chapter 1: i wanna know peace again (wanna sing a different song)
(ao3 link)
azzi realizes (with some gentle prodding) midway through her rookie wnba season that maybe she and paige were more than best friends and she just didn't know it. except they haven't really talked in more than a year. cue a mini crashout and some major life re-evaluation. and a lot of wine. (wc: ~5k)
chapter 1: in which azzi discovers the dangers of combining wine, well-meaning but invasive questions from friends, and the call feature on her iphone
AN: um hi hello! this is my first ever published fic so please be kind šš»i'll try and shorten the manifesto authors note i have in ao3, but basically this is just meant to be a silly little story! i don't think this is canon in any way i just really like angsty gays being stupid, so. this would theoretically be during azziās rookie season (so summer 2026) and operates under a reality in which p+a are very much not together and were never messing around, so make some mental edits to the pazzi timeline if you so please. i hope you enjoy this little labor of love ā¤ļø
it starts, as many things do, with dinner and one too many glasses of wine for azzi. she and a few teammates had decided to have a girls' night- aĀ realĀ girls' night, as aaliyah had called it, meaning dinner at a nice, secluded cocktail bar downtown during their few days off. they were grown ups now, or at least pretending to be, and what better way to celebrate getting through half of the season than by getting wine drunk and munching on slightly overpriced hors d'oeuvres.Ā
theyāre mostly through their food at this point, which is to say, pleasantly tipsy, maybe even teetering on the edge of drunk, and azzi leans back into the booth with a contented sigh, lazily sipping on the remaining wine in her glass.Ā
kiki and georgia are discussing kikiās new boyfriend, and azzi is only half paying attention, finding the buzz in her system making it difficult to really enjoy hearing the phrase āĀ iām just so in love with himĀ ā for the third time in the last five minutes.Ā
georgia is amused though, and azzi lets her handle it, up until georgia turns to her and asks, āwhat about you, fudd? got anything going on over there? any new suitors?āĀ
azzi rolls her eyes, sighing. āno maāam. answer hasnāt changed since the last time you asked it.ā
it should bother her, really, how little action she gets, how uninterested in casual dating sheās been. but sheās content, for the most part, with her friends and her family and the occasional one night stand. sometimes it feels like her friends are more invested in her dating life than she is.
ācome onnnn, whenās the last time you dated someone,ā kiki pipes up, and azzi thinksĀ here we go again.Ā Ā
ābro i donāt know. the whole dating and boys thing isnāt for me, okay,ā she whines, and even though thatās the truth, dating has never been something azzi cared about, the words feel a little sour on her tongue.Ā
she glances at aaliyah, whoās looking at her curiously.Ā
āwhat?ā she asks, at her imploring gaze. the wine is making her bolder, more inclined to be blunt about her disinterest in boys, and she thought aaliyah kind of understood that about her, anyways.
aaliyah opens her mouth, as if to say something, and then closes it, and azzi feels herself flush a little bit, though she doesnāt really know why. aaliyah is looking at her like she canāt quite figure something out, and it unnerves her.Ā
azzi squirms, and repeats āno really, what? now you have to tell me.ā its followed by a chorus of agreement from the other two girls, and aaliyah sighs.Ā
āhow many times have you been in love? we got kiki over here yappinā about her second guy of the year and yet iāve never heard you interested in a guy for more than a week.ā she says it like sheās trying to clue azzi in on something, yet all she can focus on is the first part of the question. and sheāsĀ embarrassedĀ .Ā
she flushes, and tries to ignore the anxiety that her biggest insecurity raises to the surface, steeling herself for her answer. her limited dating experience has never been embarrassing, because sheād always been a busy athlete and could brush it off as something she never had time for. but being 23 and never having been in love was secretly something that kept her up at night.Ā
the wine makes her bold, though, so she lifts her head and mumbles out a quick āiāve never- iāve never been in love.āĀ
the table is silent for a brief second, her words sinking in, but instead of shock or judgement gazing back at her, azzi is met with confusion and almostĀ amusementĀ .Ā
kiki is the first one to speak up. āwell we know that's not true.ā her tone is playful, as if azzi is kidding.
azzi stares at her blankly. āwhat dāyou mean?ā she laughs a little at their disbelieving looks, and then adds, ādonāt rub it in. it's not exactly something iām proud of.ā
still, sheās met with unnerving eyes. finally, aaliyah blurts out āi mean. we know you and paigeā¦ā she trails off without finishing, but the damage is done.
