Narset Transcendent was one of the most exciting and hyped card of all of Dragons of Tarkir. People were freaking out over this card saying how powerful she is and how much she was going to have an impact on Standard and Modern. Possibly even Legacy, even though thatās crazy because Legacy already has a 4-mana planeswalker that is leagues better than this one. But where does Narset actually belong in Standard. (Weāre not going to get into Modern because anything like that would be too much of a stretch)
Since her release, thereās been two main decks that have utilized Narset, U/W or Ojutai Control and Esper Control. This seems reasonable as both of those decks play a large number of spells that would be totally reasonable to draw or rebound. But in this deck she still has her own number of problems. One of which is that she will rarely be played on turn 4 in any control deck, as she will usually end up dying very quickly, and since when has a control deck EVER want to be tapped out as early as turn 4? Sure it may be reasonable in formats where you can back her up with a good olā FoW, but really? No. And the other problem is that she, in a vacuum, will not when you the game. Yes, she will generate card advantage, which will help you win games that go long, but she herself will not win the game. To compare, think about Elspeth, Sunās Champion, or Xenagos the Reveler, or even Kiora, the Crashing Wave. Simply stopping your opponent from casting noncreature spells isnāt going to win you the game most of the time as most decks in Standard are very creature based. So she doesnāt really fit in there all that well, and in the IQ I attended this past Saturday I was able to observe her in action in such decks, and she seemed very underwhelming, many of those decks were at the bottom tables.
So where else could she go? Well, the honest only other deck where she would seem at home would be Jeskai Tokens. Most of the creatures in the deck are made from noncreature spells and being able to have access to more of them is always a good thing. But that deck usually curves out at 4, and thatās usually for Stoke the Flames (or 8 for Treasure Cruise if you want to be picky, but you ever cast this for more than 3 it feels bad anyways). So is Narset really something that deck would want in the 4 mana slot?
So what do you guys think? I know public opinion of this card was high, but I want to hear your opinion, so lay it on me.