhere, love.”

Billy holds his eyes tight, finally letting go of your clothes and hiding his face in his hands. So...so ashamed of you seeing him like this. Hearing him try to hold back his crying- it was pathetic. Billy was not supposed to be like this. Not around you, not ever. 

He lets out a pained whine, and a few tears slip out. “I almost lost you and Stu.”

You try not to frown at him, sighing, “Why are you saying that?” And then you’re reminded of his bad mood as soon as he had returned home. “Did something happen when you were out?”

“I handled it,” he grumbles out.

“Handled what?”

“Just- it!” He nearly growls, barking it out harsher than intended to. “Fuck, fuck…” he grumbles to himself. He presses his hands closer and closer, till he has his palms pushed to his eyes and it hurts. He tries so hard not to think about a life on his own. One where their little secret came to light, and he and Stu- and worst of all, you, who hadn’t done anything- would have to suffer the consequences of their wrongdoings. 

“Billy,” your voice cuts through his thoughts. You have one of your hands placed on his own, gently beckoning for him to remove them from his face. It takes a few minutes, but eventually he brings his hands down. He blinks a few times, and then rests his eyes shut again. He lets out a shaky breath. “Whatever happened- you're safe now.”

“Yeah, you’ve got us,” Stu says, giving Billy a gentle squeeze. 

“Yeah,” you smile. “And we’re not going to let anything happen to you, or any of us. We’ve got each other now. Forever and always. Okay, Billy?”

Billy’s not sure what to say. A simple yes would suffice, but he can feel the tears finally begin to trickle down his face- and he doesn’t trust himself to speak. He buries his head in your chest, and pulls you close to him, wrapping his arms around you. Finally allowing himself to relax, and let Stu snuggle closer into him.

Billy and Stu had just come home from a tiring night of killing. Peeling off their ghostface garb, tossing them into a hamper dedicated to bloodied and particularly messy clothes. Stu seems to be nearly bouncing off the walls as excitement boils beneath his skin. While Billy sets their tools on the kitchen counter, their knives- covered in a thick and sticky layer of blood- and the voice changer. Making a mental note that he’d have to clean them up later. He gives a gentle smile to his partner, as Y/n comes running into a big hug with Stu. They bury their head into his chest, nuzzling and rubbing against the soft, fuzzy textures of his sweater.

“Mm, you feel so warm, baby. I missed you.”

Stu chuckles, wrapping his arms around them, “Only gone a couple hours.”

“Too long,” they mumble.

Y/n catches a glimpse of Billy out of the corner of their eye, perking up to get a better look at him. They give a shy grin, then press back, closer, into Stu. They can feel Billy behind them moments later, snaking his thin arms around their waist. He plants a kiss to the top of their head, grinning. “Miss me too, angel?” He whispers into their ear.

They hum, “Of course.”

His grin widens, “Good.” He leans in closer, so he’s resting his head on them. “Think we should move somewhere comfier, darling?”

They let out a small, muffled whine, “Mm, wanna stay right here.”

Stu giggles, his eyes crinkling as a goofy expression finds its way on his face. He begins carding his fingers through Y/n’s hair. “Feeling cozy between us?”

They gently nod.

“Well, too bad, we’re moving.” Before they can process what he’s doing, Billy briefly parts from them and Stu picks them up in his arms. Carrying them bridal style.

They let out a surprised shriek, trying to hold themselves back from laughing (and failing miserably), “Stu!”

“Aaa, Billy, help!” They joke, “Stu’s got me.”

They can see Billy shaking his head beside Stu, as the three of them enter their shared bedroom. Stu gently set them on the bed, quickly finding a cozy spot next to them.They hold onto the front of his sweater, and curl up in his arms. Billy’s quick to lay next to them. A slight curve to his position as he rests his head above Y/n’s, and next to Stu’s. Legs tangled with Stu’s, creating a spot for their angel to nestle in between them.

Stu has both of his partners tucked nicely under his arms. He leaves tiny kisses on them, and nuzzles his head closer to Billy’s, close enough their foreheads touch. They can feel their warm breaths on each other's faces. They share a short kiss, and then shut their eyes. Their breathing slowly falls into a rhythmic pattern- in sync with one another. A muffled murmuring sound startles them from near slumber. The two of them give worried glances to their baby.

“Y/n,” Billy starts out softly. “You okay, baby?”