āwhat the fuck are you guys on about?ā she immediately says in response, half laughing, trying to lessen the tension. she ignores the way the unexpected mention of paige cuts at her heart. they havenāt spoken in, god, probably two or three months at this point, and the reminder twists something ugly in her chest as she waits for what promises to be a weird joke that falls flat.Ā
all three faces peering back at her seem entirely humorless though, and azzi starts to get the idea that sheās missing some sort of crucial piece of information. āi wasnāt in love with paige,ā she gets out, ignoring the way her voice catches on the name.
aaliyahās face softens. āwe donāt have to talk about it of you donāt want to but⦠you donāt have to hide that from us, azzi.āĀ
she splutters in response. āyou guys donāt actually think that-ā but the look on their faces belays that, in fact,Ā all three of themĀ somehow think that azzi was in love with paige.
Ā āguys. come on. that was just some weird internet theory. paige and i were just best friends.ā sheās defensive now, becauseĀ what the fuck is going on.Ā
her pulse is buzzing under her skin, no longer from just the wine, and she suddenly feels like the restaurant around them is really quiet, and everyone is listening in on this conversation. the ac must not be working properly either, because sheās sweating, legs sticking to the leather of the seat below her.Ā
georgia, graciously, breaks the silence, but the relief is short lived when azzi hears the nonsense that comes out of her mouth.Ā
āazzi, come on, i wasnāt even with you guys at uconn and i know you were more than friends. you donāt gotta pretend in front of us.ā
and then kiki is chiming in with āi mean everybody kinda knew itā¦ā and azzi feels like god is playing some kind of twisted prank on her.Ā
she turns back to aaliyah, hoping she can defend azzi, except her face looks a little horrified. like sheās realizing that in fact azziĀ wasnātĀ aware that everyone thought they were more than friends. she looks for support anyways, knowing that aaliyah had seen them at uconn, had understood that they were just intensely codependent and notĀ dating,Ā for the love of god.Ā
ācāmon, tell them we were just friends,ā she pleads to the older girl, expecting back up on at least this.Ā
āazziā¦ā she trails off, and azzi can only gape at all of them. āi mean, you guys were attached at the hip. you had sleepovers like 4 times a weekā¦ā she trails off, and azzi realizes three things in quick succession.Ā
one, aaliyah thought her and paige had been actually, truly dating, or hooking up, orĀ something.Ā two, this means that probably multiple other people on the team also thought they were something. and three, if kiki and georgia also thought that⦠somehow azzi had missed the memo that not only did random fans on the internet think theyād been in love, but thatĀ everyoneĀ had. she feels like sheās going to throw up.Ā
āyou guys are wrong. we were just best friends,ā she says, with as much conviction as she can muster, and itĀ isĀ the truth, even though her audience is making it feel like a lie. they had been just best friends, truly,Ā exceptĀ .Ā
except the one night azziĀ canāt rememberĀ , after the championship, when sheād woken up in paigeās hotel room with a blinding hangover and spotty memory. that in itself hadnāt been weird, but the mark on her collarbone had been new, and the way paige wouldnāt meet her eyes had been different, and, and. azzi shuts down the thoughts of that horrible morning and ensuing weeks.
