say my nameÂ
8.5k / pairing: brat tamer!joel miller x f!reader
psycho masterlist main masterlist
summary: Itâs Joelâs birthday, and his brother, Tommy, is in town to celebrate. You meet the more charming Miller for the first time, and the two of you flirt up a storm. By the end of the night, Joelâs pissed and jealous. But that doesnât stop you from moaning Tommyâs name in bed.Â
warnings/information: MA 18+ (minors DNI), no outbreak, brat tamer!Joel, somewhat established relationship (whatever that relationship may be ((situationship, relationship, etc.)), toxic!couple, swearing, dirty talk, pet names, fingering, slapping, degradation, praise kink, spitting, choking, blood, marking kink, creampie, pussy smacking (??), lots of dom!joel brought out by jealous!joel, overstimulation, Tommy being a flirt, angst, mentions of being cheated on, Joel being a menace, unprotected p in v (wrap your willy or whateva), half-ass editing tbh
A/N: happy birthday to Joel Miller!! I was picturing this entire prompt with pixel Joel, thanks to @macfrog - this part is based off this request sent in!Â
You did a lot of stupid things tonight. Wearing your shortest dress, stalking Joel to his hangout with Tommy, flirting with his brother for the majority of the night. But now, you were ready to do the stupidest thing yet. You moan into his ear, your eyes fluttering closed in pleasure as you feel your orgasm begin to approach. âFuck me, Tommy.â It hits Joel like a ton of bricks. All his movements pause. He pulls away just half an inch and stares down at you. A cold, downright mean look crosses his face once youâve popped your eyes open to take a look at him. The room suffocates you in silence. âWhat did you say?â
September 26th, 2023. Itâs Joelâs forty-second birthday!
The thought alone riles you awake. You love birthdays. You especially love when itâs Joelâs birthday because he hates his birthday. You have no idea why, he looks more and more handsome with each year that he blows out a candle.Â
You think about these things curled up into his side, chin on his chest while your fingers lightly grazed over his stippled grey chest hair. It was barely past the early morning hours. You gently trace over the etched lines in his forehead and between his brows. He must scowl at you even in his sleep. You should be asleep, too, especially after having spent the late hours of September 25th celebrating the end of Joelâs forty-first year with a bang. Literally. Â
âShit,â you mutter under your breath, clutching his comforter to your bare chest as your panties are just out of reach on the floor a few feet from the bed. You huff and flee the warmth of his bed to retrieve them in as much silence as you can muster, watching him carefully let out a puff of air through his parted lips before lightly rolling over and spooning your pillow in the process. You stifle a giggle as you grab his t-shirt he threw off in the midst of getting handsy with you last night.Â
âHappy last day of being forty-one, old timer.â
âShut up and bend over.â
He always did have a way with words.Â
You managed to sneak downstairs without Joel catching you in his arms. Your bare feet meet the cold tile of his kitchen floor.Â
Joelâs home looked like you might imagine. Dark walls, not exactly black but not exactly grey or navy. He has a desk, a messy one that is littered with bills and invoices scattered with pencils that had the erasers shaved down to nothing. There was a large flat screen mounted to the wall, and a television console below it filled with old vinyl records and random CDs. He did have a few plants scattered around, and he actually took very good care of them. There were a few dishes in the sink from dinner last night. Empty beer cans on the half-wall by his back garage door. His keys and wallet were thrown haphazardly on the counter.Â
These are the things that make you adore staying at Joelâs place, it was so homey and cozy. These were the things that made Joel, Joel.Â
You throw your hair up and out of your way, finding the box of cake mix you stashed in the back of his pantry for this very special occasion. And just like that, you were a chef in Joelâs kitchen. Or was it a baker?Â
Despite your best efforts, the cake was just a mess. And there were no redoes with cakes. And when you were shopping, you were thinking a little too much about yourself rather than Joel, so the cake was coated in pink icing. It was a shit cake, but you hoped Joel would like it. He wasnât a guy with a big sweet tooth, but youâd force him to have a slice since this was your labor of love.Â
U CANâT PICK YOUR FATHER BUT U CAN PICK YOUR DADDY was lettered with red icing and cute pink assorted sprinkles.Â
The smell of freshly baked cake woke him up.Â
âYou burninâ somethinâ?â Joelâs tired voice echoed in the kitchen.Â
He was wearing grey sweats and his black boxers, the band peaking out from the top of his waistband as he rubbed tiredly at his eyes. He looked like a big oaf fresh from sleep, shuffling past you to the oven and turning on the fan to air out the smoke and smell.Â
âHa-ha. Nothingâs that burnt. Itâs your birthday cake!â You cooed as you showed him what you made.Â
The word birthday was enough to make him roll his eyes.Â
âDidnât have to make me anythinâ. Just another day.â He muttered but came up behind you to take a look at the cake nonetheless. You watched with a proud smile as the left side of his mouth quirked up upon reading the design.Â
âDo you like it?â You asked, turning your back to the counter and letting his hips pin you there. His large, warm palm settled low on your waist. You watch as he swipes his index finger into the frosting, observing the sugary cream before his eyes set on yours. His orbs are as black as night as he offers you a taste.Â
You maintain his eye contact as you lean in and wrap your mouth around his finger, hollowing your cheeks as you suckle it off and lap your tongue around the tip before letting him go with a soft smirk.Â
âLike it âcause you made it. Thatâs all.â Joelâs chest hums as he speaks, his head ducking down to catch your lips in a delicate kiss. The delicate part doesnât last for long. His kisses turn heavy, and his cock hardens against your thigh as he bends you backward against the counter.Â
