Paint It Black Chapter 9
Teen Natasha Romanoff x Teen Reader
Masterlist | General Masterlist
Summary: Natasha Romanoff has never known loveâor at least, thatâs what she tells herself. During her time in the Red Room, she encountered a girl whose memory was forcibly erased from her mind. Now, as an Avenger, she faces a new enemy who turns out to be more than just a threat; they share a tangled history that challenges everything Natasha thought she knew about herself and love.
Chapter Summary: R learns a truth that has her second guessing everything
w/c:3.9k
You didnât know how late it was that night. You could hear in her voice that she was tired and delirious, but neither of you moved from your spots in the hallway. Somehow, it felt like neutral ground. Somewhere you could talk about anything. There was still the fear of being surveilled, of Dreykov knowing what had just happened between you, but for some reason⊠you didnât care.
You didnât want to think about where Ken or Karen were. You didnât want to ruin the moment.
âDo you remember your mom?â Natasha asked suddenly, picking at the sleeves of her jeans. It was a nervous habit, a tell you knew she should probably break. You shouldâve warned her, but you found it endearing. It made her feel more real. More like a girl. Maybe that was the time in Ohio. Maybe that was the part she still held onto.
You wanted to ask her more about it. About her time in the States, about her life before, but you didnât want to seem too eager.
âNo,â you said softly, lifting your chin. âDespite the stories, I donât know who she is or what she looks like anymore.â
Natasha nodded. She didnât either.
âSometimes I think I do,â you went on, scrunching your nose. âItâs blurry and foggy, but itâs there. I remember her carrying me at the mall the day I was taken. I remember how quick it was.â
Natasha stayed quiet, the kind of quiet that didnât interrupt. The kind that made space.
You rested your head back against the wall, blinking up at the ceiling, the memory like a smudge you couldnât quite wipe clean.
âThere was this smell,â you murmured. âLike pretzels. And her perfume. I donât remember her face. Just how warm her shoulder was. I had my head on it, and then â You hesitated. âAnd then it wasnât warm anymore.â
Natashaâs brow twitched. She understood. Not the exact memory, but the feeling. The way the warmth leaves, and cold becomes the only thing you know.
âI screamed,â you admitted. âAnd I didnât stop for a long time. I was so loud, I think they wanted to get rid of me. The guards were pissed. One of them hit me. I guess I fell asleep after or something.â
She turned toward you at that.
âNora was the first person I saw when I woke up. Took me to the infirmary and said I had a fever. I didnât. I was just scared.â You gave a dry, bitter laugh. âShe told me to pretend I was brave.â
âI remember pretending,â Natasha said, just as quietly.
You glanced over. Her face was tilted toward the darkened hallway like she was still seeing something there.
âThey brought me in the back of a van,â she said. âI bit one of them. Got a busted lip for it. One of them told me that if I wanted to live, I had to stop fighting. So I stopped.â
The silence stretched again, heavier this time. You didnât speak. You just nudged your foot lightly against hers, a quiet acknowledgment that you heard her. That you knew.
Natasha nudged back.
The two of you sat there, side by side, young and not. Just girls. And also weapons. You couldnât cry anymore. You were too used to losing things to mourn them properly.
"Do you want to find her?" Natasha asked. "Them. Your parents?"
"No," You said.
You didnât know if that was true. You just didn't want to lose anything else. Besides, what would they think of you? A child assassin with a knack for torture and a history of murder. A girl who didnât even know her birthday.
Natasha didnât press. She just looked at you for a second longer, then turned her eyes back down the hallway.
You didnât know if it was comfort or just coincidence, but she didnât pull away.
âI wouldnât know what to say anyway,â you added after a moment. âHi, I kill people for a living. I used to be four. Now Iâm... this.â
Natasha gave a soft, hollow laugh. Not mocking. Just tired.
âMaybe theyâd still want you,â she said.
You shook your head. âYou donât know that.â
âMaybe. I donât know,â she agreed. âBut you donât either.â
You sat with that. Let it sting a little.
Maybe thatâs what being seen felt like.
âItâs easier if I donât want them,â you murmured. âI don't have to think about whether they want me.â
Natashaâs jaw tensed. She didnât like that logic. But she understood it too well to argue.