she blinks back into the restaurant to look at her teammates, and she sees the dawning realization on their faces that sheās telling the truth, or most of it anyway, and they all look, well, a little shell-shocked.Ā Ā
she asks for clarification, even though she knows the answer already, āi mean did everyone- did everyone think we were-ā she canāt even finish the sentence, and doesnāt need to. She gets three nods immediately, and the playful mood that had existed at their table only minutes before has evaporated into the low lights above them.Ā
and theyāre all wrong, they allĀ have to be wrong,Ā because azzi isnāt even really into girls, and hadnāt been in love with paige, because she would have known. surely she would have known, or at least someone would have mentioned it to her. this feels like a bad dream that she canāt wake up from, because now she canāt stop thinking about paige, and how much she misses her laugh, and the curl of their fingers together, and how they havenāt gone this long without speaking since, well, ever.Ā
she forcefully shuts down thoughts of the blonde, because sheād beenĀ so goodĀ at blocking out how much she missed her, and this conversation is just messing with her wine-addled mind. she had not been in love with paige. she just hadnāt been, couldnāt have been.Ā
āyou guys are wrong,ā she says, extremely convincingly. because it's true, obviously. and the looks she receives in response are disbelieving, but they seem to understand that this isnāt something azzi wants to get into right now.Ā
āokay. if you say so,ā kiki replies gently, words laced with pity, and azzi hatesĀ everything.
she nods, trying to ignore the fact that she kind of feels like crying, and manages to get out an āi doā without her voice cracking.Ā
aaliyah gives her a long, searching look, before deciding to drop it. mercifully, she begins asking georgia about the date she went on a couple nights before, and the attention shifts.Ā
for the short rest of the dinner though, azzi is lost in a subtle, wine-induced panic. the girls leave her alone to her thoughts for the most part, seemingly understanding that she doesnāt have much to add, and she sighs in relief when the bill gets paid and the ubers begin to be called.Ā
outside, the muggy dc air hits her face and does nothing to cool the heat that's been simmering in her veins. as they disperse in front of the restaurant to go their separate ways, aaliyah hesitates for a second before climbing in the car that's awaiting her.Ā āif you ever want to talk about it⦠you know iām here right?ā
azzi doesnāt have to ask what she means. she nods, and pastes on the most convincing smile she can muster. āiām fine, really, lili. there's nothing to talk about.ā
at her disbelieving look, azzi rolls her eyes. āreally. i mean it.ā she pauses, and then allows a meek ābut iāll let you know if i change my mind.āĀ
aaliyah hums, and reaches out to squeeze her hand, before finally climbing into her car. āif you say so, fudd. gānight. love you. i'll see you at practice.ā
ā'night. love you too,ā she responds, and shuts the door gently, before looking up and searching for her own uber.Ā
the drive home is spent staring out the window trying not to cry. and it doesnāt make sense, sheĀ wasnātĀ in love with paige, but for some reason, out of all the times sheād ever been accused of dating paige, this one has rattled her the most.Ā
sheād always thought that the rumors had been kind of funny, in a ridiculous, distant way, and though theyād stopped joking about them as theyād gotten more intense in the later parts of their friendship, azzi had always thought that paige kind of thought they were amusing too.Ā
except, now that she really thinks about it, sheād stopped joking about the speculation because it used to make paige fidgety. and azzi had always thought it had just been because the rumors were so rampant, that it was awkward because they were so wrong, but now this stupid dinner and the stupid wine is making her not so sure.Ā
but no. she knows she wasnāt in love with paige. because. becauseĀ she would have known.Ā
her mind feels like it's going at a million miles a minute, flashes of paigeās smile and the way her head would always come to rest on azziās shoulder, and howĀ safeĀ sheād always felt next to paige, and-
her impending anxiety attack is put on pause when the car gets to her building, and as she thanks the driver and heads up into the elevators, she tries to reassure herself that it's just the wine, and the surprise information that it hadnāt just been strangers thinking they were together, but friends,Ā close friendsĀ , too.Ā
and it's already late, but when she is finally engulfed by the silence of her apartment, azzi does the only thing that she thinks will bring her any sense of clarity and drags her phone out of her purse.Ā Ā
katie picks up on the second ring (she ignores the part of her thatās first instinct is still to call paige when anything is wrong becauseĀ god fucking damn itĀ ), and azzi feels moderately better at her momās familiar āhelloā on the other side of the line.