Your nails catch his shoulders in a desperate attempt not to smash into the cake. You know that if he gets too into this, heâll end up pushing it aside so radically that your creation will end up on the floor, so you quickly nudge it out of reach before continuing.Â
Heâs hungry, his tongue lines your bottom lip, still coated in a sugary taste, before he explores the inside of your mouth dominantly. Youâre whimpering in excitement as his possessive hands lift you up onto the counter, your baking instruments clattering around you and rolling, making a complete mess, but you donât care. Itâs Joelâs birthday, after all.Â
You gasp into his mouth as he cups your clothed pussy and gently pats his fingers against you. The sensation makes your head fall back, and your eyes flutter closed. Your lips part just a fraction, Joel takes the opportunity to slip his tongue back inside to wrestle with your own. He pats you again, and you feel your panties grow a wet spot as white heat pools your insides.Â
âJust how I like it, ready to be taken like a little slut in the morninâ.â His rigid voice growled, suppressing you of any strength you had left to resist collapsing across the counter.Â
Both of you pause, irritated facial expressions matching when Joelâs phone starts to ring.Â
Your heavy pants mingle in the air between you with indecision. You glare at him as he moves half an inch away, the grip on his shoulders tightening in need. Donât pick it up, Joel.Â
He closes his lips and lightly squints at you in disapproval as he stands up straight and starts toward his phone. You throw your head back and groan, slipping your hand over where his fingers just ghosted over the material of your panties. You lick your lips and watch him as he takes the call. He looks over the screen at the contact, his eyes shift to you. Heâs hesitating. Not because heâs left you hot and heavy on the kitchen counter, but because heâs shielding his phone from you.Â
So help me god, motherfucker, if I find out youâre cheating on me, I will-
Your nerves are settled when he huffs and swipes right to answer the call. ââey Tommy.â After a beat, Joel rolls his eyes to himself. âYeah, yeah, thanks. Just another day.âÂ
Your eyes blink slowly. It was his brother you had yet to meet. You hum lightly as you sink your hand past the band of your panties, soft lace grazing your knuckles while you slip your fingers between your delicate folds. You slowly pry open the one foot you have kicked up on the counter, spreading your leg wider so Joel can see you playing with yourself. Heâs still not looking. You need his attention.Â
âYeah, we can do somethinâ, if that somethinâ means youâre payinâ for beers at the bar.â He said with a tired, but playful smirk. Youâre growing so wet at the sight of him. Your fingers make a squelching noise as you slowly push two fingers inside your aching hole. This catches his attention.Â
His head whips to you like a prowling lion hearing a twig snap. His eyes narrow on the target of the noise before they dart up to you. You know that look.Â
Take your hand out of your fuckinâ panties. Donât you fuckinâ touch yourself.Â
You cock your head with an attitude. âSay it with your chest.â You pipe up, so loud that the voice on the other line chirps in.Â
âWho was that?â You smirk at the attention Tommyâs already given you.Â
âHi, Tommy!â You shout, and now Joelâs really pissed. He comes up and clamps his hand over your mouth, glaring daggers into your big doe-eyed pupils.Â
âIs that your girl, big brother?âÂ
Joelâs jaw clicks tighter, his breath coming out in hot, annoyed puffs through his aquiline nose.Â
âYou hidinâ her from me? Invite her to drinks tonight!â Tommy shoots out the invite before Joel can take it away. You slowly lick up the hand thatâs holding your mouth hostage. Joel is used to this. He only adds more pressure to his hold on your mouth.Â
He glares at you and juts his jaw around in annoyance, considering Tommyâs offer. âYeah.. yeah, weâll see,â Joel murmurs while you keep tonguing his hand. He gives your face a little slap, a stupid moan escaping your lips before he grips your cheeks again once more and covers your mouth.Â
Donât forget whoâs in charge here, little bitch.Â
You hum quietly against his hand and wrap your legs firmly around his hips. He stumbles forward half a step. You can feel his hardened length protruding from his gray sweats, your cores lightly grinding against one another as you purposely whimpered against his palm.Â
Not long after, Joel ends the phone call with Tommy, and he begrudgingly releases his slobbery hand from your mouth and pushes back from the hold you attempted to lock him in. You huff as he leaves the kitchen, watching as he rakes his fingers up and down his beard and gently scratches at the skin. What was up with him?Â
âWeâre going out for drinks tonight?â You pester after you both have taken a shower for far too long, the steam fogging up his mirror and making Joelâs skin a light rosy pink.Â
He lets out a short sarcastic chuckle. âIâm goinâ out tonight. Youâre stayinâ here.âÂ
You frown as you look Joel over, his stern facial expression matching his tone.Â
âI donât know who you think youâre talking to, Iâm going out tonight. With you. This is the third time Iâve tried to meet Tommy in person and-â
âAnd nothinâ.â He intercepts, venom dripping from his words that makes your throat become scorching hot with anger.Â
You have a hard time letting this go. Especially since whenever Tommy was in town, Joel magically came up with every excuse in the book to keep you from properly meeting his younger brother. Was Joel ashamed of you? He didnât want Tommy to think that this was the type of girl Joel kept in his company. He didnât want you to embarrass him. Thatâs always what it came down to.Â
You brushed past him, your shoulder laying a heavy hit to his arm as you fled the bathroom with haste. You enter his bedroom and find your bag carrying your clothes for the weekend. You pulled on whatever you could find as hot rage made your skin tingle.
