Modern Inheritance: Not Your Fault (Arya to Eragon)
A part of the 2024 Modern Inheritance Whimsical Whumps of Winter prompt challenge! This is a mix of the prompt Nightmares (Eragon) and Not Your Fault (Arya to Eragon). Prompts are still open so feel free to submit a request via reply, dm, ask or reblog!
I tried my best but I don't think it's exactly what you were looking for @thearunadragon so I apologize in advance. You could look at this as a bit of a tie in to the previously established story far earlier in the timeline (as this story takes place in the weird and wild extended war area and the story I'm about to mention is immediately post-Brisingr) Collateral as it deals with some similar topics.
Anyways, on to it!
TW: Mentions of child death, civilian death in warzones, soft target deaths and general war trauma. ~~~ Eragon pries himself from his Waking Dreams, haunted by the specters of civilians lost in a recent battle where he was the leader. Unable to bring himself to tell Saphira of another guilt she does not fully understand, the young Rider finds himself aimlessly wandering the Varden's camp, followed by his Waking Dreams, until he comes upon Arya having her own moment alone on a cold night. ~~~
âCan IâŠâ Movement in the corner of his vision stopped Eragonâs question dead. The little girl was still there, staring at him with wide, frozen eyes.Â
âYou said we were safe there!â Her voice wasnât accusing. Shit, sometimes he preferred when they were aggressive, so he could push back and not feel so ashamed of it. But sheâ âVivian.â he remembered with a hollow pang, the screams of the childâs mother echoing through his skull âVivian always sounded so small and terrified. Confused. âYou said we were going to be okay!â
Eragon closed his eyes and forced himself to breathe. The icy air stung his nose and crackled in his lungs. Even with the world shut out for a moment, he could still see the ghost of his Waking Dreams there. Off to the side still. Clutching at the gore soaked fabric of her woolen dress where shards of metal had shorn the cloth away to reveal destroyed flesh beneath.Â
âCan I sit with you?â
Arya gave him one of her half quirked grins. âThought we were past you having to ask.â With a sweep of her hand the woman cleared the thin layer of snow that had collected on the frozen ground beside her. âAll yours.â
Eragon did his best to return the smile despite the child weeping in the corner of his eye. âThanks.âÂ
âAnytime.âÂ
They sat together in silence. At least, it was mostly silent. Even at night the sounds of the Vardenâs camp continued, subdued by the decrease of alert inhabitants and muffled by the thin blanket of snow falling around the tents.Â
And of course, it wasnât silent for Eragon. Somehow Garrow had entered his Waking Dreams, admonishing the little girl for getting so messy, telling her in clipped tones that Eragon couldnât be everywhere at once, so stop whining that he let her die. After all, he let his own uncle die, the man who raised him, so howâ
âWho are you seeing?âÂ
Eragon jolted at Aryaâs voice, his head snapping to locate the sound despite her proximity. The elf turned the page of the small book she had splayed open on the fingers of one hand, entirely nonchalant. When the Rider did not answer, she repeated her question. âWho are you seeing?â
The young man worked his mouth, trying to find words. How could she tell? âIâm not sure I understand yourââ
âIf I donât get to lie to you about my shitshow nights, then you donât get to lie to me about yours.â Marking her spot with a finger, Arya closed the book and turned her head to look him dead in the eye. Ah. Of course she could recognize it. âIf you donât want to talk about it, thatâs fine. Iâm not going to force you.â
Eragon couldnât tell if it was relief that rushed into his chest, or another wave of hurt. There he went, worrying the people around him again.Â
He had so, so many people he could go to that would meet him with understanding and support. Brom, Glenwing, Roran, even Nasuada and Katrina had all comforted him in their own ways when he had confessed his troubles to them in confidence. Not to mention Saphira, his Partner of Heart and Mind, his everything, his other half!Â
And yet somehow, sometimes, none of them completely understood. Even Saphira, who did all she could to give him comfort and clarity, did not always understand how he felt about the war. About the lives taken, intentionally or not. The others did, in their own way. Everyone experienced it differently after all.Â
But this was Arya. Arya, who had joined the war at what was considered the elven equivalent of the age Eragon had found himself swept into the conflict. Who, at least from what he had learned, spent more nights awake than most grappling with her own feelings of how her actions affected those around her, and how to best take the weight off the shoulders of her comrades in arms. Duty and sense of right and wrong clashing with what needed to be done, making the choice and living with it.Â
Maybe that was why he came to her, after all. Not Saphira, nor Brom, Glen, Roran. To her, the only other person who might truly, fully understand where this pain, this guilt, was coming from.Â
