[The advice in this article can be adapted to suit the needs of other hidden services, including ones which are legal in your jurisdiction. The threat model in mind is that of a drug market. The tone is that of a grandfather who is always annoyingly right, who can't help but give a stream-of-consciousness schooling to some whippersnapper about the way the world works. If this article inspires you to go on a crime spree and you get caught, don't come crying to me about it.]
You've decided that you're bored with your cookie-cutter life of working at a no-name startup, getting paid in stock options and empty promises. You want a taste of the good life. Good for you, kid. I used to run a fairly popular hidden service (DOXBIN) that was seized by the FBI after 3 1/2 years of spreading continuous butthurt, then subsequently repossessed from the feds. Because I managed to not get raided, I'm one of the few qualified to instruct others on hidden services and security, simply because I have more real-world experience operating hidden services than the average tor user. In other words, very little of this advice is of the armchair variety, as you'll often find in abundance the Internet. But enough about me. Let's talk about your future as an internet drug lord.
First things first, you need to cover the legal, historical and political angles. Read up on various drug kingpins and cartels from the 20th century. Learn everything you can about how they rose and fell ( you can safety ignore all the parts about intelligence agencies backing one drug cartel over another, because that's not going to happen to you). Once you've got a good command of that, read everything you can about busted drug market operators and branch out into cybercrime investigations as well. It wouldn't hurt to make yourself familiar with law enforcement and intelligence agency tactics either. You'll find that virtually all drug kingpins either get murdered or go to prison. Let those lessons sink in, then find a good drug lawyer and make plans for being able to pay them when The Man seizes everything you own. While you're dreaming big about making fat stacks of fake internet money, do some research on Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties and extradition treaties.
Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs) are self-explanatory. Country A will help Country B do whatever it takes to aid a cybercrime investigation should some aspect of the crime bleed over into Country A. Figure out which countries don't provide legal assistance to your country in these cases, then find hosting services that are based there. You'll shorten this list by determining which hosts allow tor, or at least don't explicitly forbid it in their Terms of Service (you don't care about exit bandwidth. You just want relays. Remember this for later in the article). Last but not least, sort out which hosts accept payment options that don't make you sweat bullets over the fact that the NSA has been monitoring global financial transactions since at least the 1970s. You will want to avoid any host that advertises itself as bulletproof -- they'll probably kit your box and siphon everything of value, in addition to overcharging you for the privilege of running on older hardware -- and any host which sells a cheap VPS and promises to guarantee your privacy.
Extradition treaties mean that if you're in Country A and do something that makes Country B want to prosecute you, Country A is most likely going to give you a one way ticket to Country B. If or when your box gets seized and you know the heat is on, you're going to want to beat it to a place that won't send you back, where you will presumably live out the rest of your days. Just make sure you've made enough money to grease all the right palms in your new life, or the road ahead may be extremely bumpy. If you're smart, you'll permanently move to this country well before you have any trouble with law enforcement.
One last thing before moving on: Don't be so stupid as to attempt to hire a hitman to kill anyone. Murder-related charges have no statute of limitations, which means you won't get to write a tell-all book about what a sly bastard you are when this wild ride is a distant memory. If you've reached a point in your new career where murdering people makes sense, it's time to walk away. Don't get corrupted like Dread Pirate Roberts.
This section tries to be as operating system independent as possible. You'll want to consult the documentation of your OS for specifics. The technical side of running a hidden service and not getting owned by cops is a lot harder than just installing stuff and crossing your fingers. The recommendations in this section WILL NOT protect you from 0days in the wild, but should help somewhat with damage control. Remember, if they want to own your hidden service, it will probably happen eventually.
Before you even think about installing bitwasp and tor, you need to really understand how tor works. Go to freehaven.net and read the white papers until your eyes glaze over, then continue reading until you're out of papers to read. Pay particular attention to the hidden service papers. If you feel like you didn't understand something, come back to that paper again when you have more knowledge. A lot of the papers explain some of the same concepts with slight differences in the intros. Don't skim over them, because you might read someone's rewording that will clarify an idea for you. Check back with freehaven regularly. Once you're up to speed, a good next step is to keep up with the tor project's mailing lists. [1]
While you're doing all of this reading, it's (mostly) safe to go ahead and install tor on a box on your local network, purely for experimentation. Keep in mind that the NSA will start scooping up all of your packets simply because you visited torproject.org. That means don't post code questions related your drug market on Stack Exchange, if you want to avoid giving The Man morsels he can use for parallel construction. Once you've gotten hidden services working for http and ssh, you're going to take the first baby step towards evading casual discovery: Bind your hidden services to localhost and restart them.
The next step in your journey towards changing the drug business forever is to grab the transparent proxying firewall rules for your operating system to make sure they work. [2] They will guard against attacks that cause your box to send packets to a box the attacker controls, which is useful in thwarting attempts to get the box IP. You may wish to have a setup similar to an anonymous middle box, preferably without public IPs where possible, so if your application gets rooted tor isn't affected.