****
You werenât supposed to be there alone.
But you were.
Your task for the day was simple: return Georginaâs wallet. In theory. In practice, you were to get a better read on her. Ken and Karen had approved it. A final intel sweep before you left New York, but they didnât know why youâd volunteered.
The mission was nearly over. A few days and you'd be out of the city, off to whatever came next. But you couldnât get her face out of your mind.
The way Georgina had looked at you.
Not just politely. Not just like a stranger trying to place a familiar face.
It was deeper than that.
Like she knew you.
Like she remembered you.
You stepped off the subway at 59th Street and melted into the late-morning crowd. The walk to the behavioral center was brisk, the kind of chilly spring air that tugged at your sleeves. You didn't mind. Being out alone felt good. Right, even.
Nobody questioned a teenager riding the subway by themselves in this part of Manhattan. You were just another kid trying to get somewhere.
Youâd watched the stops go by pressing your knees together, hands in your jacket pockets, eyeing the other girls on the train. A few of them traveled in packs, loud and confident. Talking about school dances, about boys, about embarrassing moments with teachers. One of them had braces and laughed so hard she dropped the book she was holding. Another wore a denim jacket covered in glitter pins and rhinestones. They reminded you of the girls back in the Red Room.
You wondered what it would be like to sit with them. To be one of them.
To belong in a conversation about sleepovers or birthday parties.
But that wasnât your life.
Your life was here, slipping quietly into the building where Georgina worked, clutching a wallet you couldâve easily left behind. You told yourself it was about the mission. About leverage. About checking the final box before debrief.
But even as you walked up to the reception desk, your pulse was telling a different story.
The man at the desk glanced up, glasses low on his nose.
"Hi, I'm looking for Georgina. Georgina Rousseau,"
"Sign in here," the man said, motioning toward the clipboard. "Do you have an appointment?"
You scribbled a name, careful to leave nothing distinctive. No fingerprints. No signature.
"No. She just asked me to drop something off."
"ID?" he asked, holding out a hand.
You stared. "I don't have one. Butâ"
He shook his head.
"Can't let you in without an ID. You'll have to wait in the lobby or make an appointment."
"Butâ"
"It's okay."
You spun.
Georgina stood in the hallway behind you, smiling faintly, a folder tucked under one arm.
"It's all right, John," she said. "I'll handle it."
John frowned. "But she doesn't haveâ"
"She's an old friend," Georgina said, and something in her voice shut him down.
The man looked less than convinced.
"I was just returning this to you." You pretended to fumble for the wallet in your bag, clutching it firmly, before passing it over to her. "You dropped it in the park. I tried to stop by your apartment, but no one was home."
"I spend most of my days here," Georgina said. "Thank you for that."
Georginaâs brow lifted slightly, her eyes scanning your face with amused curiosity.
âSomething tells me you didnât come all this way just to give me a wallet.â
You blinked. Then tilted your head. Then gave a sheepish smile that wouldâve won awards in any Red Room training module.
âWell⊠maybe not just that.â
Georgina chuckled softly, folding her arms. âGo on.â
You gave a performative sigh and looked down at your shoes. âOkay, this is going to sound really dumb. But⊠I kind of need advice. My parents, well, my mom, mostly think Iâm too young to date.â
You saw her posture shift, just barely. Interest. Not alarm.
âAnd you thinkâŠ?â
âThat Iâm mature enough to know what I want,â you said, with just enough confidence to sound naĂŻve. âBut every time I bring it up, they act like Iâm still a little kid.â You shrugged. âItâs embarrassing.â
Georgina smiled again, softer this time. âAnd since you saw Iâm a therapistâŠâ
You nodded, grinning like you were in on your own joke. âFigured maybe I could get a free five-minute session?â
She laughed. âWell, I donât usually do walk-ins, butâŠâ
A beat.
âCome on up. Iâve got time before my next appointment.â
You followed her down the hallway, careful not to smile too wide.
******
"Your office is totally chic," you said as she stepped aside to let you in. The space was colorful, but not in a childish way. It was calming and warm. Like someone had put thought into making it feel safe.
âThanks. Iâve only had it for a few months,â Georgina replied, her grin easy. âI keep candies here if you'd like some.â
She gestured toward a glass jar filled with mini chocolate bars and Starbursts.
