Takes One To Know One - Part One
*** Summary: When the new resident Abby takes up most of Joelâs time, you canât help but feel replaced, was Joel the type of man to do that? You didnt use to think so. Tensions begin to rise when another outsider comes for shelter in Jackson, and Joel gets a taste of his own medicine. Warnings and tags: Jackson/grandpa!joel. f!reader. Reader is over 40. Use of y/n. No description of appearance given. Kiiiinda based on P2 with a twist.
The horses shifted impatiently beneath them, leather tack creaking while the morning buzz of Jackson gathered around the front gate. Saddlebags were checked twice, rifles counted, blankets tied down. Maria stood with a clipboard in hand, running through names while Tommy fussed over Buckleyâs saddle for what had to be the third time.
Joel tightened the strap beneath his mareâs chin before giving the group a quick once-over. It was the same crowd that made this ride every couple of monthsâa day away from the walls, fishing, laughing, pretending life hadnât ended twenty years ago.
Maria glanced up from the list.
âOkay. Everyoneâs here.â
Joel frowned. His eyes swept across the gathered riders again.
Tommy and Maria.
Jesse and Dina.
Ellie and Cat.
Eugene, GailâŠAbby
His brows pinched together. ââŠWhoa, whoa.â He raised a hand. âWe canât leave.â
Everyone paused. Maria blinked. âWhy not?â
Joel looked around once more as though youâd magically appear behind someoneâs horse. ây/nâs not here.â
Abbyâs smile barely faltered. âOh.â She shrugged. âDidnât anyone tell you? Theyâd be an odd number of people, so sheâs not comingâ
Joel slowly shook his head, a strange knot settled in his chest. ââŠWhy didnât she tell me?â Tommy let out a quiet snort, lowering his voice as he adjusted his horses saddle. âWhen exactly was she supposed to tell you?â
Joel looked over. Tommy didnât even meet his eyes. âYouâve been MIA for a few weeks with the new girl.â He tugged another strap tight. âHellâŠI canât even remember the last time I saw you and y/n together.â
Joel stilled, cause neither could he. The realization landed heavier than heâd expected. The last three weeks had disappeared beneath patrol schedules, training Jacksonâs newest arrivals andâwhether he wanted to admit it or notâspending most of his spare time with Abby.
She wasnât a bad kid, far from it. Scared out of her mind when sheâd first arrived, sheâd clung to the one person whoâd made her feel safe during the rescue mission. Joel.Â
Heâd told himself she just needed stability. Someone patient, familiar. Truth wasâŠhe liked being needed. Liked the way Abby looked at him like he could fix anything. Like heâd hung the damn moon.
It was stupid. A harmless little ego boost from someone young enough to still believe older men had all the answers. Joel had joked with Tommy more than once that he âstill had it,â now those words tasted sour.
From the moment Joel and Tommy brought Abby back to Jackson, something about her to you feltâŠoff. âA young woman out there on her own?â youâd questioned, unable to shake the feeling.
Everyone dismissed your concerns, insisting you were being paranoid. Sheâs just a young woman, they said. Whatâs she gonna do?
It wasnât that you hated Abbyâyou didnât. You barely knew her. But there was something about her you just couldnât put your finger on, a quiet instinct that refused to settle no matter how hard you tried to ignore it.
Before long, your suspicions became the townâs latest joke. People teased that you were jealous, overly cautious, always expecting the worst. Eventually, you stopped arguing. You simply smiled, shrugged, and let them laugh. But the feeling never went away.
He rubbed the back of his neck. âIâll go grab her.â
âBut weâre all ready, and Abbyâs right, itâll be an odd number.â Maria said gently.
Joel glanced toward your street, Abby nudged her horse alongside his. âYou can talk to her when we get back.â Her smile was easy enough. âSheâll still be here.â
Ten minutes later, Jackson had disappeared behind the trees. The rhythmic clop of hooves shouldâve been relaxing.
Instead Joel barely noticed the scenery passing by. His thoughts had wandered somewhere else entirely, when was the last time heâd actually spoken to you?
Not waved. Not nodded across town, but actually spoken.
A memory surfaced from only a few days ago. Youâd walked over while he was setting up targets for Abbyâs shooting lesson.
Youâd smiled. âHey Joel, can I ask you somethinâ?â
What had you wanted? He couldnât even remember. Because halfway through your sentence Abby had come jogging over. âJoel! I canât get this stupid thing to work!â
Heâd looked between the two of you, then back at Abby. âWe can talk later, Sunshine.â
Youâd hesitated. âOhâŠokay.â
âLemme help with the lesson and Iâll come find ya.â Heâd smiled without really thinking. âWeâll talk then.â Your smile had shrunk into something smaller. âAlright.â
He remembered watching you walk away, head dipped, hands shoved into your jacket pockets. ThenâŠnothing. Because after the lesson Abby had suggested grabbing dinner at The Bison. Joel had gone. He laughed. Stayed later than heâd planned, and completely forgotten heâd promised to come find you.