Speaking of applications, do everything you can to ensure that the application code you use to power your hidden service isn't made of Swiss cheese and used bandaids. To protect against other types of attacks, you will want to identify any pre-compiled software that your users will touch and compile it yourself with hardening-wrapper or it's equivalent, plus any custom flags you want to use. If you keep vulnerabilities from the application and server to a minimum, your biggest worries will be tor-related.
You will only connect to your production box via a hidden service. It's a good idea to get into that habit early. The only time deviating from this pattern is acceptable is when you have to upgrade tor, at which time you'll want to have a script ready that drops your firewall rules and unbinds ssh from localhost just long enough for you to login, do the upgrade, re-apply the firewall rules and bind ssh to localhost again. If you're not ready to deal with the latency, you're not ready to do any of this. Don't forget to transparently proxy the machine you use too, so you don't slip up by mistake.
On the subject of the machine, you need to automate the process of both setting up your hidden service and of destroying it. Proactively change servers every few months, in order to frustrate law enforcement attempts to locate and seize your site. Your creation script should install everything your site needs as well as all configuration files. Your clean-up script needs to destroy all evidence, preferably with a tool like srm.
Regarding time-related issues: Always select either UTC or a time zone that doesn't match the box's location. You will also do this to the box you use to interact with your hidden service every day. If you read the whitepapers, you will probably note a recurring theme of clock skew-related attacks, mostly directed at clients, in some of the older papers. Tor won't even start if the clock skew is off by too much.
If you want to have some fun at the expense of business in the short term, intentionally take your service offline periodically in order to mess up attempts to match your downtime with public information. If you're the kind of person with access to botnets, you could DDoS (Distributed Denial of Service) some provider at the same time on the off chance that someone might connect the dots. This counter-measure will only work on researchers looking at public info, not nation state actors with an ax to grind.
I've saved some of the hardest stuff for the last part of this section. It's hard because you have to make choices and it's unclear which of those choices are the best. It's a bit like a Choose Your Own Adventure book. In that spirit, all I can do is lay out the possibilities in as much of a Herodotus-like way as possible.
One thing you have to consider is whether you want to run your hidden service as a relay or not. If it's a relay, you'll have extra cover traffic from other innocent tor users. But if your relay goes down at the same time as your hidden service, it will be far more likely to be noticed. Federal criminal complaints make a big deal of seized hidden services not being relays, but three relays were taken down at around the same time as Operation Onymous, so that's not a guaranteed defense. The choice is yours.
Remember when I said to take note of hosts that don't ban tor outright? This is the part where you give back to the community in the form of tor relays or bridges. [3] The feel-good aspects of this move are along the same lines as drug barons who build schools and hospitals, but this is more immediately self-serving. You're going buy several servers to set up strictly as relays or bridges, then configure your hidden service box to use only those relays or bridges to enter the tor network. Here's where things start to get theoretical.
If an adversary is running a guard node discovery attack -- in which an attacker is able to determine the node you're using to enter the tor network -- against your service and you're using your own relays as entry nodes, the damage they can do will be limited to DoS (Denial of Service) if your relays are not linkable to your identity. However, if you're entering the tor network with bridge nodes, an attacker will probably say "WTF?" at first unless they determine they've found a bridge node. Bridge nodes don't use nearly as much bandwidth as relays because there is not a public list of them, so an intelligence agency would have less traffic to sift through, which makes correlation easier. On the other hand, using bridge nodes also allows you to run obfsproxy [4] on both the bridges and your hidden service. obfsproxy allows you to make tor traffic appear to be another type of traffic, which is a good defense against non-Five Eyes entities. For example, your hosting provider may decide to monitor for tor traffic for their own reasons. Just make sure your relays/bridges aren't linkable to you or to each other.
One last thing about guard node discovery attacks: The Naval Research Lab published a paper in July 2014 about the "Sniper Attack," [5] which in short works like this: The attacker discovers your guard nodes, then uses an amplified DoS trick to exhaust the memory on all of your nodes. The attacker keeps doing this until your hidden service uses guard nodes that they control. Then it's game over. If your hidden service's entry nodes are all specified in your torrc file and they get DoSed, your service will go offline. In this situation, if all of your relays are down, you essentially have an early warning canary that you're being targeted. In other words: This is the best possible time to book your one-way ticket to your chosen non-extradition country. For those of you with a background in writing exploits, this is similar in principle to how stack smashing protection will render some exploits either unable to function or will turn them into a DoS. Personally, I recommend an ever-changing list of relays or bridges. Add a few new ones at a pre-determined interval, and gradually let old ones go unpaid.
This section is critical, especially when things start to break down. If everything else goes bad, following this section closely or not could be the difference between freedom and imprisonment.
