To determine who Nine would hire as part of his villainous organization in a My Hero Academia universe where the League of Villains (LoV) either never existed or was defeated early, we need to consider Nine’s ideology, goals, and operational style as outlined in the provided documents, as well as the characteristics and motivations of potential villain recruits from the MHA universe. Nine, as the main antagonist from My Hero Academia: Heroes Rising, is a Social Darwinist who envisions a "superhuman society" where strength is the sole determinant of status, rejecting labels like "hero" and "villain." His original Quirk, Weather Manipulation, combined with an artificial, weaker version of All For One’s Quirk, allows him to steal and wield up to nine Quirks, making him a formidable force. His goal is to create a world where the powerful rule, and he seeks powerful Quirks to offset his cellular degeneration caused by his Weather Manipulation. His current crew—Slice, Chimera, and Mummy—reflects his preference for loyal, powerful allies who share his vision or have personal motivations aligning with his ideology.
In this speculative scenario, Nine would recruit villains who:
Possess powerful or versatile Quirks to bolster his arsenal or complement his own abilities.
Share his Social Darwinist ideology or have motivations that align with his vision of a strength-based hierarchy.
Are loyal and capable of working in a tight-knit group, as Nine is noted to be a benevolent boss who values his comrades’ loyalty.
Can help him achieve his short-term goal (acquiring Katsuma’s Cell Activation Quirk to treat his degeneration) and long-term goal (establishing a superhuman society).
Below, I’ll provide a thorough analysis of potential recruits from the list of villains in the second document (Untitled document (32).pdf), considering their Quirks, motivations, and compatibility with Nine’s vision. I’ll also speculate on how these recruits would integrate into his organization, their roles, and how they might influence the MHA universe’s narrative arcs and plots. The analysis will exclude LoV members (e.g., All For One, Tomura Shigaraki, Dabi, Himiko Toga, etc.) since the scenario assumes the LoV is nonexistent or defeated, and I’ll focus on independent villains, Meta Liberation Army (MLA) members, Shie Hassaikai, and other groups or individuals who could plausibly join Nine.
Potential Recruits for Nine’s Organization
1. Re-Destro (Meta Liberation Army)
Quirk: Stress (Transforms stress into physical power, enhancing strength and size)
Rank: A-Rank Villain (Arrested in canon)
Motivation: As the Grand Commander of the MLA, Re-Destro seeks to create a society where Quirks can be used freely, opposing hero society’s regulations. His ideology aligns closely with Nine’s vision of a world where strength reigns supreme, as both reject societal constraints and value power.
Why Nine Would Hire Him: Re-Destro’s powerful Quirk and leadership experience make him an ideal co-commander or strategist. His Stress Quirk complements Nine’s Weather Manipulation, providing raw physical power to counter close-range threats. His MLA resources (finances, networks, and followers) would expand Nine’s influence, allowing him to recruit more followers and fund operations. Re-Destro’s belief in Quirk supremacy aligns with Nine’s Social Darwinism, and his organizational skills could manage Nine’s growing empire.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Re-Destro would serve as a second-in-command, overseeing recruitment and logistics while using his Quirk in major battles. His ability to channel stress into power would make him a juggernaut in confrontations, complementing Nine’s long-range abilities.
Impact on the Universe: Re-Destro’s involvement would accelerate Nine’s plan to overthrow hero society, as the MLA’s influence could mobilize civilians with powerful Quirks. This would create a larger-scale conflict, akin to a civil war, forcing heroes to confront a unified villainous front rather than scattered groups. Arcs like the Paranormal Liberation War would be replaced by a "Superhuman Rebellion Arc," with Re-Destro rallying disenfranchised Quirk users to Nine’s cause.
2. Geten (Meta Liberation Army)
Quirk: Ice Ply (Manipulates ice with precision, creating massive constructs or attacks)
Rank: B-Rank Villain (Arrested in canon)
Motivation: Geten is a loyal MLA member who believes in the supremacy of strong Quirks. His dedication to Destro’s ideology and willingness to fight for Quirk freedom make him a natural ally for Nine.
Why Nine Would Hire Him: Geten’s Ice Ply Quirk is a perfect counterbalance to Nine’s Weather Manipulation, as he can manipulate ice to complement Nine’s storms, creating devastating environmental attacks (e.g., blizzards or ice-enhanced tornadoes). His combat prowess and loyalty to a cause make him a reliable soldier, and his heteromorphic prejudice (as implied by MLA’s views) aligns with Nine’s crew, particularly Chimera, who faced similar discrimination.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Geten would be a frontline combatant, using his ice constructs to control battlefields and support Nine’s Weather Manipulation. His tactical skills could also make him a field commander, leading smaller operations to steal Quirks or disrupt hero activities.
