#paris hall

Btw this first part was actually written before I fell behind, so DROS was a bit fresher on my mind.

"...I decide to head to the Nightclub to clear my head. Yeah, yeah. It may not make sense on paper, but I don’t want to risk going all emo mode by meditating or whatever instead." The image of emo Ellis is pretty funny lol.

[Aidan FTE 3 Start] Yay!!!

"Ellis: Lightning never strikes the same place twice, but thankfully, I do.

Aidan: Oh. You’re here.

Ellis: Just like in your dreams~" Good to see Ellis is flirting again, probably a good indication his mood has improved a fair bit since CH4 Part 1!

"Aidan: It’s not like I really do much of anything outside of the Resort, either." I kinda figured, but I'm still interested in what the guy actually does.

"Aidan: Uh… wake up, eat breakfast. Go walk, or look around, or drive to nowhere or something. Go see some city or town where nothing ever happens, because nothing actually happens anywhere. At some point there’s lunch and dinner, and… I don’t know. This is what I’m saying. It’s not like I had hobbies, or talked to people or anything." Does he have, like, a job? How does he do all this? What?

"Ellis: But, if you didn’t enjoy it at least a little, and you weren’t forced to do it, why would you do it?

Aidan: I don’t know. It wasn’t nothing, I guess. If you’re going to do nothing by yourself, it’s nice if there’s at least something to look at." What is up with this dude? I mean, we've always kinda known he didn't care about anything, but seeing the full extent of how empty his life seems to be is still kinda depressing.

"Ellis: Y’know, the party life! Or, you could be all artsy and visit landmarks and museums and stuff. You could get a job, if that’s more your speed? Actually, wait, were you not in school or employed before you were thrown into this killing game?

He shrugs.

Aidan: “Taking a gap year” was a good enough excuse for my parents. I didn’t intend on actually going to study anywhere, though." Well, that explains a few things at least. LORE!!!

"Ellis: If you didn’t know what you were gonna do, couldn’t you have spent your time figuring it out? You could search the world for whatever your passion turned out to be.

Aidan: It’s not like I didn’t try. I just… came up empty, I guess." Yeah. Extremely depressing.

"Ellis: That’s… unfortunate. But, hey, you’re the Ultimate Contrarian, right? Couldn’t you do something with that? Like, you could be a lawyer, or a critic, or a director, or something!

Aidan: Maybe, I guess. I’ll… put some thought into it or something." Well, that's something at least! Maybe.

"Why was he thanking me, though? Sure, I gave him a bunch of options, but I don’t think he liked any of them. If a super attractive, cool, and dazzling person came up to you and gave you a pile of trash, you wouldn’t have to thank them for giving you that garbage.

…Does that mean that Aidan is just thanking me for being a super attractive, cool, and dazzling person? That seems unlikely." [FTE End] Yeah, he's probably thanking Ellis for trying, if I had to guess. Given Aidan is starting to see the value in giving a shit about things, seeing Ellis actually give a shit probably helps? Maybe? Yeah Aidan continues to be a little confusing xp

"Harper: Aidan, am I correct in assuming that you and Davis have made up?

Aidan: Uh, yeah, I guess? Why?

Harper: Oh, well, I was just…

Harper rubs ver wrist.

Harper: I was wondering what all you did to mend your relationship. That’s all." Poor Harper has no idea what to do about Noah, as usual. Let's hope ve gets some ideas soon!

"Aidan: I mean, you saw it. I apologized, he apologized for some reason, and that was that. 

Ellis: Truly, you have a destiny as a self-help author.

Aidan: Definitely. Thanks for the tip." Pfft. Sarcastic Aidan's fun.

"Harper: I told him that I don’t mind anything that happened with Kennedy and Paris, but he still feels… distant. I’m not sure he’s forgiven himself for it." Yeah... Especially considering prior baggage between Harper and Noah, this is a pretty complicated situation.

"Aidan: My advice, though? Just talk to him. Say whatever it is you want to say directly without worrying about how he’ll interpret it or what he’ll think afterwards or whatever. If you tell him directly, it’s hard for him to misinterpret." Hey, Ellis might have had something with the self help idea, this is actually surprisingly good advice from Aidan of all people! Then again, for as little experience as he seems to have with actually talking to people, he is a smart and straightforward person, so it probably shouldn't be too surprising.

"I could always use some more bling. And, it’s free! Not that I couldn’t pay for it myself. (Unlike Paris, haha–)" Bro??? I get she's public enemy number one rn, but why is aris catching strays even in internal monologue??? xD

"Nothing murder-y could be happening in the Bar, right? It’s a safe zone!" All due respects, given the alcohol involved, I would actually classify the bar as one of less safe zones, but you do you Ellis :p

"Donning my luckiest look, I peek inside to see what’s going on: Noah, sipping a drink! Nothing murder-y, indeed. Wait, when did he get out of the Cellar?!" Yeah what? Noah's not about to catch any mm or traitor allegations, right?

"He turns to me with a smile. Now that I’m closer, though, I notice his hands are shaking pretty badly. 

Ellis: Uh… how long have you been here?

Noah: Not long. I just got out, like, a few minutes ago…" So probably nothing sinister, but my guy is still looking remarkably awful. Uh, hope this doesn't go too badly?

"And he headed straight to the Bar? On one hand, ayyyyyyyy [...]" Bruh xD

"Ellis: Were you… able to tell who was next in line?

Noah: No. You’re the first person I’ve seen since getting out. Though, they put me in the Cellar early morning rather than, like, now. More… morning announcement-ish." Well, good to get some kind of time frame on when the motive victim switches, and info on whether or not they're made aware of who goes in after them.

"Through further conversation, I get the sense that he isn’t that shaken up about the experience of confinement itself, unless he’s a better liar than I thought." Wait, then what is up with him? Curious...

"Oh. Ohhhhhh.

Man, I guess there would be some drawbacks to doing keggers since you were 10." Is it embarrassing if I had to look up what "doing keggers" meant? I imagine it's well established in this account that I'm a massive nerd, so probably not that bad. However, this is still an interesting and very worrying conclusion Ellis reached, let's see if she's right about it!

"It’d be super hypocritical of me to suddenly be the drink police, but I also don’t want to feed into Noah’s alcoholism. Then again, is a killing game really the best time to go stone cold sober? Even if Noah tried to quit now, there’s a decent possibility that he wouldn’t live long enough to reap the benefits. Then again, that’s the same kind of logic addicts can use to convince themselves not to seek help. My grandfather said the exact same with his blackened lungs when he was on his deathbed." YIKES. Yeah, addictions are rough in general, and killing games have a thing for making rough issues even worse.

"Was the winner of the fourth game placed into the fifth? Could it have been Mark’s friend, the Lucky Student, who eventually gave up her life for his? Did she regret not saving her closest ally in the fourth game?

If Mark and I were the last two left, and they gave up their life for mine, and I was then put into a seventh killing game, and made it to the end… would I do the same?

The other Lucky Student didn’t die without her own interference. Could I really be okay, watching my competitors get steamrolled over, and over, and over again?

Some luck, huh." Wow we're just going down a hell of a spiral, huh? That's a very depressing hypothetical, damn.

"Noah’s rejoined us, but Paris is gone. It could be because she’s decided not to eat with us anymore, but given that everyone else shows up, it seems she’s in the Cellar." Alright, new victim! Man, we're running through these days, huh?

"Harper: If it’s alright, I was hoping we could talk sometime later.

Noah: Talk? About what?

Harper: I just… wanted to check in with you, about the last week or so. It’s been a while." Go Harper! Sanest person in the cast strikes again, actually taking advice and talking through ver issues!

"It almost sounds like a teacher telling a student to stay behind after class… not that that ever happened to me. Eheh." I can't actually tell if Ellis is being sarcastic and this has happened, or if they were actually a somewhat responsible student, given they used to be a very different person than what they are now.

[People Discuss Options] I always love it when people talk about their options in stories :D

"Once again, my genius goes unappreciated. That, or I’m just being wildly unhelpful. How am I meant to figure out which is the truth, again?" The everlasting Ellis question, isn't it?

"Just as I’m starting to run the water and take off my jacket, I hear a knock at the door. I turn the faucet off (no need to waste water) and see who’s outside. It’s Aidan! It’s Aidan?" A fair reaction, especially seeing this is the start of an FTE. Usually the protagonist is the one visiting the person they want to spend the FTE with, no? Is this Aidan!RealProtagonist evidence???

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Putting a divider here because this is where I left off when I dropped off the face of the earth, as I’ve been known to do lol. If my memory of smaller details becomes suddenly horrendous, uh, this is why!

That said, and Aidan FTE is just the kinda thing you love to see when you’re getting back into reading a fangan!

“Aidan enters my room and sits on the couch upside down with his feet in the air, dangling over the back.”

Guy’s such a contrarian he sits the wrong way round, you love to see it x) Also wow new format for my reactions :O

“Ellis: I’d offer you a glass of water, but I can’t imagine it’d be easy to take a sip in that position.”

Pfft-

“Ellis: …“Hey, Ho” sounds wrong. He lets out a short laugh.”

It is a very funny surname lol. Good to see Aidan hasn’t gotten tired of jokes about it by now :p

“Ellis: I don’t do job interviews. I’m too pretty.”

Yeah I’ve missed this.

“…I looked down the road I lived on. That day, it seemed to go on, straight and empty, for ever and ever and ever. I didn’t know where it led, but I knew I was headed there. Until… a certain “stroke of luck” came my way.”

…Poetic. I guess Ellis wanted to leave her old life, which isn’t really news, but this is still pretty flowery imagery. Wonder what’s up with that.

“Ellis: Concrete. Chipping paint. A free cup of coffee from your office job that isn’t totally full ‘cause you got the last cold part of the pot. Mail with a little rust on it from the inside of the mailbox. That’s what I was gonna be doing.”

We are very poetic today, I like it! Yeah this tracks.

“Ellis: …The people I wanted in it were the people who told me that there were achievable things out there. Even though I knew there weren’t.”

Holy lore Batman! Who are we talking about, Ellis?

“Ellis: …I think it’s so nice, it makes me mean. Aidan: Really?  I look down at the floor. Ellis: You saw it in this very conversation. Aidan: In what way?  Ellis: As soon as I started talking about it, you got upset with me. Makes sense, ‘cause I was upset with myself, too.”

Ouchie. It’s an interesting perspective about it, at least.

“Ellis: Who wouldn’t? You get it. You didn’t want to be concrete, either. Aidan: No, I didn’t. And I didn’t have anyone I wanted in my future, or anything I wanted to do, or any plans either. I guess what I mean is… He glances away. Aidan: You don’t have to cover it up with me. I get it.”

Aw, Aidan’s nice :) And kinda awkward about being nice but it’s cool :))

“Man, why do I keep spilling my soul to every spiky-haired, 5’8” nonbinary he/him user who comes my way? Is that my type now?”

Wait let me check something… Alright yeah this is funny.

[FTE End] Funnily enough this felt more like an Ellis FTE than anything, but it was still very cool!

“Davis: Are you [Noah] avoiding Harper? Ve was asking if we’d seen you around a bit ago.”

Yeah, yeah… It’s not going great with those two.

“Noah: Sorry, I just, whatever thing’s going on with you is distracting me… Davis: “Thing”? Noah: Y’know, the whole…  He huffs. Noah: I’m straight, so it’s, like, a weird feeling, y’know? Davis: What do you mean…? Ellis: Wait, are you saying that you’re attracted to Davis?Ohoho, things are getting interesting. Noah: Isn’t everyone? That’s, like, your whole thing, right? Ellis: Robert wasn’t. Noah: …Oh. Haha. Hahaha.”

Okay, blatant topic change aside, meeting the Ultimate Mr-Steal-Your-Girl is possibly the funniest way to figure something like this out lol.

“Noah: Yeah… yeah, it’s… that’s… that’s totally cool. I’m fine. Everything’s fine.”

Though, to be fair to the guy, there’s probably better places to figure it out than in the middle of a killing game :p

“Noah: …Dad’s gonna kill me…”

Yeah that was the other thing I was worried about. Uh… well on the bright side this will only be a problem if Noah’s a survivor and his father lived through the Tragedy! … Which is not a very bright bright side, but it’s there.

“Davis reached out to reassure Noah, but he flinches away from him, throwing himself backwards– And over the railing.”

The way my eyebrows escaped the atmosphere. Are we good?!?!

“Upon closer inspection, Noah seems to be out cold on top of a crushed bed of flowers. Unconscious, but, definitely, thankfully, still alive.”

He better fucking be!

“We need to take him to the Infirmary. If only Vivi were still here… she’d know what to do.”

Don’t… fucking remind me about her, I’m still sad :,(

“Harper: What happened? I only heard the yelling, and… Davis: …  Is it really my place to be the one describing this? Still though, I don’t want to leave Harper totally hanging. If nobody says anything, people might start misinterpreting the situation as a murder attempt by Davis, which would not be good. I’m kinda glad Paris isn’t around to see this…”

It’s very awkward, this situation is.

“Ellis: I’m sure you’re, um… aware of some… stereotypes, surrounding frat boys. Noah ran into an… internalized bias due to Davis’ talent that made him act… erratically…?”

That is actually a pretty diplomatic way of putting that, good job Ellis!

“Ellis: Right, like Mr. Near-Resurrection via Stitches is gonna make things worse. Davis: …If they’re both my fault in the first place…”

That's a funny title, and don’t say that Davis you’re making me Sad.

“Ellis: That you’re an absolute benefit to have around, especially given that neither instance was your fault? This killing game is making people loopy. Thus, unless you’re the one who started the killing game, then it’s not your fault that the people around you are doing wack-ass things.”

It is a turbulent day when Ellis Fucking Ortiz is forced to be the voice of reason…

“Davis and I walk out of the Infirmary, and from the looks of it, he wants some space away from everyone, not just Noah. He heads back upstairs, while I, without any other ideas of what to do, continue on my path outside.”

It’s really funny to imagine this whole fiasco as basically a minor pit stop in the oh so grand plan of “going outside” lol.

“It really sucks for him that so many of his deep-seated issues are coming to life in this killing game, of all places. It’s a terrible way to go through any kind of self-improvement journey. And yet, it seems to kinda be forcing that narrative at the same time. What’s up with that?”

Wow wow wow Ellis, calm down with the meta comments or I’m gonna have to call the fourth wall police on you. That said, it seems the habit of Ellis and I saying the same things has stuck, what with the killing game environment comment and all!

“Taylor: Honestly, it’s been… pretty good. It’s kinda nice not having Paris here.”

Damn. Beef’s kinda legendary. Wonder which of the two is dying this chapter (?).

“Jeff: Yeah, it’s pretty nice. I guess it’s new to you, but cutting off people who are weighing you down is a great feeling.”

Yeah, you would say that, wouldn’t you?

“Taylor: It’d be kinda nice, though. To just… leave everything behind and start over. Vanessa: Like, here? Or at home? Taylor: I dunno. It’s just an idea, I haven’t actually thought about it. It just sounds… freeing, I guess.”

Jeff you’re corrupting them.

“Free, other than that you’re always shackled to yourself.”

Ah, there’s the poetics again! Was wondering where they’d gone.

“Taylor: I dunno. I would probably want to finish school first, so that I could have a job and everything, but just having a nice little house somewhere and making tea and reading books would be… nice.”

Nice dream Taylor :D

“Jeff: …If you’re actually, genuinely considering it… you should think about it first. Be sure you don’t want whatever you’re leaving behind. It’s harder to go back than it is to leave.  Oof, definitely sounds like there’s some history there.”

Yeah what? Is that lore I smell?

“Taylor: …For now, I guess I’ll just focus on the here and now. And breaking off from… whatever was going on with me and Paris. But… maybe someday.”

Yeah you know when you say that the death flags you’re waving are a little harder to ignore.

“Noah: Thanks for helping, though, and… making sure I was okay and all that.  Ellis: Hey, no problem. We gotta help each other out when we’re struggling, y’know?”

Nice Ellis :)

“Ellis: …It’s a nice quilt. I point at the blanket. A small smile returns to his face. Noah: Yeah. Harper’s… really amazing like that.  Ellis: I’m glad it wound up coming in handy. That seems like something that’d make ver happy. Noah: Yeah, probably.”

Nice Harper :)

“Noah: I’m surprised ve hasn’t given up on me yet. Well, not surprised, because I know ver. But… ve probably should’ve.  I start to laugh, then I catch myself. Ellis: Sorry. Not funny. It’s just… I’ve heard that kinda sentiment, like, a zillion times this past week.”

It is an oddly recurring sentiment. It’s almost like the narrative is designed to make the main character stop giving up on themselves!

“Ellis: You think you’re weak?Noah: … He won’t meet my eyes.”

Man we are Exploring Noah’s character today! That’s an almost bigger death flags than the ones Taylor was waving!

“Ellis: Although, if you need me to play damsel in distress for you, I wouldn’t be opposed to that arrangement. Wait. Shit. Maybe now is not the best time to joke about Noah theoretically being attracted to me. Ellis: I could, like, fail to do something on purpose, and you could come by and be super strong and save the day! I could, like… use a hose incorrectly? Or, uh… start a grease fire…?”

They’re calling Ellis the Monarch of Backtracking…

“That turned out better than I expected, to be honest! Like, not that I thought Noah was gonna hate crime me or anything, but… I dunno, maybe I’m just afraid of situations where I have to be the bigger person. Emotionally, anyways. Everyone knows I have a huge– Room. When I enter my room, I take a moment to appreciate how big it is.”

AYO?! You can’t just hit me with genuine self-reflection, then go to innuendo a line later! … Who am I kidding this is Ellis we’re talking about, of course he can.

—

What a nice little part we got here! Lots of Noah, lots of Aidan, lots of Ellis of course, what else could you ask for? The Mad Duo being alive again? Haha! Don’t remind me :(

Onto the next one!

Part 4

“Instead, it seems like Paris’ former bestie is the one who’s missing.”

Well, poor Taylor.

“Paris: What did you all say about me?! Ellis: Uh… what do you mean? And when? Paris: I know you were all talking about me while I was gone! Don’t pretend like you didn’t.”

Yo are we good??? I guess this is what being deprived of gossip for a day does to a woman.

“Aidan: If it makes you feel better, none of us really cared that you were gone.”

Bruh.

“Jeff: If you want the answer so much, the only one who even mentioned you was Taylor.  Paris: …Tay?”

Ooh… I’m turning into a Paris kinnie I wanna see this drama.

“Jeff: Fine. They said it was nice without you around.”

Yikes. Just out and say it, huh?

“Paris: …Mhm. Thanks for telling me~”

Oh I do NOT like that squiggly line. I doubt she’s planning murder, because she’d be the prime suspect like immediately, but there’s still other ways Paris could hurt Taylor and I’m Worried.

“Thankfully, I easily find Aidan in the Upper Common Room of all places. Why the hell is he here? Shouldn’t he be on the lower floor, ‘cause he lives– Man. Have I really learned nothing about the Ultimate Contrarian?” [Aidan FTE Start]

Yay final Aidan FTE! Also it’s immensely funny to me that the guy walks up the stairs just to live up to his talent, you gotta love the commitment to the bit.

“Aidan: …The fact that you’re one of the people who’s sometimes up here isn’t so bad either, I guess.”

YOOO! Friendship!!!!

“Aidan: It’s… probably for the best if I learn to be a little less contrary, anyways.”

Ooh, interesting!

“Aidan: I could have a future. The kind most people want. But I just… don’t. Ellis: You don’t want it, you mean? Aidan: I don’t. I don’t want the kind of life a normal, upstanding citizen does. I don’t want what my parents wanted for me. I just… don’t want anything, a lot of the time.”

This explains a couple things. It’s also nice to see how this parallels characters like Davis, who also has something you’d think most people would love with his whole “everyone wants me” schtick yet isn’t too happy about it; and of course Ellis to an extent, which is being explored here. Fun!

“Aidan: My family and the community I grew up in were always… traditional. And they didn’t like anyone or anything that didn’t fall in line with that tradition. So, from very early on, it was always, “make sure you go to church”; “you have to wear your school uniform”; “don’t question what we tell you.” It was awful.”

