Darren's Debut: An Imperfect Display of Perfection
When Darren Criss emerged from the orchestra pit in his window washer suit, hair slicked back, and purple bow tie perfectly affixed, the roar was deafening. This crowd was here for Darren.
His face was focused as he "read" intently from his companion on this journey - his book bearing the title of the show: How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. The only sign of nerves was a little tremor in his hand. Once on the ground, Criss was off and running toward success with the crowd behind him, laughing and cheering along.
 For someone so famously humble, Criss has no trouble stepping into the role of self-centered ladder-climber. Criss' J. Pierrepont Finch is at once a disarmingly charming, naive, and cunningly ruthless young man who sees people only as a means to his ends. Mastering Finch is like walking a tightrope, and Crissâ balance is impeccable.
Criss' strength is in his timing and nuance. There are a few shining moments where Criss seems to leap from his tightrope with perfect comedic technique and land again with the audienceâs hearts in their throats and in his hands. A few moments stand out. The first, Crissâ nervous, knowing laughter when his bossâ mistress declares sheâs will be Finchâs secretary and sets her sights on him. Criss communicates, with incredible comedic timing, what the audience already knows â this lady is trouble. And Crissâ breathy, nervous laugh assures the audience he knows this as well, and better yet, he has a plan.
Later, in a more obvious display, when Finch has just realized that heâs in love with Rosemary, the secretary whoâs had her eye on him since he walked into The World Wide Wicket Company (can you blame her?), Criss leaps onto the couch, and triggers that second-hand-embarrassment-inducing moment when Tom Cruise declared his love for Katie Holmes on Oprah, by giddily jumping up and down on the couch. Throughout his rendition of âRosemary,â Criss expertly leaps from couch, to stage, to desk like a lovesick man ready and needing to shout his love from the rooftops. At one point, Crissâ Finch is so excited by the music all around him, in which he can hear Rosemaryâs name, that he enthusiastically pounds the keys of an imaginary piano!
Now, fans of Crissâ Blaine on Glee are no strangers to his seemingly inhuman ability to communicate so much (namely, Blaineâs love for Kurt) in one facial expression. This skill is on full display when Finchâs cunning leads âBBDOâ (the new guy whoâs been brought in to be the head of the advertising department) to reveal heâs a Chipmunk â the dreaded rival of the Grand Old Ivy Groundhogs, the beloved alma mater of the boss, JB. The spotlight finds Crissâ face adeptly displaying the type of smugness that can only come with the success of a well-laid and executed evil plan, and the crowd erupts into well-deserved gales of laughter.Â
Speaking of the good olâ Groundhogs, Grand Old Ivy is always a much loved and heavily anticipated number. Again, Criss does not disappoint. As I heard a fan declare on the way out of the theater: âThat boy can dance!â She spoke truth. Criss runs, leaps and is carried through the air (at one point, being passed through the air while in the fetal position, during which he had the good sense to put his thumb in his mouth and earn some hearty laughter). Grand Old Ivy is a physical work out and Criss is sweating. Profusely. But it's endearing - a physical display of just how much effort he and Finch are putting into this.Â
Brotherhood of Men is another number of note. Although Criss is still developing his Broadway lungs, and it showed a bit when he seemed to lose steam on a note or two in the beginning of the number, he puts on an incredible and inspired performance, especially for a guy who just debuted on Broadway about two hours ago with as many weeks of practice under his belt. Criss nails every single move like he was born to high-kick, spin and twist on stage. And I can say that after witnessing it, it is certainly possible that is the case.Â
As someone who was privileged to also see Daniel Radcliffe in the role, I noticed some differences in the choices the two men made in portraying the iconic Finch.  Notably, near the very end, when the audience and Finch fear that all has been lost and he indeed wonât succeed, Finch reveals he began his climb as a window washer only to find out that the chairman of the board (whoâs been brought in to reprimand the people responsible for the current state of the company) began as a window washer as well. This fact immediately endears him to the chairman.
All throughout the play, when Finchâs manipulations have proved successful, the spotlight falls on his face and he gives the audience a look that says, âThis, too, was all a part of the plan.â When the spotlight found Finchâs face in this moment, Radcliffe chose to portray it as Finch's crowning moment of trickery - his face telling the audience he knew this little fact the whole time. This too was just another of his tricks to the top. However, Criss chooses this moment to humanize Finch, displaying shock and relief at the chairman's revelation. For Crissâ Finch, this moment is a stroke of luck and not the result of trickery. Ultimately, Crissâ Finch finds success not through cunning, but through the honesty of accepting and admitting who he really is.  This choice, I think, reveals a lot about Crissâ interpretation of Finch and ultimately of the man portraying him.
Darren Criss is a stunning example of the truth of exactly the opposite of what his characterâs metaphorical Bible professes to be true. In order to succeed, at least in the way Criss has and does on the Al Hirshfield stage, one must work incredibly hard.Â
 I was privileged to sit in the row directly in front of many of his family and friends. It adds a little something special to a story about a boy who rises to the top when the protagonist is embodied by a boy who has done just that and the story is backed by the soundtrack of his friendsâ and familyâs laughter and tearsâhis motherâs laugh the loudest and most contagious of all.
And while Criss may have briefly stumbled over a few lines in the end, it was clear it was caused by the sheer magnitude of it all. This man, who only a year ago was a self-professed ânobodyâ gaining and reaching out to fans through YouTube, was uttering the last few lines of his Broadway debut with his friends, family and fans within reach.  He's done it.
Everyone was on their feet when Criss emerged for his first Broadway curtain call. He graciously blew kisses to the audience, clearly just as apt to hand over his heart. As the curtain closed, you could see the gratitude in his eyes. And when the curtain finally came down between Criss and his first Broadway audience, tears were shining in his eyes.Â
While Crissâ debut was not perfectâno Broadway show ever isâit was a display of perfection in that it showed what can be accomplished with immense talent, even more effort, and a little bit of luck. Darren Criss does and should serve as an inspiration. Darren Criss is proof that the world can be what we all hopeâa place where good, hard working people, eventually reap their hard earned and well-deserved rewards.Â
With a strong beginning, it's clear that Darren Criss, should he choose, will be a Broadway success â if only because he works so damn hard.