#pll thought

1. Shower Harvey

Why the hell was Sara Harvey even involved in this whole story? Why was she red coat and why was she black widow?  Why did she even help that person in the dollhouse?  What was her motive? Why did she die?  WHAT IS WITH HER STORY?? We’re lacking Marlene. 

2. Noel Kahn

What is up with Noel? Why was he even in the Dollhouse and what was his motive? Why did he want to harm the liars?

3. Bethany Young

Why was Bethany involved in this story and why did she end up in Alison’s grave? Why was she there that night Alison “died”? And WHY THE HELL was she wearing that yellow shirt?

4. NAT Club

What was the NAT clubs motive? Yes, they taped people for fun and stuff but how was Garret involved in this story? Why did he die? Why did Ian die? Marlene once said he committed suicide but that doesn’t make sense to me. 

(s05e03 screenshot, this girl silhouttes looks a lot like alison’s... i know the screenshot doesn’t show but if you can rewatch this scene... do it! it’s the last seconds from the episode)

(s05e06 screenshot, ali’s silhoette)

(S05E12 SCREENSHOT MONA’S “KILLER”)

You might be wondering if Bethany is alive, who’s dead/on the grave?

THE ANSWER STANDS FOR ALISON’S TWIN!

Marlene said Spencer's story with Mary is taken from the books 

In the books Spencer felt different from her family, thought she was adopted and went looking for her biological mother. The woman she found made her believe she was her ‘real mother’ and tricked her into investing the Hastings’ money and made off with it. Later it turned out she was a surrogate, not in fact her biological mother. 

If they’re taking this storyline straight from the books, Mary isn’t Spencer’s ‘real mother’, just the surrogate Veronica and Peter used (it might even been Jessica who was supposed to be the surrogate but Mary pretended to be Jessica?)

It could explain why AD has been so focused on Spencer. Maybe AD is another child of Mary’s and they are obsessed with the ‘sibling’ who had it all, the perfect family, the perfect grades, and she is tied to Alison who has also been a main target from the start.