Ah, classic. Always fun to see one of these “rebels born from stifling environments” characters.

“Ellis: Sounds like it. Even if… No, maybe I should say this part out loud.”

You know for a character who’s always been pretty verbose in her inner monologues, Ellis has been pretty damn cryptic as of late. What did you want to say?!?! Please tell me!!!

“Aidan: I could’ve been “happy,” in whatever traditional sense there is. But I’m not.  Ellis: Yeah, that sucks. I’d say, “at least you’re here now,” but, uh… our current situation isn’t exactly the place in which most people want to be. Aidan: …Is it bad if it’s almost better, in some ways?”

I’d say it’s troubling, yeah. How fucking horrible does your home life have to be to even consider a killing game an improvement in some areas? Poor Aidan :(

“Aidan: It’s… weird. I don’t know why this is happening now, but, being here… For the first time, I sort of… Aidan looks away from me. Aidan: …There are finally some people that I could actually… maybe, want in my future. Assuming I have one, which I shouldn’t.  …Everyone keeps saying that to me.”

They do yeah. Not only do I hope that it’s good for Ellis’ self respect that people actually like them, I’m also very glad Aidan’s saying this in an FTE because otherwise it would be the biggest death flag yet. That aside, yay for character development! Because I assume Aidan is not just talking about Ellis, but also Davis! I… honestly forgot where their relationship was last I left off, maybe I should backtrack and check exactly what they had going on.

“Ellis: You… don’t want me around. People don’t seem to realize it, but… they shouldn’t. I…”

Ellis no… Maybe we can get some character development out of this, hold on.

“Ellis: You deserve a future, Aidan, whichever one you decide to make for yourself. The one where you travel places because you want to see how they live in those parts of the world, and wake up just to see how the sun rises over the horizon on that particular day, and order all the weird, mismatched fashion you could ever want online. I wanted to take that away from you. Just for me. Just ‘cause I wanted all those stupid, materialistic things that you see no meaning in. How could you not hate me…?!”

Aside from Aidan’s fashion choices catching the wildest stray in history, it really seems like the guilt about how Ellis was thinking about the killing game earlier on is finally catching up to him, huh? Crazy.

“A few teardrops roll down his cheeks.”

Holy shit, Aidan’s even more emotionally invested than I thought!

“Ellis: I already made up my mind that I don’t want to win anymore. Still, whenever I do anything related to that realization, people laud me as some hero. I… My entire life was already built on people thinking I’m great because of something I didn’t even do. You saw what that did to me. So, I won’t let that happen again. I’m just trying to be honest, for once.”

Fascinating character detail. Ellis’ past factors into her current sort of imposter syndrome, to the point where she thinks literally everything about her that people genuinely appreciate must be their mistake. I fucking love that so much!

“Aidan: Ellis, I’m not an idiot. It’s not like I thought you were looking out for anyone’s wellbeing before. You’re not some master manipulator.”

This is the funniest counterargument possible. “I was being dishonest - Well you weren’t good at it anyways!” lol

“Aidan: I’m telling you right now, I don’t care. The more you try to convince me otherwise the more sure I’m going to be.”

You really should have seen that one coming, Ellis.

“Ellis: …Fuck you. There’s an argument to be had against that statement, but you know I’m not smart enough to figure out what it is fast enough to respond to you in a timely fashion.”

This is also just great. Ellis you are a fangan protag debating is supposed to be, like, your thing.

“Aidan: You can be a good person or not. I don’t really care. What I do is up to me. And, right now, I’m choosing to spend time with you. So… deal with it, or something.”

Aidan’s just so damn goated it’s unbelievable.

“Then, we both remember that we were having this very loud and very personal conversation (in which Aidan actually cried, holy shit) in a completely public area.”

Oh yeah all that just happened in the common room xD

“Maybe I still don’t understand exactly who other people think I am. Maybe that’s ‘cause I never really figured it out for myself, beyond an aimless shell or a dazzling whirlwind. If you put them together, you get… I don’t know, a beautiful tropical storm? Hurricane Ellis, landing in a killing game near you. I’ll work on it. I have to, it seems.” [FTE End]

Woohoo! What a fantastic FTE! I loved it very very deeply. It’s probably my favorite from the ones I can remember. And that’s quite the note to leave off on, too! I wonder who the next FTEs are gonna be about…

“When I show up [to the pool], though, Davis and Jeff are already there at the Poolside Bar. Unlike last time, though, they’re both all smiles.”

Oh yeah, these two! I also kinda forgot where their conflict ended up last time, but I seem to recall them making up a bit during the third trial investigation.

“What did I miss? Last time I checked, these two hated each other. I mean, I guess Jeff kinda stood up for Davis in the Class Trial, and Davis told Jeff and I about the nature of his bachelorhood, but… that doesn’t automatically put you at bro status! What gives?!”

Or the trial. Again, fuzzy on the details because I fell into the void.

“Jeff: You want a drink?  I look down at my hands.”

Damn, Ellis took Noah’s alcoholism hard. If I recall correctly, I think I ended up giving Ellis addiction governance in the playlist post and Noah Poison, right? Too late to swap those around? lmao.

“I keep to my word of having only one drink as Davis, Jeff, and I continue our conversation. I can't exactly say that they have a lot in common, but in some ways, it seems like their differences balance each other out. That’s nice.”

It is! This was a surprisingly drama freee check-in with these guys!

“In the Buffet, I wind up with an odd crew: Paris, Vanessa, and Aidan.”

That is odd. I don’t think I remember Vanessa talking to Aidan outside of investigations and trials, though I’m probably forgetting something. {Hindsight: How the hell did I forget the entire Gun situation. Point kinda stands, though}

“Vanessa: Hey, is everything okay…? Aidan: What’re you sulking about? Paris: And why do you care all of a sudden?!”

Okay, so… Paris is doing horrible, as expected.

“Aidan: I’m not doing anything.”

Lmao.

“Paris: I thought Tay and I were friends. For real.”

Interesting perspective there. I seem to remember getting bad vibes from Paris and Taylor’s relationship from the very start, but I always kinda did it under the assumption that Paris didn’t quite see Taylor as an equal, if that makes sense. Like, they were always doing what Paris wanted, I don’t think that’s an entirely unreasonable assumption. But I guess Paris was just sort of entirely oblivious to the issues Taylor was having, and genuinely wanted to be friends and just didn’t know how to do that properly, which does fit what I remember well enough

“Ellis: If you want to win, that’s probably what you have to get used to. Paris: …When I said it, I didn’t mean it. Do you remember? I said Tay and I could find a way to win together. But… I guess somewhere along the way, I started believing it.”

I… really should brush up on what was happening when I left. But, yeah. It’s actually pretty fun that Paris is just now falling for the trap of focusing too much on winning, just as Ellis escapes that same trap. It’s one of those parallels that work so well you almost forget that Ellis and the rest of the cast have different creators lol.

“Aidan: Look, if there’s someone out there that makes you happy or whatever… don’t just give up on them out of nowhere. If you actually care about someone for once, that should matter. If you give up, maybe you didn’t actually care in the first place.”

Wonder who Aidan’s thinking about! (Hint: It starts with D and ends in avis. Probably).

“Paris: But… what do I do? Tay doesn’t like me anymore.  Aidan: I don’t know, talk to them? Apologize? Explain how you’re feeling? Why does everyone keep trying to ask me for advice?!”

Poor Aidan ended up with the reputation of the guy with common sense, and now people actually expect him to be socially competent, a true greek tragedy.

“Paris: …Then… tomorrow, I guess. I’ll… I’ll find a way to make Tay like me again. Somehow…”

Woohoo! You know, I think they could actually be good friends if Paris gets her shit together. I just hope we can all ignore that this feels like yet another death flag for Taylor and possibly Paris. I do think we’ve got enough time until the next murder for them to talk regardless, so I doubt it is. Hopefully.

“Still, Paris’ plans to do something “tomorrow” ring a little hollow. It’s not that I don’t think she’d actually do it– beats me as to whether Paris really wants to make a change or is just trying to lull us into a false sense of security– it’s that I’m really unsure about what tomorrow will bring.”

See it’s funny you say that because I very explicitly said I didn’t want to read that comment as a death flag, and now you’re making me worried.

“Taylor got imprisoned twice in a row, huh? That’s rough.”

…Motherfucker.

“Paris: …They haven’t been responding to my messages for a little while. I thought they just didn’t want to talk to me, but… Oh damn. I kinda forgot that you even could message the people trapped in the Cellar.”

That pretty massive oversight aside, I think we all know why Taylor’s not responding. The death flags… they were real.

“We all get to the bottom before any of us spot it: a body, charred beyond recognition. Is that… Taylor…?  Ding, Dong, Bing, Bong!”

God fucking damn it. You know, I joke about death flags so often I didn’t actually think those ones would come into play, but alas, I was foolish. Taylor no!!!! Also, charred? Yikes! Never something you love to see. I mean, actually I do tend to enjoy fire related mysteries, but I feel like Taylor would get mad at me for saying that lmao.

Anyways, this is sad. I liked Taylor a lot, and now they’re gone :( Lets try to quell the sadness with some mystery solving!

““The victim is Paris Hall. She died of poison in the Cellar last night at 2 AM.””

Never mind, first I panic. My heart fucking leapt out of my chest when I saw the wrong victim, then I remembered the file always has a lie, then I saw the poison and I’m going insane. I guess the first assumption is that the poison and time of death are true and the victim is false (given the location is trivially true), but the missing person does happen to be the Ultimate Impressionist, so I have to wonder…

“Paris?: What the hell is this?!”

I do like the question mark after her (their?) name, it’s fun.

[Investigation Start] Woohoo! I’m back in the building again!!!

-

You know, this is usually where I do the prediction game think, but, uh… I don’t think I can. Because I don’t actually know who the victim is. Again, my first assumption is that the victim name has to be the lie, because while Taylor disguising themselves as Paris sounds possible, in practice the switcheroo would get resolved, like, immediately at the start of the next part. Still, while the possibility of a disguise is on the table, I’m not gonna get ahead of myself. Let’s go straight into investigation!

Part 5

Weee! Investigation time! Let’s see what’s up with the victim thing!

“With Taylor’s talent, it’s totally plausible that they could be putting on the performance of their life as Paris right now. I have no idea how I’m supposed to prove who’s who.”

I mean, I feel like even with Taylor’s talent this can’t be that hard. Hair dye is probably an option, but there’s surely other differences in their bodies that would get noticed, right? There’s no way they look identical from the face down, right? And I have to check the handbook to see if the height matches. There are a lot of ways to prove this, is my point. Still, I guess we’ll keep that mystery going for a while.

Checked. Taylor’s height matches Paris’, but no one else’s.

“The body is burned. That’s all I can tell.”

Yep. Worries me that an immediate reason to do this would be hiding the identity of the corpse. Maybe Paris is the killer and is hoping people think she’s Taylor disguised as Paris? Or, I guess any killer could try to make people think Taylor is disguised as someone else. Because Taylor being the killer disguised as Paris would feel too obvious.

“Vanessa picks up the e-Handbook from the body and turns it on. Vanessa: It’s Taylor’s.”

See, I don’t like that this is how we’re doing it, because this is the one identity verification method which can most easily be faked. At least we can make sure “Paris” sent the messages they said they sent (I still don’t know what to do with the pronouns lol). Though, speaking of good fortune, it does feel a little odd that the entire body burnt but the handbook is functional. I don’t fully remember the handbook specifics, though, maybe they’re fireproof or something.

While we’re here, if Taylor is currently disguised as Paris, they may have been disguised like that for an entire day, which would mean that the whole Paris conversation about seeing Taylor as a friend wasn’t actually Paris. Part of what makes me think Taylor really is dead, and that the evidence they may be alive was planted by the killer specifically to make people doubt that fact.

“Ellis: Well, you’re not allowed to steal e-Handbooks, right? So that must mean that Paris is actually alive, and that first statement is a lie.”

I… forgot about that rule. Still, I figure taking a dead student’s handbook wouldn’t be a problem, maybe? So Taylor could be disguised and just put their own handbook next to the corpse, carrying the corpse’s handbook out of the cellar. Or Taylor really is the corpse and I should stop worrying about this.

“Vanessa: Well, Paris has been messaging Taylor a ton. They responded two days ago, when Paris was in the Cellar, but not yesterday, when Taylor was in the Cellar. If anything, I’d have guessed it’d be the opposite.”

At least the messages are real. I still wonder about the rules regarding dead students’ handbooks, though.

“Ellis: Well then… maybe the time of death is wrong, and Taylor died way earlier?”

Yeah, the lack of messages on Taylor’s side is strange. This is a clusterfuck lol.

“Vanessa: There’s… another weird thing. Um, I don’t know if you remember this setting exists, but in preferences, you can let other people have access to your room with their e-Handbook.  Ellis: …I did not. Vanessa: Well, it looks like Paris has access to Taylor’s room.”

Surprisingly, that’s one of the things I did remember, because it always felt like it could come up. This is peculiar, though. I need more evidence before I start going crazier than I already am.

“Harper: …I should mention… I did ask Monoquin. Contestants were… theoretically allowed to volunteer, if they wished.”

…Huh. Superficially, this doesn’t seem useful, because you can just walk down here in the night and that’s it. Maybe for setup time? But I have to wonder if it would have been possible for Taylor to impersonate someone and “volunteer” them to go down here. Would Monoquin see through that? Questions, questions…

“The wall suddenly falls backwards, knocking Jeff into a space I can’t see. There’s some noises behind the wall that I can’t tell the origin of; it sounds like movement. Then, a few moments later– Mark: Ow! Mark hits the floor of the Cellar. Ellis: Woah, wife swap. I mean, what?”

I- What? The fuck?

“Mark: I was in the Closet up in the Gym. How’d I get here…?  Ellis: Jeff… stepped on something, I guess? He was pulled into some darkness back there, and then an angel fell from heaven right before my eyes.”

I… Okay. This is a thing now. ???

“Mark: It’s not that I thought there was [a secret door], it’s that if there was one, I thought it’d be in here.  Jeff: And that’s because…? Mark: If you look at the map and think about how the Cellar is laid out and how big it is, the corner basically overlaps with the Closet. Plus, I never understood why this Closet even existed instead of being a rack or something, so I thought it could be relevant.”

Huh. Good reasoning from Mark! They’re so goated.

“The three of us work through figuring out exactly how the secret passage works. Our experiments conclude that the door only works if two roughly human-weighted things swap places. When something is on each location’s pressure plate, the mechanism activates and swaps the two, albeit a bit roughly.”

I- Okay, this is a little insane, but it works. I… don’t know what it means yet. Then again, if there really was nothing else in the cellar, it almost feels like the fire has to have happened somewhere else, so maybe this is a way to transport the body? I have no idea what’s happening here.

“Jeff: Why’s there a swap door in a Resort in the first place? I guess if this was for some kind of underground business, it’s an escape route…? Mark: …Right, yeah, the Resort. I don’t know either.”

I mean, I kinda doubt this was an actual resort ever, but I guess it’s never been confirmed whether this was specifically built for the game or not.

“Ellis: Anything of note? Aidan: Yes, but only because the answer is no. Davis: Meaning, there isn’t anything, even though it feels like there should be. Isn’t there supposed to be poison in this case…?”

That is most curious. People still get told if someone orders something anonymously, from what I remember. But Antonia had already used poison, right? Could someone have gotten hold of that?

“Ellis: Uh… well, poison can come from a lot of places! Maybe somebody repurposed something like cleaning supplies or pool chlorine that you might already be able to find around here.”

This also works, yeah. I imagine we’ll find some evidence indicating that if that’s the case.

“Aidan: Wouldn’t need it anymore. With the Salon and Makeup Store, you could change your appearance without having to order it, right?”

Oh yeah, speaking of disguises, forgot those are open now. Also, completely unrelated, “In Too Deep” is probably a pun on the cellar being underground I take it, but I am slightly worried about it being some kind of reference to “deep cover” (Kotoko reference?!?!- no), given the disguise thing.

“Paris?: Oh, hey Ellis. Welcome to Tay’s room.  Ellis: …Thanks. I take it you’ve been here before? Paris?: Yeah, a bit. Tay and I usually hung out in my room, though, so I honestly haven’t seen it all that much.  Ellis: Did Taylor also have permission to enter your room, then? Paris?: Yeah, of course~ It made it easier to hang out. See?”

Interesting…

“But, no matter how hard I look, it looks like Paris. Am I overthinking this? Does that just mean it really is Paris?”

Yeah I definitely got ahead of myself thinking it’d be easy to tell if this is Taylor or not. I’m leaning on “no”, though.

“However, when I check inside [Paris’ room], nothing seems out of the ordinary. There are only two empty hangers in her closet– one for the jacket and one for the dress, it seems, based on how her other clothes are hung up– but that’s just the copy that “Paris” is wearing. The body was so burnt that it tattered the clothes, so the body was probably wearing Taylor’s clothes at the time it was burnt. That, or something really weird is going on.”

It’s odd…

“Dun, Dun, Dun, Dun!”

Wait already?!?! We don’t even know how the fire was made! Or what the poison was! I can’t even tell who the victim is!

“Really, I was able to retain more from this investigation than I was from any of the past three, because this time, I was paying the most attention. I’m not going to turn a blind eye to these Trials anymore– at the very least, if my luck makes it so I have to win, I want it to be somewhat earned.”

Hell yeah.

“Why commit the crime at 2AM if it is in the Cellar, and nobody is trapped in there?”

I hadn’t even thought about that, but it’s so true. Is it possible it wasn’t in the cellar? I’m losing it.

““Paris” stands behind Paris’ podium– is that something we can use as evidence? Would Monoquin stop Taylor from standing there?”

I mean I’d assume Monoquin would let them, it’d kinda be pointless otherwise.

[Part End] Alright, time to check over the handbook and see if I can get literally any semblance of an idea of what happened, because right now I have absolutely no guesses!

… There’s fucking nothing there. I don’t know how the fire was made. I don’t know where the poison came from, or if there was even poison involved. I can’t tell what part of the file is a lie. I don’t know why Taylor didn’t respond to messages the day they were in the cellar, even though they’d replied to messages the day before.

Still, I guess I have to do a

Murder Theory

So, let’s start with a simple statement. If Taylor is not the victim, they are the killer. That tracks, right? Because if they’re not the victim, they’ve disguised themselves as the actual victim and are hiding within the group right now, which is silly unless they’re the killer. Thus, to know who the victim is, we may need to first ask if it’s possible for Taylor to be the blackened.

And I’m leaning on “no.” Because, to put it bluntly, it would be insane for the Monoquin file to say the victim is Paris if the killer is really Taylor. Their entire plan would revolve around the hope the class believes they’re dead when they’re really alive, so to cast doubt on that would be pointless. There’s some kind of reverse psychology 15D chess argument that Taylor could use this exact reasoning to defend themselves during the trial, but we don’t have Kennedy here, and they’re really the only one who might believe that. For now, we leave it there.

So, Taylor seems like the most likely victim here. Since the victim of the Monoquin file would have to be the lie, then everything else about it is true. Thus, “Taylor was killed by poison last night at 2 AM in the cellar.”

Now, at the risk of sounding like a certain Tetro Pink character, the poison’s gotta be right. Mostly because everything else about this is so absurdly nonsensical that I can’t see how that, of all things, would be the lie. Of course, I have no idea what the poison actually was, but we can go with it for now.

Then there’s the time frame, and this is what actually presents the biggest problem. Already, why Taylor would be in the cellar at 2 AM is a little beyond me, but perhaps the killer knocked them out somehow, dragged them down there, then the poison did the work. But the bigger issue is that Taylor just… wasn’t responding to messages the day before. Could the killer have stolen the handbook? There’s a rule against that, so you’d think it impossible.

So, heres the situation. If it were possible for the killer to stop Taylor from accessing their handbook for the entire time they were locked in the cellar, then I think that’s what happened. The killer somehow knew Paris was sending messages, so they hoped that Taylor’s lack of response would make people doubt the time of death. If the Monoquin file lied about the time of the death, the victim would have to be Paris, so the killer must be Taylor in disguise, killer gets away.

