Heartslabyul meeting Mafuyu!Reader
Riddle Roseheart
At first Riddle thinks you're a trouble maker because you're friends with Ace, Deuce and Grim.
However over time he realizes you're a good student unlike the other three when he interacts with you more.
He'll come to respect you for your amazing grades and knowledge since you're magicless.
Unlike Adeuce you follow the rules which make Riddle think highly of you.
So he might invite you to some study sessions and tea time together.
After his overblot he'll start to notice how dead your eyes seem and how your smile doesn't seem real.
If you decide to open up to him, it'll be at one of your tea times or study sessions.
Out of all the boys he probably understands your situation the most and is able to relate to it.
Sometimes you talk about your mothers and their heavy expectations and how you guys want to make them proud.
He would share sweet treats with you or notes for future lessons just so you can relax a little.
Riddle will do his best to try save you just like how you helped him when he overblotted.
Also the first time he sees Miku appear from your phone he dropped his teacup out of shock.
Trey Clover
Trey doesn't think of you as much in the beginning when he firsts meets you.
You're a good student and friend to Ace and Deuce, so he didn't think anything was off.
He'll only start paying attention after the tart incident and how Riddle seemed to not mind your presence.
You thought your meet ups with Riddle were going to go unnoticed? Who do you think baked all of those treats?
After Riddle's overblot, Trey starts seeing some similarities with you and Riddle.
Like how you tense up a bit at the mention of your mother as if waiting for her to come say something.
It honestly scares him a bit but he'll just start being nice to you.
Like straight out of nowhere nice, you thought he was nice before? Prepare for a bunch of baked goods at your doorstep.
He'll personally deliver them or have Ace or Deuce do it, if Trey does go himself he'll try make small talk.
Asking about your day and how you're feeling, stuff like that.
If you decide to open up to Trey, he'll take you very seriously.
He definitely thinks your mother is like Riddle's and how she shouldn't be treating you like a trophy.
You're his friend and he's grown to care about you overtime, you can certainly say that he'll do his darn best to save you.
The first time Trey meets Miku is when you accidently left your phone on the coffee table and she popped out to check on you.
Carter Diamond
Carter see through your act easily, you think he wouldn't know when someone was putting on a mask? It takes one to know one.
Your eyes look dead to him, it's almost like there isn't any light in them. It scares Carter a bit because he's never seen someone like you before.
He avoids you as much as possible at first, always making excuses but overtime he slowly warms up to you.
Like when you helped him paint the roses and noticed how he wasn't fond of sweet treats.
Especially after Riddle's overblot, Carter starts to consider you as a friend and appreciates you helping out.
He'll try to get to know the real you, the one behind the mask you put on around others.
Even though Carter's the one trying to help you, sometimes you make him feel real. Like you see through everything despite how hard he tries.
When you do give him an actual smile, Carter is quick to snap a photo and maybe take a selfie if he's lucky enough.
He won't ever post it on his social media, instead he keeps it in a special folder. Overtime it might grow and it'll become an archive full of moments of your friendship with Carter.
If you choose to open up to Carter, he'll take you very seriously.
No jokes or side comments, you'd have his attention and care. Carter would hold your hand and let you cry into his shoulder.
He'd compare your mother to Riddle's mother and he'd make sure that you wouldn't end up like him. Even though you didn't really act like him before overblot.
When Carter first meets Miku, it's when you're showing him a picture of Grim. She just popped out of the screen and caused Carter to stumble a bit.
Ace Trappola
Ace thinks you're a goody two shoes and a teachers pet at first but when he sees you give your most honest opinion of Crowley.
Well, he thinks you're okay now.
He'll tease and mess around with you a lot and your lack of reaction sometimes annoys him a bit.
Eventually when he gets a reaction from you, it's safe to say he's a bit scared of you.
Ace however does remember the time you, Ace and Grim went to the mines.
He remembers how unfazed you were at the prospect of death and that made him worry for you. Like a lot.
No one else is allowed to make fun of you and if someone dares say something awful about you. Detention is the less of his concern.
Despite how you act around him sometimes, Ace appreciates your blunt honesty even if it hurts sometimes.
He knows you care because you let him stay at Ramshackle when Riddle is mad at him.
After Riddle's overblot be prepared for a tiny bit more clingy Ace, he sees a bit of Riddle in you and he doesn't want anything bad to happen to his best friend.
If you give him a real smile or actually laugh at one of his jokes, Ace will be over the moon and cherish the memory.
He won't tell you any of this of course, that wouldn't be like him.
If you open up to Ace, be sure to have a bunch of tissues prepared. Not just for you but for Ace as well, he'll tear up at your story a lot.
He thinks your mum is like Riddle's and will definitely let you know that you deserve better.
Overall, he won't really change how he acts around you but you'll feel like a weight has been lifted from your shoulder because you don't have to keep up your act around him.
It's not a lot but you appreciate how Ace doesn't seem to dislike you without the mask.
When Ace firsts meets Miku, he was using your phone while you were in the bathroom. She scared him a bit causing him to drop your phone, luckily it didn't break. Miku then asked him to help save you and that became his mission ever since.
Deuce Spade
Deuce admires you because he wishes to become a honor student and he sees you as one.
You two get along and a mutual trust was built after the mine incident.
Sometimes you two study together but it's mostly you helping him out. But Deuce tries so cut him some slack.
When Deuce sometimes goes back to his delinquent ways, he's always worried that he may scare you off. However you don't seem to really care.
After Riddle's overblot he become more protective and always makes sure you, Ace and Grim are alright.
It's very sweet and you both soon become best friends.
Eventually he begins to notice how your smile doesn't seem to reach your eyes, how you seem a bit sad when talking about your dreams and the way you seem to be acting all the time.
So he'll take time out of his day just to hang out with you, play games, chat about random thing or sit in silence.
Deuce doesn't want to pressure you to open up to him but he makes sure you know that you can always talk to him.
If you do open up to him, well... he's punching pillows and walls and cussing out your mother.
But he'll give you a big hug and a bunch of your favorite snacks. You may watch a comedy movie together to make you two feel better.
In the end you know you have a friend that you can rely on, that can take your blunt words and you without your mask.
Because in Deuce's eyes, you're worth saving.
The first time Deuce meets Miku is when you accidentally forgot your phone at the library after one of your study sessions. He's shocked to see her but when she asks him to save you. He throws everything out of the window and promises to do his best.
Back to the beginning?
That was my first ever headcanon, I'm quite proud of it. Other dorms will be coming out soon :D I'll probably edit or change this in the future