They let out a low sound, not dissimilar to a purr, as they try to muster the words from their sleep riddled head. “I love you,” they all but whisper out.

lets start off with everyones favorite boys- Billy and Stu :3

I’ve already spoken about this a bit before, but these bitches ADORE spooky rides !!

They’re also both sorta thrill seekers- roller coasters are a must!

They’ve been on the haunted castle ride about a hundred times- minimum. they know where all the twists and turns, surprises and scares are! Billy and Stu love just goofing / joking around with each other, and making fun of other folks' reactions on the ride.

if its ur first time on the ride, they'll probably be a little chiller. at least Billy will. he has a much better sense of when it is or isn't okay to joke (even though he's a twisted little fuck, he wouldn't want to upset his baby <3)

besides....Stu's Stu. what do ya expect from him, really? /j

"Aw, come on," Stu pouts, attempting to give puppy dog eyes to Billy. A fruitless cause, really. Billy hardly ever falls for that. You, on the other hand, are far more likely to be persuaded by it. I mean, how could anyone say no to that face?

You give Billy a gentle tug on the end of his flannel sleeve, and a look- the combination of which you hope gives the feeling of 'give Stu a chance- let him do the one thing he really wants'.

"We do this all the time, Bills."

Billy sends him a pointed look, "Stop using that nickname, Stu."

He giggles in return, "Whatever you say, Bills."

as you can see Stu tends to push at peoples buttons. and boy, does he know it what he's doing :)

yall know the stupidly hard to win games, where all the prizes are little stuffies?

Stu's not very good at them...too impatient. Billy's okay, has won a few times, but his anger usually gets the better of him. The games are frustrating, okay??

you are fantastic at them though!!

you end up winning two tiny stuffies- you give one to Stu. Who proudly shows it off to you and Billy.

And the other you hand to Billy, who turns it over in his hand- as if examining it- and then pockets it in his flannel. as he pulls the three of you away from the booth, you catch a small smile playing on his face.

you could have kept playing, Stu certainly had the money to allow the three of you too. But you just decided you'd rather spend the rest of the day/night doing something the three of you could enjoy.

....that said...

the time we've all been waiting for!! Billy and Stu spot the Ferris wheel. Stu all but drags the two of you there, an excitement of energy seemingly bursting through him.

Y/n's eyes trail up the large circular ride, nervously gulping. "Are you sure we have to?" He looks back at his boyfriends hopefully.

Billy gives him a side glance and a teasing smile, "What, scared of heights?"

Y/n fidgets with his hands, after a moment huffing out- "No, of course not!"

The three of them stand in line for a while, and as they get on- Y/n settling in between the other two boys- and it starts to move backward, Y/n- who'd been unusually quiet till now- pipes up. "Okay, I might've been lying."

Billy raises his brow at him.

He lets out a shaky breath, "This is kind of scary."

Stu runs his hands through Y/n's hair, beginning to play with it, twirling it in his fingers. Rising his eyebrows, he shoots a mischievous look to his other boyfriend. "Whaddaya think, Bills?"

Billy reaches over and harshly nudges him in the side with his elbow. Only a few grumbled words come from Stu, then he continues, "Think we should let them off?"

Billy grins in return, "You know, I think we'll just have to stay right here. You're our brave, brave boy, right? I think you can make it through this.

Y/n's eyes widen. "Fuck off," he mutters. "I'm serious guys, this is freaking me out."

Stu stops playing with his hair.

Billy frowns, holding Y/n's head in his hand and pulling his boyfriend closer to him. He presses a gentle, protective kiss on the top of his head. He smooths his hand down his hair, and loosely wraps it around his boy's arm. Y/n can feel himself slowly gravitating towards him, as he finally rests his body into Billy's.

Stu stays quiet, giving his boyfriends sad apologetic puppy eyes. He leans into Y/n, leaving a soft kiss on his cheek. One arm is lazily brought around Y/n, connecting his hand to Billy's. The other one drifts to his scared boyfriend's lap, resting it against his leg- allowing him to fidget with his sleeve. He always knew it helped calm him down.

As the three of them reach the bottom, Y/n lets out a shaky sigh, "Thank you."

He doesn't catch it, but Billy and Stu share a fond smile with each other. Proud of their baby boy for getting through it and making a silent note not to do this with him again.