But that’s the thing; it’s an if. I have no idea if the killer would actually be able to do that, since stealing handbooks is against the rule. Maybe you can steal a handbook from a corpse under the argument they’re no longer a “player”, but for that to work, both the victim and the time of death have to be lies, and we’re cooked.

So we need to account for the possibility that the killer can’t directly interfere there. And that’s a gigantic issue, because I have no idea why Taylor wouldn’t answer. Maybe the nature of the messages changed? Paris learnt Taylor badmouthed her that day, so maybe her messages got aggressive and Taylor decided not to answer those. But if that were the case, surely we’d get some details about the messages themselves, right? So that’s a dead end too.

Was Taylor outside the room, disguised as who knows who, and just busy? Insane, though. Surely they’d be able to sneak in some messages in there somewhere.

And now we’ve gone in a circle. Because if there’s no way for the killer to stop the messages, and I can’t think of any reason Taylor wouldn’t answer them, something must have happened the day Taylor was supposedly in the cellar. Was Taylor passed out the entire day???

Of course, there’s the other option. That the murder did happen then, which would mean the victim actually is Paris. So the Paris in the trial is Taylor. Is that possible?

Let me say right now that the clothes aren’t an issue. Taylor could have grabbed the clothes from Paris’ corpse and replaced them with their own before burning everything. That works. Any other problems?

The messages are the damn problem, again. It makes no sense for Taylor to send messages and not answer them. Maybe they needed to leave their own handbook with the corpse in case someone found it before this point, but they could just not send messages from Paris’ under the argument that “she” was mad about what Taylor said the day before.

So Taylor!Victim fails due to the lack of messages on Taylor’s side, and Taylor Killed Paris fails due to the existence of messages on Paris’ side. I could see some insane plays where Taylor is somehow disguised as someone else, but height difference makes me hesitant that that’s the answer. I’m losing it.

Thus, we seem to arrive an impossibility. Taylor’s not the victim, and they don’t seem to be the killer. The only option is that someone else is the killer, Taylor is disguised as Paris for some other reason, and just doesn’t want to admit that because it would make them look really bad.

…But why??? And how does the killer factor into it??? How the fuck would the cast even find the killer??? What the fuck are we doing???

You know what? I accept defeat. I can’t. Venus, you beat me. I have nothing. We have no alibis. I don’t know where the poison came from. I have no idea how the gym thing comes into play. I don’t know why it’d be important for Paris and Taylor to get into each other’s rooms. I don’t even know how the fire started. I can’t even tell who the v i c t i m is. I feel like I could make better guesses seeing what way the trial starts, to see what options get ruled out first, but I can’t right now. So, congrats! I have nothing. Sorry about that!

Let’s just… Let’s just get to the next part, shall we?

Part 6

Trial time!

“Davis: You did lie last Trial. It’s not out of the question for you to lie again. Paris?: Hey babe, if you’re saying I’m lying about being me, then I would be dead! Make up your mind!”

It’s very confusing to talk Paris right now lol. Glad to see the characters are also having issues with that.

“Vanessa: We usually start with the MQ File, right?” [Evidence Select]

… Am I just supposed to pick the file?

[Right Answer: MQ File #4] Yeah lol. I guess it’s immersive that you have to do it even when it’s not really a puzzle lmao.

“Noah: Wait, but if you’re alive, why would it benefit the killer to say you’re dead? Doesn’t it just make the lie, like, super obvious? Jeff: It’d probably imply that she’s the killer. We’d be less likely to want to vote for the “victim.””

This is part of why this one’s so hard to think about. There’s a million ways the cast could take the file, so it’s not abundantly clear why the file would lie about the damn victim.

“Paris?: It could also mean that, shocker, someone is trying to frame both of us! Like, if the only logic you all can come up with for the lie is that either Tay or I is the killer, that’s probably what the actual killer wanted!”

Yeah, this is kinda what I’m leaning on in the end, but it’s still hard to wrap my head around the time of death in that case.

“Davis: I think the takeaway here is that we do need to address who the victim is. That’s one of the most basic case facts, right?  Harper: Yes, that’s… a fair approach. I suppose we’ll be debating this now after all.” [Nonstop Debate]

Save me, Nonstops, save me.

“Paris?: Tay could’ve picked anyone to impersonate!/Aidan: Taylor is the Ultimate Impressionist. Personality wise, they’d be able to pull off being any of us.”

I’m guessing we’re meant to shoot “Taylor’s Profile + Paris’ Profile” for the height thing, but both of these statements are literally the same so it could be either or. Leaning on Paris’ statement from a vibe check more than anything.

[Answer: Taylor’s Profile + Paris’ Profile -> could’ve picked anyone] Hell yeah! Off to a good start! I’m glad I remembered composites lol.

“Paris?: Isn’t it? Genuinely, do you think Tay could fully replicate my face? My charm? Do you really think that they could just become me, just like that? Mark: …We have to account for the possibility. Paris?: …”

She is NOT happy they think that lmao.

“Aidan: It’s a fair point, though. If you assume that Paris or Taylor is the killer, arguing too much one way or the other could be suspicious. It’s probably better for her if we don’t actually know who’s who. Mark: Or, if she is innocent, she might not want to admit that she doesn’t have a way to prove her own identity.Davis: There must be some way to figure it out.” [Nonstop Debate]

It’s not a great situation. Wonder if the clothes are gonna be brought up.

”Harper: It seems that the body showed no indication that the victim was Taylor.”

After reading the whole thing, it seems like it’s actually Taylor’s e-handbook getting shot at this, maybe?

[Answer: Taylor’s e-Handbook -> no indication] Well at least I’m doing better in the trial than in the investigation lol.

“Aidan: Anyways, I don’t think it’s definitive at all.  Harper: Because of the possibility of it being planted? Aidan: Right. All it proves is that Taylor, alive or dead, is fine having their e-Handbook on the body we found. That still leaves the option of Taylor being the true victim or impersonating someone else.”

Very true, but I’d like to talk about “Paris” having Paris’ handbook and the rule about stealing handbooks, because that’s the biggest thing on my mind right now. Does it count as stealing if it’s from a corpse?

“Mark: There must be something we can figure out with this, right?” [Question Completion]

I take it we’re gonna bring up the handbook rule?

Yeah this is pretty clearly “where is Paris’ e-Handbook now?”

[Answer: That] Yippie!

“Harper: Is that enough evidence, then?” [Evidence Select]

I take it we’re gonna choose the rule about handbooks, Regulation #13, yeah?

[Answer: Regulation #13] I never miss. Ignore all the times I’ve missed please.

“Mark: It’s true that when I asked Monoquin before, he said that while a dead student’s e-Handbook could be “borrowed,” it had to be returned before the Trial.”

I… forgot that was a thing that had been asked before! Yep, Paris is Paris, that’s nice.

“Paris?: Exactly what I’ve been saying the entire time!” [Select the Person]

Sorry, what am I selecting? The victim? Then, I guess we’re doing Taylor.

[Answer: Paris] …This one doesn’t count I didn’t know what the question was alright?! Good.

“Paris: Thank you, Ellis. I can’t believe you all doubted me like that for so long.”

Yay, the question mark’s gone!

“Mark: Speaking of Paris’ identity, though, that means that we really should know who the victim is.”

[Select the Person] NOW it’s Taylor, got it. [Answer: Taylor]

“Aidan: …Taylor would have trouble visually and/or vocally impersonating anyone else, and I’m not really sure what the incentive would be to put Paris’ name in the File if you’re trying to pretend someone else is dead. If Taylor’s impersonating anyone, they’d have to be the killer, so it’d make more sense to have the File back up your central lie with a truth.”

Yeah, this makes the most sense. Let’s see what’s up with the messages then.

[Nonstop Debate]

“Vanessa: That means Taylor must’ve been poisoned before being selected for the motive, right?”

It’s maybe a bit bold so early in the trial, but I’d shoot this with Cellar-Closet Swap Door. Because it was possible to go in and out of the cellar during the day, it wouldn’t be impossible for them to have been poisoned afterwards.

[Answer: The Fourth Motive -> must’ve been poisoned before] Okay, so I was right on what to contradict, except the argument was actually that there’s a two hour time frame between Taylor getting released and dying lol.

“Mark: It’s true that Taylor died in the Cellar either way. That means that, if they were poisoned after being released, they must’ve returned to the Cellar after being poisoned. Paris: But, like, why? It’s not like anyone liked being in the Cellar.  Mark: No, definitely not… Vanessa: Then how’d they end up dying there?” [Puzzling Pieces]

This sure is puzzling! It’s one of the weirdest parts of this case. Let’s see if the pieces help!

“Noah: If it was something that’d incapacitate them, the killer could’ve just, like, carried them back into the Cellar, right? Vanessa: But, did the killer even have access to the Cellar?”

Yeah, that’s kinda what I’m thinking. The swap door is probably the play here.

“Aidan: Monoquin wakes you up. Aidan: If you’re too tired to actually get up, though, I don’t know what happens.”

Interesting bit of trivia there, thanks Aidan.

Maybe we could go with Aidan’s idea? “Taylor was too weak from poison to leave the Cellar.” It’s a little janky, and I’m not confident on it, but it could work.

[Answer: Taylor was too weak from poison to leave the Cellar] Why do I doubt myself? I should lean more into my God complex, that feels like a good step for my character arc.

“Paris: But what about the rest of the day? Tay literally could’ve messaged me at any time. There has to have been a time where they realized they were dying before they couldn’t do anything, right?”

Thank you! The messages are driving me insane, we gotta talk about them.

[Nonstop Debate] Woohoo!

“Jeff: It’s also possible that, if they were gonna die either way, they didn’t really care what happened to us. Jeff: If we fail the Trial, it doesn’t matter much for them.”

That’s… a little harsh, Jeff!

“Paris: Besides, given the Customer Service Desk, the poison could be anything!”

I’m not sure if this is the direction we’re supposed to be taking, but you could shoot Customer Service Order List here, since we know the poison didn’t come from there.

[Answer: Customer Service Order List -> the poison could be anything] Man I am on a roll today!

“Aidan: Even if it’s, like, a household cleaner or something, where would they get it? The staff does everything around here.”

We brought up hair dye during the investigation, I’m sure the salon and makeup stores probably have some amount of things that are deadly to ingest.

“Mark: …Unless it’s not something common.”

I wonder. I did bring up someone potentially having gotten hold of Antonia’s poison, but that feels a little out there. Also that one might have been too deadly. I wonder if Taylor had any allergies… is that what Mark is getting at with that question?

“Mark: That’s true, but it doesn’t really matter, as long as the order description doesn’t give away any details on how the poison works. The File tells us it’s poison anyways, right? The killer must’ve had something in mind already for what they’d use to poison Taylor. Something they could get themself, or just by asking the staff. Jeff: And that mystery poison is?” [Hangman’s Gambit]

I actually have no clue.

I accidentally saw the answer, though, and I was right, surprisingly! It was Antonia’s poison! Hell yeah girl, go haunt the narrative!

“Jeff: Antonia’s poison was fast acting, right? Vivi told us, and Cass died from the poison before the stab wound.”

Yeah, that kinda throws a wrench into things. There is, of course, the argument that ingesting it would be less immediately lethal than getting it injected into your bloodstream, but it’s hard to be sure of that without knowing what the poison actually is.

“Jeff: Taylor would’ve had to be poisoned only a short time before they died. Fifteen minutes, maybe? Ten?”

But… it doesn’t seem like that’s the argument we’re going with! So… idk.

“Mark: Between midnight and 8 AM, when no one is in the Cellar for the motive, is the door open? Monoquin: No. It remained locked for the duration of the motive. Should the spotless win, it will remain unlocked for the remainder of the game.”

So I guess we know how the swap door comes into play here.

[Nonstop Debate] Door time! By the way, kind of completely unrelated, but I’m a little worried that Aidan hasn’t been as active in this trial as in others. Surely he’s not the killer, right? It’s been worrying me for a while now.

“Noah: But, until Taylor died, there was no way to get in or out of the Cellar, right?”

Swap door! That’s the bullet I’m shooting, obvs.

“Paris: Though that still doesn’t explain why Tay didn’t respond to my messages…”

Yeah this is still a problem btw.

[Answer: Cellar-Closet Swap Door -> no way to get in or out] Woohoo!

“Noah: Even if there is the swap door, though, does that really help? I mean, I guess it’d give a way for Taylor to get back in, but there should’ve been no one on the Cellar side to trigger it, right?”

Is this implying the killer must be someone who’d been in the cellar? Since it’s locked at night, the only way for them to put something on the cellar side is for them to have been there as a result of the motive. That might be getting us somewhere.

[Progressive Deduction]

1- What is our best lead on how Taylor died in the Cellar? a) They never left the Cellar b) They walked back in after they were poisoned c) They were swapped in through the secret door d) They didn’t

Going with c) here, though it’s interesting the question isn’t framed definitively. “Our best lead” and “the truth” don’t necessarily have to coincide. I think they do here, but still.

2- What would the killer have swapped into the Cellar? a) Themself b) Taylor’s body c) Me d) Nothing

“Me” is very funny, but I assume we’re going with b), Taylor’s body. Admittedly, it’s a weird way to phrase that, because Taylor must have still been alive when they got swapped into the cellar.

…Wait, how? Taylor died in the cellar, but how did their body get burnt? The killer would need to swap themselves in after Taylor to do that, or at least swap in something that could start the fire (even though that would probably leave behind evidence which isn’t there). So… the killer must have actually swapped themselves in. Final answer will be a), though I’m not 100% sure on that one. Maybe if the victim could be Paris, and the location was wrong, but we ruled that out because Paris has her handbook. I’m losing it.

3- What could the killer have swapped out of the Cellar? a) Themself b) Taylor’s body c) The next person selected for the motive d) An object

It’s gotta be d), an object. The next person wasn’t there yet, and both Taylor and the killer have to be in the cellar at the same time for the fire to make any amount of sense, so.

Here’s what I’m thinking. The killer gets put into the cellar as part of the motive, and somehow knows about the swap door. They leave a wine barrel or something on top of the pressure plate before they leave. When Taylor gets sent in, the killer uses the gym plate to get swapped into the cellar, with the understanding that the barrels will land on the pressure plate on the gym. The killer ties up Taylor or something (explaining the lack of messages), then leaves via pressure plate, swapping with the barrels again. Night comes, and Monoquin comes to collect Taylor, but they can’t leave, because they’re tied up, so they get locked in. Killer comes through the swap door again, poisons Taylor, burns the body, leaves. This all presumably to confuse the time of death and location, which would raise doubts about what the lie in the MQ file is, allowing for the possibility that the victim listed is wrong, which would incriminate Taylor.

I did tell you I’d have a better idea when the trial started, right? Still, I could see a lot of this being very wrong. Let’s see.

[Answer: c, b, d] For example, I could get what got swapped wrong. Oops. I still think my theory makes some amount of sense though. Assuming you can reliably get the barrels to stay on the pressure plate after swapping.

“Mark: I don’t think it’s likely that anyone would’ve figured out that that swap door existed unless they were in the Cellar. There’s no indication in the Closet that it’d swap you, and it’d be a pretty big assumption to make.”

I mean, you could know, given your previous killing game involved this cellar, but still.

“Aidan: …The barrels.”

I was right about that, apparently. And Aidan’s being helpful again, yay!

“Harper: I see. You could return the barrel to the Cellar when retrieving the body to burn it.”

I mean, you still have the issue that Taylor died in the cellar. So when we say “Taylor’s body”, we mean “Taylor’s still alive body, but probably very poisoned and thus kind of immobile”. But that still means Taylor was alive in the cellar, and could have crawled away from the pressure plate, making burning the body impossible. I’m losing my mind again, I don’t know what’s happening.

“Paris: By having Monoquin open the door for “investigation?” I guess it’d probably work…”

I… forgot that was an option oops. Yeah, that makes a lot more sense then.

“Davis: If that’s true, then we’re working with a smaller group of possible culprits than before, right?” [Evidence Select]

Fourth Motive, I take it? For the list of people who were in the cellar.

[Answer: The Fourth Motive] Yep. So that’s Aidan, Mark, Noah, Paris and Taylor. Plus Ellis was in the cellar when it first opened, but Aidan can probably confirm she didn’t do anything weird then.

… It kinda feels like it’s down to Paris and Noah, right? Taylor’s the victim; Mark helped discover the swap door, which would’ve been insane to do if he was the killer; and Aidan brought up the barrels and had little motive to leave (outside of FTEs anyways), arguments which by themselves mean little but together they’re strong enough. Interesting.

[Mixed Matches]

Murder Weapon: Poison, specifically the same fast-acting kind Antonia used. (B)

Location of Murder: The Cellar, as accessed through the swap door. (E)

Time of murder: 2 AM, the night between Taylor’s disappearances. (D)

Victim: Taylor, though the Monoquin File claimed it was Paris. (A)

Other Injuries: Burns, from an unknown source. (C)

[Answer: B - E - D - A - C] This might be the easiest trial minigame I’ve ever seen lol. It’s funny.

“Jeff: Sort of like Antonia, right? Even if someone’s around, the Resort’s big enough you can probably avoid them at nighttime. So, it’s really just about where you could manage to burn a body.”

I guess if there’s no fire damage in the cellar, it makes sense for the body to have been burnt in some other place. Hadn’t thought about that.

“Vanessa: Where, then? If everywhere would leave too much of a trace that we didn’t find, where’d it actually happen?” [Hangman’s Gambit]

There’s… no place on the map that matches four letter word + nine letter word, what. Maybe “pool…” something? Sure, let’s go there.

[Answer: Cafe Fireplace] I forgot that existed lol. But yeah, good call. Accirax clearly didn’t forget, that’s a pretty clean Hangman’s!

[Lie Detector]

I… kinda forgot how this one works. Was it always composites?…

“The victim is Paris Hall” -> MQ File Lie + Regulation #13/Taylor’s e-Handbook

“She died of poison” -> MQ File #4 + Customer Service Order List (??? I don’t know what the hell you want from me here)

“in the Cellar” -> State of the Body + The Cellar

“last night at 2 AM” -> MQ File #4 + Absolutely no idea.

Yeah I forgot what this minigame actually wants from me. This is probably very, very wrong.

[Answer: 1 -> MQ File Lie 2 -> State of the Body + Customer Service Order List 3 -> The Cellar + Cellar-Closet Swap Door 4 -> The Fourth Motive + Taylor’s e-Handbook]

You know what we’ll call it close enough!

[Intermission] Woohoo! It’s been a nice trial so far, hasn’t it? Everyone’s been pretty agreeable (probably because Kennedy’s gone :(), there’s been relatively little drama beyond the murder… it’s been chill. Let’s see how little that lasts now that accusations are gonna start going around, shall we?

Part 7

“Paris: I mean, Mark’s totally the most suspicious, right? Mark: I am? Paris: Uh, yeah? Like, think about it.” [Puzzling Pieces]

Wow, that was fast! Let’s see if it holds up.

“Harper: I suppose it’s possible there could be a hidden room on the same floor as the Cellar. Harper: Perhaps that would have a passage that leads outside, or to another place in the Hotel?”

What, like the Grotto? Ha ha, ha ha ha… Yeah no. I don’t remember where exactly it is, but I doubt it’s that.

I’m gonna go with “The killer wouldn’t want us to find the swap door”, because that’s what makes the most sense to me.

[Answer: The killer wouldn’t want us to find the swap door] Woop!

“Aidan: There is… something to the Mark argument, I guess. We haven’t seen them around much lately. Kinda makes you wonder what he’s been up to.”

Aidan, don’t… do this. You’re being silly, and that’s worrying me. Don’t be the killer please.

“Ellis: Mark wouldn’t sacrifice us just to leave. […] Paris: They could have memories that they’ve gotten back. We don’t know.  Ellis: And you got mad at us for throwing you under the bus…”

Man, Ellis is getting defensive, it’s fun to see!

