Scenario or Headcanons of Tmnt (bayverse) x reader who is very friendly and affectionate (maybe crush or beginning of the relationship) but when she gets affection (the boys are e one starting it) she malfunctions? I’m talking getting clumsy, flustered, blushing, stuttering automatically, kinda comical tbh lol
Thank you and hope you have a good day!
ahh, thank you so much for the ask! :3 i hope i don't disappoint, so here goes nothing!! also, likes and reblogs are appreciated as usual ✩
pairings: (bayverse) leonardo x reader, raphael x reader, donatello x reader, and michelangelo x reader (gender neutral)
will include: fluff
while you're usually the more outgoing one in terms of affection, it's not an excuse for your favorite turtle to be reserved with his. in fact, he has his shining moments!
Leonardo
i personally see leo's favorite form of affection is through a kiss
you frequently give him kisses when you see each other and when you're about to part ways after spending time with each other
leo's favorite place to be kissed is on his cheek. he thinks it's sweet and endearing!
he still remembers the first time you did it to him
"See you tomorrow." Leo bows his head down shortly, before he meets your eye again. He turns his back around to make his jump down the fire exit to your apartment, but he feels you tap on his shell.
When he turns around, he's surprised at how swift you are to plant a kiss on his cheek. It was soft, and he wished it lasted longer.
"Goodnight, Leo." you grin, holding your chin up on your palm as you wave the turtle goodbye.
you know he enjoys the gesture, and you enjoy doing it too him as well. so, it's a win-win situation
until, one night, leo decided to turn the tables around you
You just finished brewing two cups of tea for you and Leo. You held the mugs and carefully made your way back to the dojo, where Leo was sitting and having trouble meditating. You offered to make him a cup of tea, and decided to make yourself one too.
"Here," you offer him his mug, "is your tea. I made sure to brew your favorite pack." You smile at him as he takes his cup from you.
"Thank you." He returns the smile. You hum, taking a seat next to him and blowing the steam away from your tea.
You didn't notice that Leo hadn't stopped looking at you.
You were so focused on drinking your tea, you didn't register that Leo had gently pulled your head towards him.
Then, you felt him kiss the top of your head.
Out of surprise, you spit your tea back in the cup abruptly. This backfires on you, because the hot liquid splashes you in the face and you shriek.
"Oh my mutagen, are you okay!?"
you were flustered that night. when leo usually gives you affection, it's in return of what you gave him
however, that day, he did it without you initiating it first- which is what caught you off guard
leo jokes and laughs about that night as much as he can, making your cheeks red from embarrassment
there is one more thing, however
"I still can't believe you actually spat back the tea over that." Leo finishes his sentence after a while of laughing, while you were busy covering your face and groaning into your hands.
"Leo, pleaaaaase. I beg you to forget about it." You whine, albeit muffled.
And since you were covering your face, you had fallen for the tricks of the mighty leader. Which is using this moment to press a kiss on your head again while pulling you close to him.
"Oh my gosh– Leo!" You uncover your red face to look up at him. He just smiles back before kissing you on the lips this time.
Raphael
i like to think that raphael loves callsigns. however, there are different types to these nicknames
there's obviously the nicknames he uses on the bad guys to demean them
then there's the nicknames he uses on his brothers to annoy them
then there's the nicknames he uses with you (yet)
you see, when you first met, you were already calling raph different things
"Hey, hotshot, could you grab me a slice?" You ask Raph from the couch, turning yourself around to give him a pretty smile.
or...
"Raphie, have you seen my history notebook?" You come up to his room where he was doing reps. He nearly dropped the weights on his feet, had you not exclaimed in time for him to jump away.
it came natural to you to call him special nicknames
and it made raph soft. it made him feel special, because you never called his brothers the things you called him: hotshot, big guy, raphie, and, his favorite, handsome
but raph never showed how soft it made him, of course, it would ruin his tough guy reputation!
he thinks about the names you call him at the end of the day when he's laying in his bed
and, one day, he wakes up with the same confidence as you
You were pissed from school today. Your partner for the project the teacher gave for the period wasn't helping you at all and, somehow, they got all the credit.
You were heading down the ladder to the lair and when you turn your head around, you see Raph lounging by the table and watching the tv from afar.
You hurriedly get down the ladder and start stomping your way to the turtle, ranting about your day. You were standing next to him and obviously fuming, until...
"Slow down, gorgeous/handsome. Grab a slice, won't ya?" He smirks, throwing one hand behind the seat.
Your rant comes to a stammer as you feel your cheeks heat up. You slowly turn your head to the turtle, pointing a finger at him.
"E-Excuse me?" You stutter.
"I said... Relax and grab a slice, sweetheart." Raph chuckles, standing up from his seat and helping you into tour own.
He even had to help you eat, because somehow you were messing up eating a pizza from how flustered you were. He also waited until you could properly function again.
