Siren
Pairing: Will Ramos x Jolly Karlsson
Content Warnings: 18+, monsterfucking (will is a siren), tentacles, knotting (? yeah I guess), implied/mentions of edging, overstimulation,
Word Count: 1.4k
A/N: @jestersnotebook request from this prompt list (overstimulating until theyâre begging). I know I said I may not be able to do the weird siren sex, but I managed to cook up something. Sorry it took me 3 months. I hope itâs decent. Also, please donât ask me how siren!Willâs anatomy works, I donât know. I couldnât make up my mind so I gave him that weird penis and some tentacle tendril things.
divider by @saradika-graphics
Jolly woke with a painful gasp. His chest ached fiercely, body heavy like lead with a chill that penetrated his bones down to the marrow. The ground beneath him was just as cold, and horribly hard. Slowly, his surroundings came into focus. Smooth, dark gray stone disappeared up into the ceiling where stalactites hung precariously, as well as protruded from the floor. Jolly couldnât tell if there was still daylight or if the cave was just dark.
This definitely was not his boat.
Splashing caught his ear and he sat up quickly, instantly regretting it. The room spun round and round, pulsed, pulled at his brain until it throbbed. Jolly clutched his head and gasped, body shaking as he fought the urge to vomit.
"Oh, so you're not dead. How delightful!" A voice spoke.
Slowly, Jolly turned his head toward the sound and visibly recoiled.
Eyes blacker than night watched him, and a mouth full of too many teeth grinned. Human arms lined with iridescent fins crossed on the stone ground a few feet away as a head full of dripping wet ringlet curls rested on them. Peeking through the surface of the water was a large, bubble gum pink and seafoam green fish tail.
"Siren." He spat, disgusted.
The creature frowned. "That's some thanks for saving your life."
"Thanks for saving my life?" Jolly repeated. "Your kind beckons sailor's deaths so forgive me if I lack enthusiastic appreciation."
It looked at Jolly, pout plastered on its face, though it didn't appear as if it were attempting to garner sympathy, more so like a mockery.
"And your kind seeks mine for trophies and bragging rights." It smiled. "An eye for an eye, yes?"
Jolly wanted wanted to argue, but another wave of nausea inducing dizziness washed over him. He pressed his forehead to the cold stone beneath to ground himself.
âItâs so rare I get such a delicious looking treat all the way out here,â the creature grinned with all their teeth; they were sharp and jagged, like theyâre meant for ripping flesh. âI do hope youâll be staying a whileâif you don't succumb first.â
After the first fourteen days and nights, Jolly lost count of how long he'd been resigned to the siren's home. He grew tired of fish. On occasion, the sirenâwho went by Will, but Jolly had been reluctant to call him by his name, up until he stopped responding to Sirenâwould bring him meats or sometimes a sweet confection. He didn't question how he obtained the foods, lest he discover Will lured other sailors to their demise.
By the time thirty days passed, he gave up any hope of ever seeing land again.
Some time around the first month, Will revealed he could walk on land. Jolly tucked away to desperately, loudly, pleasure himselfâdeep, rumbling moans, quick and spit slicked strokes all bounced off stone walls. Jolly hadn't heard his name being called or the damp footsteps approaching. His peak was rapidly approaching, but before it could crest, Will appeared. Jolly scrambled to cover himself, beat red embarrassed, and Will? Completely unbothered.
Despite his embarrassment, Jolly couldn't help his wandering gaze, noting each trail of water that followed every toned muscle of lightly sun kissed skin. Nothing about him screamed inhuman. His once black eyes were now normal, brown like his soaking wet hair, and the teeth peeking through his amused smirk were human. No fins, gills, no tail. Just⌠a very attractive, very naked, fit man.
At sixty days, pent up restlessness consumed him, his hand no longer sufficient enough to take off the edge, and exacerbated by naked images of Will plaguing his mind. Will had cheekily offered assistance when he first caught Jolly, which he declined, but now desperation sunk in, clinging to him like invasive urchins.