âWhere you goinâ, angel?â Joel tries to half-ass console you, stopping your movements, taking the keys you had just dug out from the depth of your bag, and holding them up so tall they were out of your reach even on your tippy toes.Â
âGive them back, Joel.â You had a burning feeling in your chest, and Joel was fighting with fire.Â
He just shakes his head, his eyes looking over you with a tight jawline. âNeed you to relax. Last time you got this pissed at me, you keyed half of my fuckinâ truck.â He muttered, your eyes narrowing on his as you crossed your arms.Â
âAnd Iâll key the other half if you donât give me back my-â
âKeys?â He asked with a cocked eyebrow, wiggling the keychain with the cute dangly accessories on it and making you absurdly annoyed. You swallow a lump thatâs growing in your throat. Joel sighs and cautiously brings one of his hands up to cup your cheek. You hate denying how comforting it is when his warmth courses through your body like this.Â
âWhy wonât you let me meet your brother?â It sounds more whimpery than you intended, big soft eyes looking into Joelâs hardened ones. âI mean, I know weâre not anything serious, but weâve been together for a while, and itâs your birthday, and I know that you hate that itâs your birthday, but I love your birthday, and I sort of love you, and I want to meet the people you care the most about.âÂ
The room tenses as your eyes connect. Shit. Thatâs how you chose to tell him? That you sort of loved him? Fucking idiot.Â
Joel pauses before he starts slowly shaking his head, and your chin dips defeatedly. You think heâs shaking his head because he doesnât feel the same way, he doesnât sort of love you like you sort of love him. How could he? Your emotions for one another were a mangled mess. One night, you were fighting like cats and dogs, and both of your eyes lit up during the heat of yet another fight. Then the next night, you were begging him not to stop fucking you, to never leave you, to never betray the trust you had in him that you two had built together over time.Â
His thumb delicately courses up your cheekbone then gently across the arch of your chin. His hand moves to the back of your neck and pulls you in until youâre close enough he can set a delicate kiss on the crown of your head. This was what made it so confusing. Were you still fighting? Were you two making amends?Â
âYouâre not meetinâ Tommy. Not tonight. Thatâs final.â His words are whispered but somehow still piercingly cold, his voice monotone and flat as he forbade you from meeting his brother. âWant you here when I come back so we can celebrate together. Just you and I.âÂ
A frown etches into your features. More like so he could have a warm body to fuck on his birthday.Â
He brushes by you and starts his day like any other. He didnât even say he sort of loved you back.Â
---
Did he really think youâd give up without a fight?Â
You managed to convince Joel that you were fine without meeting Tommy tonight, that maybe he just wanted some brotherly time together. He leaned into that shit-ass excuse like it was his last lifeline. He could care less about his familial bond, he just wanted you not to be fucking pissed off. But you were pissed off. And you looked hot pissed off.Â
You especially looked hot and pissed off in the skin-tight dress you wore, accompanied by the designer clutch Joel purchased for your last birthday.Â
Youâd assume that the hardest part of your little plan was knowing which of the many bars Joel and Tommy could make their trek to. But Apple Air Tags came in a bundle of four, so you slipped one into Joelâs truck. What else were you going to do with the extra ones? Might as well put them to use.Â
You took a car service to the downtown Austin brewpub, Blue Owl Brewing. Letâs just say you were a bit dressed up for the establishment.Â
You spotted Joel sitting at a small table in the back, facing the entrance of the bar as you strolled in with a devilish smirk on your face. His large hand was nursing a tall glass of amber-colored beer, a wide and genuine smile on his lips as he jeered conversation back and forth with Tommy, whose back was to you.Â
You slowly made your way through the dark oak bar, Joelâs eyes connecting with yours almost immediately. He looked like he could break you in half the way his eyes narrowed on you. But Joel was smart. He didnât let much of his anger or annoyance seep through, because the damage was already done and you were already here.Â
âHi, Joel,â you innocently coo before resting your hand on his brotherâs bicep. âYou must be Tommy?â You ask with a smile so sweet it was probably giving Joel a toothache. He was taking a long, steady drink of his beer, the foam lightly frosting his mustache as he observes you with cautious eyes as you interacted with his brother.Â
Tommy looked starstruck by your beauty. His eyes donât hold back from lightly grazing over your short dress and the exposed skin that accompanies it. âArenât you a beauty,â he pauses and looks to his brother with a small smirk of disbelief that his brother could bag a catch as hot as you. âYou must be Joelâs girl he keeps me from.âÂ
His comment makes you giggle, your hand cascading down his bicep to his forearm, your nails lightly adding pressure which makes Joelâs stature more domineering, even from across the table.Â
Tommy was younger, with medium-length dark curly hair and a mustache that mirrored Joelâs. But he doesnât have Joelâs beard, the facial hair youâve grown to love. His mouth carries a dangerous little smirk, and it hasnât left since you joined their table. He was handsome, it was a family trait the two brothers shared.Â
âPlease, sit down, beautiful.âÂ
You hum softly at the compliment, watching as Tommy grabs a nearby barstool from a table close by and sits you down at the end of the table, between both Tommy and Joel.Â
âJoel, I thought you said your girl couldnât make it out tonight?â Tommy inquires, waving down the waitress to come and get you a drink.Â
âOh, did he?â You ask curiously, crossing one leg over the other and lightly leaning over the table as your breasts nearly spill out of your dress. Your eye contact with Joel was on fire. He was torn between chewing you up and spitting you out right here in the middle of the bar, or dragging you away and ripping off this too-short dress of yours.Â
You and Tommy were quickly buzzing with conversation. He was buying you cocktails and complimenting you every chance he could get. If you didnât know any better, he was flirting with you openly in front of his older brother. Joel didnât say much, a grunt here and there, a swift kick under the table to Tommyâs kneecap after he talked a little too much about the gorgeous curves of your body.Â
âJust canât believe you are datinâ my brother, didnât know he could score someone so-â As Tommy attempts to find the words, his warm palm settles on your thigh, dangerously high too. He takes an inch or two of your dress with it, and your breath snags in your throat. You canât deny the jaded way you feel about it, feeling a hot flash course through your body as you feel your head flush with heat.Â
âWatch it.â Joel finally mutters coherently. Perfectly coherent. Like he needs Tommy to hear it crystal clear. No one touches you.Â
Tommy seems to like the rise out of Joel just as much as you do. Which is perhaps why youâre leaning into it.