[Nonstop Debate]

I have no idea what to do here. Everything everyone’s saying is true, there’s not really a lot separating the people who went to the cellar. I’m leaning towards someone having an alibi I’m forgetting, but I don’t even know what truth bullet to shoot there. Or maybe it’s wrong that “any of them could’ve had their whole plan figured out before leaving the cellar”, maybe Aidan was missing details due to being first, but I also don’t know how to argue that. Is it possible one of them wouldn’t be able to get the poison? Why though? I might have to take a wild shot here. Uh…

“Aidan: Any of us could’ve gotten Antonia’s poison, too.”

Shoot “state of Paris’ room” here, maybe? The poison wasn’t there, it’s the only thing I can come up with.

[Answer: “known that people are released at midnight” -> “Any of them”] I did forget about these bullets! It’s what I said before, that Aidan would be lacking info because he was first, right?

“Ellis: Actually, it would’ve been a lot harder for one of them to plan the entire crime in advance. Since Aidan was abducted first, he couldn’t’ve known that his imprisonment would end at midnight, or that the Cellar would stay empty until 8 AM the next day. Aidan: That’s… true, I guess.”

Yippie. Also I love how Aidan seems hesitant even about an argument to his own innocence lmao.

“Ellis: [Aidan and Davis] got back to good terms right after, so [Aidan] wouldn’t have wanted to spring the trap now even if that was his original plan. Not to mention how he feels about the rest of us…”

I love how everyone is defending Aidan all of the sudden, and how Ellis’ own defense seems at least partially influenced by the FTEs!

“Vanessa: It’s just Paris and Noah left as potential culprits then, right?”

As I said, yeah.

[Third Party Analysis] Woohoo!

Concession: Paris: “Besides, even if I’ll admit I want to win the killing game, I wasn’t, like, planning to kill about it!” [Closest thing she has] Noah: “I get that I’ve been taking this killing game pretty hard, and that might seem like a reason I’d want to kill.”

Defense: Paris: “So, if anything, they’d probably be more on their guard around me than anyone else.” Noah: “I’ll… start by saying that I don’t think I would’ve been in the headspace to come up with this kind of a murder when I was in the Cellar.”

Attack: Paris: “Noah’s been all prone to freaking out. If someone’s gonna snap and kill out of nowhere, it’s him.” [These are short sentences I’m allowing myself to put two of them here] Noah: “Even if it wasn’t her directly killing someone, she was willing to manipulate someone else into killing last Trial.”

Proposal: Paris: “Going to the Cellar probably totally freaked him out, so he’d be all ready to do something stupid right after he came out.” Noah: “Even if they weren’t as close as before, it’s possible that lingering relationship could’ve helped her get away with the crime somehow.”

Inquire! Paris’ Defense/Noah’s Proposal -> Taylor’s e-Handbook + Paris’ e-Handbook [Putting two options because they’re the same. Either I disagree with Paris saying Taylor would have been on guard, or I agree with Noah saying the relationship could have helped Paris, because they were still talking on their handbooks. Of course, there is the day of radio silence from Taylor which still worries me, but y’know].

[Answer: Basically the same thing for Distill. Inquire! Taylor’s e-Handbook -> Paris’ Defense] Yeah that works!

“Ellis: I don’t think you can say that Taylor was that afraid of you. After all, they never even revoked your ability to enter their room.”

That was the other argument, yeah. Probably a bit more important lol.

“Paris: Fine! Clear his name too! You think I care?! Jeff: …Yes, based on that reaction.”

Pfft-

“Aidan: What we’ve already said is pretty incriminating towards you. It’s not like we’re going to forget about all of it. Speaking of which, going back to the beginning of the Trial, you’re the one who’d benefit the most from us thinking you’re dead through the File’s lie. Paris: Okay, yeah, but if I really was the blackened, I would’ve just, like, pretended you were right!”

I was going to bring that up too, yeah. It’s a bit odd for her not to go with that strategy, though I guess if she got found out, she’d be immediately cooked, so.

“Paris: Oh, and now you’re using that as logic. Not when I say it, but when it’s against me. How thoughtful of you.”

Chat I think Paris’ persecution complex is going stronger by the second. The type of shit that losing your only friend does to you ig.

[Nonstop Debate] Gonna be real, I also have no clue what to do on this one. Maybe I’m missing something obvious, but I’ll go with my first thought. Earlier in the trial, Paris confirmed that she knew Ellis had been in the cellar when it first opened. Paris didn’t name any source. It’s possible, then, that she overheard them talking when they were investigating. And I’ll say that she was in the gym at the time, overheard them through the passage in the closet, and that’s how she figured out the connection. Final answer:

“Jeff: The killer is the one who figured out the switch door.”

Take this statement…

“Paris: Nothing actually links me to the way the crime was carried out, right?”

And shoot this one. I’m not too confident on it, but let’s see.

[Answer: Customer Service Desk + “they could have ordered from the CSD” -> “Nothing actually links me”] Ah, this actually makes more sense, yeah. The killer could’ve ordered poison, unless they needed it delivered in less than 48 hs. Paris would’ve either needed to order before going into the cellar, or risk not getting the poison in time. She’s the only one who would’ve had this problem, so she’s linked. Nice!

“Paris: No! You don’t get to do that! You don’t get to suddenly start feeling sorry for me now, after everything! You don’t get to pretend like you had no way to see what all of this was doing to me! All: … Paris: The Taylor who was my best friend? They’re gone. They don’t exist anymore. And every other suspect in this Trial has someone tripping over themself to defend them. Mark and Ellis, Aidan and Davis, Noah and Harper– all of you have someone! Just because my best friend never actually cared about me, suddenly I’m the bad person? Even though I cared about them…? Aidan: …Are you… actually crying? Paris: I’m a real person too!“

Holy crashout! I always expected Paris to do something evil at some point, but I hadn’t expected to feel so bad about it. Of all reasons for her to snap, huh? And again, it’s kinda fascinating that Paris genuinely viewed Taylor as a friend, even though she was a horrible friend to them. Very fun stuff!

“Paris: I’m a person. And I have wants, and needs, and dreams, and just because none of you see that, that doesn’t mean that I’m the villain you want me to be.”

…. *quietly pushes the Paris!mm theory under the rug.*

Who even is the mm at this point? Harper? I got no fucking idea which of these people could possibly be behind this mess, I’m losing it.

“Aidan: Can you come up with one thing that actually disqualifies her from being the culprit? One piece of evidence that actually points to somebody else? For all we know, this is just another manipulation tactic.”

Bit harsh, but fair.

[Scrum Debate]

Oh yeah, we gotta do one of these!

[Paris is innocent: Paris, Vanessa

Paris is the killer: Ellis, Aidan, Jeff, Davis, Mark, Noah, Harper]

Okay wow, I thought these things were supposed to be somewhat equal? That’s really funny.

“Paris: You’re totally saying that I’m the killer for, like, no _____!” -> Mark/reason.

“Vanessa: Just because Paris isn’t as _____ to the group doesn’t mean she’s the killer!” -> Harper/close.

“Vanessa: Paris and Taylor were _____! It’d be hardest for Paris to kill Taylor out of all of us.” -> Jeff/friends.

“Paris: So what if I _____ last Trial? That was for all of your sakes!” -> Noah/lied.

“Paris: You all only want to vote for me ‘cause you _____ me! It’s not fair!” -> Davis/hate.

[Answer: I got it right :)].

“Ellis: …Look, I don’t want to claim that you’re not a person, ‘cause you are.”

Lmao.

“Paris: Oh, so now you want to listen to me. Aidan: You have ten seconds to start talking or we vote.”

The group is. So done.

[Freestyle Feud] Let’s do it!

“You just want me to be the killer so I won’t mess up your little friend group.”

I’d prefer no one be a killer, but the evidence condemns you.

“What the hell is the reason that I would kill my friend?”

You had a falling out, and the loneliness you couldn’t bear. (?)

“You’re acting like I’m cruel, even though it wasn’t my fault!”

If you’re the blackened, boo, then I’d say that is wrong.

“It’s not my fault if she betrayed me first!”

What the fuck.

Uh… alright I’m freaking out but I have to finish the rhyme:

And it’s a twist, Mx. Long, but now I feel, the only things betraying you are your loose lips! (?)

You’re supposed to shoot a truth bullet at the end, right? Maybe Taylor’s Profile, which states their pronouns as “they/them”?

[BREAK!] Okay apparently you didn’t need a truth bullet, kinda forgot that. Also:

“Ellis: Woah, wait a minute– who’s the “she” in your outburst?”

I love that this doesn’t even rhyme, Ellis is so flabbergasted it threw off their whole flow xD

“Mark: Wait, but… that was impossible. We figured out that she had to be Paris.”

One thing that comes to mind is that Paris could have lent Taylor her handbook, so even if she died afterwards, it wouldn’t be stealing if Taylor still had it on them?

“Paris?: …Oh, yeah, I’m like, totally Tay! Can’t believe it took you all so long to figure out~”

Let’s go Paris Question Mark!!!

“Vanessa: Wait, but if Paris is the victim, then we don’t have a lie in the File, right? Like… that’s kind of part of the reason we believed it too, right? Mark: Let’s… talk it over. We can figure this out.” [Puzzling Pieces]

You know, the lack of messages for a full day before the supposed murder still worries me…

While there’s interesting points being brought up about what the lie in the file could be doing to help Taylor, I’m going with the solution “Paris could’ve given Taylor her e-Handbook willingly”, to address the main question.

[Answer: Paris could’ve given Taylor her e-Handbook willingly] Have I mentioned how much I love Puzzling Pieces, btw? Because I love it a lot.

“Paris?: What, so you could finally vote for me like you want to? Jeff: Guilt tripping’s not going to get you anywhere, considering that whoever you are, you’re definitely the killer.” That’s so funny. “I don’t even know who you want me to feel bad for but I don’t feel bad for you anyway.”

Lmao.

“Ellis: …Is there anything else we can look at? Like, what about the rule where you can volunteer to enter the Cellar? Could that have anything to do with it…?”

I’m wondering if we’re thinking the same thing about Taylor volunteering someone else via impersonation. Don’t fully know what the point would be, though.

“Mark: It’s 50/50 odds no matter who guesses, right…? It might as well be you.  Ellis: But… but, my luck doesn’t work like that. It only helps with picking the right stocks to invest in, and getting lucky poker hands, and…  Vanessa: I, uh… I bet you five dollars you pick the wrong answer?  Ellis: …Five dollars?”

Holy shit we’ve cracked the code. It’s easy! Why didn’t Celeste think of this in DR1?

“Mark: Take a deep breath. It doesn’t have to be right. We can talk about it afterwards, if you want. But, if you had to pick… who would it be?” [Select the Person]

That’s crazy. There’s literally no way to tell what you’re supposed to pick here. I wonder if accirax would have been able to pick either or if there was only one answer. Leaning on on only one answer, but who knows. {After reading the rest, yeah there was definitely a right and a wrong answer lol}. I am gonna go with Taylor, because while I still have many questions, interrogating the Paris idea is sort of a dead end since we’ve already talked about it. At least Taylor as a suspect might give us new ideas, and possibly explain the message issue.

[Answer: Taylor Long] Yep. Also: “Ellis: It’s… you?” The question mark stocks are Rising this trial!

“Taylor?: …” [Closing Argument]

Wow… Taylor Question Mark, long lost sibling of Paris Question Mark! Also, doing a Closing Argument without actually being sure of anything is so funny. Anyways, let’s see if what I’ve gathered makes any sense.

1- The Fourth Motive. Paris got locked in the Cellar two days before the trial.

2- Customer Service Order List. Here’s where it gets iffy. I’m gonna claim Taylor picked up Antonia’s poison by asking the staff for it only after Paris got locked in the cellar. I can’t be sure if that’s right or not.

3- Cellar-Closet Swap Door. After Paris escapes the cellar, Taylor poisons her, and uses the swap door so Paris dies in the cellar.

4- Paris’ Room. There’s a clothes swap here. Taylor puts their own clothes on Paris’ body, and grabs one of Paris’ outfits to disguise as her.

5- State of the Body. The body is burnt.

6- Paris’ e-Handbook. Somehow, Taylor had gotten permission from Paris to use her handbook, and so Taylor uses it to send messages to their own handbook. They had to leave their handbook next to Paris in case someone stumbled onto the corpse (that’s why they couldn’t respond), but also needed to send messages to replicate Paris’ recent behavior. It’d be suspicious if Paris had only sent messages one day, and not the other.

7- MQ File #4. The body is found, the MQ File is distributed.

I feel like there’s several ways to arrange this depending on what info you take of each truth bullet, but oh well.

[Answer: Motive -> Room -> Handbook -> Order List -> Swap Door -> State of Body -> MQ File] Other than the room and the handbook, I got it right. We call close enough!

“Ellis: The case began with the motive, as it usually does. “Usually”... ugh."

Yeah, sorry buddy :(

“Ellis: When the killer was trapped underground– one of five people to find themselves in that scenario– they planned a murder to enact upon their escape.”

You know, I completely forgot the killer had to go to the cellar before learning of the swap door. Uh, oops?

“Davis: Is it… really okay to vote, if we don’t know for sure? Aidan: Are we ever going to know for sure? Mark: …It’s okay. I trust that this is the right answer. So, if everyone’s ready, then… let’s vote.” [Vote]

This is crazy. You know, I’ve seen a cast almost get a vote wrong before- hell, I know a fangan where the cast does in fact get a vote wrong. But I don’t think I’ve ever seen a fangan cast vote before anyone’s actually sure about the killer. Crazy stuff.

“Monoquin: That is correct. I inhale sharply, and tears prick my eyes. I hide my crying eyes behind my arm. Ellis: Thank god… I didn’t… I didn’t kill you all…”

Welp! There’s one for the trauma books! Holy stress! And now Vanessa owes Ellis five dollars, lol.

“Vanessa: But, why? I mean, things were going pretty well… Taylor: Why would I kill Paris? You’re seriously asking me why I would kill Paris?”

I mean. You were also going to kill everyone else in the process. It’s kind of a lot.

“Taylor: I hate her. I hate her perfect fucking face and her stupid flawless pictures and I hate the way “I” was the only one she ever cared about in her entire life, but the “I” she cared about never even existed in the first place! Davis: “You” didn’t exist…? Taylor: “Oh, sorry! That wasn’t really me just there. I’m here to support you, so don’t worry about it!”  Taylor’s “usual” smile fades back to deadpan. Taylor: Not all of it was fake. But it wasn’t “me,” either. It was the person Paris wanted me to be. The person Paris would actually consider a friend, and the person who Paris would learn to care about.”

Holy! There’s some crazy reveals going on here. I guess I should’ve at least wondered if maybe the Ultimate Impressionist was putting on an act for a while :v

“Taylor: I don’t want any of this anymore. The me here, the me with my family, the me at college, the “me” anywhere, isn’t actually who I am. I wanted to get away from everything. To start over. To take the time to figure out who “I” am…  I look at Aidan. He looks back at me, but he doesn’t say anything, either.”

…They’re calling it the greatest timing for an FTE of all time! What are the damn chances it worked out this perfectly with the themes of the chapter? Crazy stuff.

“Taylor: Could I? Paris certainly wouldn’t have allowed it. She’d be all, “Tay, why are you being like that? We were totes besties~!” and you’d probably be weirded out, too. Besides, what kind of a place is a killing game to figure out who you are? Mark: …”

To be fair, Ellis’ inner monologue has kind of agreed with Taylor in the past, but goddamn Ellis’ friends are catching strays in Taylor’s final speech!

“Taylor: But, y’know, if you’re all living in happy friendship land, I won’t be stopping you, apparently. Continue living here forever, if that’s what you’d like. Keep hanging with your besties– those of you who have them, anyways.”

Well. Someone was speaking their true feelings while masquerading as someone else, it seems :p

“Vanessa: …Did you ever care about her? Taylor: Did I? They think. Taylor: …Yeah, I did. But not enough to try.”

Damn. Kind of a crazy thing to admit, but I respect the ability for self-reflection here.

“Ellis: …I guess this is what happens to people who want to win the game. Who give up. Who decide that their escape is more important than everyone else. I’m… not like that. I wasn’t. And I won’t be. I promise.”

Character development!!! *fire emoji* *fire emoji* *fire emoji*.

“Taylor: …I hate the part of me that hates her, too.”

Welp! That’s horribly sad!

“Taylor looks out at the crowd and bows. Taylor: Farewell from me… and her. “Besties stick together ‘til the end~””

Fantastically theater kid of them, it’s peak. And I love the one last weird impersonation of the dead for the road!

“What would your execution include?”

Damn. Taylor boutta get the 9-in-1 special, their own execution and everyone else’s! Though, now that I’m considering this, isn’t it kinda crazy the mastermind is able to arrange an execution based on the players’ vote? Like, there’s no way to account for every single possibility, right? Unless this is a simulation, which I doubt, or the mastermind is supernatural, which I doubt only slightly less. The mm might just be an Analyst like Junko, very certain of what people are gonna pick, but otherwise I don’t know how you pull this off. Or maybe I’m just thinking too hard about it xD

“Would they take away any input from me, then? Chain me down, prevent me from speaking, block my vision? Would they take away everything I had, everything my luck has given me? Let everyone see the truth behind the heart shaped sunglasses? The truth… isn’t as harsh as I feared. Everyone else told me that. But, if I were the killer… everyone would have shown me that truth, instead.

What would your execution include? YOUR ANSWER: Who everyone else thinks I am.”

That’s some pretty interesting philosophizing, especially regarding the truth and all. Still, writing down “who everyone else thinks I am” knowing it’s related to Taylor’s execution specifically is crazy lmao.

“Idk.”

Aidan is just fantastic for this xD

“The floor bucks Taylor backwards, slamming them into a wall. Then, just as fast, another piston fires, and another wall slams into that one with a deafening slam. When it pulls away again, there’s only the bloodstained impression of Taylor’s body left in the wall.”

YIKES. That’s a pretty horrible one, goddamn.

“The room is quiet. Without Paris, our usual chatterbox, it’ll probably never be loud in the same way again.”

Damn. Already missing her, huh?

The usual post-trial conversation with Mark and subsequent monologue are as fantastic as always. Really hitting us in the feels with reminiscing over everyone who was, and no longer is. And also:

“You never know when there might be another miracle around the corner.”

We end on a hopeful note! That’s how you know we’re closer to the end, the protag is getting ready for those hope speeches!

Anyways, thoughts on the trial. Holy damn, it was a rollercoaster. There were enough twists and turns in there that I really could’ve believed anything part way through. And making the seemingly obvious answer, “Taylor in disguise”, the correct one is a very bold move for a chapter 4, but I think it works! There’s so many other seemingly good possibilities that, even though the first possibility discussed turned out to be the right one, it never really felt like we were going in circles. Not in a bad way, anyways. Plus, Taylor's emotional state, revealed through their speeches as Paris and of course at the end, is a great source of drama and makes them a very fascinating character. Peak!

And while Ellis is busy doing that, we have a game to check up on. Finally knowing both the victim and the killer, it’s time to see where we stand!

Anyways, thoughts on the trial. Holy damn, it was a rollercoaster. There were enough twists and turns in there that I really could’ve believed anything part way through. And making the seemingly obvious answer, “Taylor in disguise”, the correct one is a very bold move for a chapter 4, but I think it works! There’s so many other seemingly good possibilities that, even though the first possibility discussed turned out to be the right one, it never really felt like we were going in circles. Not in a bad way, anyways. Peak!

And before we go to the Bonus Scenes, we have a game to check up on! When I left off at the end of CH3, bronze had 14 points, accirax had 16, Jonas had 17, and I had 20. Finally knowing both the victim and the killer, it’s time to see where we stand now!

Starting with Paris, we have what I believe may be a first! Three people guessed the exact same thing: CH3 victim! With the right role, accirax, bronze-ocs and I all get 1 chapter point! Jonas had predicted her as the mastermind (which would have been my guess at literally any point other than the prologue lmao), so that’s 2 chapter points and 2 role points! Welcome to the 21 point club, Jonas :,)

Bronze and I also agreed on Taylor, putting them as a survivor; that’s 2 role points and 2 chapter points. Jonas got the chapter right, but the wrong role, while accirax got the role right, but she predicted a CH2 kill for them, so they both get two points.