āhi,ā is the only thing she can come up with in response, and she mentally curses her vocal cords for breaking on the singular word. so much for not revealing to her mother that sheās upset.Ā
āazzi honey, are you okay?ā comes the response, gentle with concern. and she is,Ā she is okayĀ except she kind of feels like the rug has been ripped out from under her, and she just needs her mom to tell her that everyone else is crazy.Ā
āiām fine, iām okay,ā she releases, but that feels like a lie so she continues. ācan i- can i ask you a question? and you canāt. you canāt laugh or think it's stupid or whatever.ā
katie hums in confusion on the other side of the line, and azzi just needs to say it before she loses the confidence of the wine sliding through her system.
ādid you ever- did you ever think i was in love with paige?ā
from the strangled sound on the other side of the phone, it's clearly not what she expected azzi to ask.Ā
āazzi.Ā sweetheart.Ā did you- were you not?ā and that. that gets her to finally shed the tears that have been brewing since dinner.Ā
her panicked āno!ā sounds a lot less convincing than she intends it to be, and she doesnāt- she doesnāt understand whatĀ the fuckĀ going on.Ā
katieās voice is gentle when she continues, understanding the fragility of the moment (and azziāsĀ sanityĀ ) and she states quietly, āi mean. i always thought the two of you were a little bit in love with each other. less so when you were younger, but.Ā azziĀ . i mean, you guys lived out of eachothers pockets for years. i always kind of thought you guys were more than friends.ā her words are soft, like she knows azzi canāt handle anything else, but they still pierce her heart like knives against a target.
and what the fuck ever.Ā
sheās really crying now, though sheās trying to keep it quiet and preserve the barest amount of pride she has left. it's just. everything everyone is saying isnāt making any sense because it's impossible to be in love with someone without knowing it.Ā
and yet, here azzi is, on the phone with her mother and maybe possibly coming to the realization that maybe she and paige werenāt exactly the most platonic of friends and it's at least a year too late. and then that last thought hits her square in the chest: the fact that she and paige havenāt been alone in the same room together in over a year, havenāt called in maybe longer, that it very well might be too late, and then her tears arenāt so silent anymore.Ā
she lets out a sob over the phone and her momās voice sounds worried when she says āoh, azzi. we thought you guys broke up last year. you never wanted to talk about what happened and we just assumed you were dating in secret and something happened. youāre telling me you werenāt- you neverā¦ā
she cuts her mom off with another āno!ā and this really might be the worst thing thatās ever happened, becauseĀ her mom thought they were dating. and then, because she needs to know for sure she asks again, voice thick with tears āso you think. you think that i was in love with paige?āĀ
thereās silence on the other side of the phone for a second, as katie processes how to respond. and then her mom mustĀ hate herĀ or something because all she says in response is āhoney, only you can answer that question. but i think that if youāre asking me, then you already know.āĀ
and, well, sheās right. and isnāt that just fucking awesome.
after hanging up on her mother and swearing up and down that sheāll call tomorrow when sheās more calm and coherent and notĀ losing her fucking mindĀ , azzi takes a long, still slightly tipsy shower.Ā
she thinks of paige six different times in the span of twenty minutes and contemplates slamming her head against the tile walls.Ā
itās as if aaliyah had uncovered this part of azziās brain that had been locked away, unbeknownst to her, and now that it was released it was determined to wreak as much havoc as possible.Ā
she knows she wonāt be able to sleep right away, the buzz of adrenaline, alcohol, and unexplored feelings too potent to let her rest, so she does probably the dumbest thing she can think of and grabs a bottle of wine and the blanket that paige bought her when she was 17 and plants herself on the couch. she figures she deserves the pinot something-or-other that someone had gifted her when sheād had her little housewarming party in the spring.Ā
and then sheās reminded of said party, and the last minute invite sheād sent to paige as a peace offering, as a plea for normalcy. the older girl had been in the area, azzi knows because drew had mentioned it to her brothers, and she hadnāt exactly expected paige to show up and be normal, relaxed and funny paige,Ā azziāsĀ paige, but she also hadnāt expected the text saying she couldnāt come with a half hearted excuse.Ā
that had been the nail in the coffin for azzi, the sign that she should stop trying. because as much as the unanswered texts and awkward interactions after uconn visits and stilted hugs after team trips to watch the wings had hurt, the realisation that paige had decided not to be there for azzi on a night that was supposed to be a celebration of her accomplishments had made her understand how wide the gap between them had really grown. paige hadĀ neverĀ chosen not to be there for azzi.Ā
and now sheās beginning to understand that it had been heartbreak, in its truest form, that had settled into her bones that day, not merely disappointment. sheād cried in the bathroom at her own party, briefly, when sheād realized that paige wasnāt coming, and.Ā
and so many things about their relationship are starting to make sense.Ā
the way theyād told each other everything except anything to do with love interests or hookups because it was an unspoken rule between them that the other didnāt want to know. the way azzi had been completely comfortable with nudity in front of teammates except around paige, always turning around when the blonde was changing and vice versa. the way they didnāt gone more than a couple hours without communicating unless one of them was asleep for like. eight years. the way paige had slotted so seamlessly into her life that sheād felt like family, except the word sister had never seemed like an appropriate word for what they were to each other.