His shaky breath out spawned a cloud of mist in the air before him. âIâve beenâŠhaving nightmares again.âÂ
âVisions?â
âNo.â Eragon shook his head. âNothing like that. JustâŠâ He bit his tongue as Vivianâs crying reached a hysterical pitch. âThe wolves. In my head again.âÂ
Arya did not respond with words. Instead, Eragon felt warmth hovering over the back of his hand and flicked his gaze down to find that the elf had hesitantly reached out to him. He gave her a tiny nod and her fingers settled over his, a point of contact for him to follow should he fall.Â
âI keep thinking about the last mission. That town.â Vivian abruptly stopped crying at Aryaâs touch. She vanished into the softly falling snow, Garrow following her, as Eragon finally shook off the final dregs of waking sleep with his continued speech. âI knowâŠI know we did everything we could to get the civilians out of the way, butâŠâ His voice caught suddenly. âThe little girl. And all the others. So many of them died.â
âI canât stop thinking thatâŠâ Eragon swallowed, the next words thick in his throat. A grim confession, an admittance of his guilt. âThat she died, and the others died, because we were there.â The young man tightened his grip on his knees, fighting to contain the tears that welled up. âThat fight wouldnât have happened if we werenât there. And it wouldnât have gotten so out of control if Saphira and I werenât there. Itâs my fault.â
Arya did not answer immediately. The elf took a moment to properly mark the page she had held with her finger and set the book aside before she leaned her head against the rock at their backs. Eragon took no offense at her pause, having long ago come to understand that when Arya took her time it was out of sincere care for the subject at hand.Â
She took a long, calming breath in before letting it steam out of her nose in twin clouds of vapor in the chilled air.Â
âYour logicâŠâ Arya began slowly. âIs not inherently wrong.â Eragonâs stomach sank. She must have caught his dropped expression, because the woman put her hand out in a gesture of calm. âHold on. Let me finish. Your logic is not inherently wrong, but it only takes into account a single moment.â
Arya held her extended hand up and curled it into a fist, her thumb extended to the side. âYes. That fight would not have happened if the Varden had not sent us there. However, the Varden would not have sent us there if the Broddring soldiers were not sent there to conscript all the men in that town for Galbatorixâs army.â She raised her pointer finger. âThe need for more men to be conscripted to Galbatorixâs army would not have happened had the Varden not engaged the Empire in full scale war.â Another finger joined the others. âThe Varden would not have engaged the Empire in full scale war had Galbatorix not sent the Urgals to Farthen DĂ»r to attack the resistance at its heart.â Again, another.Â
âEragon, I could go on and on and on.â Arya dropped her hand. âI can go back over a hundred years, to the day that Galbatorix and Jarnunvösk chose to enter the Spine knowing full well that it was Urgal territory and arrogantly considered themselves untouchable despite the known risks.âÂ
Eragon wiped his eyes. Even as the woman spoke, he felt the lump in his throat rising. âThatâs true. But I still gave the orders that day. IâŠIâm the one who told the families to hide in that part of town, even thoughââ
âEragon. Stop.â Rough palms settled on his cheeks, gently turned the young Rider to face her. Aryaâs eyes shone in the darkness, flickers of familiar pain that Eragon was sure he would see had he found a mirror that night. âEnough. It was not your fault. This war, it is not your fault.âÂ
âButââ
âShush.â Soft but commanding, Arya silenced him with a finger to his lips. âIt is not your fault, and it is not Saphiraâs fault, that you both were thrown into this war. This war was made by a man who never took time nor responsibility for his grief and instead decided to inflict it on the world.Â
Every day, since the day I met you, I have seen you and Saphira take action.â She lifted his chin, swiped away a tear with her thumb. âAnd every time, I see you both consider the consequences in all that you do. You came into this war as children, forced into it without a choice in the matter, and you both have learned and grown so much despite your circumstances.âÂ
Eragon swallowed hard and tried to shake his head. Saphira, he would agree, had taken on her role like a fish to water, likeâŠwell, like a dragon to the skies. But him? The scruffy farm boy, the fool who had not only taken part in battles where hundreds of lives had been lost, but the imbecile who had cursed an innocent babe, had failed to save so many, hadâ
Aryaâs voice took on a brittle tone for a brief moment. âEragon, if you keep disagreeing with me right now while Iâm trying to comfort you and explain this, I swear Iâll have Saphira relocate the cook tentâs viscera pile to your bedroll. Am I clear?âÂ
Oh, he did not doubt her in the slightest. He summoned his will to, at the very least, bite his tongue and nodded.