Jolly didn't bother hiding this time. He pleasured himself out in the open, leisurely dragging it out and tormenting his self to keep hard until Will returned. He had no way of knowing how long he would be gone or how much time had passed, but Jolly quickly began to tire of edging and his wrists grew sore. Frustration brewed until his bones itched and he could feel every blood cell flowing through his body. By a miracle,Jolly heard the familiar splashing of water letting him know Will had returned.
His name came in shallow, quiet breaths, heating his cheeks in shame. Approaching wet footsteps caused Jolly to speed up to once again bring himself to the edge, just to stop at Will's knowing and borderline condescending chuckle.
"You beg for me yet won't allow me to help?" Will cocked his head to the side.
Jolly swallowed the last of his pride. "I would like to ask now."
"Oh?" Will flashed his teeth. "And how would you have me?"
The question confused Jolly. He was well familiar and far from a stranger to sex with men; one does what one needs during long, grueling journey's at seaâand truthfully, he much preferred the male couplings to women. Unless Will was asking who was penetrating, in which Jolly usually was, but he didn't possess the strength or patience.
"I don't care," Jolly whispered, tears prickling his eyes. "I just need relief. Please, Will."
Will stood above him, unmoving, dark brown eyes boring into him, like he was studying Jolly, looking at him like prey. Jolly felt wholly vulnerable and exposed.
He began to hum, the solemn tune sinking deep in his ears and making them vibrate. Static slowly filled his head that spread through the rest of his body, heating him with warmth that was almost fuzzy. Almost comforting. Will held out a hand. Jolly grasped it without hesitation.
Hand in hand, gazes locked, Will led Jolly towards the water's edge. The smile he gave was unnerving, but it failed to phase through the fog swirling inJolly's brain. He was far too clouded by lust andâŚ
"It's been a pleasure having you, Jolly."
Jolly was yanked into dark, bone chillingly cold water. The gasp caught in his throat was swiftly forced out as Will slammed him against cold stone. Gone was the attractive human man he plead for, replaced by the horrifying creature with the sharp grin and abysses for eyes he met firstâyet, Jolly found himself not caring.
Something large and bulbous circled his hole, prodding and teasing with a mind of its own. Jolly tried to wiggle and get more stimulation, but Will clasped a strong hand on his throat. Small tendrils, around a dozen, maybe more, trailed along the thick vein on the underside of his erection. The appendage between his cheeks pressed, pressed, pressed against him until it finally popped inside to secrete a viscous liquid to allow a second, much larger bulb to notch. It pulsed as it thrust inside him, the first knot swelling as it went deeper and deeper while the other stayed in place, stretching him and keeping him in place.
At the same time, the tendrils wrapped around Jolly's length and squeezed. Three or four stroked over his tip, smearing and collecting his dribbling seed. Overwhelm washed over him all at once. If not for Will's hand on his throat, Jolly would have gone entirely limp and sank like a rock. His gasping, mindless moans were trapped beneath his grasp and grew dangerously light headed because of it.
"PâŚleaseâŚ" Jolly blinked one eye at a time; he was unsure if his plea was even audible. "Ple-easeâŚ"
"Am I too much for you?" Will grinned, wide and wild, baring all his teeth. "Or are you begging for more?"
Jolly wasn't sure how much more he could take. Between his earlier efforts and Will's current, he was surprised he didn't immediately erupt. Jolly begged again. And again, until it all truly became too much and he cried, pitifully spilling his seed. A tendril slid and flicked at the slit, acting as lapping tongue. Inside him, the first bulb grew warm. Jolly felt it getting bigger and bigger, swelling to the size of the second and he swore even bigger. The pressure was intense, stretching him far beyond what should be possible, then in the blink of an eye, it was gone.
A thick, thick substance flooded Jolly. At some point, Will let up on his chokehold because Jolly heard the absolutely depraved and whorish moan that burst from his lungs. He was impossibly full, stuffed and plugged with foreign and fantastical sperm.
"What a shame I won't take," Will sighed, disappointed, "A waste of my seed."
Will Masterlist
Jolly Masterlist