âYouâre too kind, Tommy, really.â You take his hand off your thigh and maneuver it back into his lap. âSometimes I feel like Iâm the one Joel has to deal with, not the other way around.â You tease, and Tommy lets out a drunk laugh.Â
âTrust me, gorgeous, if you were my girl, I wouldnât let you out of my sight. That was Joelâs first mistake tonight, leavinâ you at home.âÂ
Your eyes soften, and you glance over to Joel. Heâs damn near snarling the way heâs gritting his teeth and staring daggers into Tommy. You had never seen him so possessive before.Â
âThatâs enough out of you,â Joel remarks as he heavily sets down the empty pint glass and shuffles his barstool back, letting out a screeching scrape.Â
âWeâre leavinâ,â Joel tells you, making your jaw tick tighter. Where did he get off telling you what to do? Â
âI donât think I-â
âNow.â He says more seriously. The giddy feelings you shared with Tommy were now squashed under the weight of Joelâs boot. You decide to hop off the barstool and call it a night, for both of our sakes. You accomplished your mission, met Tommy and disobeyed Joel. So letâs leave while weâre ahead.Â
You turn to Tommy, who is also stepping down from the barstool and putting cash on the table to cover the tab. âIt was nice meetinâ you, sugar. Take care of my big brother, will ya?â He asks as he settles his hands warmly on your waist and pulls you in for a kiss on your cheek. Â
Heat sets your body alight. Tommy was gentle, if not even a bit calculated with his movements. Why did all of a sudden you feel like the pawn in Tommyâs game rather than the other way around?Â
âGoodnight, Tommy.â You whisper with a tight-lipped smile, taking Joelâs hand and letting him guide you out of the brewery.Â
---
The ride home in the truck was quiet. Real fuckinâ quiet. You tried to be content just listening to the low volume of the radio or the soft rumbling of his truck. You went to switch the station off of country and more to something you liked, but Joel smacked the volume to mute, making you groan. You grew so bored that you started counting the random tar lines in the road, adding to the total with each one you passed over. You stopped counting after fifty, or so.Â
âJoel-â
âEnough.âÂ
He doesnât let you speak. It makes your blood boil.Â
âIf you just-â
âI said enough, god dammit. Donât you think youâve done enough tonight?â His words cut sharp, and you feel as small as you did this morning. This morning after you confessed that you sort of loved him. Heâs breathing in heavy puffs, and heâs driving faster as he tries to get both of you back to the house.Â
âWhy are you going so fucking fast?â You finally ask. Youâre already in deep shit, you donât care about him telling you to shut up. He ignores you for a moment before you probe him again. âJoel?â You ask with an annoyed tone. His eyes finally meet yours in a quick glance.Â
âGetting you home and out of that fucking dress.â He mutters, his large palm reaching across and cupping harshly at your upper thigh. A whiny gasp leaves your mouth as his fingers dig deliciously into your flesh. So thatâs whatâs got him driving so damn fast.Â
He pries your leg open, and he takes one look at how beautiful you look. More importantly, heâs looking at your lacey panties.Â
âRed. Perfect for you. Like the fuckinâ devil.âÂ
You smirk as you grip his wrist and guide his hand to your clothed mound, a weak sigh leaving his lips as he cups over the wet spot that was forming just for him. Joel didnât have to put in much work for you to be on the edge for him.Â
âI fucking hate you, Joel.âÂ
He puffs out another breath of air through his nose. His way of laughing lately.Â
âFuckinâ hate you more, baby.âÂ
He toys with your panties for the remaining minutes of the drive, your nails having sunk so hard into his arm that youâre drawing small bits of blood from the moon-shaped cuts.Â
He damn near hauls you out of the truck once youâre parked. You leap into his arms as soon as the two of you walk past the threshold of his front door.Â
You force him to walk blindly through the house. Heâs easily holding you up by one arm as you tighten your legs around his waist, causing your dress to ride up from the tension. You kiss him in a clash of teeth and tongues. Youâre both ferociously horny for one another. And heâs pissed.Â
âFlirtinâ with my brother all fuckinâ night? You have fun with that?â He mutters against your mouth, slamming you up against the wall with a thud as your breath nearly knocks out of you from the force. He takes the opportunity of you planted there to grab the hem of your dress and push it up and off your body. His mouth latches to your exposed breasts, a throaty moan leaving your mouth as your small fists take him by the hair at the nape of his neck.Â
âFuck,â you let out breathily, throwing your head back against the wall and humming lowly.Â
âAnswer me.â He ruts his hips up against your core, and youâre painfully aware of how naked heâs making you and how clothed he still is.Â
âHeâs actually really nice-â He suckles harder on your nipple, forcing a hiss out of your mouth. âThink I might trade in my older model for something younger.â Your tone is teasing, but the words are enough to make him detach from your nipple, a sinister look wavering his features cold. Â
He sneers and tilts his head to the side and back before shaking his head slowly. âI donât think so.âÂ
He rips you from the safety of the wall, your hands quickly scrabble to his shoulders to keep yourself upright while he leads you up the stairs to his bedroom. His heavy boots thud menacingly. You try to hide your smile in the crook of his neck, leaving angelic kisses on his neck and marking him with your lipstick, knowing how good Joel is about to make you feel.Â