This is important enough to re-state: Transparently proxy your tor computer. This is a good first line of defense, but it is far from the only way to protect yourself.
Do not contaminate your regular identity with your Onion Land identity. You're an aspiring drug kingpin. Go out and pay cash for another computer. It doesn't have to be the best or most expensive, but it needs to be able to run Linux. For additional safety, don't lord over your new onion empire from your mother's basement, or any location normally associated with you. Leave your phone behind when you head out to manage your enterprise so you aren't tracked by cell towers. Last but not least for this paragraph, don't talk about the same subjects across identities and take counter-measures to alter your writing style.
Don't log any communications, ever. If you get busted and have logs of conversations, the feds will use them to bust other people. Logs are for undercover cops and informants, and have no legitimate use for someone in your position. Keep it in your head or don't keep it at all.
At some point, your enterprise is going to have to take on employees. Pulling a DPR move and demanding to see ID from high-volume sellers and employees will just make most people think you're a fed, which will leave your potential hiring pool full of dumbasses who haven't even tried to think any of this out. It will also make it easier for the feds to arrest your employees after they get done arresting you. If your enterprise is criminal in nature -- whether you're selling illegal goods and services or you're in a repressive country that likes to re-educate and/or kill dissidents -- an excellent way of flushing out cops is to force them to get their hands not just dirty, but filthy, as quickly as possible. Don't give them time to get authorization to commit a crime spree. If there's a significant amount of time between when they're given crimes to commit and the commission of those crimes, you need to assume you've got an undercover cop on your hands and disengage. If they commit the crime(s) more or less instantly, you should be fine unless you've got the next Master Splynter on your trail. [6]
Disinformation is critical to your continued freedom. Give barium meat tests to your contacts liberally. [7] It doesn't matter if they realize they're being tested. Make sure that if you're caught making small talk, you inject false details about yourself and your life. You don't want to be like Ernest Lehmitz, a German spy during World War II who sent otherwise boring letters about himself containing hidden writing about ship movements. He got caught because the non-secret portion of his letters gave up various minor personal details the FBI correlated and used to find him after intercepting just 12 letters. Spreading disinformation about yourself takes time, but after a while the tapestry of deceptions will practically weave itself.
Ensure that your communications and data are encrypted in transit and at rest whenever applicable. This means PGP for e-mail and OTR for instant messaging conversations. If you have to give data to someone, encrypt it first. For the tor-only box you use for interacting with your hidden service, full disk encryption is required. Make a password that's as long and complex as you can remember ("chippy1337" is not an example of a good password). Last but not least, when you're done using your dedicated tor computer, boot into memtest86+. Memtest86+ is a tool for checking RAM for errors, but in order to do that it has to write into each address. Doing so essentially erases the contents of the RAM. Turning your computer off isn't good enough. [8] If you're planning to use TAILS, it will scrub the RAM for you automatically when you shut down. Once your RAM is clean, remove the power cord and any batteries if you're feeling extra paranoid. The chips will eventually lose any information that is still stored in them, which includes your key. The feds can do a pre-dawn raid if they want, but if you follow this step and refuse to disclose your password, you'll make James Comey cry like a small child.
Use fake info when signing up for hosting services. Obfuscate the money trail as much as possible and supply fake billing info. I prefer registering as criminals who are on the run, high government officials, or people I dislike. If your box gets seized and your hosting company coughs up the info, or if a hacking group steals your provider's customer database (It happens more often than you'd think), your hosting information needs to lead to a dead end. All signs in Operation Onymous point to operators being IDed because they used real info to register for hosting service and then their box got decloaked.
Speaking of money, you're going to have to figure out how to launder your newfound assets, and we're not talking about using a couple bitcoin laundering services and calling it a day. You also shouldn't go out and buy a Tesla. Living beyond your means is a key red flag that triggers financial and fraud investigations. Remember, money is just another attack vector. Washing ill-gotten gains is a time-honored drug business tradition and one that you would be a fool not to engage in. You can only use your hard-won profits to send shitexpress.com packages to people you don't like so many times.
Take-away: If you rely only on tor to protect yourself, you're going to get owned and people like me are going to laugh at you. Remember that someone out there is always watching, and know when to walk away. Do try to stay safe while breaking the law. In the words of Sam Spade, "Success to crime!"
Sources: [1] https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo [2] https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/TransparentProxy [3] https://www.torproject.org/docs/bridges [4] https://www.torproject.org/projects/obfsproxy.html.en [5] http://www.nrl.navy.mil/itd/chacs/biblio/sniper-attack-anonymously-deanonymizing-and-disabling-tor-network [6] http://www.pcworld.com/article/158005/article.html [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Canary_trap&oldid=624932671 [8] https://freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/felten/new-research-result-cold-boot-attacks-disk-encryption/