and then. and then azzi is suddenlyĀ angry.Ā angry at herself for not figuring this out sooner. angry at her friends for never informing her that she was in love with her best friend. and most importantly, she was fucking furious at paige. because the more she thinks back at their relationship, and the good and the bad, the more she realizes that paige had to have known. sheās struck with the thought that paige had probably been in love with her too, but instead of comfort, all azzi can feel is the grief of losing her before they were ever even something more, and theĀ furyĀ at paige for letting them fall apartĀ .Ā
because it had been paige that had stopped responding to text messages. paige who had subtly put a stop to any and all physical contact that azzi had tried to instigate. and it had been paige who had started and ended their dizzying, agonizing conversation about the championship night.Ā
azzi knows sheād fucked up by refusing to aknowledge the fact that they had definitely kissed, definitely more than kissed that night. except itĀ hadĀ been hazy. she couldnāt remember the details of how theyād gotten from the after party in the hotel to paige's room. she couldnāt remember what theyād said or done or even what the time frame of that night had looked like. she only remembered blurry snapshots of paigeās mouth against hers, and the feeling of her hands tangling in the blondeās hair, and the proof, stark against her chest, that paige's mouth had moved lower andĀ meantĀ it.
and then azzi hadnāt acknowledged it the next morning, because what on earth do you say when youāre pretty sure you made out with your best friend of eight years but you canāt actually remember. and paige had been in a horrible mood, and theyād fought, like they never did, about something entirely unrelated, and azzi had been blindsided, like she was missing something throughout the entire argument.Ā
and now. azzi is starting to understand that it hadnāt been that paige didnāt care when sheād put distance between them, flitting off to the league and leaving calls and texts unanswered, but that sheād caredĀ tooĀ much.Ā
still, this doesnāt make azzi feel better, and sheās pissed. because how very dare paige fuck off without telling azzi that theyād been in love, and leave her to think that paige hadnāt needed her.Ā
she must be drunker than she thought she was, because suddenly her anger boils over and sheās doing probably the stupidest thing she possibly could, which is picking up her phone and dialing the number still pinned at the top of her contacts list.Ā
its late now, like beyond a reasonable time to be calling anyone, let alone your ex best friend who you donāt speak to anymore, but somewhere in azziās hazy mind she knows that paige is an hour behind and that sheĀ alwaysĀ picks up the phone for azzi.Ā
it rings four times, and each one causes her heartbeat to pick up even faster, and azzi doesnāt know what would be worse, paige answering or paigeĀ not.Ā (she does know. it's not the former)
and then the line clicks midway through the fifth ring and paige says āazzi?ā and azzi hears her voice for the first time in months, since they played each other in may and could barely look at eachother, and all the fight and anger that was simmering in her blood seems to disappear at how broken her name sounds coming from paigeās lips.Ā
she can only muster up a strangled āhiā into the phone,Ā really eloquent, azzi, great jobĀ , and she realizes when she says it that sheās crying again because sheĀ sounds like sheās cryingĀ , and isnāt that just perfect.Ā
immediately, azzi can sense the shift in paigeās energy over the phone as her voice rings out in a worried āazzi? are you okay?ā and azzi has forgotten entirely why she called in the first place or what to say.