You reached for a Starburst, unwrapping it slowly. âThanks.â
âSo,â she said, settling against her desk. âTell me about this boy.â
âHis name is Allen. Heâs fifteen,â you began, leaning into the story with practiced ease. âOnly a year older than me. Not even bad. He asked me to the spring fling, but I wasnât allowed to go with him. Though⊠we did dance together.â
The lie came smoothly. Part of it borrowed, overheard on the subway from a girl your age, but it felt good to try it on. Like slipping into a version of yourself that couldâve been real, in another life.
She raised an eyebrow, intrigued. âA spring fling. That sounds⊠sweet.â
You gave a bashful laugh, popping the candy into your mouth. âHe smelled like cologne. The strong kind,â you added, wrinkling your nose. âBut it wasnât bad.â
âMmm. Allen wears cologne,â Georgina teased, eyes warm. âSounds serious.â
âMaybe.â You toyed with the wrapper in your hand. âI just feel like grown-ups forget what itâs like. To really like someone. Or want to be seen.â
"I do know," she said, more gently this time. Her gaze didnât leave yours.
You shifted in your seat. "So basically, I need your help convincing them, maybe?"
Georgina blinked, caught off guard. âYour parents?â
You crossed your arms. âThey think Iâm going to get pregnant or something, which is ridiculous. Iâve done plenty of things on my own. I think I can handle dating.â
She smiled faintly, but didnât speak right away.
You could see the question in her eyes.
Still, she just said, âYou seem very self-possessed for someone your age.â
âIs that a compliment?â
âItâs an observation,â she said with a smile. âBut yes. It is.â
Georgina leaned back slightly, hands folded in her lap. âSo whatâs Allen like? Besides cologne-forward.â
You grinned. âHeâs nice. Funny, too. Not like cool, funny. More like⊠awkward funny.â
âI always liked that kind,â she said, thoughtfully. âLess likely to break your heart.â
You shrugged. âMy heartâs fine.â
Georgina smiled. âOf course it is.â
There was a beat, light but weighted.
She tilted her head. âDo your parents talk about dating much? You mentioned theyâre strict.â
You kept your face neutral. âThey have⊠expectations.â
âExpectations,â she echoed, as if tasting the word. âThat can be hard. Especially when youâre still figuring out what you want.â
Your fingers paused on the candy wrapper. âI know what I want.â
âI donât doubt that,â Georgina said quickly. âItâs just not everyone your age talks like this. Youâre careful with your words. Like someone trained you to be.â
That caught you off guard. Your gaze flicked up too fast.
She didnât press. She just offered a gentle smile and grabbed two more Starbursts, holding one out to you. âSo, are you more of a math girl or literature?â
You took the candy, heartbeat a little quicker. âLiterature,â you answered. âI like stories.â
âMe too.â Georgina unwrapped hers slowly. âBecause thereâs always something underneath them. The good ones, at least.â
There it was.
That slight shift in her tone.
You looked at her again, just a second too long.
She met your gaze, still easily. Still warm. But her eyes? They were looking through you now.
And then she said it.
âYour storyâs good,â Georgina said lightly. âBut something tells me itâs not the one you came in with.â
A long pause stretched between you.
You tilted your head, matching her smile. âYou read minds now?â
âNo. But I read people.â
"What does that mean?â you asked, the words sharper than you intended.
Georginaâs smile didnât falter. She moved slowly, rounding your chair with the easy grace of someone unbothered by confrontation. As she passed behind you, a subtle whiff of her perfume trailed in the airâwarm, powdery, and oddly familiar.
Your fingers twitched. You knew that scent.
Not exactly. Not anymore. It was newer now. More polished. But underneath, it was the same one youâd pocketed from the locker two days ago. Not because you liked it. Because it felt⊠close to something.
She settled in the chair across from you, crossing one leg over the other, hands resting lightly in her lap.
âWe grew up much the same way,â Georgina said softly. âDreykovâs girls have their tells.â
Your spine stiffened.
âWho?â you asked. Your brows furrowed. âWhat are you talking about?â
Georginaâs smile faltered just enough for the warmth to drop from her eyes.