Only to call you with another nickname.
Donatello
personally, i don't see donnie as verbally or physically affectionate as his brothers
however, he is a sucker for acts of services
and it just so happens that you enjoy doing stuff for donnie. handing him beakers, writing down notes when his hands are too occupied, and bringing over food and telling him to take a break
"Hey, the guys ordered pizza." You step back in his makeshift lab with a plate full of pizza for you two to share.
You take your seat next to Donnie, who was soldering wires together for a new machine he was making. You hum, tapping on the table gently to break him from his focus.
You learned to not tap on his shell from the last time. You nearly got spilled with deadly chemicals...
Eventually, he pushes up his goggles and meets your eyes. His face softens into a smile and you could feel your heart swell with joy.
"Time to take a break, Donnie." You tell him, watching him set aside his project before you place down the plate of food to share.
"Thanks," he says, "I really would miss more meals if you weren't around." He adds, grabbing a slice. You click your tongue while shaking your head.
and once you're out of the lair, the rest of his brothers (without missing) collectively turn their heads to the lab to hear the squeal that echoes through the entire sewer
he goes to bed at night thinking of all the things you did for him that day
sometimes, he wishes he had the confidence you had to treat you just as fair
however, it's as natural to him as it is to you
You squirm uncomfortably on your chair because it was wobbling. That's unusual, considering Donnie does his best to make his workspace as comfy as can be to enhance his focus.
Donnie seemed to notice how uncomfortable you were and paused on his work. "Here," he stands up from his seat and guides you onto it. "Sit on my chair for now." He smiles at you before facing his work again. "I have a big suspicion that Mikey broke my chair bouncing on it earlier." He clicks his tongue as he rolls his eyes.
"Uh-Uh huh..." You reply softly, cheeks turning red and body turning stiff. You were so in your head, screaming about what just happened, you didn't notice Donnie glancing at you when he asked you to reach for his solder.
He chuckles and taps on the table space in front of you to break you out of your daze. You do, but there is still blush on your cheeks. "Did I do something wrong?" He asks softly and you quickly shake your head.
Michelangelo
this one is a bit difficult to write, considering mikey is the most affectionate of his brothers- but i realized something
other than april, vern, and casey, you're the only other human he's ever interacted with! what makes you different is that, you're more affectionate compared to the other three
he's not used to it! you're so sweet that he ends up freezing on the spot whenever you run up and give him a hug, which he returns ofcourse! after some stammering...
"Oh, hey Mikey!!!" You spot him at the bottom of the ladder as you make your way down and call for his attention. He looks up and grins, waving at you.
"What's up, my favorite human!?" He greets you back with just as much enthusiasm.
"Come on, catch me!" You yell and jump off from the ladder with the widest smile.
Mikey panics and quickly stretches out his arms to catch you. When you land in his arms with no effort, aside from a small 'umph!' from you once you landed, you're giggling and wrapping your arms around his neck.
"Nice catch!" You tell him, giving him a pat on his shell before asking him to put you down. You walked away to greet the other turtles, leaving the orange masked turtle in shock.
because you're the first human to ever be affectionate to him, he isn't as confident as he thought he would be when it came to this type of situation!
he likes you, definitely. so when his brothers find out, they all just laugh it up by saying its just his nerves.
mikey 'psh's them and says he doesn't get nervous around you
but sometimes he gets caught in the moment
You recently bought a new game and wanted to play it with the turtles! You got down to the lair and immediately invited the first turtle you saw, which so happens to be your favorite turtle.
"Mikey-angelo, my guy!" You grin and jump your way over to the couch, where he was. He greets you with the same enthusiasm and you two share a high five.
You mention the game and the two of you don't waste a second in getting it set up and handing each other the controllers. It was a multiplayer game and you two had to work with each other to reach the set goals.
You two played for a while and after an hour or two, you finally defeated a boss for the mission. You cheer from your spot on the couch and turn to high five the turtle, but...
He cheers louder and gets up from his seat, grabs you by the sides, and lifts you up. He spins you around in joy, and you would join him in cheering, but there was one problem.
You're so surprised by this that your face turns red as you admire the turtle's face. He had the widest smile, and you can tell how relieved he is to have defeated that boss. He looked so happy.
When he opens his eyes, he stops spinning you when he realizes what he's done. He begins to stutter as he awkwardly sets you down, and you turn your head in hopes to calm your blush by not looking at him.
Then he brings back your attention by asking, "let's order pizza?" You quickly turn your head back and nod frantically. You go for your pocket to pull out your phone, but it slips from your hand.
Mikey watches as you comically keep trying to catch your phone, but it keeps slipping until it falls on the floor.
You two stare at each other for a while, but it ends with the two of you eventually laughing.
"Who knew you to be the touchy turtle, Mikey." You comment between chuckles.
"I am! I am the touchy one! I just get nervous!"