Impact on the Universe: Geten’s ice-based attacks would amplify Nine’s environmental destruction, making their battles more catastrophic. This could lead to new arcs focused on mitigating environmental damage, with heroes like Todoroki and Momo developing strategies to counter combined ice-storm assaults. Geten’s presence would also deepen the narrative’s exploration of Quirk-based prejudice, as his alliance with Chimera could highlight societal issues.
3. Overhaul (Shie Hassaikai)
Quirk: Overhaul (Deconstructs and reconstructs matter, including human bodies)
Rank: B-Rank Villain (Arrested in canon)
Motivation: Overhaul seeks to restore the Yakuza’s former glory and eradicate Quirks, believing they’ve corrupted society. While his anti-Quirk stance seems to conflict with Nine’s vision, his desire for a new societal order and his pragmatic approach to power could align with Nine’s goals if framed as a temporary alliance.
Why Nine Would Hire Him: Overhaul’s Quirk is exceptionally powerful, allowing him to heal, kill, or modify bodies instantly, making him a potential solution to Nine’s cellular degeneration (if Katsuma’s Quirk is unattainable). His strategic mind and leadership of the Shie Hassaikai would make him a valuable asset for planning and resource management. Nine could convince Overhaul by promising a role in the new superhuman society, where Overhaul’s control over matter could elevate him above others.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Overhaul would act as a strategist and medical expert, using his Quirk to heal Nine’s degeneration or enhance allies’ bodies. In combat, he’d be a precision striker, dismantling enemies or creating barriers. His Yakuza connections could provide black-market resources, such as illegal Quirk support gear.
Impact on the Universe: Overhaul’s involvement would introduce a darker, more surgical threat to hero society, with his ability to dismantle heroes instantly. This could lead to a "Yakuza Resurgence Arc," where Nine’s gang collaborates with remnants of the Shie Hassaikai to undermine heroes through targeted assassinations. Overhaul’s anti-Quirk ideology might create tension within Nine’s group, leading to a potential betrayal subplot, enriching the narrative with internal conflict.
Quirk: Bloodcurdle (Paralyzes targets by ingesting their blood)
Rank: Unknown (Deceased in canon)
Motivation: Stain, the Hero Killer, seeks to purge society of "false heroes" who lack true heroism, valuing strength and conviction. His extreme ideals align with Nine’s belief in a world where only the strong matter, though Stain’s moral code might clash with Nine’s pragmatism.
Why Nine Would Hire Him: Stain’s combat skills and Bloodcurdle Quirk make him a deadly assassin, capable of neutralizing heroes quickly. His ideology, while focused on heroism, could be swayed by Nine’s vision of a strength-based society, especially if Nine frames it as a way to eliminate unworthy heroes. Stain’s reputation would also inspire fear, boosting Nine’s influence.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Stain would be an enforcer and assassin, targeting high-profile heroes to weaken hero society. His stealth and combat prowess would complement Slice’s agility and Chimera’s brute force, creating a balanced attack unit.
Impact on the Universe: Stain’s alliance with Nine would intensify the ideological battle, forcing heroes to confront their own values. An "Ideological War Arc" could emerge, with Stain’s actions inspiring vigilantes or rogue heroes to question hero society, creating a schism. His eventual conflict with Nine over methods (e.g., harming innocents) could lead to a dramatic showdown, adding depth to the narrative.
5. Gentle Criminal and La Brava (Independent)
Gentle Criminal: Elasticity (Makes surfaces elastic, allowing for unpredictable movements)
La Brava: Love (Boosts the power of someone she loves)
Rank: C-Rank (Formerly villains, reformed in canon)
Motivation: Gentle Criminal seeks fame through "honorable" crimes, presenting himself as a gentleman thief, while La Brava supports him out of love. Their desire for recognition could align with Nine’s vision if he offers them a platform to showcase their strength.
Why Nine Would Hire Them: Gentle’s Elasticity Quirk is versatile for evasion and environmental control, complementing Nine’s battlefield dominance. La Brava’s Love Quirk could amplify Nine’s power significantly, making him nearly unstoppable during key battles. Their loyalty to each other ensures they’d be reliable if Nine earns their trust.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Gentle would serve as a tactical operative, using his Quirk for stealth missions or to disrupt hero strategies. La Brava would be a support member, boosting Nine or other key fighters during critical moments. Their media-savvy nature could also help Nine spread his ideology through viral propaganda.
Impact on the Universe: Gentle and La Brava’s involvement would add a theatrical element to Nine’s operations, with their crimes broadcasted to undermine hero credibility. A "Propaganda War Arc" could see them manipulating public perception, forcing heroes to counter Nine’s growing influence. Their potential redemption (as in canon) could create a subplot where they defect, providing heroes with crucial intel.
6. Lady Nagant (Independent/Former Pro Hero)
Quirk: Rifle (Transforms her arm into a sniper rifle, with self-made bullets)
Rank: Unknown (Formerly arrested, defected in canon)
Motivation: Lady Nagant, a former hero turned villain, was disillusioned by the Hero Public Safety Commission’s (HPSC) corruption, leading her to defect. Her skills and cynicism make her a candidate for Nine’s cause, especially if he offers her a chance to dismantle the corrupt hero system.