Ultimately, the standings are: I’m still in last place with 25 points, though I closed the gap by one point, as Jonas now has 23. Bronze-ocs and accirax keep themselves just under the 20 benchmark with 19 points each, tying for first place! Man, remember when accirax had the most points in CH1? The comeback is generational!

Will I manage to get back in the race? Will Jonas pull away from me? And how will the accirax-bronze tie resolve? See all of that, in the next post!

Anyways, Bonus Scene reactions!

1: Aidan & Davis

Oh hell yeah.

“To state the obvious, it’s dark in here. My eyes have more or less adjusted, but the majority of the light comes from the crack in the trap door.”

Oh, in the Cellar, cool setting!

“It’s not like I’m new to the sensation of sitting around and waiting for the day to be over. It’s like a reminder of what I’ve left behind, right when I realized I didn’t know what the Hell I was doing in the killing game, either.”

Well, I guess at least Aidan isn’t taking it too badly. Still :(

“Davis, then. I guess it’s not that surprising. I did kinda think he would still be mad about earlier, though…”

You’ll have to forgive me for kinda forgetting what that’s referring to, but from what I recall, something about Aidan not caring about certain things enough, or not communicating that he did, anyways.

“Davis: Is there, um… anything else that’s been going on? Aidan: Can we just talk about whatever you came here to talk about already…?”

Lmao. “There’s not any bushes in this cellar you can beat around” huh?

“Davis: I’m just… worried about you, is all. I missed talking to you. But, if you want, I can leave.  Aidan: No, you don’t have to. Ugh, what am I even doing…? How do I talk to someone that I actually… want to…?”

Bruh.

“Davis: …You’re not the first person I’ve had to worry about like this. I guess I’m sort of used to it. But, it feels sort of different now. I actually get to talk to you afterwards.”

… What? Ominous.

“Davis: It’s been seven relationships now, each ending more unfortunately than the last. From moving away to cheating to death, or anything else. I’m used to losing people. I… was scared I’d lose you too.”

Bro??? I guess we kinda knew relationships never work out well for the guy, but I never really thought death was a part of that equation. Poor Davis.

“But, even then, he’s comparing me to previous people he’s dated…?”

Yeah I wonder what that means Aidan, do you have any idea? xD

“Davis: But I was never the one breaking up with them. It was always them, breaking up with me. Even when it was their fault…”

… Even for the death ones? That’s kinda yikes if so.

“Davis: I don’t really blame them for it. This sort of thing happens to me all the time. So, I don’t really think of it as their fault… Aidan: Well, maybe you should!”

Davis no! Aidan get your guy some better self-esteem please!

“I did the same thing, after all. He’s right. It is the same thing. I… took away everyone else’s choice in the matter, to go ahead with whatever I wanted…”

Ooh… self-reflection! Aidan is so mature and smart and that’s very cool of him :)

“Aidan: Yeah. Just… I get how frustrating it is when people don’t let you decide how you want to do things. You deserve better than that.”

Oh, yeah, FTE backstory. You know a ship’s good when the narrative foils go crazy.

“Aidan: Well, I don’t mind talking, if that’s what you want. I wonder if that’d make him smile.”

Aww…

“I guess… maybe I like talking to him, too.”

AWWW!

That was a very cute and fluffy bonus scene, hell yeah! We love ourselves some wholesomeness in our killing games. Here’s to (hopefully) two more chapters of Aidan and Davis being cute with each other! :D

2: Vanessa & Mark

Ooh, a very interesting pairing here! Wonder what they could have to talk about!

“I know that this whole Cellar randomizer thing happens every day, and that it’s probably designed to be a miserable experience for whoever’s inside, but wouldn’t it be a whole lot nicer if it wasn’t…? I already feel kind of bad that I didn’t try to talk to Aidan or anything, especially after he’s been keeping my secret about the gun this long. So, if Ellis already talked to Mark today, maybe I should pay him a visit too!”

Yay Vanessa PoV! And she’s so nice…

“Mark: That… makes enough sense. I definitely don’t mind the company, so…  Yay!”

Vanessa’s inner dialogue sounds like me lmao.

“Vanessa: Well, how’s it been going? Mark: … Uh… did I ask something wrong…?”

Off to a stunning start!

“Vanessa: …Hey, Mark, what do you think is happening in the outside world? Like, beyond the Resort and all that?  Mark: Wouldn’t you know better than me…?”

Yeah you kinda asked the absolute worst person Vanessa lol.

“Mark: I still don’t really remember much about what it was like before, or what happened to it. If your memories are more intact, you’d probably have a better prediction. Vanessa: I guess, but you’re smarter than me. Mark: …Thanks…?”

Bruh. Ness come on have a little more faith in yourself!

“Vanessa: Do you ever wonder… if it’s safer in here? In the killing game? Mark: No.”

Wow, immediate. I guess fair, especially if he doesn’t remember much about the Tragedy, but still.

“Mark: You might be right. I have no idea what the world would be like, out there. All that I know is that the killing game shouldn’t be allowed to exist, because it’s too awful. Even if the outside world is worse, the fact that there are more options makes it easier to change for the better. The way you’d move forward outside… it’d have to be to change it, right? To find safety, to reinvent civilization.”

Wow. Alright? I see you Ultimate Hope. Lmao.

“Vanessa: …You still don’t remember anyone, right? From before all of this. Mark: No. Not in the slightest…”

Alright so we’re lying now. I guess unless Mark takes their previous killing game as part of “all of this,” but I don’t think Vanessa is privy to that information yet lol.

“Vanessa: …I sometimes wonder if my parents are okay, wherever they are.”

:(

“Vanessa: I just know that they’re not really… resourceful? They don’t really problem solve, or take things into their own hands. So, I’m sort of worried about them on their own…”

Alright? that’s… a pretty interesting opinion to have lmao. At least she’s honest about it?

“Mark: …What about your sister?  Vanessa: She’s really capable, so, it’s a lot easier to trust that she’s doing fine, wherever she is…”

That’s nice at least! Vanessa’s sister sounds cool.

“Being apart from her now has to be okay. I can handle myself. This is how I can prove that. I can make it through this killing game on my own…!”

Well, that’s… an interesting motivating factor lol. Works, I guess.

“Vanessa: Do you remember anyone well enough to miss them?  Mark: …”

Ooh… they’re thinking about the previous Lucky Student :o

“Vanessa: I’m sorry if it hurts that you forgot… Mark: …I’ll be okay.”

Aww :(

That was pretty nice! Fun stuff about the Tragedy and Vanessa’s family, though talking to Mark about anything that isn’t strictly killing game related is always gonna be a little awkward. Still, very nice scene!

3: Harper & Noah

Well, you can’t go wrong with this duo!

“How long does it take someone to wake up from a concussion?”

Ooh, and it’s after Noah fell from the railing, fun!

“Noah: I was… freaking out, because of Davis’ whole thing, and I ended up falling from the Promenade. That’s all. I frown. It seems like Davis’ attractiveness forced Noah into some form of self-acknowledgement.”

Just wanted to repeat that this is an immaculate plot point, fantastic way to figure out one’s sexuality lol.

“I’m sorry this is all happening to him, and I know he doesn’t want to acknowledge it, but… I feel as though I can help him. Or, at least, I can try to…”

Go Harper! Good luck!

“Harper: …Is your hesitancy towards self-acceptance related to your father’s beliefs? I’ve always…  My phrasing has really gotten away from me… Harper: …heard less-than-ideal remarks, when I’ve conversed with him.”

Yikes! You know shit’s bad when Harper can’t keep ver wording in check.

“Noah: What has he said to you…? Harper: Nothing I’m not used to.”

Yikes x2

“Harper: It’s not your fault who your parents are. Noah flinches slightly. Right. His mother…”

God, we are just piling on the family problems for the poor guy, huh?

“Harper: I, um… haven’t ever met your mother before, and I hadn’t heard you mention her, either. Is there… a reason why…?  Noah pauses as he processes my words. Then, his eyes begin to tear up, and he tries to stifle a sob.”

Alright, so this one’s gonna get extremely angsty then, awesome.

“I embrace him as he wipes at his eyes. Noah: S-sorry… I… Harper: No need to apologize. I’m here for you.”

At least Harper’s really nice :)

“Noah: My dad… isn’t a very good dad. Our relationship isn’t great, but I have to spend a lot of time with him, ‘cause of frat stuff. He rubs the back of his neck. Noah: And, um… my mom… didn’t want to deal with it anymore. So, one day, she left. Harper: I see. That makes sense. Noah: …She took my sisters with her. Not me, though.”

Well, that’s… sad. The backstory’s very interesting, but geez. Kinda rough for his mom to take the sisters and not him, what the hell?

“…I’m sure Noah asks himself these questions often, too. And, I can only imagine… seeing his mother again, but in the context of the roulette…”

Yeah, yeah… :(

“Harper: I, um… understand the feeling, with my own parents.”

I… well, that’s surprising! We haven’t really heard much about Harper’s backstory, have we?

“Harper: No one becomes as rich as my parents without exploiting others. Even if I’m not directly responsible for it, I’ve always felt guilty for reaping the benefits of their wealth.”

Yeah, that’s what I figured. Do you think Harper’s parents run a vineyard? I still wonder why that’s listed as ver dislike in ver profile.

“Noah: And, you give a lot of money away, anyways… Harper: I do. As much as I can. But, is that because I truly want to help people? Or, is it just because I don’t want to feel that guilt…?”

Ooh, interesting questions… Harper’s one of the characters which has been explored the least, I feel, so it’s nice to get this much insight on ver thoughts!

“Harper: Yeah. I’m really glad I’ve gotten to know you better, Noah. He smiles back. Noah: I’m glad I got to know you better, too.”

Woohoo! Nice talk! Really lovely to get more on these two, since again, I feel like we haven’t gotten much about them in the main series. Onto the final one!

4: Taylor & Paris

And of course, I guess we couldn’t end it off without the Trial’s main characters! The besties turned worsties… I wonder how this one’s gonna play out.

“It feels a little strange as I’m stretching my legs and walking through the Resort again after leaving the Cellar. After all, I’m not going to be here much longer, one way or another.”

Oh damn, are we gonna get a murder PoV as a Bonus Scene? That’d be incredible.

“I guess I don’t know how long it’ll take them to find “my” body, but the whole thing feels like a farewell tour of sorts. Like, look, it’s the Courtyard. Not sure if I’ll ever go back there again.”

Melancholic!

“Paris: OMG, Tay! Are you okay?  She takes a half-step forward like she’s about to hug me, but reconsiders.”

Aww, she’s trying :(

“All I have to do is get back on her good side for one night. That means telling her what she wants to hear– grovelling at her feet, admitting how wrong I was to doubt her. I can manage something like that, at least.”

Damn, killer PoV goes kinda crazy.

“Taylor: I just thought you were upset, since you stopped messaging me since yesterday…”

Oh my god are we finally gonna address what the deal was with this???

“In the moment, I just didn’t want to respond to her. Now, it’s part of my plan. I pick up my e-Handbook, pretending to look at my own chatroom. Taylor: Weird, it’s still not there. Can I have that?”

Holy genius plan! That works so well! Everything makes sense now!!!

“Taylor: Aww, you left my room permissions? I thought you might’ve gotten rid of them… Paris: Of course not. Besties always stick together~ Sure.”

Oof. They’re mad mad. I mean, given they killed the woman, I figure that should be obvious, but still.

“I run out of the room, quickly ducking into my own. I grab some snacks and two drinks from the mini bar, opening Paris’ drink and pouring the poison inside.”

And that’s how the poison was administered. I’m loving this frankly.

“Paris: …I’m really happy to have you back, Tay. Taylor: Really…? It’s surprising. Her tone is earnest, genuine. She doesn’t usually sound like that.”

Oh oh.

“Paris: I’ve never really had an actual friend before. So, you’re really special to me, Tay. What…? Paris: In high school, all of my “friends” were people I hung out with because we were of similar status. We had fun and all that, but we didn’t, like, care about each other. It was all politicking and rumors to stay at the top of the social ladder. Taylor: But, what about before that? Paris: I wasn’t really popular before that. I just sort of… watched everyone else. If people did go out of their way to talk to me, it usually wasn’t good.”

Oh no… we’re getting the entire tragic backstory only now that she’s drank the poison… At least the backstory on Paris is great, but I’m starting to feel sad.

“Why is she saying all of this now? What purpose does it serve her?”

Though I am living for Taylor not buying it even though it’s clearly the truth.

“People don’t really change. She seriously expects me to believe she was a totally different person just a few years ago? Even if her reputation was different, I’m sure she was still the same person deep down.”

Case in point. It’s so weird to hear “real Taylor’s” inner monologue, I don’t think I’d expect the person Taylor pretended to be to say something like this. Cool!

“Paris: Because I think I went too far in the other direction. I got used to being in power, and thinking like I was the only one that mattered. But that isn’t true. I can’t care about no one because I care about you.  Taylor: … No, you don’t. Don’t say stuff like that if you don’t mean it. Paris isn’t the kind of person who’s capable of actually caring about anyone, let alone “me.” Besides, she only thinks she knows who I am. She doesn’t actually know anything.”

Holy angst Batman! Taylor is now in deep denial to avoid feeling awful for what they’ve done, always a fun thing to see.

“Taylor: What is it that you like about me so much, anyways? […] Paris: You’re quiet, but that’s okay. I like that you’re different from me, and different from the people I’m used to. You’re… honestly kind of mean sometimes, but I like that too. I mean, how couldn’t I? It’s the same kind of thing I do. It makes me feel like we really are friends who can just be our authentic selves around each other.  Her voice is getting softer, quieter, as she continues talking. My heartbeat picks up. Why is she getting closer and closer to… what I’m actually like…? The kind of person I want to be, but can’t, because it’s not what anyone else wants?”

Holy shit this is getting devastating. Taylor is so desperate to keep hating Paris and it’s getting harder and harder the more likable Paris gets. Redemption and angst causing arc all in one conversation, Paris on that speedrun mindset.

“Taylor: You’re not telling me you like me because you actually like me. You’re just saying it because it’s what you want to hear about yourself. So, I’m not giving up on anything real. I’m just giving up on you.”

Yeah keep telling yourself that Taylor.

“…A plan well-started. But I don’t have time to dwell on that. I need to move on to the next step. And, once I’m out of here, I never have to think of her again. I look at her again. She really never saw this coming, did she? …Never again.”

Oof.

This was probably my favorite Bonus Scene of all time. I mean, the angst? The explanation of loose threads? The Paris redemption arc? The Taylor denial arc? It’s peak! What else can I say? Delightful writing, delightful pain and suffering, it’s great.

-

And that’s all for CH4! Wew, what a ride! To recap: Noah stumbled out of the closet so hard he fell off a railing, also he may be struggling with alcoholism and both daddy and mommy issues, Aidan started looking forward to the future through his FTEs, Davis improved his relationships and explained why Ultimate Bachelor is not Ultimate Boyfriend, Ellis’ self-esteem hit rock bottom and now she’s confused as to why people actually like her, Jeff accidentally corrupted Taylor with their “fuck this shit I’m out” mindset, Paris and Taylor’s friendship crashed and burned in spectacular fashion, the trial had as many twists and turns as Paris had followers, disguises were made that would put the Ultimate Imposter to shame, Antonia did a bit of recreational narrative haunting with her poison, etc, etc. Eventful!

"Harper: Where’s Noah? Is he okay…?

Monoquin: Mr. Walker is fine." Alright he's not dead we're safe.

"Jeff: It is what it is. ‘Sides, isn’t it kinda unfair to the people who’ve already died if we stop it now?

Vivi: Isn’t it more unfair to give up on them…?

Robert: We’ve gotta come to a conclusion sooner or later, right? Otherwise, the game’s gonna make the decision for us…" The tensions are rising! Cool!

{Holy shit this is the most egregious case of my color coding being screwed I've ever seen xD. Three blue characters in a row??? Pain}

"Paris: But, like, did we ever sign up for the rules in the first place…?" Does this count as anti-mm? I feel like it's just on the border between lining up and not making sense, you know?

"It’s broken by the sound of footsteps as Davis runs out of the Movie Theater." Pour one out for my guy T_T

"Aidan: …Goddamn it.

Aidan runs after him." Is this a rare instance of Aidan... giving a shit?!?! Wild. This has to be a ship at this point yeah?

"Kennedy: Does it really matter [who the corpse is]? Someone’s dead who matters to him. What does it change if we know who?" I'm kinda surprised it's Kennedy of all people who's saying this. Mx. Conspiracy Theorist always struck me as the type to ask all the questions, regardless if the answers are immediately and obviously important or not. Maybe there's some personal reason she wants to protect Davis from speculation on this? Who knows.

"Jeff: Are we sure about Aidan’s theory that there are blanks in there? Not like I can come up with anyone who’d be in there for me, but it’s possible they got creative.

If Jeff’s saying that, then the likely truth is…" Alright! Another case of Ellis and me thinking the exact same thing. If Aidan's theory is completely correct and there aren't any shenanigans like "Cass and Antonia aren't part of the five blanks so there's more people who don't have a loved one to put in danger" or "Mark secretly has a loved one they'll remember when the corpse drops", then Ellis really does have someone!

"Ellis: …Kennedy. Any leads…?" Wow we've really hit rock fucking bottom with this one huh? Also what happened to "I'm just gonna coast off my luck and survive all the way to the end without caring about anyone", Ellis? Are you undergoing character development against your will? xD

In all seriousness, I'm guessing the angle is that Ellis just figured out she's not one of the blanks because of what Jeff said, so she's worried her loved one's gonna die. Even if they're lucky, if no one dies then the wheel will have no chance but to land on Ellis eventually, so. Then again, it's also possible that Ellis is just gradually growing into a more proactive "end the killing game" attitude based on the revelations he had at the end of the first trial. Who knows!

"Kennedy: …Give me the day to think. I’ll figure something out." Well that doesn't sound like a death flag in the slightest! Do we think if Kennedy dies Vivi will try to revive them, fucking up the investigation in the process by destroying evidence? I could see that happening.

"Why are the two people we’re supposed to rely on most the Conspiracy Theorist and the Mad Doctor?" Accept the Mad Duo supremacy!!! Especially because both of them are waving death flags the size of a mountain right now!!!

"Maybe part of me wanted a less vague reaction so that I could make sure Davis wasn’t just pretending, as a mastermind or traitor type. That’s kinda messed up, right?" Wow we are really diving into the Conspiracy Theorist rabbit hole huh? Not that Ellis didn't always have thoughts like this, because she did, but y'know.

[Robert FTE] Let's go!!!

"Robert: It’s sort of comforting to just… have a normal breakfast, even with everything going on.

Ellis: I can see why that’d appeal to you.

Robert: Oh, right. You’re not bothered by all of this, right…?

Ellis: Nope. Not at all." Yeah... this makes sense.

"Barring this whole mess, it’s probably cancer or old age for Robert." Fair observation. Does this mean Robert's safe, because dying in a killing game isn't "normal"? Then again, being in a killing game isn't exactly "normal", Tragedy notwithstanding, and Robert's talent didn't save him from that, so.

"Robert: I think it’s normal to be scared in a situation like this. I mean, here I am, surrounded by talented strangers who are being told to kill me, and there isn’t a way to get out unless I kill one of them…? That’s… terrifying, isn’t it?

Ellis: I… guess?

It’s hard to imagine how terrifying it is for all of these people who are actually going to die. What can I say…?" Well I guess we haven't exactly moved past this mentality yet lol.

"Ellis: If you need someone to hold you through the night, I’m always here." Never lets one go, you know this by now xp

"Robert: Well… what do you do when things normally get weird?

Ellis: Roll with it, baby.

Robert: Okay… I guess I can try…!" Let's go Robert, roll with those punches!!!

"...Robert announces that he’s “got to skedaddle"..." The fact Robert's always saying shit like this is honestly super charming xD

"I head back to my room, too, passing the time alone before hoping to find some others. Alive. Preferably. Although, I guess dead would speed up my exit ticket." This mentality is already twisting in on itself, I think it may not make it past this chapter chat.

"Taylor and Paris spot me as they’re chatting in the Lower Common Room. They’re wearing swimsuits.

Paris: Hey babe! You should, like, totally join us today!