He tosses you onto the bed like a ragdoll, your bare body finds warmth in his sheets. You admire him from below as he pulls his shirt off by gripping the material at the back of his neck and hauling it off him in one swift motion. The sight alone makes your pussy ache and your insides churn.Â
God, he was so handsome. He had this soft bulk to his body that expanded from the hardened planes of his chest and toned tummy to the light bulge in his biceps. His chest hair was a sprinkle of dark black stippled with light grey hairs that became sparse before trickling to a thicker patch, creating his happy trail. Â
Holy fuck, he looked like he was going to devour you.Â
Joel wasted little time with formalities. He had your legs parted, the rough denim of his jeans grinding against your soft skin. His tongue explored your mouth while both of his palms massaged the supple plushness of your breasts. He was pinching your nipples between his fingers, making you whine into his mouth for relief while they hardened in his hold.Â
You slip your hands between your middles, fingertips gently trailing down to capture the button of his jeans and push down his zipper. You have to wiggle around a bit, as Joel is pinning you to the spot. Youâre so desperate for him that it almost turns into a fight to get his jeans off. He tugs on your bottom lip, a light whimper leaving you upon tasting the metallic tang of blood fill your mouth.Â
You smack Joelâs arm until he releases you, huffing at him.Â
âAsshole.â You mutter.
He sneers at you as he places a delicate kiss to your lips in apology. âThatâs what cunts get.â He mutters under his breath. The term makes you flinch, your hand coming up to give him a good smack across the face, but he captures your wrist and pins it back to the bed. You both eagerly consume one another in a desperate kiss. You think you see him smiling as he tastes the light scrape of blood heâs caused.Â
Joel moves his weight to his forearms and aids you in the ongoing war between you and his pesky jeans. With his weight off you, you easily push down his jeans and his black boxers, your feet pushing down the last of the material around his ankles. He sits back on his haunches, heavy hands gripping the sides of your panties as he pulls them down your legs, leaving you bare with him.Â
You immediately slip out of the hold he has on your wrist and put your hand between your legs. Your fingers move eagerly between your glistening folds and slick them up with arousal. He smacks your hand away and pins your wrist to the bed once more. So fucking disobedient.Â
Once he settles between you, a soft gasp escapes your lips once you feel his thick shaft landing heavily against your sex. He was thick and ready for the taking, his tip was red with anger and need.Â
âYou were a real fuckinâ handful tonight.â He mutters, letting his tip slide up and down your glistening folds. You were not in the mood for teasing.Â
You grit your teeth and glare up at him. âI think Tommy agreed.â
âShut the fuck up.â He growls, your chest rising and falling quickly. He takes notice as your body tingles with excitement.Â
âSuch a pain in my goddamn ass sometimes, more trouble than your worth.â
âWhy donât you toss me to Tommy then, huh? That way I can see which Miller brother fucks me better.â You sneer, a sloppy smirk crossing your features. Itâs harshly stripped from you as Joel takes your face and squishes your cheeks with the grip of his hand. Your eyes clench closed at the slight pain, feeling him angle your head to face him. Heâs power-hungry.Â
âOpen those eyes, pretty girl.â His voice is rocky and lust-filled, dangerous like gasoline. It takes a moment, but you flutter them open. You didnât realize that you were holding onto Joelâs puffed-up biceps, hard as a rock under your hold.Â
He slowly scans you, up and down, weighing his options of how to handle you. The problem that you were. His little brat. âYou wanna cum tonight?â
Your ultimate weakness. A sheepish whimper leaves your squished lips, trying to blink back the slight tears that are forming from his manhandling. Mascara stings your eyes, but you hold his eye contact, because he asked you to, because itâs Joel, and youâd do anything for him at the end of the day.Â
You manage an âMhm, please.â Joelâs eyes soften as he comes back to you and your warmth.Â
He doesnât say anything, just angles his hips just right since you two fit perfectly together and thrusts inward. The breath in your lungs is punched out, head grinding back into the bed as your chin angles to the ceiling. You hiss at the initial discomfort that his thick cock causes. Heâs fucked you a million times, but thereâs nothing better than the first thrust where youâre still adjusting to his size, his girth, his length, his everything.Â
The clamp his hand has on your cheeks eventually releases, shifting the weight back to his forearms as his head settles above yours. He places another gentle kiss on your lightly swollen bottom lip. His loving reassurance warms your body. Heâs starting steady, honorably letting your arousal take the lead in getting you both lubed up. He feels like heaven coursing through your tight hole, making himself the perfect fit for you.Â
You wrap your arms around his neck a little too tight, bringing him down into you as he breathily laughs against your ear.Â
"Y'know, it's kinda hard to be rough with ya when you're bein' so sweet."