Why Nine Would Hire Her: Lady Nagant’s sniper abilities and Rifle Quirk make her a perfect long-range assassin, complementing Nine’s Weather Manipulation for coordinated attacks. Her experience as a hero gives her insider knowledge of hero tactics, making her invaluable for strategic planning. Her disillusionment aligns with Nine’s rejection of hero-villain labels.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Lady Nagant would be a covert operative, eliminating key heroes from a distance and gathering intelligence. Her professionalism would balance the more chaotic tendencies of Nine’s crew, ensuring efficient operations.
Impact on the Universe: Lady Nagant’s involvement would expose hero society’s corruption, deepening public distrust. A "Hero Betrayal Arc" could focus on her targeting former colleagues, forcing heroes like Hawks to confront their past. Her potential redemption (as in canon) could lead to a climactic moment where she turns against Nine, aiding the heroes.
7. Kuin Hachisuka (Villain Factory)
Quirk: Queen Bee (Controls a swarm of explosive bees)
Rank: Unknown (Part-time villain, status unclear in canon)
Motivation: Kuin operates as a part-time villain while posing as a high school girl, suggesting a flexible approach to villainy. Her willingness to work for the Villain Factory indicates she’s open to alliances for personal gain or chaos.
Why Nine Would Hire Her: Kuin’s Queen Bee Quirk offers versatile, unpredictable attacks, complementing Nine’s large-scale destruction. Her ability to operate covertly (as a student) makes her ideal for espionage or infiltration. Nine could appeal to her thrill-seeking nature, offering her a role in his grand vision.
Role in Nine’s Organization: Kuin would be a scout and saboteur, using her bees for reconnaissance or to disrupt hero operations. Her youthful persona could infiltrate U.A. or other hero institutions, gathering intel on potential Quirk targets.
Impact on the Universe: Kuin’s covert operations would add a layer of paranoia to hero society, as her ability to blend in makes her a hidden threat. A "Spy Game Arc" could see heroes struggling to identify her, leading to increased security at U.A. Her erratic nature might also create tension within Nine’s group, adding internal drama.
Integration into Nine’s Organization
Nine’s current crew—Slice (prehensile hair), Chimera (animal-based Quirks), and Mummy (mummification)—is small but effective, with each member bringing unique skills. The new recruits would expand this dynamic:
Leadership Structure: Nine would remain the supreme leader, with Re-Destro and Overhaul as co-strategists, managing operations and resources. Lady Nagant and Stain would handle covert and assassination missions, while Geten, Gentle, and Kuin form a versatile combat and espionage unit.
Nine’s Weather Manipulation and Geten’s Ice Ply create devastating environmental attacks.
Overhaul’s precision and Stain’s paralysis complement Slice’s agility and Chimera’s brute force.
Gentle and La Brava provide support and propaganda, while Kuin’s bees add unpredictability.
Ideological Cohesion: Most recruits share Nine’s belief in strength or disdain for hero society, though Overhaul and Stain’s differing views could spark conflict, enriching the narrative with internal power struggles.
The expanded roster would reshape MHA’s narrative:
Superhuman Rebellion Arc: Re-Destro and Geten’s MLA connections would mobilize a large-scale rebellion, challenging hero society’s foundations. Heroes like Midoriya and Endeavor would face moral dilemmas about Quirk regulations.
Covert Operations Arc: Lady Nagant and Kuin’s espionage would force heroes to adopt defensive strategies, with arcs focusing on counterintelligence and protecting U.A. students.
Ideological Clash Arc: Stain’s presence would spark debates about heroism, with characters like Iida and Todoroki confronting his ideals. Gentle and La Brava’s propaganda would amplify public unrest.
Medical Crisis Arc: Overhaul’s pursuit of Katsuma’s Quirk, combined with his own healing abilities, would create a race against time to protect the Shimano siblings, with heroes developing new strategies to counter his Quirk.
Climactic Battle Arc: The final confrontation would see Nine’s full roster—bolstered by La Brava’s Love Quirk—facing Class 1-A and pro heroes. Midoriya and Bakugo’s shared One For All moment (as in Heroes Rising) would be the decisive factor, symbolizing unity against Nine’s divisive ideology.
Nine would hire villains like Re-Destro, Geten, Overhaul, Stain, Gentle Criminal, La Brava, Lady Nagant, and Kuin Hachisuka to form a formidable organization. Their powerful Quirks, aligned motivations, and diverse skill sets would enhance Nine’s ability to pursue his superhuman society and counter his cellular degeneration. This roster would shift MHA’s narrative toward ideological warfare, environmental destruction, and covert operations, creating a darker, more complex universe. The interplay between these villains’ motivations and Nine’s vision would add depth to the story, with potential betrayals and redemptions shaping the heroes’ journey.
