My two cents on every Dystopian/Utopian Teen/YA novel that has come out in the past decade:
Iâve always found âfuturisticâ books unreasonable. A lot of the time, it simply doesnât feel well thought out. Sometimes it is, and I can give credit where itâs due, but thatâs for a different text post another day.
I just donât understand how so many books I read have the same exact government as every other book in that genre. All of it is based on Communism, or a lack of government at all. Occasionally, there will be a dictatorship, but that falls more often in the Fantasy genre.
I havenât found a book about advanced technology that can explain in smooth pacing how the technology works. Even in dystopia, everything is so advanced and, more often than no, thereâs passing comments on how advanced the technology is. And these comments fail at their one job to be subtle. Think about how today, in 2016, we have smartphones. We see that as normal. Sometimes we look at these small computers and say, wow this is impressive stuff, cool that technology has come this far. But only rarely do we see âadvancedâ technology, meaning, in comparison with what everyone around us has, some organization somewhere has something way more rare and way more impressive. Say, a 3D printer that can print flesh and organs. When a character in these YA novels remarks on their own society as anything but normal, it takes you out of the atmosphere and mind of the main character. When they stop at every paragraph to explain that their watches project holograms and how everyone carries a swiss army knife but they donât call it a swiss army knife because Switzerland isnât a country anymore because of âThe Great War of Switzerlandâ that happened in 2024 which then triggered the third world war because Switzerland was a world power back then, itâs dull and confusing.
Why does every protagonist and narrator in these books have a mindset from the present times? Why do they all have an extensive knowledge of the history of everything and how all technology works when the fucking governments is supposed to be oppressive and withhold relevant education?
No character is like that. If you make a character that is not congruent with its setting, you failed at making a good character, and a realistic setting.
These comments only note the book medium of this genre, because I know there are movies and tv shows and video games that donât follow this formula. But for some reason, this industry is facing another epidemic that happened when Twilight came out -- all of a sudden, every book was about a shy protag who fell in love with a mysterious, jaded vampire. But now, its about a shy protag in the future who fell in love with a mysterious, jaded person.
Not to mention how every one of these futuristic books are heteronormative as hell...
Trust me, I liked the first dystopian YA novel I read, and the second one, too, but then the third, fourth, fifth, twelfth book from this genre only left me disappointed that there was no new content to consume. That these books every day become more and more heartless and written simply for a paycheck. Thatâs not what books mean to me.
I want a story. Not a formula.








