LYNZ PRETENDED TO BE INDIAN
In 2012, Lindsey caught the attention of fans by claiming to have half French and half Indian ancestry. The post remains on her Twitter. As soon as an Indian MCR account started interacting, so did the lies.
Let's look at some things that are indeed problematic when lying about your ancestry:
First of all, it all started when she did a survey on a kind of , to test her ancestry, nothing out of the ordinary so far. The big problem was her creating a narrative and then expanding the story from there, like saying she had a grandmother in Kashmir, that she knew how to read a language older than Hindi, and that one day he would visit his "roots".
Well, as soon as I made that post on Instagram, several Indian fans came to tell me that she got several things wrong, such as the fact that she didn't even know what she was talking about when she posted a a sentence in that language she claimed to be such an expert in
Furthermore, she also said that she was adopted. The problem with trying to say something that isn't true is that many people may end up identifying with your story. Many fan accounts, which she follows, began to spread the narrative that she was adopted. The same account there was a post She also included a photo in which she claimed it was Lindsey herself with her real mother.
The whole story was denied by her sister, Amy.
So, a certain account here that simply said exactly what her fervent fans wanted to hear, this tried to create a narrative that Lindsey was just joking because she removed the information from websites that track your ancestry. And to my surprise, she tried to say that this same criticism from fans didn't happen when her husband, Gerard Way, had also taken a quiz around the same time where he said he was Spanish. Let me explain a few things that make this comparison inconsistent:
Let's say Gerard had taken the test that revealed he was half Spanish. Imagine Gerard saying his grandmother was from Catalonia, a place fighting for independence and living in conflict, and that his dream was to see the infamous bullfights, and that he knows how to read a language older than Spanish, which is Latin. Would you believe it? Would you be moved by his story that Gerard suddenly wasn't more Scottish and half Italian, and yes, half British and half Spanish. Does that make him any less white? Definitely not.
Saying you're Spanish doesn't carry the same weight as saying you're Indian. Spain is part of Europe, and it's one of the countries that has been most involved in the process of colonization throughout the centuries (Latinos and people from Southeast Asia can attest to that). India is a country with a predominantly Aryan Indo that suffered greatly at the hands of British colonization; it carries a lot of weight if you decide that you come from a certain background Asian, without even knowing the basics of the country where you invented the A story of ancestry, and all this because of an internet quiz. Furthermore, if you're going to lie about your story, make sure you at least know basic geography.
The fact that she even fabricated a story about having a grandmother in Kashmir is almost comical. With so many places in India to mention, she chooses one that isn't even entirely part of India? (For the uninitiated, Kashmir is a place that borders Pakistan, Afghanistan, India, and China, and is constantly fighting for civil independence), and remembers the passage from "that" blog that said that There was no problem with her saying her grandmother was from there, since according to the author "they don't even consider themselves Indian"? That's true, but she forgot to mention that, the vast majority of this population is Muslim (She probably thought of Led Zeppelin's music called Kashmir when she tried to invent the lore of her ancestry) swapped one ethnicity for another...
" But then why would she lie about being Indian?"
Well, this invention happened while she was still on tour with MSI in October 2012. She must have thought: "And if I say that I'm not as white as I look, people will leave me alone and stop questioning the 'sarcastic' lyrics."
The important thing was to show that she did this narrative that somehow, she wasn't a 100% white and privileged person, but rather that she had a little bit of that "a person of color," and meanwhile, his band wouldn't stop putting us on that horror show against Black people with their "sarcastic lyrics, but if you don't understand, you're the one who's a idiot" (Didn't Urine once say that he had Mexican ancestry even though he was born in New York, and therefore thought he had the right to speak the Nword?)
The fact is that, just six months after this incredible discovery made by the Indian Mcrmy account, he tried to talk to Lindsey again, but since she thought Lindsey was an expert in speaking in Sanskrit, she decided to offer a simple greeting in that language, thinking Lindsey would understand easily, but...
Well, Google Translate existed back then at least...
Well, in 2020, when Lindsey Way was trying to return to Instagram, she received a barrage of criticism about the lies she told over time, and someone sent her a DM asking about her saying she was Indian and French. This was her response.
Even though she made a Twitter thread during the BLM movement that year acknowledging that she was a white person, months later she was still lying about her ancestry.