Cater Diamond for the character meme
ACCEPTINGย โย Give Me a Character;
How I feel about this character
Love him to bits. I've written him myself before, but my muse for him tends to fluctuate heavily. I relate to him in a lot of ways ( the blatantly obvious depression, the overcompensating, the ' persona ' he puts on for others ), so he's comforting for me. Of course his text speech ( actually saying ' lol ' out loud my god ) is hilarious and so is the aforementioned persona, but I really appreciate the side of his character that he hides underneath and all of the little hints that he gives us every so often that he's not doing as well as he seems. To me, it feels like he thinks he won't have anything to offer anyone if he isn't always easygoing and fun caykun, a reliable and friendly upperclassman, an entertaining and easygoing friend, and prepared to offer up a quip or a joke ( even self-deprecating ) at all times for the sake of a laugh. I don't know - he gives me a lot of feelings. I wish things were easier for him. I'm sad that he struggles to find his identity and be satisfied with it. But I do love the parallels between that particular trait of his and his unique magic. Wonderful character trivia.
All the people I ship romantically with this character
ririkei / lilicay: I love the idea of immortals falling in love with humans, I always have. And there's something about the idea of Cater and Lilia falling for each other with Cater not even knowing Lilia's real identity as a high ranking general for the Valley, OR that he's Silver's father, OR how old he is. Lilia struggling with that and having to figure out when and how to tell him because he doesn't want to lose him...that kind of thing is SO good. But all of that aside I also really enjoy their canon interactions, and I love how they're in the same club and seem to really like spending time together. Idk there's just something I really like about these two for some reason.
idekei / idicay: popular boy and borderline hikikomori. Must I say more? It's a good ship. I saw some fan art awhile back about Idia messaging his discord kitten in front of Cater and then Cater's phone chiming, which KILLED me. They have awesome potential as being the funniest ship ever, but I also think Cater could really be himself around someone like Idia and not feel pressured or judged by it which would be a pretty big deal. I'd love to see it.
My non-romantic OTP for this character
Riddle and Cater. I love the way Cater jumps to Riddle's side, ready to help him whenever he needs it, and even when he doesn't ask for it. Even when he was at his worst point and embodying his most tyrannical self pre-overblot, Cater stuck with him, which I think is really lovely, especially because imo Riddle has a hard time feeling like he can give a title to his relationships with others, or figure out the depths of them, but like Trey, Cater has created an inability for their relationship to be anything other than true ' friends ' with his loyalty and his genuine concern. Even when the rest of the dorm turned on him, Cater was trying to defend him, which says a lot. Trey did it because they have a long and complicated history, but he and Riddle presumably only met the year before when Riddle entered NRC. Riddle is unpopular, and clearly disliked in their dorm, but even though it went completely against Cater's character and his never-ending chase of popularity and being as well-liked as possible, he stuck with Riddle. So, I thought that was great. I also love how he kind of has an unofficial position as Riddle's third-in-command. He and Trey always seem to be following after Riddle together, rather than just Trey himself ( the vice housewarden ). As for Riddle's contributions - the fact that he took the time to learn Magicam ( no easy feat for him ) and use it to create a way to help Cater study says it all for me. He doesn't put in that type of work for everyone, and he definitely doesn't change his way of tutoring to suit the individual. I think they both care about each other very much, and I think that's wonderful.
I also love Kalim and Cater, Trey and Cater, and Che'nya and Cater. The first two bc they're obviously ppl he considers close friends, and the last one bc that's my ideal chaotic duo haha.
My unpopular opinion about this character
I guess that I don't think he's as 2-D as some ppl make him out to be? Idk.
One thing I wish would happen / had happened with this character in canon.
I have a few things, actually. I talked a lot about his relationship with Riddle up above, but I'd like to know how that kind of loyalty became established in the first place, and why Cater would go against his natural behavior and interests to stand by Riddle ( even when it affects his own image ).
Maybe this is corny, but I'd also like to see some of the other characters start to notice that there's something wrong with him/he's struggling in ways they didn't realize before. I want him to get the recognition and help he deserves!
I'd also love to learn more about his mental state and the progression from wanting as many friends as possible while being lonely moving around so often as a child to creating this carefully crafted and researched persona of his and this desperation for popularity. I want to know how exactly it happened and what was the catalyst for him essentially losing his real identity.