Costas Lapavitsas and Stathis Kouvelakis reflect on the reasons for SYRIZA's defeat and what it would take for the radical left to once more win power.
The results of the recent European elections were the natural outcome of SYRIZA's disgraceful capitulation in the summer of 2015. SYRIZA did not face the immediate outcry experienced by previous Memorandum Governments. On the contrary, the Third Memorandum was accompanied by social passivity that eventually brought about a turn towards the Right, and indeed a tough neo-liberal version of it, driving the Left in its entirety toward paths that are difficult to tread.
This shift is not a Greek exception. Along the length and breadth of Europe, all variants of the Left are at historically low levels. The major victor is the European Far Right, purporting to be an "anti-systemic" actor, capitalizing on the anger of societies wounded by decades of neoliberalism. The rise of the Far Right demonstrates the loss of the Leftâs radicalism, its transformation into a manager of a system that is now systematically and unconditionally unmaking a centuryâs worth of social gains. The bonds between the Left and the working and popular classes, once its natural base, have been broken.
What is original in the Greek case is that a party of the classical conservative faction, New Democracy, is on the cusp of returning to power. The forthcoming parliamentary elections are certainly not the same as the European elections, but they will also formally signal the close of the cycle opened in the squares in the summer of 2011. It is indeed evident that SYRIZA is unable to articulate a political discourse with elementary persuasiveness. Its electoral message is that it has a program that will produce "growth" alongside "fiscal stability" and "social justice". The government and the prime minister have once more become radicals, prepared to clash with the "conservative circles of Brussels" and the "extreme neo-liberal" leader of ND Mitsotakis.
This is but a reheated meal of a bygone age. What confrontation with Brussels, when they have accepted the abusive surpluses of 3.5% until 2022 and austerity until 2060 in order that the debt is served unhindered? What growth, when taxation is severe, and public investment is continually cut in order to bring even greater surpluses? What confrontation with neoliberalism, when public wealth is systematically privatized and sold off to foreigners? What social justice, when the "Katrougkalos" law has ravaged a meager layer of small businesses in order to support a pension system that has no hopes of surviving in the long run?
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
'Greece: tensions rising after Eurogroup talks break upâŚ' by Stathis Kouvelakis
As talks in Brussels over Greece's bailout programme break down, Stathis Kouvelakis comments on the vast disparity between the position of Eurozone finance ministers and the demands of the popular movement behind Syriza. Furthermore, he provides context to ongoing pressures within the party itself.
As the media and the Athens stock market (down 4 percent yesterday) had widely expected, yesterdayâs finance ministersâ meeting ended in failure, perhaps even a momentous one. The tone of the Greek governmentâs official communiquĂŠ, which the whole media were quick to pick up on, was very tough indeed: âCertain circlesâ insistence that the new Greek government implement the Memorandum is absurd and unreasonable. The implementation of the Memorandum programme was not on the table at the summit, and those who try to put it back there are wasting their timeâ.
Such language is entirely out of the norm for this type of context. But we have to say, even before the beginning of the meeting. Wolfgang Schäuble, the German finance minister, had been particularly insulting in his remarks, even by his own standards, declaring that âhe felt sorry for the Greeks because their government is behaving irresponsiblyâ. He made barely veiled threats that Greece would be expelled from the Eurozone if it did not fulfil âthe minimum of the claimsâ and accused the government of acting âas if it was playing a high stakes hand of pokerâ. We did not have to wait long for the response from the Greek governmentâs spokesperson Gabriel Sakellaridis: âfor my part, I can also say that I find the German governmentâs attitude irresponsibleâ.
It seems that during the discussions the European finance commissioner Pierre Moscovici and the IMF managing director Christine Lagarde accepted a version of the joint communiquĂŠ that made no reference to continuing with the present Memorandum programme and agreed to Greeceâs proposal for a four-month intermediate programme guaranteeing European financing of its debt repayments, in exchange for it committing to ârefrain ⌠from unilateral actionsâ.[1] But this compromise text came up against German opposition, and the Eurogroup president Jeroen Dijsselbloem hurried to withdraw it and put forward another plan which, as Paul Krugman underlines, the Greeks could never have accepted.
Faced with the Greek governmentâs flat refusal to give in to diktats, Jeroen Dijsselbloem â this time accompanied by Pierre Moscovici â went on to the offensive and gave Greece until Friday to request âan extension of the existing programmeâ. He insisted that the current framework cannot be changed unilaterally and demanded that Greece commit to guaranteeing the loan repayments. Moscovici, for his part, stated that âthere is no alternative to requesting an extension of the [existing] programme. We have to be reasonable, and not ideologicalâ. Lagarde, speaking for the IMF, declared that there could be no new supply of credit without the Troika first evaluating it.