Your chest heaves with his words, a sudden and impactful sense of vulnerability passing through you. It makes you nervous. It makes your skin swelter with warmth and makes a bead of sweat form at your temple. You and Joel donât have this type of warmth in your relationship. Warm in the sense of boiling, too hot, too much, screaming and shouting and fighting and kissing. Not this. Not the gentle thrusts lightly rocking into you, letting you adjust to him, pulling him in for a gentle embrace as you capture him in a needy hug.Â
Youâre not the I love you type, yet you said it to him this morning. Sort of. You swallow the lump in your throat and quickly shake your head.Â
You remind yourself that he didnât say it back this morning. He wasnât saying it now. Was he just using you? No.. no, it wasnât that. But he wasnât going to let you meet his family. He wasnât going to say he loved you. He wasnât going to marry you if thatâs even what you wanted right now. It wasnât. But you couldnât deny you thought about your future with Joel. Even with all the fighting, the anger, the jealousy, it was all out of love. But maybe that love was one-sided.Â
The arms you had draped around his neck turned into sinking your nails into the base of his back. You slowly began scraping them upwards and forming long, raised red lines in their path. Joel grunts and hisses at the burn heâs feeling, broad shoulders tightening and his hips snapping into you more ferociously now.Â
Your lower lip trembled with anger, but you didnât let him see as you pushed his head down to your breasts. He took the hint with a broken moan as he suckled a bruise on your collarbone.Â
The pain of his thrusts turned into numbing pleasure, his tip kissing your cervix with each and every heavy snap of his thrusts.Â
âFuck yeah, Joel,â you moan. You stroking his ego only makes his movements more methodical, one of his hands pushing your leg down onto the bed rather than snaking around his waist and exposing you to a new angle that left you searching for air. Joel returns his forehead to rest over yours, both of your sweat glistening. You stare into his eyes, and all you feel is anger and regret for saying you loved him. He was fucking you so good too, you both had never gone as slow as you had at the start. It was twisting the coil inside of you so smoothly, that your brain was getting foggy.Â
You did a lot of stupid things tonight. Wearing your shortest dress, stalking Joel to his hangout with Tommy, flirting with his brother for the majority of the night. But now, you were ready to do the stupidest thing yet.Â
You moan into his ear, revenge and regret swirling inside of you like an insidious tornado. Your eyes flutter close in pleasure as you feel your orgasm begin to approach. âFuck me, Tommy.â
It hits Joel like a ton of bricks. All his movements pause. He pulls away just half an inch and stares down at you. A cold, downright mean look crosses his face once youâve popped your eyes open to take a look at him. The room suffocates you in silence.Â
âWhat did you say?â His voice is slow, slick with a cursed concoction of lust and fury.Â
Too far. Way too fucking far.Â
You pause as you try to recollect yourself, having just been nearly blinded by your approaching orgasm. âI- I said Joel,â Now you were just trying to convince yourself that you didnât accidentally or not accidentally just moaned his brother's name in bed. âI-â
âDonât fuckinâ lie to me.â He mutters, chest puffed up and muscles straining with veins like thick rivers coasting up his arms.Â
He starts slow. His hand shifts to fasten around your throat, and with each word that leaves him, his grip tightens. âTell me⊠what you said.â He speaks through gritted teeth, eliciting a whimper from you as he snarls.Â
You swallow a lump in your throat, cold goosebumps flooding over your previously scorching hot skin. You were starting to feel the neglect from his lack of thrusts, whining softly as you tried to grind your hips up into his.Â
His large palm slams into your hip with force and pins you to the bed, letting out a whine of annoyance.Â
âYou want Tommy fuckinâ you instead? Huh?â His jaw is tight and only clicking tighter as he stares daggers into you. Fuck, you were only flooding him with more of your arousal. You purposely flexed your tight walls around the swell of his cock.Â
âN-No, Joel -- fuck -- want you.â You whimper out as your hands soften on his shoulders, and you gently cup his face. He shakes his head loose of your hold, annoyance and anger still shooting up his spine.Â
âI donât think you do, pretty girl, think you want someone else. Tommy.â His hips were thrusting again, harsh snaps that physically rocked your body up the bed with force that made your jaw drop. Fuck he felt so damn good. The lack of air was making your head swirl.Â
You took in a sharp breath as he manhandles your face once more, forcing you to look at him. âDirty fuckinâ slut, you want both of us, donât you?â Well, you canât deny the thought hadnât crossed your mind. He licks his lips before he spits on your face, lathering you in his saliva as you gasp in shock.Â
