Venomous hearts
Mattheo and Theo have both set their sights on you igniting a rivalry.
I might make this a series.
No warnings.
The Slytherin common room was dimly lit, the emerald glow from the fireplace casting an eerie shimmer over the cold, stone walls. You sat in your usual spot by the window, attempting to focus on the Potions essay Snape had assigned, but the atmosphere in the room was far too tense for concentration.
Mattheo Riddle lounged across the couch, his dark eyes locked on you like a predator watching prey. He twirled his wand lazily, but his jaw was clenched, betraying the storm raging beneath his cool exterior. Across the room, Theodore Nott leaned against the wall, his arms crossed over his chest. His icy blue eyes flicked between you and Mattheo, his expression unreadable yet charged with unspoken challenge.
The tension between them had been brewing for weeks, and you, the unwilling centerpiece of their silent war, were caught in the crossfire.
âIs the essay really that interesting, love?â Mattheo drawled, his voice dripping with a mixture of arrogance and irritation.
You glanced up, trying to ignore the way his lips curved into a smirk, though his eyes held a sharper edge. âUnlike some people, Mattheo, I prefer to pass my classes.â
Theo let out a soft scoff from across the room, drawing both your and Mattheoâs attention. âMaybe she just prefers spending her time with people who donât treat everything like a game,â he said coolly, his tone a deliberate jab.
Mattheo sat up, his smirk vanishing. âCareful, Theo,â he warned, his voice low and dangerous. âYouâre treading on thin ice.â
Theo pushed off the wall, taking a step closer. He looked calm, but you could see the tension in his shoulders, the way his hands twitched at his sides. âWhat are you going to do, Mattheo? Hex me because sheâs tired of your theatrics?â
âGuysâ you started, but your voice was drowned out by Mattheoâs sudden rise to his feet.
âYou donât get to talk about theatrics, Nott,â Mattheo snarled, his wand now pointed at Theo. âYouâve been circling her like a bloody vulture for months. Iâve seen the way you look at her.â
Theo didnât flinch. Instead, he tilted his head, his lips curling into a taunting smile. âAnd what about you? Acting like you own her, like sheâs some prize to be won. Thatâs not affection, Riddle; thatâs obsession.â
Your heart pounded as you stood, placing yourself between them before things escalated further. âEnough! Both of you!â
Mattheoâs eyes flicked to you, softening slightly, but his grip on his wand didnât loosen. Theo, however, stepped back, though his gaze lingered on you.
âYouâre not some pawn in their game, Y/N,â Theo said quietly, his voice laced with an unexpected vulnerability. âYou deserve someone who sees you, not someone who uses you to stroke their ego.â
Mattheo scoffed, but you caught the flash of hurt in his expression. âDonât act like youâre some kind of hero, Theo. We all know youâre no better than me.â
The room fell silent, the air thick with tension and unsaid words. You looked between them, your heart aching at the pain they both carried, the pain they were now projecting onto you.
âIâm not a prize,â you said firmly, your voice steady despite the turmoil inside you. âAnd I wonât let either of you turn this into a competition. Figure out your own issues before dragging me into them.â
With that, you grabbed your essay and stormed out of the common room, leaving them both behind.
As the door slammed shut, neither Mattheo nor Theo moved. For the first time, they were forced to confront the truth: their feelings for you werenât just a game, but the scars theyâd leave might be too deep to repair.