âYou donât recognize me yet, do you?â she asked. Her voice wasnât teasing anymore. âThatâs okay. You were very small. But I remember you.â
You said nothing. You couldnât. Your throat had gone dry.
âI knew when I saw you in the park,â she continued. âThe posture. The calculation behind your eyes. The hesitation before you reached for your pocket, like someone still monitoring you even when theyâre not there.â
You stared at her. Every word scraped something loose inside you.
âWho are you?â you asked again. Quieter this time.
Georgina leaned forward, elbows on her knees, her voice a low hum. âI was you once. The favorite. The clean one. The one Dreykov didnât want ruined yet.â
You blinked. Everything in your body told you to run.
âI defected just over a year ago. Long enough to rebuild a life. Short enough that I still check my windows twice before bed.â
"Who are you?" You asked more tersely.
Georgina simply narrowd her eyes and stared at you. "I think you know?"
You didn't want to play a stupid guessing game with her.
"We've met a couple times in the Red Room. We've crossed paths," she answered. "Even then, it was clear he was grooming you."
Your jaw clenched. You felt it before you registered it, your body coiling, defensively, instinctively.
âI wasnâtââ you started, but the words caught somewhere between your tongue and your chest. They sounded too much like shame.
Georgina held up a hand gently. âI know. I know what that word feels like when it lands on your skin. I know how fast it burns.â
You hated this. Hated how she looked at you. Like she knew you. Like she could see everything youâd built to protect yourself and was still reaching through it.
âHe doesnât pick favorites because he likes you,â she said softly. âHe picks favorites because he owns you.â
Silence.
Thick, suffocating silence.
You wanted to scream. You wanted to shove the candy dish off the desk and run. But you didnât move. You just stood there. Still. Unblinking.
âYou think Iâm lying,â Georgina said, almost with a smile. âBut somewhere in you, a part of you knows Iâm not.â
She leaned back. âI wasnât a perfect soldier. I made mistakes. And he punished me for it. But I made it out."
You finally exhaled, the sound more like a breath escaping from a cracked dam.
âI donât care if you defected,â you snapped, though your voice wasnât convincing. âI donât care if you think you know me.â
Georgina nodded, unbothered. âThatâs okay. You donât have to care. But you came all the way here, alone. That means something.â
You hated how true that felt.
Her tone softened. âCan I ask you something?â
You didnât answer. You didnât nod. But she asked anyway.
âWhat would it look like if you werenât his anymore?â
Instead, you asked her a different question.
"Are you her?" You began. "My mother? Did you know her?" You tried to get your thoughts in order. "Did you take me?"
She hesitated.
"I knew her." Georgina paused. "Yes. I did."
You weren't sure why the confirmation made you angry. Or sad. You felt like crying, but no tears came. Just a lump in your throat.
"Is she dead?"
Georgina didn't answer immediately. Instead, she reached for something on the desk behind her. A card. She slid it toward you like it had been waiting there the whole time.
"The organization I work with," she began, her voice calm. Steady. âThey help girls like us disappear. Make new lives. New names. If you want it.â
You stared at the card. Didnât touch it.
âSo thatâs it?â you said coolly. âA little card and a pep talk and you think Iâll just walk away from everything?â
âI think you already want to,â she replied.
Your jaw clenched. âYou donât know what I want.â
She nodded like she respected the fight. âYouâre right. I donât. But I remember what it felt like to start asking.â
You hated that she wasnât trying to convince you. She wasnât pleading or desperate. She was sure of herself. And somehow that made you want to scream.
"That girl you were with?" Georgina said, like she was talking about the weather. âHow long until he figures out sheâs your Allen?â
That did it.
The stillness inside you shattered. cracked open, but you didnât let it show. Not fully. You blinked once, slowly. Steady. You sat back in your chair like her words hadnât just sliced you open.
You smiled. Not kindly.
âYou should be careful what you say.â
Georgina raised an eyebrow, unbothered.
âYou should stay away from me,â you said, each word colder than the last. âFrom all of us. We know where you live. We know what youâve been doing. Theyâre coming for you.â
Georgina only stood taller, something hard flickering in her eyes. She didnât look surprised. She didnât even look afraid.
âThen I guess Iâll have to get to them first,â she said lightly.