āno, yeah, māfine,ā she answers, but she know she doesnāt sound convincing, and wow, okay, this pinot something-or-other must be like, at least 15% because azzi then blurts out a pitiful āmājust drunk and i miss you.ā
paige exhales sharply into the phone, the ensuing silence deafening, and azzi feels humiliation curl in her gut, regretting everything between the day she was born and now that has led her to this moment.Ā
but then paige says, weakly, her voice slightly muffled over the distance, āi miss you too, az. so much.āĀ
she expects to feel relief at the words, the knowledge that paige misses her too, probably just as much, but itās only a reminder to azzi of how badly theyāve fucked everything up.Ā
and then she suddenly remembers that they have an away game in dallas, in only a week or so, and she really needs toĀ get a gripĀ but instead she hears herself speaking again, before she can process the words. āwhen iām in dallas next week, can we maybe-ā
sheās cut off by a womanās voice in the background, on the other end of the phone, asking, āpaige? are you still staying over?āĀ
azzi feels like sheās been thrown off the side of a mountain.Ā
or rather sheĀ wishesĀ she was thrown off the side of a mountain because that probably feels better than the absolute devastation currently coursing out from her heart and into her bloodstream and clogging her lungs.Ā
she makes a choked off sound in the back of her throat, just as paige stammers out an uneven ācan you give me a second?ā her voice sounds distant, because it's not meant for azzi, and for the second time in the span of a minute, azzi regrets being born at all.Ā
she hears movement through the phoneline, imagining paige moving through this unknown womanās house, andĀ fuck,Ā why hadnāt she considered this? that paige had moved on? here azzi was, finally figuring out her shit, and calling paige in the middle of the night like some desperate ex-something and paige might have had a wholeĀ girlfriend.Ā
azzi feels bile rise in her throat.Ā
somehow, she musters up the courage to croak out āno paige, it's okay. you go. iām sorry for calling so la-ā
āno,Ā no, azzi,Ā itās fine, it's never too late for you,ā and. well. that might just be the fucking joke of the century.Ā Ā
āno, really paige, it's okay. i need to sleep too.ā
thereās resigned silence between them for a second, and azzi thinks paige is going to simply hang up, and then the older girl whispers āwere you gonna ask to hang out? in- in dallas?ā
azziās āyesā is embarrassingly quick to tumble from her lips.Ā
paige lets out a quiet laugh, and it's brief and small, and really probably more of an amused exhale through her nose than anything else, butĀ she laughs,Ā and azzi feels the twisted fluttering of hope bloom in her chest, despite herself.
āokay. text me tomorrow, then. if you really want to do something.ā there's a challenge in paigeās words, like she doesnāt think azzi will, and that stings, a little, but she tries not to let it.Ā
āi will. i promise.ā a pause, and then when the other girl says nothing, āgānight paige,ā she whispers, and she means that promise. she knows sheās drunk, and she guesses there might have been a similar exchange all those horrible months ago, hence paigeās quiet mistrust, but she knows in her bones that sheāll remember this tomorrow, that sheāll want to see paige.
āgoodnight, azzi. sweet dreams.ā and then, the dial tone.Ā
in the silence of the room, masochistically, azzi realizes that thatās the first time theyāve hung up the phone without saying i love you since they were fifteen. the irony is not lost on her.Ā
she falls asleep that night curled up into a ball, cheeks wet and the blanket paige got her still tucked around her feet.
AN: ummm thank you for reading! and please tell me how you liked if you so please! i am a people pleaser to my core so it might make me write faster. there should only be one more part and i'm about halfway done writing it! i hope this inspires you freaks to post stuff on ao3 bc it is NEEDED. xoxoxoxo
update: chapter 2