FINALLY! Now this is what I’ve been waiting for." Lmao. I, for one, have also been awaiting Paris-Taylor content, so I'm with you on this one, Ellis. Even if it's for different reasons xD

"...it’s a nice, sunny day." You know, I hadn't thought about it, but the fact the air isn't post-apocalyptic level bad could imply this really isn't too far from the start of the Tragedy, right? Could be a fake sky, maybe. Or the bad air didn't fully spread to the US, or it's actually far after Junko's death and the air's actually cleared, hm... Too many possibilities, I say.

"Taylor: Well, we were going to do a bit of a photo shoot, too, but mostly just relaxing!" So this is the scene of the chapter announcement! I figured it was, but this makes it even clearer. Neat!

"Ellis: I’m sure I’ll enjoy seeing you work on your tan, too.

I raise my eyebrows at her.

Paris: Take as much of a look as you want~" Never lets one go, and Paris sure doesn't mind ;)

"Paris: How’s your day been, babes?

Ellis: Normal.

Taylor: Were you talking with Robert…?" Pfft-! Taylor immediately reaching that conclusion is genuinely hilarious what the hell xD

"Paris: Oh, duh! Did he say anything interesting?" Also Gossip behavior, ya' love to see it.

"Jeff: I’ve just been hanging by the Pool, as usual. It’s nice here; you see anyone who leaves the Hotel, and most people drop by for a quick word.

Paris: Wow, for real? I guess going through the Fountains means people all pass the same places…" This... sounds like a trial point. Maybe not for this trial necessarily, but for some trial in the future maybe.

"Jeff: Damn, you guys have been doing this too? Kinda wild that we never ran into each other out there.

Ellis: I was just thinking the same thing. I know I’d remember your faces around~

Taylor: I guess you all just missed each other…?" The oddity of no one but Noah and Harper knowing each other from before the killing game has been mentioned in the past, I think, so the fact it's coming up again is interesting. Maybe the killing game specifically picked people who'd never run into one another, just missing that Noah and Harper did? Or maybe it really is just coincidence.

"Ellis: You can find me everywhere, except at your guys’ sides, apparently. Worry not, for we can change that.

Taylor: Oh, thanks…

Paris: Now that we know each other, we’ll obviously be besties for life~" You know, maybe I was sketched out for nothing. Paris seems to be a pretty genuine friend for now. I'm not ruling out that she has sinister intentions with Taylor, but I'm more prepared to be proven wrong on that now. This doesn't necessarily have anything to do with this line, btw, this was just a gradual thought that fully materialized at this point :v

"It’ll be kinda hard once you’re all dead, but, maybe we can remain besties in death, too." Yeah that's also what I was thinking lol.

"I really underestimated how much hanging out at the Pool with some cool people– WITHOUT anyone judgily interrupting– would put a pep back in my step. Take that, Davis!

…Man, now I’ve made myself feel like the asshole." Lol. Lmao, even.

"Would Robert and Kennedy’s uniquely individual weird vibes ruin the pool party?

Harper definitely wouldn’t. Harper is chill." xD

"Kennedy: I’m getting closer. I’ll let you all know tomorrow." Kennedy put down the fucking death flag-

"Kennedy: It’s not going to be something we can act on before the next reveal, even if we do figure out the details. So for now, we’re using today as planning and tomorrow as time for action.

Robert: So… there’ll be another death tomorrow, then…?

Kennedy: Seems that way.

Isn’t she… worried?" Yeah, I wonder who their "loved one" would be if they're not really all that desperate to end it that quickly. The fact there is a plan is curious, though, I wonder if she'll live to tell it.

"Kennedy: I’ll do it tonight. By tomorrow, there’ll be a solution." I told you to put down the flag, Kennedy!!!

"Harper: I’m terribly sorry, I wasn’t focused on this conversation… What were you all saying?" Wow, ve is... not doing well. Still worried about Noah, I imagine.

"Harper: Apologies for sounding like a broken record, but… I’m still quite worried about Noah. How long has he been alone in his room now…? Two days?

Ellis: Wait, he hasn’t come out? I thought he was feeling better!

Harper: I’ve seen room service delivered to his room a few times, but no actual activity from him." Yeah... at least he isn't dead yet! ...Unless someone else is ordering room service to his room. Is that possible? Is this something I have to be worried about? I fear.

"Robert: Well… everyone here is really special, right? They’re rich for this, or they’re famous for that, and it seems like nothing can affect them. So, if you’re actually feeling things that are bigger than you’re used to, it could feel… daunting, I guess, to think about trying to explain it. It feels like no one’s gonna understand you.

Kennedy: Noah’s an Ultimate, too. He’s not different.

Robert: Still. There’s a big difference between your talent being a passion, or a career, and your talent just being… you." Interesting points brought up by Robert!

"Kennedy: What, think Noah doesn’t believe he’s good at parties?

Robert: I think that that’s nowhere near as useful in this situation as believing you’re good at theorizing or particularly lucky.

Ellis: Partying is always a useful skill.

Robert: Even when your mom dies?" Dude, Robert's going off this Part, goddamn!

"Normies aren’t supposed to clap back like that!!!" Yeah right?! xD

"Robert: …Aren’t you his friend?

Harper: What?

Ve tilts ver head.

Harper: Of course.

Robert: Then… be there for him, as his friend. As long as he knows you’re still there… he’ll talk to you if he wants to. And if he doesn’t, give him space. That’s all." I'll repeat the sentiment, Robert's been wilding this Part.

"Then again, believing in the power of Kennedy doesn’t really seem that much better [than believing in the power of friendship]." Yeah lmao.

"As I try to fall asleep, I can’t help but think of how Davis is doing. He was at dinner, unlike Noah, even if he was pretty quiet and reserved. Did Aidan say something to him? Did he say anything to Vivi?" Good questions, though at least it's good to know Davis is alive. Noah's still worrying me.

"In my usual seat, I wait for the drama to unfold, Kennedy’s or otherwise.

Before the lights dim, Kennedy seemingly sets out to prove it’ll be the former." Well, they're alive... for now.

"Kennedy: No! It means… the only thing I can think of to give us leverage is if we could make the gamerunners break a rule without breaking one ourselves." Ah, the Kyoko theorem! We know from canon this theory has legs. Why did this idea have to wait until morning, though? Gave me a heart attack for no reason, now that Kennedy's officially lowered the death flag :p

"The visual disappears. The lights raise. Is that… it? Did we get somebody with no loved one today?" Someone dead? Davis, Noah? Grace spoke, so not them. Everyone else should be in the room for the motive to happen. Gotta be Noah, right?

"Monoquin: Rest assured, Mx. Young, you’ve seen all there is for today. Mr. Walker is still alive in his room.

Davis: Then, what does it mean?

Aidan: It means I’m right.

Aidan looks triumphant." False alarm, we're chilling yet. Also I like Aidan feeling proud of the one theory he came up with, lol.

"Monoquin: The roulette wheel today landed on Ms. Hall’s placement." :O My jaw is honestly on the floor. There are extra blanks! I think? If Antonia and Cass don't count as blank, then we can have Ellis, Jeff, Aidan, Mark, Paris as the five blanks. Not gonna lie, though, the idea of Paris being a blank did cross my mind, but there were better candidates so :p

"Paris: …Oh, what a relief! They must’ve realized that I love all my followers equally, so they couldn’t choose just one that would wound me most~

Ellis: Hey, that’s my line!" Yeah they do not know how to bs their way out of this one, huh?

"Paris: …Or, y’know, my bestie Tay is right here with me! It wouldn’t be right to axe another contestant like that, so they must’ve been at a loss of what to do with me. 

Taylor: Really…?

Aidan: That still means you don’t care about anyone back home.

Paris gasps, offended.

Paris: I totally care about everyone back home!" Man she is, uh, struggling here, huh? Bit of a knock on the Paris!MM theory, maybe? But then, this Part was also a knock on Davis!MM (maybe? I guess the fact we don't know who his person is yet could be seen as suspicious), so I'm kinda running out of my top mm candidates :v

Oh yeah by the way this is another point of suspicion on her relationship with Taylor. If she doesn't care about anyone outside, how could she care about Taylor? That might be why she's fumbling trying to come up with reasons for her not to have a person. Idk, kinda sus.

"Paris: You’re both so right. We’ve been letting this whole motive thing get in the way of our routines! We should totally all go eat breakfast like normal and just enjoy the gift that today is! 

Shouldn’t she be, like… happier about this?

…Or sadder?

If there’s really nobody that it would distress her to lose, maybe she has no reason to care in the first place. What does that say about Paris, though? Whether someone came up for me or not, if it were my name that was spun, I feel like I would have a bigger reaction than this." Yeah, even with her kinda throwing a bunch of excuses, I feel they lean more to covering her ass rather than lying to herself to cope. Strange.

"Davis: It’s… sort of nice, to feel like things are a little closer to normal again.

Grace: Oh, yes, definitely normal." I concur with Grace- Davis your person died yesterday what do you mean "closer to normal" what.

"Kennedy: It means that we have to make today count! I’m off to figure out how to end this game. If anyone’s joining in, come now!

Mark: …Yeah, okay.

Kennedy: You’re in, Mark?

Mark: Why not? If it could actually work, it’d easily be worth it.

Kennedy: Then, we’re off!" Theory Trio!!!!

"Would I look sexy playing croquet?

Stupid question, I always look sexy. So, that’s a maybe." Yo why's he so funny for?

"Soon, I wind up by the Villas, where I’m surprised by some noises from inside one of them. Is that… crying?" Oh, oh... this is gonna be depressing chat!

"But, I guess there’s some possibility that somebody found a dead body and is crying all alone in there, and in that case, I should probably check it out to get things moving." Another example of Ellis thinking exactly like me. I was worried about the exact same thing lmao.

"Ellis: HOLY SHIT, IS THAT A GUN???" HUH???????? What do you mean???? Oh my god was Vanessa about to attempt suicide?! Surely not, right?! Was she going to murder someone?! What the fuck is happening?! I'm assuming she got it from the Costumer Service Desk but WHAT THE FUCK?!?!?!

"Vanessa: I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I can’t do it, I can’t do it anyways, please don’t be mad…" Vanessa are we good?!?!

"I hastily pick up the gun, and– aah, how do you put the safety on these things?! I’ve never held a gun before! I hold it behind my back, so that if it does go off somehow, hopefully it won’t hit either of us." Jesus fucking Christ.

"Vanessa: Toni… I thought a lot about what she said. That all you had to do was kill someone… but, but that’s a lot! It’s really scary, and really hard…" Okay, okay. Somehow this feels easier to deal with than a suicide attempt. Not that this is ideal necessarily, but you know. At least she's already regretting having the idea.

"Ellis: Uh, I mean, yeah… I wouldn’t… wanna do that… but you like, actually got a GUN for this?! Don’t you know how suspicious this is gonna be if we actually do have a Class Trial?

Vanessa: I-I…

She turns her face away. 

Vanessa: I wasn’t… thinking about that part…" Oh, Ness...

"Vanessa: Maybe it didn’t matter that much." Nevermind there's the suicidal thoughts.

"Vanessa: …Breakfast this morning was really nice. I wanted to… to protect it… 

Ellis: How was killing somebody supposed to help that?

Vanessa: Because the motive would be gone! People… people wouldn’t have to worry about it anymore after that, right?" Ness... I feel so bad for her... this is genuinely hurting a lot (in a good way) T_T

"Vanessa: I never said I’d be at the breakfast…" Vanessa...

"A loud thud interrupts us. It sounds like it’s from somewhere next door.

Vanessa: Wh-what was that…?

Ellis: Shit can not be going down out there when I’m holding a gun…!" Okay that made me laugh- this absolutely is the worst time to be holding a gun, because we know damn well shit's going down. The Deadly Life warnings are up, after all.

"I sigh, then slide the gun under this Villa’s couch." Oh, this is a horrible idea...

"Where we find Aidan, shoving the lifeless body of Robert Smith, the Ultimate Normie into a closet." HUH???????? ROBERT?????? Holy shit that came straight outta nowhere what?! What do you mean??? I was expecting quite literally anyone but him the hell???

"Aidan: Oh, great." Oh yeah also he's here xD This is quite a funny situation to find you in, Aidan. Good to know you're not the killer, though, given the whole "too obvious" clause and all.

"Ding, Dong, Bing, Bong!" Oh yeah also that. Although I've been wrong on this before, that should clear Aidan, Ellis and Vanessa, since the BDA rule excludes the killer in the count of three. I can't immediately think of any way to trick it here like Antonia did, but then, we really don't know shit about this murder yet, so.

"Vanessa: Why do you have a body?!" It's a valid question, I think.

"Ellis: Noah… Nice to… see you…?

Noah: …Yeah…" I'm gonna be real, Noah, I am shocked you are alive, but I'm also very glad!

[INVESTIGATION - START!] And the crowd goes wild!!!

-

Wow, what a fucking chapter! I'm still reeling from everything that happened, genuinely very exciting stuff here! From the reveal that Paris is a blank, the mysterious Davis person, Vanessa having a gun, and ROBERT??? He certainly stole the spotlight this chapter, what a guy he is! Or, was, I guess. What can I even say? I'm shooketh.

But while we're all mourning the most normalest guy ever, we also need to pull out our bingo cards, and play the prediction game! As you may know, there are four prediction boards I'm aware of in Tumblr dot com; mine, accirax's, Jonas', and bronze-ocs'!

(In case it's hard to see, mine is top left, accirax's is top right, Jonas' is bottom left, bronze-ocs is bottom right)

I’d put down Robert as the CH1 killer because I figured the whole “normal” shtick would be hard to make work for very long, and having the “normal” one being the first killer would drive the point home that anyone can kill, no matter what. Evidently I was wrong on the latter part, but maybe I wasn’t too far off with that first idea. Robert did have plenty of very interesting and compelling interactions in regards to his normality, though, so it’s not like he couldn’t have made it further while still being an engaging character. Alas, we won’t get the chance to see that. In any case, regardless of the reasons, Robert being the CH2 victim instead gives me 1 chapter point and 2 role points. Combined with the 7 I already had, I now have 10 points! 

Now, back at the end of CH1, there was a three way tie between me, bronze and Jonas. And now… there’s still a three way tie between the same people :v Jonas predicted Robert as the CH3 killer, giving them 3 points as well. The tie with bronze is even more ridiculous, because they also predicted Robert as the CH1 killer. And for those keeping score, yes, this is the third guess in a row where both bronze and I guessed the exact same thing. Our boards aren’t exactly the same, so we’ll differ eventually, but it is surprising that so far we’ve predicted the same thing for all the dead people xp In any case, all three of us now have 10 points each.

Finally, accirax actually had the best guess this time around! She also guessed a CH3 death, but as a victim, meaning she only received 1 chapter point. Alas, she started this chapter with 13 points, so she now has 14, and is still in last place. However, the distance has closed!

Is this the start of the accirax comeback? Will the tie break at the end of this chapter, or will it continue? Or is it possible that we achieve the legendary four way tie? Find out more… in a few weeks!

“Even if it contains a lie, I should still look at the Monoquin File first. I just know that Kennedy is gonna try to psychoanalyze it in court, and I don’t wanna be caught off guard.” Hell of a reason to review a piece of evidence xD

“The victim is Cassidy Torres. They died in the Upper Common Room at approximately 2 AM due to poisoning. She has been stabbed in the stomach as well.” She was poisoned! Or, well, I guess that could be a lie lol. The possible lies are location of death (her torso could have been moved), time of death, poison, or stabbing. Looking at the stomach should clarify whether that last one is the truth or not though. For right now, I'm leaning to the time or location being the lie, but who knows. In any case:

Truth Bullet Obtained: Monoquin File #1

“Mark: …Everyone. I know this is going to be hard, but… we have to do this, okay? Standing around isn’t going to solve the mystery.

Vivi: Right. Okay, listen up! I’m gonna ask that people help me round up all the pieces of the body in the Infirmary. I’m gonna take a better look at them there.” Interesting that Mark's the one who speaks up first. Are we possibly looking at an Ultimate Detective of some kind? Probably not lmao. Also Vivi moving such important pieces of evidence around sounds like trouble. I get that you're not experienced in this, but come on :v

I'm also seeing that a lot of the usual steps in investigations, like getting two people to guard the crime scene or arranging investigations in pairs, isn't happening. Cool!

“Despite Mark’s words, there’s something definitively crisper about the way they’re talking. I almost want to ask, “does this bring anything back for you?”, but that seems unnecessarily rude and accusatory.” Huh. Maybe I wasn't actually that off with the detective guess lmao.

“Mark: I’ve been looking through Cass’ e-Handbook.

They turn it so that I can see it.

Mark: There’s not really much to gain from it, though. Just the one message to Jeff, which we saw her send. No notes, no other messages, nothing.

Ellis: Wait. Where’d you get your hands on that?

Mark: …In the pants pocket. Of her legs.

Ellis: You found their legs??” Holy hell they move fast! They've been split for one second and people are already finding more body parts??? Damn. Also where?

“Ellis: No notes, though? Seems kinda weird, considering that it seems like they were looking into Antonia and the two of us as potential mastermind candidates. Maybe she was the type to keep things in her head?

Mark: Maybe. I’d definitely take notes, if I were them…

Mark wipes a smudge off the screen thoughtlessly. When pink appears on their white glove though, they furrow their brows.

Mark: Given the state of the body, it makes sense that there would be blood, but that doesn’t mean I like it.

Ellis: I’d have to imagine that chopping Cass’ body up like that would produce tons of blood.

But then, where did all that blood go…?” No notes is strange, I wonder if someone erased them? Then again, unless the notes can be restored somehow, I don't see how that would be brought into the trial. The blood thing is definitely important though. I do love how the blood is described as pink, btw, very funny :v

“Cass’ room looks pretty normal and undecorated. The only notable thing seems to be a laptop on her desk, which has some kind of device plugged into one of the USBs.” So she wasn't dismembered in her room, which is kinda what I'd been expecting. Unless the killer put a tarp under them or something. But that USB thing sounds interesting. 

“Ellis: What, like a tracking device? Is it something in here, or something outside?

Mark: I’m not sure. It’s tracking when something activates… some kind of sensor, maybe? It was quiet pretty much all night, but it just activated a bunch of times a few minutes ago.” Motion sensor? Where? Why? Was Cass tracking Ellis and Antonia's movements maybe? 

“Mark points to a small fleck on the wall. Upon closer inspection, though, it appears to be a tiny sensor.

Ellis: What the… How did you find that?

Mark: Uh… I don’t know. I guess I knew where to look…? I was just using logic.” Well that sounds like a motion sensor alright! Very interesting… Also yeah Mark definitely has a talent for this, be it Detective or Escape Room Master or Puzzlemaster or Logic User (?) but they've definitely have something going on.

“Ellis: So then, Cass was trying to track who entered the Upper Common Room?” That is very strange. Sounds like the question of why Cass was doing that is gonna be a pretty important point of this trial. {Hindsight: Maybe they were just doing the "neighborhood watch" thing actually :v}

“I march back into Cass’ room, and wait for the results of whatever the hell Mark is about to try. As I watch, I get more familiar with the display. Looks like there were two overnight triggers: one at 1 AM and one at 6 AM.“ So the 2 AM time of death looks… I don't know actually. It kinda sounds like Cass might have died at 1? Unclear for now. But that is a very long time. How early do these people get up again? If some people are already up by 6, then it'd be very dangerous to move the body around then. 

Okay let me finish this section before I speculate more.

“Mark: If you stand in front of the sensor and move around, it doesn’t do anything. And, if you’re trying to avoid the sensor, you can step over it.” This seems like it's very important. The fact Cass can avoid the sensor explains a few worries I had just thinking about it, so this helps. 

“Mark quickly heads over to the sensor and takes a pillow off one of the chairs. Though they throw it in the path of the sensor, nothing appears on the screen.” Huh? Alright, so it's not just motion, it's probably infrared looking for heat, would be my guess? 

Truth Bullet Obtained: Cass’ e-Handbook

Truth Bullet Obtained: Floor Movement Tracker

Alright, so what did we learn? Something very important, actually. I'm gonna assume the killer's the one who set the sensor off at 1 and 6 AM, because I don't have any reason to assume they weren't for now. 

