Ā @goblins-riddles-or-frocks replied to your post:Sunday Snippet
I love this!! I think my favorite take on these two is just throwing them together post r&r and seeing how they claw their way out of their respective traumas. and idk second choice romance is so poignant to me.
I love what a gut punch it is for her to say āI thought I wasā there. where do you even go from that! especially after already getting married, and the nature of royalty being what it is I get not knowing how to resolve it tho, Iām stalling on pretty much the same issue myself alas
Ahhh, thank you!! I love the dynamic between these two, and doubly so during and post R&R. They have #CompatibleTraumas, and I think itās a lot of fun to explore the ways the charactersā traumas and emotional needs interactāboth for better and for worse.Ā
And yesĀ to your statement about second choice/second chance romances!
IMO, even more than her feelings for Mal or the Darkling, the main obstacle to canon Nikolai/Alina isĀ that canon!Alina is unsuited for life as a political figure. From a Doylist perspective, this unsuitability boils down toĀ Bardugoās desire to have Alina end her story by returning to Keramzin with Mal at her sideāan ending that wouldnāt work anymore if Alina was allowed to fully grow into her leadership role.Ā
I think youāre the person Iāve discussed this with before, but while I understand what Bardugo was trying to narratively achieve, and I donāt wholly disagree with it, it still frustrates me to see Alina start to reach her potential, only to repeatedly have it cut off and watch her start from scratch over and over again. Iāll freely admit that this is a matter of personal preference as much as it is objective critique!Ā
Iām sure a thousand metas have been written about how Alinaās different love interests symbolize different parts of herself and different paths she could have taken, but it always hits me anew each time I think about her canonical relationships.
I feel like Nikolai could respond to Alinaās accusations by retreating behind hisĀ āperfect princeā veneer, or he could be emotionally open with her, as he has been in the past. Likewise, I can see Alina either retreating from him or having a real conversation with him. Despite the rocky start to their acquaintance, the two of them have been pretty low-drama together when it comes to the personal stuff!
Yeah, the nature of royalty means divorce or even an official separation arenāt really optionsāespecially not without the existence of an heir and a spare!āwhich would only make Alina feel more trapped. That said, I can see Alina going on a PR tour/diplomatic trip/secret mission by herself (albeit accompanied by guards/friends) as a solution of sorts, as that would temporarily give her space from Nikolai, the palace, and her ordinary duties. Likewise, I think it would help Alina if she did more work with the common people, as thatās something that feeds her soul in the same way working with the nobility drains her.Ā
The role of queen canāt be completely changed without creating problems for the Lantsov reign, especially since Nikolai came to the throne under the circumstances he did, but I think Alina and he could get away with tweaking it some. Alinaās sainthood would aid them in this, as it lets conservatives write her off as the exception rather than the rule, while also gradually accustoming everyone to a different type of queenship.
That said, I think my resolution might simply be adding Zoya into the mix (and potentially moving the entire sceneĀ into my WIP Nikolai/Zoya/Alina fic).Ā
Zoya tosses her dark, glossy curls back. āSelf-pity isnāt a good look on you, Starkov.ā
āNone of us forced you to stay; no one forced you to marry Nikolai. This was your choice. And now you want to quit because, what, itās too hard?ā She sniffs derisively. āIf youāre going to run away, do it now before youāve established yourself any further. Iām sure someone will step up to fill your place.ā
Alina sputters, furious. āIāIām not running away.ā
Even if I wanted to, I have nowhere left to go.
āIf you say so.ā Her tone is infuriatingly, airily dismissive. āBut then, thatās your modus operandi, isnāt it? Running away when things get too real?ā
āIām not a coward,ā Alina spits back.
Zoya smiles, all teeth and disdain. āThen prove it.ā