âJ-Joel,â your words canât come out smooth with how roughly heâs fucking you. His hips are slamming your thighs, and the bedframe is smacking the wall with all his might. âFuck-ing- shit,â you throw your head back now up into his pillows and try to grip onto the sheets to maintain your position. That coil that was smoothly coursing you towards a gentle orgasm was long gone, as was Joelâs right mind. Now the coil was tightening and nearly breaking, your mind going blank and seeing stars.Â
âSay my name,â Joel grunts, his hand coming up and smothering the saliva he spat on your face. It runs black with your mascara tears and messy red lipstick before he brings his hand back to your throat.Â
You breathe heavily as your mind tries to connect syllables and make a coherent word. âI- I..â You canât focus, and Joel punishes you for it. He spits on you again, hot and warm on your face, and all you can picture is if it was his cum showering you instead. âFuck!â You shout at him. He takes the opportunity of your mouth open to speak, forcing two fingers inside.Â
âSuckâem, pretty little bitch,â Joel mutters, watching you with eyes from hell.Â
You whimper and suckle around his fingers, trying not to choke on them, focusing all your energy on trying not to get in more trouble. You line your tongue up and down both digits, tasting him, tasting Joel. He pulls his fingers from you with force and leaves your own saliva dribbling out of your messy mouth and down your chin.Â
He puts his slimy fingers to use and starts slowly circling your clit. Your eyes light up, wide, and you grip onto his bicep for desperation. âP-Please, too much, Joel,â you whimper, feeling the coil close to snapping as he starts doing precise figure-eights on your swollen nub. It was all too much.Â
âSay my name,â Joel says on repeat, your glassy eyes only being able to focus on him, just like he wanted.Â
He starts marking you with his mouth, ferocious teeth nipping at the sensitive skin along your breasts and collarbones, so harshly that they burn once heâs done, and covering you in red and purple splotches.Â
Joelâs grunting above you, withholding his own orgasm as another form of torturing you. âSay my name, god dammit, tell me who owns this fucking pussy.â He spits on you, mean and hot, and heâs all you can see, all you can think.Â
Say my name. Say my name. God dammit, say my fucking name.Â
âJ-Joel!â You cry out his name and clench your eyes closed, but he doesnât slow his thrusts or his fingers. âFu-Fuck me, Joel, keep fucking me good, Joel, Joel, Joel- fuck!â you swallow down the lump in your throat as you see his goading smirk, his hips slamming you with all heâs got.Â
âCome on baby, want Tommy tâhear you, want the whole damn neighborhood tâhear you-- shit,â he mutters, eyes clenching closed as your walls flutter around him in a nearing orgasm.Â
âSay my name!â He shouts, and you cry out in pleasure.Â
He was like God, your God.Â
âJoel!â You cry out. The coil snaps, and the curtain falls down. Your back arches, and you throw your hips into Joelâs, fisting the sheets and dipping your eyes closed again as you let out a moan that shakes the entire house. Joelâs not long behind you, he paints your walls white in adoration, load after load marking your walls as his own, no one else's.Â
A few minutes pass and heâs still buried inside of you. You look psychotic, fucked dumb and raw. âIâm yours, Joel.â You say barely above a whisper, desperate eyes searching his own for warmth.Â
Youâre twitching below him, overly exerted and tired. Youâre motionless, half-dead under the man who resurrected you. Heâs panting heavily from doing all the work per usual. His mouth is agape, trying to catch his breath as your numb limbs lie in place while he pulls out of you. Heâs dripping with your arousal-cum mixture. Oh, but heâs not done. He kneels on the bed and smacks his hand against your pussy before cupping it.Â
It makes your eyes widen, and you let out an overstimulated cry at the feeling. You quickly shake your head, grip his wrist, and meet his eyes with a pleading expression. âN-No Joel, canât -- fuck -- canât do another one right away, give me a sec baby-âÂ
âDo you know why I didnât want Tommy to meet you?â His words ram your numb brain senseless.Â
You whimper as heâs already starting slow circles on your clit, goosebumps forming once more. You muster up a shake of your head.Â
No. No, I donât know why you wonât let me meet your fucking brother, the question has been gnawing at me all damn day, though.Â
âWhen we were younger, Tommy had a bad streak of sneakinâ off with my girlfriends.â He did? You had no idea. Joelâs voice is deviously quiet during his story-telling, wrecked with residual anger and desire for you.Â
His thumb takes over massaging your clit, feeling both his index and middle finger slowly curl their way into your entrance. Your head nudges back against the pillows again, releasing a string of whimpers as he works you up again. Heâs pushing his cum back inside of you while his fingers squelch.
