I haven't really read any Spiderman comics, and I have never heard of Mysterio (that's the name of the guy Jake Gyllenhaal is playing right?) before. From what I saw in the trailer he seems like a good guy but when I went through the Marvel Wiki that doesn't seem to be the case? You're the resident expert on all Spiderman so I've come to you! Thank you in advance (whether or not you want to answer/get around to answering)
Jake Gyllenhaal is playing Mysterio, and in every comics continuity I can think of, Mysterio is a villain. Mysterioās civilian name is Quentin Beck and he was a movie special effects expert before he became a supervillain. He uses that special effects knowledge to create complex illusions as a hallmark of his supervillain career. In short, heās a super cool and very meta candidate for the villain of a supervillain movie ā if heās playing the villain. Like you mentioned, so far in the trailers and in interviews given the MCUās Mysterio has been cast in the light as a good guy, a supposed traveler from another earth and an introduction to the multiverse. Promotional material has shown Peter interacting with him with his mask off, which, even if this Mysterio is a good guy, I really hate because frivolity with his identity even among the good guys is something no version of Peter Parker has ever been known for before, and it makes him seem very irresponsible and careless. But letās move on.
Now, as many people have already pointed out, MCU Mysterio could be lying. Lying is, after all, what a showman supervillain who creates complex illusions does, and this is an adaptation of the character who once made Matt Murdock question whether a baby was the antichrist. (Comics!) So itās not out of the realm of possibility that the plot of Far From Home is that this Mysterio is claiming to be from the multiverse and has somehow⦠tricked the greatest intelligence community in this fictional world⦠including Nick Fury himselfā¦Ā to, I donāt know, rob Venice or whatever?Ā
But letās leave the question of whether or not this Mysterio is lying for possibly nefarious purposes aside for a sec. I want to tackle two things about the decisions being made here that I really, really donāt like. The first is related to the mask issue I talked about a little above. Mysterio is being peddled in interviews with director Jon Watts as something of a mentor figure for MCU Peter:
āWe thought it might be interesting to play Mysterio as almost like the cool uncle,ā Jon Watts said. I mean,Ā āinterestingā is a word for taking a supervillain and making him into a mentor figure but I think if thereās one word you canāt throw around in Spider-Man without some serious consequences for your narrative, itās uncle. Not only does the big Endgame spoiler appear to be affecting MCUās Peter in Far From Home far more than theyāve even bothered to reference Uncle Ben, now Jon Watts is calling MysterioĀ āalmost like the cool uncle.ā Itās a real slap in the face to Peterās origin story to discuss the character using that term no matter how the Mysterio storyline in the film ends up going down.
The second issue is something I often reference talking about the MCUās Spider-Man adaptation decisions, and thatās the Miles Morales problem. Now, whether or not this Mysterio is from another earth or whether heās lying, we have to address that there is a comic involving Mysterio, Nick Fury, and the multiverse: Spider-Men. Spider-Men is the first comic wherein Peter Parker meets Miles Morales when he himself accidentally travels to the multiverse. So once again weāve taken the trappings from a comic that featured Miles and then removed Miles from them so Peter gets to be the plucky young Spider-Man coming into his own.
(Spider-Men #4)
I think Mysterioās a really interesting choice for the villain of the piece because like I said itās very meta to use a character who traditionally worked in film in the comics within your movie adaptation ā if the villain is in fact what heās playing. If heās not, and Iām not making any assumptions at this point, I donāt really see the point of using this specific character in the film when there are so many Spider-Man characters, both good and bad, to adapt, and the multiverse angle borrowing from yet another comic featuring Miles Morales annoys me.Ā

