There's two options here: either their room is on the fourth floor, in which case Cass died and was dismembered before 1 AM (time of death being the lie in the File) and the killer spent 5 hours during the night spreading the body around before returning at 6; or what I find a bit more likely, the killer's room isn't on the fourth floor, so the 1 AM trigger is them going up there, possibly waiting an hour for the poison to kill Cass (or the time is a lie), and spending 5 hours dismembering her before going to spread the body and return to their room after 6. More evidence is gonna be needed to say for sure what happened, though.

“Taylor: We’ve been messaging people. It sounds like the pieces were found here, in the Movie Theater, the Customer Service Area, the Infirmary, and the Casino.” Interesting, I guess? We still don't know why the killer did the dismemberment so.

Truth Bullet Obtained: Locations of the Body

I don't have much to say about this one for now. I don't see anything immediately meaningful about the locations, so.

“Grace: While Vivi was rounding up the body, I gathered these. They’re all identical, and pieces of the body were found in all of them.

Ellis: I assume it wasn’t just our box that seemed impossible to open at first glance?

Grace: Yes, that’s the general consensus.” What are these things, anyways?

“Grace: We didn’t do anything. All of the boxes opened at exactly 8:15 AM. I found timer mechanisms inside; they were all set to open at the same time.” … What? I guess that's to avoid an early discovery. Don't know why else that would happen, or why the killer would want breakfast to happen before the body was found, though.

“Ellis: Sharp timing.

Grace: I can respect that much about them, even if I can’t respect anything else.” Pfft. Grace's love of punctuality is really funny.

Truth Bullet Obtained: Timer Boxes 

“Vanessa: All the boxes opened at 8:15. That’s when the BDA went off.

Antonia: Obviously, Monoquin instructed everyone to arrive at our location, but I’m not sure if we can truly say that we three discovered the body. After all, everyone had a hand in it, didn’t they? I see no reason why the torso in particular would signal the discovery.” Well, there goes BDA based elimination of suspects. Shame. Pretty interesting way to go around it, though.

“But, would the killer really go to all that horrible effort just to dodge that one effect of the rule? I’m starting to feel like a sicko myself for even having the thought…” I agree with Ellis, dismemberment is the kinda thing that requires a little more justification from a strategic standpoint than just dodging BDA reasoning. And yes it always is a bit of a trip to think about such things from the perspective of the killer, but don't worry Ellis, you'll get used to it.

Truth Bullet Obtained: Body Discovery Announcement

Wonder how this is gonna come up in the trial lol.

[Jeff's Account] Well, they weren't lying about the Ultimate Absentee intuition, huh. Still, though, kinda huge that there wasn't anything in the Movie Theater at 2:30, because it gives credence to the idea that the killer was still in the fourth floor at that time. That would imply that my second idea for the tracker is more likely, that the killer came from a different floor at 1 and left the fourth floor at 6. 

Then again, the fact that the Movie Theater defaults to dark instead of lit is strange, wonder how that plays into it.

Truth Bullet Obtained: Jeff’s Account

Truth Bullet Obtained: Resort Lighting

[Dollies and Black Sheet] Well, that explains a few things, I guess. I wonder if the killer could ask staff to help hide the body…

Nope, Rule 12, got it. Still, this one's pretty straightforward, thankfully. Also, around this time I'm really getting restless for the autopsy for some reason lol.

“Ellis: Sucks to see you.

Aidan: What a warm greeting.

Ellis: Well, I was trying to trick you into complimenting me or flirting with me. I deserve it, after everything you’ve put me through.

Aidan: I don’t think you really do…” Pfft- Ellis, is this really the time? xD

“He hands me the list from the desk. Among lots of regular orders, there’s a section Aidan’s flipped to of several anonymous orders from four days ago: poison, five timer boxes, and a large black sheet.” Welp. Can't really get much more explicit than that with this one lol.

"Ellis: If anyone can stumble into something like this, then clearly their real talent lies somewhere beyond what Monoquin told us. Unless it’s Mark, I guess. That is the kind of move that would make me go ???.” How do you even pronounce triple question mark with your mouth??? 

“Aidan: Anyone could’ve been lying to us about what they do or don’t know. It’s not like anyone’s going to admit to knowing how to do any of this.

He pauses.

Aidan: Other than Vivi, anyway.

Ellis: Point taken.” Pfft.

Truth Bullet Obtained: Customer Service Order List

(Btw since this thing became a real Truth Bullet, I removed it from my personal non-canon Notes :p)

“Harper quickly leans down to pick up the poker chips. However, as ver hand touches the floor, ve pauses.

Harper: It’s wet.

Ellis: With water, or…?

Harper: It seems to be water, yes.” ??? Alright so this one's breaking all sorts of ideas I had. If blood was spilt here… What does it mean? I got nothing for now, I'll come back to it ig. {Hindsight: I realize it sounds like I think the liquid is blood and not water lol. I should have clarified that my first instinct was that blood was spilt on the carpet and got washed :p}

Also I wonder to what extent the fact that Noah accidentally knocked the chips down was affected by Ellis’ luck. I've always found it funny how any time Ultimate Luck is involved, you can easily write out plot convenience as Ultimate Luck business xD

“Noah: If [Staff members] break a rule, do they get executed…?

Harper: There are certainly a lot of questions surrounding this place…” Good question! Interesting to think about.

Truth Bullet Obtained: Damp Casino Carpet

“The pieces have been laid out on the Infirmary’s bed, roughly recreating Cass’ normal figure. Vivi looks over the body while Kennedy stands nearby. Robert sits on a nearby chair, looking decisively away from the body.” Bro get my boy Robert outta there, he probably wants to be literally in any other room ToT. 

“Vivi: Yeah. Stabbed in the stomach, then cut up into pieces. Sewed the seams of the pieces for transport, put them in boxes. Pretty simple, once you boil it down to basics.” Well. Cass sure was stabbed, so there goes one possible lie. Also "pretty simple” is wild.

“Vivi: I mean, I’d be lying if I said I hadn’t done a few Vivi-sections before, but on a person…?

Robert: …Do you mean dissections…?

Vivi: …Yup!” Judging from that triple dot, Vivi's absolutely done actual vivisections hasn't she. At least they haven't done it on humans I guess.

“Kennedy: It was found in five groups. The arms were together, and the legs were together. Then there was one for the stomach, one for the torso, and one for the head.” Well… more info!

“Vivi: So, did you wanna hear my autopsy?

Ellis: Go ahead. It’ll be… music to my ears…

Ugh, even my lines aren’t faring well…” Yeah no xD

"Vivi: The stab wound, while it might’ve been fatal if untreated long enough, wasn’t the cause of death. The poison was.” So I was right last week about the poison being the murder weapon. Still heavily side-eyeing Paris because of the “Toxic” cover, because judging from… everything going on, it's the type of foreshadowing I could see this completely demented (/positive) writer pulling off :p

“Vivi: The time of death… It’s not really my specialty, and there’s only so far you can get with forensics. I think that Cass died sometime between 1 and 2:30, which could support the File. It could still be a little off, though.” Hm… I wonder how close to the actual time of death the file needs to get to be considered correct. But I'm starting to really consider the idea that the murder happened in the Casino… I'll come back to it.

"Vivi: The poison seemed to be pretty fast-acting… the stab wound happened before she died… aaand, I think it’d take any killer a few hours to cut up and sew the body, even if they did have experience with it. Though, given the time of death, that’s pretty achievable for anyone.” Stabbed before she died is actually quite huge. Again, more stuff to think about. 

Truth Bullet Obtained: Chopped Body

Truth Bullet Obtained: Vivi’s Autopsy

“Dun, Dun, Dun, Dun!” Yeah, it felt like it was coming. I'll finish the part, then really start thinking about the murder.

“To cut up the body like that, hemming their edges and scattering them about the resort like a cat with a bird… that’s fucked up!!! My first thought is clearly that someone like Vivi (...or, looking at the rest of the field, just Vivi, I guess) must have done the crime.” Bruh. Why does no one trust the clearly mentally unstable doctor with the evident ability to perform the murder? No respect for the classics smh.

Also I love the images in this section! Particularly appreciate the Cass one, I like seeing where she was cut because I'm insane! :D

“Or did the killer know something that could be used to target her that we didn’t?” Hey, I was kinda thinking the same thing!

Why is Paris still smiling like nothing's wrong is she crazy? I love her.

“Like, I had assumed that we were just gonna deal with a “Professor Plum with the rope in the kitchen” situation, and we’d figure out who didn’t have an alibi for 3 PM.” Okay so the professor Plum thing is apparently a reference to the board game Clue (or maybe the movie or something, idk I only know the board game), which I guess makes sense for Ellis to think about since it’s close enough to other luck based board games that are actually seen in casinos lol.

However, the fact Ellis chose to reference "Professor Plum” specifically worries me. Surely, he doesn't actually think plum is a good name for a color, right? Can't believe accirax would let her silly ideas of what colors are called seep into the characters she plays smh, that shit's purple call it what it is (/silly reference). 

“I’m gonna have to get used to this, won’t I? Now that brutal blood has been spilled and new motives are queued to the setlist, there’s no way that Cass’ death will be the only one. I hope they won’t all be just like this, but… yikes. Not to mention, all future killers will now have a better grasp of what these “Class Trials” are like. Sheesh. With a crime this bizarre, I kinda feel like I have to pitch in. Should I go grab a cheerleader outfit?

…I guess if I come up with something brilliant, I can speak up, too. Who wouldn’t want to hear my melodic voice?” Come on Ellis, you should have a little more confidence in yourself! You're played by a really smart person, after all ;) As long as no one asks you to name colors, you'll be fine. 

[CLASS TRIAL: START] Woohoo!

-

Extremely fun chapter! The investigation was very well paced, and has a great mix of answers and questions to raise! Cannot wait for the trial, it's gonna go crazy. 

But of course, now that the evidence is there, you know what we need to do.

Pre-Trial Murder Theory

Let's start by looking at the cause of death, because this is the quickest mystery to explain. There's obviously a few questions that arise just looking at how Cass died, especially taking account they died during the night. Mainly, how did Cass get poisoned that late in the night, when she'd probably not trust any food given to her? And, why was she stabbed if the poison was fast acting and the real cause of death anyways? Without knowing what the poison was and what the stabbing implement looks like, these are tough to answer.

I thought up a few different explanations (such as the stabber and the poisoner being two separate people), but what I find most likely is that, in reality, the stabbing and the poisoning weren't two different attacks on Cass' life. No, I believe Cass was stabbed with a sharp object tipped with poison. That would explain why the stab was necessary while still giving an explanation to how Cass got poisoned in the first place.

The next question would be the water on the casino carpet. This one has a pretty straightforward explanation, but it's important to mention now. Basically, at first glance, it seems Cass was actually murdered in front of the locked door in the casino (the place the water was according to E-Handbook text), potentially lured there by the killer saying they had a way to open that door (complete speculation, I don't really know). The water would come from the killer washing the carpet... I guess. As a result, the Monquin File Lie would be the location of death.

The other explanation is that the killer may have taken the carpet outside the casino, murdered Cass somewhere else, and used the carpet to soak up all the blood from the dismemberment, before washing it and putting it back in the casino. However, given we don't know of any other place where the murder could have happened, I find the first option more likely.

And believe it or not, that, combined with the floor movement tracker, potentially narrows down our suspect list... or does it? [cue Vsauce music]. See, assuming Cass avoids her movement tracker (which is a pretty big assumption, to be clear), the killer trips it once at 1 AM, and once at 6 AM. Assuming Cass died in the casino at 2 AM, that would mean that the 1 AM detection represents the killer leaving the fourth floor, and the 6 AM detection represents them going back into the fourth floor, presumably to leave the torso up on the upper common room. However, the sensor isn't tripped again until the next morning, meaning the killer must have stayed in the fourth floor. They probably couldn't have slept in Cass' room, because it was locked (see: "Mark walks over to the door to Cass’ room. After displaying the e-Handbook, the door unlocks") and Cass' E-Handbook was locked inside one of the 8:15 AM boxes. That means the only option is that the killer's room is on the fourth floor...

Or is it? Let me run through the proceedings, and see if you can spot the issue.

The killer goes up to Cass' room, and tells them they have something to show her in the casino. For some reason, Cass believes them, and goes with them. On the way, Cass avoids her movement sensor, but the killer trips it, generating the 1 AM reading.

Now, an interesting issue is that these two leave the fourth floor at 1AM, but Jeff was wandering around until 1:30 AM (again info from the E-Handbook, I don't think the guy actually says it), and didn't see anyone. I believe this is where the resort lighting comes in: Cass and the killer didn't want to be spotted (I guess?), so when they noticed Jeff was wandering around, they hid in the Movie Theater's darkness until Jeff finally went into the Lower Common Room (third floor).

In any case, they wait a bit more to make sure Jeff is actually gone gone, and finally get down to the casino around 2 AM. The killer stabs Cass with a poison tipped sharp object, and Cass dies very quickly.

Then, the killer does something that causes a noise at 2:30 AM that Jeff hears. I'm gonna be honest, I don't have a great answer for this one. My current guess is that the killer maybe went to retrieve the dolly from the Customer Service Desk (second floor), and somehow made a noise loud enough to be heard from the third floor? Possibly operating the elevator or rolling the dolly down the stairs if it's too big for the elevator or something. Both the elevator and the stairs down to the first floor are directly under the lower common room, so I don't find it 100% impossible. Maybe Jeff just sucks at identifying the direction sound comes from?

Yeah this is the weakest point of my theory imo.

In any case, after the noise is made, the killer dismembers Cass. I imagine they did this over the black tarp found in the Costumer Service Desk, so they could avoid soaking the Casino carpet with more blood than necessary. In fact, washing that carpet before the blood dried is probably important, but that's a minor point.

The dismemberment takes a while, but with no one around, it's easy enough to pull off before morning comes. The killer then distributes the body pieces throughout the building for as of yet undisclosed reasons. They return to the fourth floor, hide the torso in the upper common room box, and finally go back to their room. And because the sensor was only tripped once at 6 AM, the killer's room must be on the fourth floor, right?

...

Right?

...

Did you spot the problem?

...

That's right. The dolly's final location.

Indeed. The day after the murder, the dolly is found in the Costumer Service Desk, on the second floor. And since this dolly was presumably used to distribute the body parts (see: blood on the dolly), that means the killer would need to somehow go into the fourth floor to drop off the torso and back down to the second floor to drop the dolly off in a way that only set off the sensor once. That's a problem.

So, how do we explain this? I considered a few options. For one, I thought that maybe the killer could have killed Cass in her own room at 2 AM, or the upper common room at 1 AM (the lie in the Monoquin file being location or time of death respectively). If they went into the fourth floor with the dolly and tarp, they could have dismembered Cass then and there (presumably in Cass' own room to avoid other people seeing), put their torso in the box of the upper common room, and left to distribute the rest of the corpse at 6 AM. However, that fails to explain the carpet in the casino and the noise at 2:30 (not that I have a great explanation for the latter anyways, but y'know), and there are no signs of struggle in the fourth floor that could point to this possibility. Because of that, while I consider this possible, I don't consider it the most likely option.

Then, there's the other option. The killer did everything I described, but did something strange that caused the sensor to only go off once at 6 AM. For example, leaving the dolly in the CSD before dropping off the torso, and carrying said torso up to the fourth floor by hand. The problem is that the killer has no reason to treat the box on the fourth floor any differently than the others, so they wouldn't have any reason not to go into the fourth floor with the dolly.

That is, of course, unless the killer knew about the sensors.

It makes sense, doesn't it? Cass would need to trust someone very heavily to follow them out during night, and especially if I'm right about them going into the darkness of the Movie Theater together. Hell, she even said in Part 3:

"Mark: Then… what should we do?

Cass: The same things you’ve been doing. All you need to do is keep an eye out for any suspicious activity and engage in safe behavior. Stay in groups or well-lit areas. Don’t go out at night. Those sorts of things should keep you safe enough while we figure out the mysteries of this place."

So they're clearly aware of the dangers they took going out, but they still did it. If they trusted the killer this much, I don't think it's impossible that they might have told the killer about the sensors.

This is where the lack of notes in Cass' E-Handbook could come in. If Cass told the killer about the sensors, she might have written that down as a note. And since that note would have likely included the identity of the killer, said killer chose to wipe out all the notes to avoid being implicated through them. They likely did this with bloody hands, explaining the blood on Cass' handbook. In this process, they could have also wiped incriminating chat logs, if any existed. Assuming that's a thing they can do, of course.

In any case, the killer knowing about the sensors could allow them to easily tamper with the info simply by dodging detection whenever they wanted, as the sensors are easy to dodge if you know they're there. Keeping in line with the theory I was working with, they could have intentionally tripped it when they went up to the fourth floor with the dolly and the torso, and dodged detection on the way down (or the other way around, it's indistinct).

The big question, then, becomes "why?" What were they trying to accomplish by screwing with the readings? Well, to know that, we need to figure out what location the killer wants the cast to believe is the real death location.

See, if the cast thinks Cass died on the fourth floor and takes the readings at face value, they would arrive at the conclusion that the killer's room is on the third floor. Conversely, if the cast thinks Cass died on any other floor and takes the readings at face value, then they would arrive at the conclusion that the killer's room is on the fourth floor. Do the math in your head if you don't believe me. But if the readings were tampered with, we'd need to flip that. A fourth floor killer would want the cast to believe the killer's on the third floor, so they'd want the cast to think Cass was murdered on the fourth floor. Meanwhile, a third floor killer would want the cast to think Cass was murdered somewhere else.

Does that make sense? Sorry if this is hard to follow, I don't know how to explain it in any simpler way :v

And, well, where does the killer want the cast to think Cass was murdered? I think it's hard to say for sure, but given they hid evidence she died in the casino by washing the carpet, and that they left the dolly in the second floor (which would imply the killer wants people to interpret the 6 AM reading as the killer leaving the fourth floor), I'm gonna say the killer wants people to believe the killer lives on the third floor. Which especially makes sense if they want to frame Antonia, who was Cass' number 1 hater up until their death and happens to live on the third floor. With this, it's very possible the killer lives on the fourth floor.

The fourth floor room havers are Kennedy, Ellis, Vivi, Robert, Grace, Cass, Noah, and Harper. Ellis can't be the killer through protag privilege, Robert has been shown to be too queasy to pull this off, and I'm gonna go out on a limb (pun not intended) and say Cass didn't somehow dismember themselves. Crazy assumption, I know.

As for the others, Vivi can probably be eliminated due to how useful she's been, and Harper's the one who originally found the water on the casino carpet that the killer wouldn't want found. Noah's a weird case, because he originally thinks the water is unrelated, which could be a blackened play, but he flags down the staff member to ask about it, which suggests he genuinely believed that, which is spotless behavior. Finally, I can't really see Kennedy as the first killer, though I think she's the second most likely of the fourth floor just because I don't actually have any real evidence to clear them.

That leaves us with Grace- how has this happened again. I swear I don't have anything against Clockmakers, they just keep being in the wrong place, and ironically at the wrong time :v

However, just because I think Grace is the most likely to be the killer out of the fourth floor crew, doesn't mean I think they're the most likely overall. It's possible the killer didn't think about the implications of the dolly, and that there's an even more elaborate plan at play here.

Here's the idea I'm working with for a third floor killer. They'd effectively have two separate ideas at play during the trial. First, they'd try to convince the cast to vote for Antonia, because she's likely going to be the number one suspect due to her pre-existing beef with Cass. For that to happen, they need the cast to think the murder happened in the fourth floor, be it Cass' room or the common room, because there's no way Cass would follow Antonia literally anywhere else on the building. That's why they'd initially try to hide the blood on the casino carpet, so that the first plan doesn't fall apart immediately. However, if Antonia gets cleared somehow, they have another card to play. They can reveal that they "found" the water on the casino floor (or wait for someone else, like Harper, Noah or Ellis to do it), implying Cass was murdered there, and with the sensor readings, argue that the killer must live on the fourth floor. Of course, this assumes that the dolly's final location is an oversight by the blackened, and probably the mistake that would lead to the killer's downfall.