Paul Krugman commented on the Eurogroupâs brutal blackmail in the following terms: 'There was absolutely no way Tsipras and company could sign on to such a statement, which makes you wonder what the Eurogroup ministers think theyâre doing. I guess itâs possible that theyâre just fools â that they donât understand that Greece 2015 is not Ireland 2010, and that this kind of bullying wonât work. Alternatively, and I guess more likely, theyâve decided to push Greece over the edge. Rather than give any ground, they prefer to see Greece forced into default and probably out of the euro, with the presumed economic wreckage as an object lesson to anyone else thinking of asking for relief. That is, theyâre setting out to impose the economic equivalent of the âCarthaginian peaceâ France sought to impose on Germany after World War Iâ.â
With its very firm statements the Greek government has effectively rejected the ultimatum: âacross the whole of European history, the democracies have rejected ultimatums. They do not sink to blackmail, and nor do they give in to blackmailâ. Letâs not forget that the Syriza government has been backed up against the wall by the ECBâs decision to shut off the main tap providing funding to the Greek banks. But the popular support for the government, abroad as well as within Greece, has reached unprecedented levels â as we saw with Sundayâs demonstrations and mass rallies throughout the country as well as dozens of cities across Europe. Surveys in recent days have suggested that over 70 percent of the Greek population support the government taking a confrontational approach toward the Troika, including a very large majority of KKE [the Greek Communist party] voters as well as almost half of the New Democracy conservative electorate.
At the level of domestic politics, the significant opposition within Syriza to the party making current European commissioner Dimitris Avramopoulos its nominee for President of the Republic (as seems probable â Avramopoulos being a figure from the âcentristâ/âmoderateâ wing of New Democracy and a former minister in many right-wing governments) has led to this decision being put off till tomorrow evening, in the wake of this eveningâs meeting of the partyâs parliamentary group. Sundayâs meeting of the Syriza political secretariat showed that such a proposal â which Alexis Tsipras was meant to announce last night â would meet with strong opposition, far beyond the ranks of the Left Platform alone. Yesterday, at an emergency meeting of the parliamentary group, Tsipras proposed Prokopis Pavlopoulos, another figure of the âcentristâ wing of New Democracy, who is expected to be elected by the Parliament this evening. Panagiotis Lafazanis, the leader of Syrizaâs Left Platform expressed publicly his disagreement with that decision but also said that he couldnât vote against the decision of the prime minister.
So it seems that, faced with rising pressure and increased EU blackmail, the Syriza government has no alternative but to hold firm. In taking this road, it will enjoy the active support of its own people, but also that of a growing section of European public opinion, which is becoming conscious of the stakes of this confrontation for the future of the entire continent.
[1] As Paul Mason revealed with a series of leaked documents.
Yesterday Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras made his first policy speech in the VoulĂ ton EllĂnon, standing firm in his position on debt and austerity. Following on from his excellent analysis of the Greek election results, Stathis Kouvelakis considers Tsipras's programme.Â
 Tsiprasâs inaugural policy speech before the Greek Parliament was followed particularly attentively within Greece as much as in the European chancelleries â and no doubt in the White House too. Within Greece, after the ECBâs blackmail and the continual attacks by the European leaders, there is a spreading mood of mobilization, of regained dignity, of a desire both to support the government in the face of the blackmail and to put pressure on it to halt any retreat. Externally, and more specifically within the governing European circles, every word and above all every measure announced were weighed up to seek to gauge the determination of the prime minister and his government. Most expected a significant shift, prefiguring a retreat, which would facilitate a âcompromiseâ during the European summits this coming week, which would in reality signify Greeceâs submission to their diktats. In this they were undoubtedly disappointed. For Alexis Tsipras, in truth, made no fundamental concessions. To be sure, he avoided using the term âcancellation of the debtâ. But he strongly insisted on its unviable character and demanded its âreductionâ and ârestructuringâ. True, he also failed to announce the immediate reinstatement of the minimum wage to its 2009 level (751 euros) but he did commit to doing so during 2015. As for the rest, he went through all the points of the Thessaloniki programme: emergency measures to deal with the humanitarian disaster (food, reconnecting electricity, transport and medical coverage for all), reinstatement of labour legislation, disbandment of unjust land taxes, fiscal reform to make the rich pay, a rise in the tax threshold to 12,000 euros, rehiring the sacked public sector workers, an end to privileges for the private media companies, reconstitution of ERT (the public radio and TV company), activating the powers that the state has as a shareholder in the banks, a stop to the auctioning off of public assets (ports, infrastructures, energy), a end to police repression of demonstrations.Â
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Qualityâ Free Actions
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
Here are some good reads regarding the historic far left victory by the Syriza coalition in Greece.
Syrzia is a acronym meaning "The Coalition of the Radical Left."
"Greece: Phase One,"
by Sebastian Budgen & Stathis Kouvelakis in Jacobin
"Ending Greece's Nightmare,"
by Paul Krugman in New York Times
"On the Doorstep of Power,"
by Leo Panitch, in Jacobin
Sam Seder interviews Maria Margaronis, the European editor for The Nation magazine regarding Syriza/Greece from a few weeks ago.
"How Much Success is Syriza Likely to Have in Ending Austerity?," by Yves Smith for Naked Capitalism. [The story contains many other links to quality analysis.]
"EU Should Give Tsipras A Chance to Govern," by Kevin Less for suffragio
"After Syriza's Victory, Confrontation or Capitulation," by Stathis Kouvelakis in Jacobin