âGood. Now. I have met countless men and women three times your age and more, who hold the lives of their troops in their hands, and they did not even consider what could happen when they give their orders and make their choices. They didnât even give time to the idea of thinking any of it over! But you and Saphira do.âÂ
Arya gave him a soft smile. âSo I know. I know neither of you intend to hurt anyone you donât have to. You try so hard to keep the civilians out of it. You set clear, hard boundaries and fight for them when they are tested or broken. But warâŠfuck, war hurts. It hurts everyone. And if you didnât feel some guilt then Iâd honestly be more worried about you than I constantly am!
âEragon, it is not your fault that war did what war does. You and Saphira did everything in your power to try and keep those people safe. You stacked the deck in their favor and yet war decided to say âfuck youâ and snapped a cable in some shitty old Broddring artillery that shouldnât have even been there and shouldnât have been aimed into a town allied with its owners and sent a fucking cannonbomb into what happened to be the same area we, yes, we, agreed to shelter the civilians while we rooted out the soldiers.âÂ
Arya released her grip on his face and shifted her hands to his shoulders. âEragon. It was not your fault.â She shook him gently. âSay it.â
âIââ
âSay. It. Donât you call me a liar to my face. Say âWar sucks. Itâs not my fault.ââ
Eragon dropped his gaze. âWar sucks. Not my fault.â
âSay it again and maybe Iâll hear it this time.â
He breathed in. Breathed out. âWar sucks. Itâs not my fault.â
âOne more time and maybe Iâll believe you.â
That quirked a tiny smile at the edges of his lips. Hell. He was starting to believe it himself. âWar sucks. Itâs not my fault.â
The elf pulled him closer after the words left his mouth and, in one of the favorite little gestures they shared, pressed their foreheads together. No words were spoken, just a thread of relief that passed between them in the contact. His relief at the confirmation of his lack of guilt, and hers at his understanding of what she tried to convey.
And then Arya drew back and settled against the rock again, shoulders squared. The posture told the Rider multitudes. Eragon was with her, and he needed help. Arya was protecting him, alert, watchful, that vigilance colored with warm care towards her friend. Not quite On Duty, but happily taking him on to keep his demons, real or imagined, at bay.Â
He couldnât have asked for a better friend.
Eragon sniffed one final time and rubbed away the last traces of tears on his face. He already knew her answer from the way she had shifted, but he always felt the need to ask. "Can...Can I stay here? I don't want to worry Saphira. She'd understand better if she finds you watching me."
"You can stay, but only if you get in here. Iâm fucking freezing." Never taking her eyes off the tents around them, Arya lifted her arm so that her cloak opened to him, gathered warmth spilling out into the chill night. "Come on."
The easy smile she gave him was all he needed in that vulnerable moment. Eragon scooted over and let the elf drape her arm over his shoulders and rearrange the warm fabric so that it wrapped around them both. A gentle squeeze had him leaning into her side. He tucked his legs up to where he had pulled his arms and fists under his chin, and just like that...Eragon found himself being cuddled.
Arya rubbed his far shoulder with a quiet sigh that ghosted puffs of mist into the air. "Damn, you've definitely got that elven blood going. You're warmer than you used to be." With a deft flick of her wrist the elf opened her book to the page she had marked. "Now get some sleep. I'm not going anywhere." It was silent for a handful of seconds after Eragon closed his eyes. â...Youâre going to keep me safe if Saphira gets jealous of this, right? This is usually her move.â
Eragon let a sleepy smile grace his lips. âIâll try my best, but no promises.â
âFantastic. Go to sleep, dork.â