Now, make no mistake, this is fucking insane even for my standards, especially for a first trial, but I think it makes enough sense to maybe work.

This is how Paris!Culprit can still win, which if you don't remember, is born from the fact that Paris made Cass and Antonia's beef public (establishing motive for a potential frame job), that she could start talking to Cass with the excuse of getting help with the "Paris Pairs" idea mentioned in Part 3, and that she covered Toxic in Part 1. Though, admittedly, Mark being the one to find the sensor readings is suspicious in its own right, but I don't really think they're the killer, especially since they'd have the least motive to escape out of anyone. No one else on the third floor really strikes me as particularly suspicious, especially since third floor killers require fifteen more hoops to jump through than fourth floor killers with my murder theory.

Overall, I think Grace, Paris, and Noah are my main suspects, and if I have to lock just one in... I really don't want to say Grace because it'd just be ridiculous at this point (I already said they might be the mastermind someone save my pal T_T), so I'll say Paris and hope that the clinically insane mindgames I described in the third floor killer idea make enough sense to anyone else.

Of course, though, this entire theory is just that, a theory. There's a very high chance that I'm just completely off the mark, and that'd be perfectly fine! This is all just for fun, after all, and I'm just a silly Tumblr user thinking too hard about fictional characters. I'm by no means an expert in solving murders or anything lol. Extremely excited to see just how horrendously wrong I am next week, I'm sure the trial will be absolute peak!

If you made it this far, you've earned a complimentary poison tipped knife! Please be careful with it. See ya'!

Truth Bullets:

Monoquin File #1 - Cass’ E-Handbook - Floor Movement Tracker - Locations of the Body - Timer Boxes - Body Discovery Announcement - Jeff's Account - Resort Lighting - Customer Service Order List - Chopped Body - Vivi's Autopsy

Canon Notes:

Staff Members - Customer Service Desk - Monoquin’s Hands - Killing Game Explanation - Monoquin File Lies

Personal Notes:

I'm like three paragraphs in, but I'm already enjoying the changes of Jeff being there and Antonia and Cass continuing to beef with each other. I just really like these characters lol.

“Grace: I’m surprised you don’t seem to be hungover, Noah?

Noah: Oh, that doesn’t happen with me. Pretty cool.” Bro what. How much do these talents do.

“Antonia: Cassidy is just being a little paranoid, that’s all. Don’t mind her.

Cass: …

Vivi: Uhhh, okay…? Are we just gonna pretend that nothing’s happening here, or?

Antonia: I don’t know, Cassidy, do you have anything you’d like to tell us?” Why do they hate each other so much??? Love 'em.

“Paris: Cass and Antonia are at each other’s throats all the time now because they both think the other is the mastermind~” Oh Antonia actually thinks Cass is the mm? I kinda missed that, or I forgot something from last week. I thought she was just being petty but I guess this makes a bit more sense.

“Kennedy: Please. If it’s that obvious, it has to be the wrong answer.

Antonia: I wouldn’t say Cassidy is being “obvious.” I simply trust my extensive experience with determining when someone is lying.

Cass: Antonia just admitted that she deals with lies all the time. Sometimes the reason why someone is the frontrunner is because they’re perfect for the job.” Love Kennedy keeping up the Tumblr theorizing logic, and Cass and Antonia hating each other means more Antonia content for me so I'm just happy :)

“Robert: …Alrighty! Well, I’m glad we’ve talked this over…” We really haven't but thanks for trying to keep things positive, Robert, appreciate ya'.

“Cass: I will figure out your secrets.

Antonia: Of course you will, darling.” :D No further commentary.

[Paris FTE Start] Wooo, FTE! And Paris, too, I really like her! We're probably not gonna get many more FTEs this chapter (in fact I'm sorta expecting this to be the last one), so let's enjoy this while it lasts :')

“Ellis: Your makeup’s looking great. How is it that you’re such a knockout both in and out of it?

Paris: Aw, thanks babe! Appearances are everything, after all~” Alright damn. Classic Ellis opening with a pickup line, and Paris, what?

“For the first time in a while, I’m actually flustered from someone pulling me close. It’s not exactly a romantic attraction, though… it’s more from the sheer energy she holds as she anchors her hand on my shoulder.” Someone got Ellis! Admittedly, not by flirting so much as by being weird about gossip, but counts xD

“Paris: You should have Antonia tell you how she got into dealing someday. It’s an interesting story.

Ellis: Oh, have you been spending a lot of time with Antonia since we got here?

Paris: I spend time with everyone, hon! I can’t believe it’s taken me so long to talk to someone as intriguing as yourself in more depth.

Ellis: Hey, give me some credit! Maybe I was trying to keep my intrigue up on purpose…” Ooh, well I'm always glad to hear about Antonia, and of course Paris spends a lot of time with the others. Also Ellis, who was playing an icebreaker game just the night before, implying they wanted to keep up the intrigue is funny.

“I wasn’t, but that’s not important.” And this, dear readers, is why we read slightly ahead of whatever we're commenting on in this kind of post xD

“Ellis: You’ve definitely done your research.

Paris: Totes! If you want to hear some real research, though, I know Cass and Kennedy both do a lot on their own time.” I mean we kinda knew this, but I'm liking how much we're referencing other characters here, really justifies the whole Ultimate Gossip thing.

“Paris: Hmm. It is true, it’s a bother that I can’t check on any of my beloved followers… 

Ellis: Do you know stuff about all of them, too?

Paris: I hear what they say. But that’s about all I can do, isn’t it?

Ellis: Of course.” ‘I hear what they say’ strikes me as a weird way to respond to that question. Might be nothing, but it does make me wonder if maybe she knows more about them than she's letting on… not that I know how that could be relevant to the killing game lol. 

“Paris leaves me in the Common Room, a little stunned. She truly is a master of social techniques–every time I tried to dig for info about her, she dodged, and threw the question right back at me. Looking back, it seems like we were just talking in circles for fifteen minutes before she ran off to her “prior commitments.” With who? And doing what?

In the end, I agree with my immediate assessment: I don’t want to get on Paris’ bad side. She’s dangerous… though I never said I didn’t like dangerous women.” Yeah, she's someone to look out for, isn't she? Kinda curious to see just how far this stuff can go.

“As I sit on the couch, I notice Aidan and Davis approaching the Movie Theater.” Davis with Aidan again, wonder if he prefers Aidan's company given the whole "not attracted to him” deal. Then again, the straight guys and Vivi also wouldn't be attracted to him, so Aidan's not necessarily unique in that regard.

“[The Movie Theater bulletin board] reads, “MOTIVE ANNOUNCEMENT: TBA.”” Oh yea, motives! Kinda forgot they were a thing lol.

“Aidan: Someone was already planning a murder, from what we can tell. Even with that, is it still taking too long? And if it’s meant to rush us, why isn’t there an actual release date…?” Oh yeah the poison lol. Yeah, bit of a weird situation, huh?

“Aidan: It just doesn’t make any sense.

Kennedy: Not if you think about it so simply!

Kennedy and Vivi come up from the stairs, joining us outside the Movie Theater.” Kennedy and Vivi! :D Just in time to annoy Aidan, fantastic!

“Vivi: [Kennedy]’s been itching for something new to look at for a while now…” Love the image of Vivi just hanging around Kennedy and watching the guy descend into madness from lack of intel lol.

“Kennedy: Maybe the mastermind knows someone’s going to kill soon. It could be setup for the next murder, if they think no one else would go for it just because of the killing game. Or, maybe the mastermind wants to create multiple killers at the same time! There’s a regulation about it. Or–” Kennedy kinda cooks with these theories, they're always a blast lol.

“Aidan: Jesus, will you shut up already?

Vivi: Hey, there were good ideas in there!” You know I'm really glad I asked for that Vivi & Kennedy Bonus Scene because they're a very fun duo. Maybe I'll send in Aidan & Kennedy if there's Bonus Scenes voting post CH1, it's funny how much they beef lol.

“Ellis: Why would someone try to kill if the person running the game is already setting up shop for once you’re dead and buried?

Kennedy: Because even if the mastermind knows that they’re setting up for the next murder, they think that we think it’s for this murder, so they think we think that the motive is a threat to us now, which might make us more likely to kill!” I had to read that like three times to figure out what the hell Kennedy was trying to say damn. They are very hard to follow it's fantastic.

“Vivi: Wait! What if the motive’s up now because the first murder already happened?” There are… not a lot of pages left so I’m worried Vivi might actually be right. I do find it interesting she's the one to bring it up, though, given how hellbent she was that no one was gonna die in the Prologue. Wonder why that is.

“Somewhat surprisingly, everyone’s okay.” Okay, no, we're chilling… for now. 

“Big oversight from the killing game planning community. They should fire those guys and hire some new maniacs to the board.” You gotta love characters criticizing the bad guys for sucking at torturing them lol.

“Paris: OMG Tay, I’ve been wanting to talk to you ever since your talent show performance! It was so good!

Taylor: You think so…?” Taylor's just the most popular person around it's actually kinda funny. Everyone loves them and they don't know how to handle it lol.

“Taylor: Oh, well… if you ever wanted to perform together, I’m sure we could.

Harper: You two would certainly make for an interesting duo.” Yay friendship! :D

[The entire rest of that conversation] Oh hey they actually are going to be besties, let's go! I kinda love that dynamic so that's awesome.

“In the dark of my room, I pull out my e-Handbook, hovering over the chat function.” It's cool that this thingy keeps being brought up, I think it's pretty interesting.

“Antonia: …Apologies for disturbing all your thoughts, but… has anyone seen Cassidy this morning?” Well, that's… concerning. I could see someone targeting them to frame Antonia, but surely Cass is just skipping to avoid said Dealer, right?...

“Aidan: Shouldn’t you be worried about getting murdered or something…? Someone probably just died.” Bro can I ask for a little bit of optimism? I guess not given the talent, but y'know xp

“Harper: It’s a fair point. Perhaps we should split into groups of three. That seems like a safe number, and it… divides evenly…” Oh wait, we're actually doing this? I was kinda expecting Cass to respond in chat. Oh oh guys, she might actually be dead.

“Vanessa, having moved some of the furniture around, discovers a large, metal box, about the size of a mini fridge.” What…?

“Ellis: Just say “open sesame” and it should open right up.” Pfft. Appreciate you alleviating the tension, I'm actually very nervous. 

“We continue to look the box over, trying to figure out some way that it might open. Then, we hear a quiet beep, and it swings open naturally.

The scent is our first sign that something is wrong. Vanessa, who was nearest to the box, frantically crawls backwards, putting more distance between it and herself.

Inside… is a torso.” I'm fucking sorry??? It's Chapter 1 and they're already dismembering people???? AAAAH-!

“Vanessa: What the fuck?!

Antonia: O-oh… oh my…

Ellis: Hh… wh… AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!” Yeah sounds like appropriate reactions.

“Though I already suspected it, as the rest of our group joins us, it’s clear as day that the victim must be Cassidy Torres, the Ultimate Agent.” Well, while everyone is undergoing severe trauma, now that we have explicit confirmation of the victim, it's time to tally up some points in the guessing game!

I predicted Cass as the CH2 killer, so I get 1 Chapter point and 2 Role points (and in case you don't remember, getting points is bad). I'm pretty happy with that, given Cass’ role was a complete toss up for me, and I did manage to predict she'd go relatively early. I feel bad for accirax, who I'm pretty sure got the maximum amount of points possible here by guessing Cass as the mastermind (7 points ouch), sad times. The only other game I have available for comparison is Jonas', and while they got the role right, they'd guessed Cass would die in CH5, meaning four points there. Somehow I appear to be in the lead out of the three guessing game boards for now, which is probably not gonna last very long but you know.

Speaking of this game, I'm also probably guaranteed one chapter point from Vanessa now (plus some kind of point from the actual CH2 killer), because as a first impression, both she and Antonia are probably safe! The BDA rule in this fangan specifically says "three spotless” for the announcement, so unless there's some weird pre-discovery by a random other spotless, Ellis, Vanessa and Antonia can't be the blackened. Hell yeah.

Speaking of, though, I probably also got the CH1 killer wrong in the game.

“Noah is half-carrying Robert, who seems like he’s barely conscious at the moment.”

My bad if this is going to be a canon note or truth bullet, but for now:

Personal Non-Canon Note: Robert's Quesianess. Robert was barely conscious at the sight of Cass’ body, implying he couldn't have been the one to dismember them. 

I'm pretty shocked Cass was the one to die, actually. To quote myself from the last First Impressions post:

“I’m loving all the Antonia content this episode, but is it me or are we getting a lot of Cass? I’m starting to get worried for their safety. Considering what she said in the Bonus Scenes, I kinda doubt she’d go too early, but who knows.”

I'll give myself some credit for noticing Cass was getting a lot of content and wondering if that would mean she was gonna die, but as I said, I really wasn't thinking she'd go so early. I guess I overestimated how important her plans for the outside (don't remember their exact wording oops) would end up being. 

But it's not like I dislike the choice! Cass did in fact get a few good scenes in, and their beef with Antonia, while short-lived, was very fun to watch. Very curious if this is all we'll get from her from now on, or if the secrets Antonia said Cass was keeping will end up being relevant later. Given first victims can often end up haunting the narrative a fair bit, I wouldn't discount the possibility.

Anyways, I'm talking a whole lot for someone who hasn't even started the Investigation, huh? Let's see what we can figure out in the short time this Part has left! 

“Jeff: Thanks or whatever, but you see, I’d actually really rather not be here, so…” Yeah, Jeff wants out out by now, huh?

“Monoquin: The second thing is a piece of information that you’ll gain: the Monoquin File.” Ooh, one of these! You know, it's actually been a while since I've seen a fangan use something like this, I wonder what they'll be like.

“Aidan: Isn’t that unfair to the blackened?” Nice job not looking suspicious in the slightest Aidan, no one could possibly think you might be the killer after saying this! xD

“Monoquin: In every Monoquin File, there will be one lie.” Oh that's hilarious and incredible, I love it. I know Monokuma files in canon were also customized to hide information the blackened wanted hidden, but actually putting lies in the files is much more interesting. Can't wait to see how this gets used!

Note Obtained: Monoquin File Lies

It's been a while since we've gotten an actual canon note, lovely!

“But, this is what I wanted, right? I mean, not this, exactly– I would’ve been fine if whoever it was did use that poison, especially if it meant a slow and painless death. But, still… a murder happened, and I’m not the victim or the killer. That’s how it should go for the Ultimate Lucky Student, right? This is just one step of many to be the one sole survivor at the very end.

So… chill, Ellis. Clearly this is some kind of great tragedy, but it was also inevitable. I’ll pay my respects, do my best to lend a hand in solving the case, and then go on with my daily life.” Well, Ellis’ "plan” seems to be holding up! Fun :)

Also interesting that Ellis was wishing for a "slow and painless” death as opposed to the more common “fast and painless”. I guess, though, if it's painless, it's better to wish for a slow death so the person has more time. 

Which leaves us with murder theories! Though, obviously, we have next to no information. In terms of what happened to Cass, we only know she died at some point in the night (they were spotted at dinner the night before, after all), that the killer dismembered her, and that said killer left Cass’ torso in a metal box that opens… through some mechanism. It wasn't a box that was common knowledge, though.

An interesting point is the location, maybe. Here's the map of the fourth floor:

Cass’ room is there, which is decently notable. It's very possible the killer killed Cass in her own room, or perhaps in the killer's own room if it's on the fourth floor, as it would be weird for someone as paranoid as Cass to stray too far from her room during nighttime. Not too solid, though. There's the question of why dismembering her would be important, but that's impossible to know without more information. Hiding bodies isn't too important in this kind of killing game, but I guess there could be something about the torso itself that the killer didn't want the cast to know. Or maybe they wanted to delay the discovery? Again, impossible to know for now. 

There's also the matter of the poison, which I doubt is unrelated. I have two early theories: either Cass was poisoned, and the killer dismembered them after their death; or Cass herself was the one who requested the poison, she invited someone to her room to kill them with it, but the person decided to kill Cass before she could try. Kinda find the first one more likely, especially because the "other stuff” that got requested alongside the poison could be the implements necessary to dismember and transport the corpse, but again, could be totally off.

Speaking of, the method of transport is an interesting question-

Okay give me a moment. While I was writing this, I pulled up Part 1 to see if anyone had requested anything notable for the talent show, and I saw the Chapter title along the way. While I'd already read it, I didn't realize until that point…

“Piece It Together"????? Venus???? That's- wow. I just- That's kinda fucked up… I love it I just can't believe you did that holy hell.

Back on track though. I couldn't find any notable request in the talent show, aside from possibly the wrapping paper Grace used, which could have technically been employed to hide the body parts during transport. Because of course it's the Clockmaker I find evidence about. Did you know their room is right next to Cass', too? xD

I jest, I don't really think Grace did it. For now, I can really only say what people I don't think it was. I already explained Robert (because he's too queasy), Ellis, Antonia and Vanessa (because BDA), but aside from that… you can stop counting lol. No one else really acted too unsuspiciously, though Kennedy requesting the search and Harper talking about the groups of three (ideal number for BDA stuff) might count for some loss of suspicion points? Then again, there is this part of Harper's line:

“Harper: That seems like a safe number, and it… divides evenly…” Make no mistake, this is an insane reach, but given the chapter title situation, I don't think it's impossible that Harper's slight hesitation right before ve says "divides evenly” could indicate that ve knows Cass got dismembered, aka ve's the blackened. The idea would be that ve's kinda disgusted by what ve's done, so ve regrets the word choice mid sentence. Of course, though, it's far more likely that ve hesitates just because ve's more used to the group being sixteen people, so the number three evenly dividing the group is an unfortunate reminder that they're missing one person. I don't really think Harper's too likely as the blackened, even though there is some setup for it with the fact ve's becoming restless in the game and the fact ver room is also on the fourth floor. 

If I have to go for a read right now, though… well, Kennedy and Vivi had a positive interaction with Cass, and Vivi in particular would have the knowledge and experience to properly dismember a body. Not that I know whether or not there is such a thing as necessary knowledge and experience to do that, but there is a limit to the things I'm willing to google for these posts. Either could have maybe convinced Cass to be alone with them to discuss mastermind business, and both are on the fourth floor, but that's kinda it. On the other hand, Noah and Grace have both gotten a decent bit of screen time, are also on the fourth floor, and Grace in particular has the whole "hates wasting time” thing as a possible motive.

However, the one that worries me the most is actually Paris. She was noticeably silent during the original Cass and Antonia confrontation, and she's the one who brought it up, which could certainly be a strategy to frame Antonia by making it seem like she has a reasonable motive. She also more or less has an established motive with her fans, and could have potentially arranged a meeting with Cass either for mastermind gossip or the whole "Paris Pairs” brand she brought up earlier. Befriending Taylor so suddenly could have been a strategy to get an ally during the trial, and her symbol of teacups could kinda be connected to poison aside from the more immediately obvious "spill the tea” connection. Of course, that last point is only important if Cass was actually poisoned…

… And I just remembered that Paris specifically danced to "Toxic” in the talent show. In the chapter someone requested poison out of the Customer Service Desk. Oh god she might actually be a lot more suspicious than I thought she was. Oh oh.

-

Well… that sure was a thing! Really exciting body discovery, can't believe we have a dismemberment in chapter 1 already, damn. Also cool because Antonia and Vanessa don't seem to be the killer, which is great! And now I'm extremely worried about Paris’ survival, which is not so great, I like that one! Then again, I like all of these guys, so I'll get sad no matter who the blackened is.

As for Cass themselves, I'll mourn the loss, though I think it's very possible we still haven't heard the last of them. The secrets and lies Antonia caught still haven't been revealed, after all. 

In any case, hope you enjoyed reading, and look forward to next week, when we'll probably get just enough information for me to go truly insane over the murder method! See ya'!

Canon Notes:

Staff Members

Customer Service Desk

Monoquin’s Hands

Killing Game Explanation

Monoquin File Lies

Personal Notes:

Clockmaker’s Intuition

Kennedy’s Spiked Rings

CSD Request List

Noah’s Earbuds