You stood, your chair scraping against the floor. The businesslike smile on your face was almost convincing. Almost.
âThis conversation never happened.â
Georgina simply stood before you. âYouâre right. It didnât.â
You walked past her without another word, back straight, fists clenched so tightly your nails bit into your palms. You don't breathe until you're down the stairs, past the annoying security guard, and out on the pavement of the street.
Your lungs finally drag in air like youâve been underwater. But itâs not relief. Not even close. Your head was spinning, your palms were sweating, and your pulse was still climbing.
You couldn't see straight, not really. You almost ran into three people crossing the sidewalk before you whip your head around, half expecting someone to grab you from behind.
And there she was.
Stupid red hair. Stupid sweatshirt. Stupid face that looked way too calm for someone who just followed you halfway across Manhattan.
âSeriously?â Your voice cracked. under the force of it. âWhat do you want?â
Natasha didn't flinch. She just stopped a few feet away, not moving closer.
âWhy did you follow me here?â you asked again, louder this time. âYou shouldnât be here.â
âI didnât know where you were going,â Natasha said evenly. âYou just left.â
âI had to,â you snapped. âI had to get out for work. Jesus, you donât get it.â
She took a step forward.
You backpedalled. âDonât.â
Natasha froze.
"Don't treat me like that," Natasha said quietly, the calm in her voice almost scarier than if sheâd yelled.
You let out a bitter laugh. âAs opposed to what? Iâm supposed to treat you like my friend? Like my girlfriend?â
Your voice cracked on the last word. You hated that.
Natasha's eyes narrowed, hurt flickered there, but she didnât rise to it. Instead, she stepped forward quickly and grabbed your wrist, tugging you into the narrow alley between buildings.
âLet go of meââ
âNo. Youâre freaking out and saying stuff you donât mean.â Her voice was low, urgent. âWhat happened in there?â
You yanked your arm free. âDonât touch me.â
But you didnât leave.
You leaned back against the wall, chest heaving, breath fogging in the night air even though it wasnât cold. Your hands went to your hair, gripping at the roots.
âShe works for SHIELD,â you said finally. âThatâs what the card was. Some kind of off-the-grid organization that helps girls like us disappear.â
Natashaâs brow furrowed. âSHIELD?"
You nodded. âGeorgina defected. Over a year ago. And Dreykov wants her gone. Thatâs why I was sent. Thatâs why we were sent.â
Natasha went still. âWait. Thatâs what this mission is?â
âShe knew my mother,â you added, your voice flat and distant now. âShe was supposed to get close to me. Gain my trust. Just like weâre trained to do.â
Natasha opened her mouth, but you steamrolled right through it.
"He knew. He fucking knew," you seethed.
You turned on her, fists clenching and unclenching, the words spilling over.
"And he sent us here to test us," You paced in circles. "He's not only testing you. He's testing me. He wants us to kill her. Ken and Karen are just here for show and..."
Before you could respond, Natasha moved forward and kissed you. You stopped in your tracks, frozen in place, but not at all fighting it.
"You do know this isn't a movie and kissing people to shut them up is weird?" You opened your eyes.
She didn't back down. "You do know I don't care?"
"You're not listening to me."
"I am listening." She paused. "But you need to calm down and stop talking."
You glared, but didn't pull away.
"Look, it's okay."
âNo. Itâs not,â you said again, this time with bite.
Natasha didnât flinch. She just stood there, hands low at her sides like she knew any sudden move would make things worse.
âHeâs going to find out,â you hissed. âAbout what she said. About what I know. About us.â
âYou donât know that.â
âI do,â you snapped. âI do know that. He always knows. Thatâs the point.â
You stepped back, needing air. Needing space.
âHeâs going to think Iâm compromised.â
Natashaâs voice was low. âThen we figure it out.â
âNo,â you said sharply, cutting her off. âDonât say anything. Donât try to fix this.â
She blinked.
âNot until I figure out what Iâm going to do.â
Your voice cracked at the edges, but you didnât let it break.
âI mean it,â you added. âDonât follow me next time. Donât ask me questions. Just give me space.â
Natasha didnât like it. You could see that.
But she didnât argue. She didnât step closer.
She just gave the slightest nod. âOkay.â














