#pcask

Hi there from the wild west! I’m so glad that you enjoy this, or whatever is left of it.

In terms of our original ambition as a youtube project I’m sad to say the answer is no. I don’t think people realize how absolutely unwieldy projects like this are with a wide cast of characters, technical difficulties, a lack of a strong vision/core group of writers and artists, etc. The sad truth of the matter is it’s difficult to find the required number of people who are willing and able to stick through a project like that to the end and then do it all over again, and again, and again. It was still hard in 2009 for us in IAMP at what I feel was the fandom’s peak and I don’t have any interest in reviving the project in that form. On top of school and work and the pandemic, it could be as crushing as it could be liberating for some. Even here when I propose having little art and writing challenges I get little to no response, so I’m mostly content to just sit back and share the work you guys choose to share with me when you’re ready to do so.

However, I’m used to sitting in the centre of this network and saying hello to new fans of IAMP and whatever the heck we had going on here and I’m happy to continue reblogging your fanworks featuring ctcsherry’s characters so we can find each other. I’m cool with talking about my own perspectives and avenues for stories to get those creative juices flowing and occasionally i even draw Serious Comics, I’m just not interested in holding anyone to a schedule or doing the heavy administrative labour involved with the old projects. I still occasionally post my own headcanons and stuff (and once in a blue moon i do VA stuff for my original roles lol) on my main blog @allbeendonebefore​ and you guys are welcome to hit me up any time to reminisce or send me your weird memes :)

stay groovy and give’r bud

Like I said in response to plans for Canada Day, I can barely think a day in advance let alone a month. Please assume for the duration of this pandemic that I have absolutely no plans for this blog other than reblogging what I see pop up in the tag and to answer general project related questions unless I say otherwise.

I mean this with affection, but running this project was exhausting enough while I was in school. With current events both globally and personally, it is still exhausting. I don't even have plans for Myself for Halloween other than to look at the moon.

Hi there,

Saskatchewan never received a full canon name in the course of IAMP, only an affirmation that there would be a reference to Tommy or Douglas as his first or last name. All other names were fanon and Williams was just a placeholder.

During Project Canada, Owen was a popular fanon name that was accepted as his first name. While I don't know where Carswell came from and have never heard that used for him in either project, I do know that there was some debate in ProCan about Colwell (not sure where it came from either) vs. Douglas. I believe we did finally make his name Owen Douglas in the end, but I would have to dig up screencaps from the now defunct forum via the Wayback machine.

Personally, I preferred Douglas because we had already decided there would be a reference back in IAMP. My collaborators from Sask during ProCan also liked Gabriel as a first name, so I had typically thought of him as Gabriel Douglas.

I'm sorry if this is rather unhelpful; in short, Saskatchewan is one of the characters who never received an official name from Sherry and all names are fanon for now even though we had made a commitment to a Tommy Douglas reference in IAMP. You're welcome to choose the combination you like best for your own purposes.

(contd ask) So is it wrong for someone to assume Seams gender as

male/female/non-binary since it is never stated?? I am confused.

Aw, I’m flattered you thought to go to me first! I admit I haven’t been as involved in Deltarune-centric discussions as some other blogs, but I’ve heard some talk about this topic.

@everyone-needs-a-hoopoe was one of the first people I saw noticing that Seam doesn’t use any pronouns in canon. As they point out in their post, when Seam is referred to in third person, no pronouns are used.

This post also discusses the Japanese version and points out that Seam uses a first-person pronoun (atashi / あたし (translation)) which has historically been associated with men and with women. While Toby is notorious for avoiding making concrete statements about his characters’ genders, taking this into account alongside the English version‘s avoidance of using any pronouns for Seam, I think that for the time being, it’s reasonable to assume that is an intentional choice on Toby’s part and could very well be taken as a sign of Seam being nonbinary. Especially when you consider that a lot of nonbinary people don’t use pronouns in English and other languages. (apologies for the wikipedia link, it’s the best I could find on short notice outside people’s personal blogs)

So to answer your question, while the only official source we currently have is chapter 1 of Deltarune, if you want to stay true to canon it would be nice to try to refer to Seam as has been shown so far (example on how to skip using pronouns for someone). Plus, it can act as a vector for practicing how to refer to real nonbinary people who don’t use pronouns, which I think is an excellent side-effect of popular content featuring diverse nonbinary characters! :)

As for correcting people… This is only my personal opinion on the subject, but I think that depends on you. I can’t tell you to go out and fight people over this, but I do see that you are doing rather well in asking a nonbinary person (albeit one who does use pronouns) about a nonbinary character and considering how you can show the most respect to nonbinary people. So while I can’t tell you what to do, I think we could always use more people like you with open minds and open ears, and if you want to you can feel free to direct any friends you have who are curious about this subject to relevant discussion, and help nonbinary voices reach them! ^^

Oh, yes, of course! Sorry I failed to mention that instance, I remembered it, however…

There are, of course, many instances where the word “you” is used! The reason I didn’t mention Flowey’s speech is because I was focusing on when the narration, that is to say, Chara as the very probably narrator, uses the word. And in the case of Flowey’s speech…

“Chara.”

It does seem he is talking to Chara, if he refers to them by name. Toby could have very well left that part out, ended the speech on “See you later…”, but he didn’t. I think that means something.

I can see the connection between characters talking in “the void”, where Frisk isn’t visible, but there are other such situations where we know Frisk is present!

Sorry I derailed your post, I do agree with the points focusing on Chara! I just thought that there wasn’t enough evidence to account “the Player” into the theory, when there were simpler answers in the game already! You are, of course, entitled to your headcanons, and I love seeing different interpretations of the game! However, I did see your post as aiming for a slightly stronger interpretation of canon, so I felt “the Player” as a theory was slightly unnecessary to it, as it could have worked well without opening that can of worms. ^^;;

I don’t know, I hope my arguments hold water, I don’t like to stretch it too far. I don’t aim to change your mind, just to have a friendly discussion and try to come closer to a possible canon!

Go to sleep, darling!! Sleep is good for you!

ok then [thumbs up]

honestly i’m really… not sure what this has to do with our blog but yeah cool info