𝓥𝓮𝓷𝓲𝓬𝓮 𝓑𝓲𝓽𝓬𝓱 - 𝒯𝒽𝑒𝑜𝒹𝑜𝓇𝑒 𝒩𝑜𝓉𝓉
you’re beautiful and I’m insane
Your private dorm is warm tonight.
That’s the first thing you notice as you settle deeper into your blankets, the soft glow of enchanted candles flickering lazily against the walls. Being Head Girl meant space—your own room, your own quiet—and you’d made it yours in every way that mattered.
A knitted throw draped over the end of your bed.
A small stack of books on your nightstand, organized but well-loved. A teacup, still warm, resting beside you. The dancing flame of lit candle fills the room with a vanilla scent.
Outside, the castle hums faintly with distant life—laughter echoing far away, music muffled through thick stone walls.
The Slug Club party.
You imagine the glittering dresses, the clinking of glasses, the smoke curling through the air, the loudness.
And then you look back down at your book.
You turn the page. You chose this.
-
The knock startles you more than it should. Not loud. Just… wrong.
Out of place in the quiet you’ve carefully built.
Three uneven taps. A pause. Then two more, heavier this time.
You blink toward the door, heart giving a small, confused thud.
No one visits you this late.
Another, impatient, knock.
“Now who could that be?” You whispered to yourself, as you slowly uncovered your bare legs from the soft blanket, your sock covered feet carried you to your door.
You hesitate for half a second before opening the door.
And then you’re face-to-face with your fellow head boy, Tom Riddle.
Composed, as always. Dark eyes sharp with quiet amusement, like he already knows how this is going to go.
“Good evening,” he says smoothly.
Your brows knit together.
“It’s nearly midnight, Tom.”
“I’m aware.”
There’s something in his tone—too calm, too certain—that immediately puts you on edge.
“What do you want?”
He doesn’t answer right away.
Instead, he steps slightly to the side.
And the world shifts, because suddenly you see him.
Theodore Nott is leaning against the stone wall just behind Tom, like it’s the only thing keeping him upright.
He looks… softer.
That’s the only word your brain can settle on, even as everything else about him suggests the opposite.
His tie is loosened, collar slightly open, sleeves rolled just enough to reveal his wrists. His hair—normally neat in that careless, Slytherin way—is more disheveled now, like someone’s run their hands through it one too many times.
And his eyes—
They’re unfocused.
There’s a faint flush across his cheeks, and even from where you stand, you can smell it—smoke, alcohol, something bitter lingering in the air around him.
Your chest tightens.
“He’s drunk,” you say quietly.
“Yes,” Tom says. “And you’re helpful.”
Your eyes flicker towards tom, your brown eyes squinting at him.
“I declined for a reason.”
“And yet,” he gestures lightly toward Theo, “here we are.”
Your gaze flickers back to Theo.
He shifts slightly, like standing upright is becoming optional.
And then his eyes lift to find yours.
And something in your chest pulls tight.
“…you didn’t come,” he murmurs, his eyes made him look like a sad puppy.
Your chest tightens.
You hadn’t realized he’d notice. You hadn’t realized he’d care.
Tom clears his throat lightly.
“I’ll leave him with you.”
“Wait—”
But Tom is already moving down the stairs towards his dorm.
And just like that, it’s only you and him.
—
Your eyes travel back at Theo. He hasn’t looked away from you.
“…Unbelievable,” you whisper, though there’s no real bite to it.
There’s something unguarded in his expression now. Something loose and uncertain, like whatever usually holds him together has slipped just enough for you to see underneath.
“Can you walk?” you ask gently.
He blinks slowly, then moves his head to glance down at his feet before trailing back to your eyes.
“…probably.”
“That’s not reassuring.”
Still, you step closer. Carefully. Gentle.
When you reach for him, he doesn’t resist. If anything—he leans into your touch.
His arm drapes over your shoulders, heavier than you expect, and for a second you have to adjust your footing just to stay steady.
“Okay,” you murmur, tightening your grip around his waist. “Careful—don’t fall, please, I’m not equipped for that.”
A soft huff of laughter brushes past your ear.
“You worry a lot.”
“I have to,” you say. “Someone has to.”
-
You guide him sit on the edge of your bed, steadying him as he sways slightly.
“There,” you say softly. “Stay.”
“Bossy,” he murmurs.
“Drunk,” you counter.
He doesn’t argue.
You move away just long enough to grab a glass of water, your fingers brushing the rim of your teacup as you pass it. The warmth has faded slightly, but it’s still comforting.
When you turn back, he’s watching you.
Not in the usual distant way. Not guarded or annoyed. Just… watching.
You hand him the glass.
“Drink it Theo.”
He takes it, slower than usual, fingers brushing yours for the briefest second. He looks down at the glass before taking a slow sip.
“You didn’t come,” he says again.
Your chest tightens slightly.
“I know.”
“Slughorn invited you.”
“I’m aware, Theo.”
“…why not?”
There’s no judgment in it. Just quiet curiosity from the taller boy.
You hesitate for a moment, then shrug slightly.
“I don’t like those kinds of things.”
He looks up.
“How come?”
“They’re loud. And crowded. And…” you pause, searching for the right word. “Too much.”
His gaze lingers on you.
“I think you would’ve looked nice.”
Your heart skips.
“…Theo.”
“What?” he mumbles, like he doesn’t even realize what he said.
You shake your head, but there’s a small smile tugging at your lips despite yourself.
“You’re impossible.”
“And you’re—” He pauses, his eyes looking you up and down before they find your eyes once more, “You’re beautiful.”
The room stills.
Your breath catches, fingers tightening slightly in the fabric of your pajama sleeve.
“Theo—”
“And I’m insane.”
The words fall quieter.
He leans back against your pillows, gaze drifting but still fixed on you like you’re the only thing keeping him anchored.
“You read,” he continues, voice softer now, slower. “You stay here. You don’t… do any of that.”
His hand lifts vaguely, gesturing to everything he came from.
“And I do all of it.”
You step closer to your bed, “You’re not—”
“I ruin things y/n,” he murmurs, cutting you off, voice barely above a whisper. “People. Nights. Whatever I touch just—” he exhales shakily. “It doesn’t stay good.”
You’re right in front of him now.
Close enough to see the way his eyes flicker, the way something vulnerable cracks through the surface.
He goes quiet. His eyes lift to yours, and for once—there’s no distance, no walls, just something fragile. Something real.
“You’re not insane,” you say gently.
He frowns slightly, like he doesn’t believe you.
“I am.” He responds in a whisper, shaking his head at himself.
“You’re drunk,” you correct, softer this time. “And you’re overwhelmed.”
He doesn’t argue again.
“Lie down,” you murmur.
You don’t expect him to listen but he does.
You help him shift properly, guiding him back against the pillows, pulling the blanket over him and tucking it carefully around his shoulders without even thinking about it.
He watches you the whole time.
“…stay,” he murmurs.
“I’m right here Theodore,” you whisper.
And you are.
You sit beside him, just for a moment.
Your hand hesitates before brushing a stray curl away from his forehead.
You expect him to pull back but he doesn’t.
Instead—he leans into it, into your comforting touch.
Just barely.
But enough to make your breath catch.
And slowly he falls asleep, while you’re stuck sitting there wondering where you relationship with Theo will head.