His stomach sank. ââŠShit.â
Tommyâs horse drifted alongside his. âTold ya.â
Joel sighed heavily. âLook, TommyâŠwe rescued the poor girl. Sheâs comfortable with me. I donât know what else Iâm supposed to do. Iâm training her, is all.â
Tommy looked ahead, not angry. Just disappointed. âFrom where Iâm sittinâ, brotherâŠâ he said quietly, âa shiny newâyoungâtoyâs craving your attentionâŠâ
Joel winced.
ââŠand sheâs removing your close friends one by one without even tryingâŠand without you realising.â
Silence stretched between them.
Tommy glanced across. âHonestlyâŠwhen was the last time you and Sunshine did anything together, just the two of you?â
Joel opened his mouth, nothing came out.
âHer guitar lessons still going on?â
His chest tightened. Shit, they werenât. Not because youâd stopped asking but because he stopped showing up.
Every few days youâd catch him around town. âHey, when you free this week?âŠCan I come by tomorrow?â And he answers with âWeâll seeâŠjust been busy.â
Always busy, always later and later had quietly turned into weeks.
Tommy sighed. âBrotherâŠyouâve been different since Abby got here, and I reckon Sunshineâs finally got tired of waiting around for you.â
Joel stared at the trail ahead. Tommy wasnât saying them to be cruel, he was saying them because they were true.
Joel tightened his grip on the reins until his knuckles turned white.
The moment this ride was overâŠhe wasnât going home, he wasnât stopping at The Bison with Abby. He wasnât doing anything until heâd marched straight to your front door. Because somewhere along the way, without even noticingâŠheâd let the best friendship heâd ever had slip right through his fingers.
The day out hadnât meant much to Joel. Heâd spent most of it staring into space while Abby drifted over every so often, determined to keep him company. He barely heard half of what she said. The whole day had felt heavy, dragging on longer than it shouldâve. All he wanted was to get home.
Jackson finally came into view, earning relieved sighs from almost everyone.
Joel had spent the ride back beside Tommy, with Abby repeatedly trying to wedge herself into their conversations.
âSo, Miller boys,â she chirped, flashing a grin. âI was thinking we hit The Bison and drink this night away, huh?â
They both declined without hesitation.
Tommy just wanted to get home.
Joel just wanted to see you.
âAww, youâre just a pair of boring old men,â Abby huffed dramatically. âMaybe another time.â
As they approached the gates, Tommy spotted the watchmen waving frantically, shouting for him to hurry.
His expression immediately hardened. He shot a quick glance back at the others before digging his heels into the horseâs sides, racing ahead. The rest of the group followed close behind.
Several council members and a handful of worried residents were already waiting near the stables. âWhat the hellâs going on?â Tommy asked, swinging down from his horse with a heavy thud.
One of the guards stepped forward. âTommyâŠan outsider showed up at the gates. We werenât sure what to do.â
âAlright.â Tommy tugged off his gloves. âTell me about him.â
By then, the rest of the group had dismounted, listening in.
âYoung man. Came in about two hours ago. We put him in quarantine just to be safe.â The guard hesitated. âHe wasnât too keen on us checking him over.â
Tommy nodded.
âGood. Maria, come on. Letâs go see him. Whoâs with him now?â
The guard glanced towards the infirmary.
âY/N. Sheâs been sitting with him for a while.â
Tommy looked over at Joel and jerked his head towards the building. âYou coming?â
Joel didnât answer. He simply started walking.
âSo⊠Iâll see you later then, Joel,â Abby called after him in the sweetest voice she could manage. He gave a distracted wave without looking back.
âHeâs shown no signs of twitching or aggression,â the doctor explained, handing Tommy a clipboard. âIf he stays that way, weâll reassess tomorrow.â
Tommy skimmed the notes. âNo name?â
âHe hasnât given us one.â
Tommy handed the clipboard back before making his way towards the sealed quarantine room.
Separated by a thick sheet of reinforced plastic, you sat on one side while the stranger occupied the other. You were laughing, a proper, head thrown back laugh.
âOh my God,â you gasped between giggles. âThatâs so funny. Youâll have to take there one dayâIâve never been to Mexico.â
The sound made Joel stop for half a second.
It had been a long day, and all heâd wanted was to see you. Instead, he found you smiling and laughing with another man.
You turned at the sound of approaching footsteps. The moment you spotted Tommy, MariaâŠand then Joel, your smile softened, faltering just enough for him to notice.
You stood, brushing your hands down your jeans. âHey, guys. Hope your day out was fun.âÂ
The man behind the glass coughed, giving you a smile. You glanced back at him behind the glass. âOh shit, sorry.â You laughed out.
âUmâŠeveryoneâthis is Manny.â














