That fucking thing Ray Bradbury was talking about
/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\Dooom! Dooom! Dooom!/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/apr/27/vetting-for-stereotypes-meet-publishings-sensitivity-readers
âVetting for stereotypes: meet publishing's 'sensitivity readers'
Publishers hoping to avoid offence are increasingly turning to sensitivity readers. But is this good practice, censorship, or just another way of maintaining privilege?
When reviewers first saw Keira Drakeâs The Continent, this story of a teenager trapped by a war between two ânativeâ tribes quickly found attention on social media â though not much of it was good. This young adult novel was attacked for its âwhite saviour narrativeâ and its stereotypical portrayal of people with âreddish-brown skinâ or âalmond-shaped eyesâ. The author Justina Ireland called it a âracist garbage fireâ.
Drake apologised, said she would âaddress concerns about the novelâ, and delayed the release. Her publisher, Harlequin Teen, sent the book out to two âsensitivity readersâ, who vetted the manuscript for stereotypes, biases and problematic language. Armed with a list of potential problems and possible solutions, Drake went back to the drawing board.
Itâs a story that has become all too familiar in recent years as publishers and writers struggle to adapt to a new world where cultural appropriation and racial stereotyping are called out online, and where campaigns such as We Need Diverse Books push for a corrective to the lack of books featuring people of colour (POC).
According to Debbie Reese, an academic who focuses on the representation of Native Americans in childrenâs books, many authors arenât as receptive as Hecker. Reese dabbled in being a sensitivity reader in 2016, charging $100 an hour, but stopped.
âI quit doing them because they were exhausting and sometimes authors wanted to argue with me,â she says. âThey werenât open to the feedback. They werenât trying to understand the feedback. They were insisting on the rightness of what they were writing.â
Sometimes, sheâd find herself highlighting problematic words or phrases such as âlow man on the totem poleâ â a term which is sometimes used to describe people with little status. âIâd say that was a misrepresentation of an item originating with a specific nation. That hierarchy isnât applicable. The phrase is used a lot but it is what generally gets called âaÂ
And now, Bradburyâs Coda.
/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\Dooom! Dooom! Dooom!/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\