âHe was flirtinâ with âem, harmless at first, âtil he decided he wanted âem for himself.â Your jaw tightens as he moves his thumb faster on your clit, angry that you let Tommy manipulate you into getting a rise out of Joel, just like he used to. He was using you as a pawn tonight.Â
âGot into so many damn fights over it. Sâwhy my nose is a lilâ crooked. Tommy broke it with a punch, fightinâ about some girl I was seeinâ in my twenties.â You frowned. Stop talking about your other girlfriends, Joel. Â
A quiet whimper left your lips as your pointer finger came up to brush along the light curve of his nose that you loved so much.Â
âDonât feel bad for me, angel. I broke his goddamn arm for fuckinâ me over like that.â He had a dangerous smirk on his lips, one that you liked, one that made your heart race as he circled your clit even faster and started massaging your walls with his thick fingers.Â
âFuck, Joel,â you whispered, the heated coil in your tummy churning again out of the protectiveness and jealousy he felt for you today.Â
âHeâs never met any of my girls since, so when I saw you walk into that bar..â he trailed off and started shaking his head. Your clit pulsed anxiously under the pad of his thumb, biting down harshly on your bruised and bloody lip. âWould never let him take you away from me. Never.â Your heart gushes for him.Â
âIâd never leave you, Joel,â you lightly whimpered, your body twitching and writhing under him. He shook his head and gently shushed you, cupping your cheek with his free hand. Your glassy eyes watched him in adoration, seeing crooked stars in your vision as you felt another orgasm heatedly approaching.Â
âShouldâa told ya sooner. And you shouldâa stayed home. Listened to me for once,â He told you in a warning tone. You swallow the lump in your throat and gently nod, your thighs shaking against his legs that pinned yours wide open.Â
âSâwhy when I saw ya in the bar, knew I had tâtake you home and make you mine, devil woman.â He muttered with a small smirk. The nickname made a desperate smile trickle on your lips.Â
âYeah?â You said in a sheepish whimper, your walls fluttering around his fingers that were gently exploring your insides, leaving you so close to cumming again. It was too fast, and too damn hot in the room, but Joel was making you his, and thatâs all you were going to focus on.Â
âSo what dâyou say?â He asks, raising a curious eyebrow.Â
ââM sorry.â You muster up. âI-Iâm sorry, Joel,â Heâs got you panting for dear life as your thighs twitch while you near closer and closer to the edge.Â
He slowly shakes his head. âAnd what else, pretty girl?âÂ
You cock your head and furrow your brows at him, unsure of what he wants you to say next.Â
âSay my name, tell me you love me again.â His fingers abandon your entrance and solely focus on pleasuring your clit, going so fast, too fast. His head comes down by yours, resting his forehead against your temple as your eyes force themselves closed. Â
âFuck, Joel,â you whimper.Â
âLook at me, baby.â He whispers to you, placing light kisses by the corner of your eye to bring attention to him.Â
Your long lashes flutter on your cheeks before your fucked out face turns to Joel. âI love you, I love you, Joel, I love y-you- fuck,â you moan out loudly, throwing your head back and grinding your hips up into his hand. You do love him, the sick bastard that he was.Â
Your second release is only minutes from your last; it sparks you like a firework, and you feel your bones tingle. This man was not one to contend with. But you did anyway because you loved him.Â
You come down from being overstimulated. He plays this mean game where he grazes his fingers as light as a feather on different parts of your body, watching as your muscles and body twitch from being short-circuited.Â
âFuck you.â You murmur.Â
His feet find the floor, his cock still hanging by his thighs, drenched in residual slick. He disappears into the bathroom, and you hear the faucet run. It rings in your ears, still trying to center yourself after being fucked to oblivion tonight.Â
You didnât realize your eyes had fallen close until you heard his feet padding towards you as he approached with a warm washcloth. You hum softly gently wipes your face from his spit and your mucky mascara before he rotates the washcloth and wipes at the inside of your thighs. Youâre still a little sensitive, you canât help but let your face twinge.Â
Heâs careful as he makes sure youâre clean, catching any residual spill. He tosses the washcloth into the laundry basket before he goes searching in your bag for something you can wear.Â
âJoel?â
He pauses his movements. âAlready know what youâre gonna say.â You instantly smile and observe him. He was so handsome.Â
He stops looking through your bag for clothes and moves to his closet. He takes his time choosing what he wants you to wear, which makes you giggle a little bit from bed. Youâre motionless, with no energy to move or even roll over. Barely enough to speak.Â
He settles on a Metallica band t-shirt, at least twenty years old, with the cotton perfectly soft and worn in. He moves to his dresser and fishes out a clean pair of boxers. They were the most comfy to wear, you had to admit. Panties were to show off your ass before sex. Boxers were for after all that was finished.Â
âYou okay?â he whispers, to which you slowly nod. Heâs always been so good with aftercare, even after a full day of arguing followed by a full night of fucking.Â
The boxers are soft as they coast up your legs, and he settles them on your hips. The band reads Calvin Klein. You muster up enough strength to sit up on your elbows, and he helps you put the baggy shirt on. It messes up your hair, and he tries to smooth it over, which makes you bubble up a laugh. âItâll just get all messed up when we sleep, but thanks,â you whisper before falling back into his pillows once again.Â
Joel smirks widely before he lays down tiredly beside you on his front, like a big giant collapsing with a large huff. Your hand travels gently up his back, seeing the raised and jagged lines your nails had caused, your anger had caused. His jaw twitches, but he doesnât let you know heâs feeling pain.Â
âJoel?â You whisper and work up the energy to shimmy closer to him, your foreheads gently resting together.Â
âHm?â He murmurs.Â
You feel shy all of a sudden, still vulnerable. âHappy birthday, Joel. I love you.âÂ
He slowly smiles, a sense of pride flooding his body as he pulls you in closer to him by your hip. He gently glides his thumb across your swollen bottom lip and kisses you lightly. âI love you, too. No matter how much of a brat you are.â
You slowly grin and close your eyes as your heads rest beside one another.Â
âOh my god.â You mutter to yourself. Joel pulls his head away to look down at you.Â
âWhat is it, angel?â
You groan lightly and hide your face in your hands. âThe cake! I left it out all day, itâs probably dry as fuck now!â
Joel lets out a puff of laughter, stroking your sweat-soaked hair away from your face. âSâokay, wasnât gonna have any, anyway.âÂ
âYes, you were.â You huff, your finger gently gliding down his nose once more before you gently kiss the tip in adoration.Â
He hums softly at your decent behavior. âGood girl.âÂ
---
masterlist
A reminder that I no longer use taglists!! to keep up with my writing, follow @hellishfics and turn on notifications to keep updated!












