#false498acase

Husband Caring For Parents Is Not Cruelty: MP High Court Cancels Wife’s Maintenance.

A husband was dragged into maintenance after the wife lived separately and also filed 498A against him and his family.

The husband and family were acquitted, yet the Family Court still granted maintenance to the wife.

The Madhya Pradesh High Court corrected it and said a wife cannot claim maintenance just because the husband gives attention to his parents.

Know the legal remedies available for men in India against false 498A, maintenance, domestic violence, custody battles, divorce cruelty and malicious criminal cases.

NEW DELHI: Indian law does not give men a separate “men’s rights statute”. That is the problem. But it does give men constitutional protection, criminal defence remedies, civil remedies, matrimonial remedies, custody remedies and remedies against false prosecution.

The bigger problem is not absence of law. The bigger problem is that most men wake up only after FIR, arrest threat, maintenance notice, DV complaint, child custody battle or divorce case has already hit them.

A man who is falsely accused should not beg for sympathy. He should build evidence, use the law, protect his family, and fight strategically.

1. REMEDY AGAINST ARREST IN 498A / SECTION 85 BNS CASES

Earlier, cruelty by husband or his relatives was prosecuted under Section 498A IPC. After the new criminal laws, the corresponding provision is Section 85 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, while Section 86 defines cruelty.

The first remedy for a man is not panic. It is arrest protection.

Police cannot arrest mechanically merely because a wife has made allegations. In Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, the Supreme Court clearly held that arrest in offences punishable up to seven years must not be automatic. The police must examine whether arrest is necessary.

Under BNSS Section 35, notice of appearance is a major safeguard. If a man cooperates with investigation, arrest should not be used as punishment before trial.

Practical remedies:

File anticipatory bail where arrest is likely.

Seek compliance of BNSS Section 35 notice.

Keep proof of cooperation with investigation.

File quashing petition if allegations are vague, omnibus or revenge-based.

Do not run away unless advised legally. Absconding helps the complainant more than the accused.

2. QUASHING OF FALSE FIR

If the FIR is vague, exaggerated, impossible, filed after delay, or ropes in the entire family without specific allegations, the husband and relatives can approach the High Court under Section 528 BNSS, corresponding to old Section 482 CrPC, for quashing.

The Supreme Court has repeatedly warned courts against allowing criminal law to become a weapon in matrimonial disputes. In Dara Lakshmi Narayana v. State of Telangana, the Supreme Court deprecated the practice of implicating husband’s relatives in dowry cases without specific role or material.

This remedy is powerful when:

allegations are general;

relatives live separately;

no dates, places or incidents are mentioned;

complaint is filed after husband initiates divorce;

FIR looks like a pressure tactic;

criminal case is being used for settlement bargaining.

A false case should not be allowed to become a lifelong punishment.

3. DIVORCE ON GROUND OF CRUELTY BY WIFE

Men often think only women can claim cruelty. That is legally wrong.

Under Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, a husband can seek divorce on the ground of cruelty, desertion, adultery, conversion, mental disorder, renunciation, presumption of death and other statutory grounds.

Mental cruelty by wife may include:

false criminal complaints;

character assassination;

public humiliation;

denial of marital relationship without just cause;

threats of false cases;

turning child against father;

physical violence;

abusive behaviour towards husband or his parents;

filing repeated malicious complaints.

In K. Srinivas v. K. Sunita, the Supreme Court held that filing a false criminal complaint can amount to matrimonial cruelty and can justify divorce.

In Samar Ghosh v. Jaya Ghosh, the Supreme Court explained mental cruelty broadly and made it clear that cruelty is not limited to physical violence.

4. DEFENCE AGAINST MAINTENANCE CLAIMS

Maintenance law is often used as a pressure tool. But maintenance is not meant to become lifelong extortion.

A husband can contest maintenance by showing:

wife is earning;

wife has concealed income;

wife is qualified and intentionally unemployed;

wife has sufficient assets;

wife deserted without valid reason;

husband has liabilities;

husband is maintaining children or parents;

wife has filed multiple overlapping maintenance claims.

In Rajnesh v. Neha, the Supreme Court directed both parties to file detailed disclosure of assets, income and liabilities. This judgment is important because it prevents one-sided financial storytelling.

A man should never fight maintenance casually. He should file proper income affidavit, bank records, liabilities, expenses, medical expenses, parents’ dependency proof and proof of wife’s earnings.

5. CHILD CUSTODY AND VISITATION RIGHTS

A father is not an ATM with visitation rights. He is a parent.

Under Indian law, child welfare is the paramount consideration. Courts do not decide custody only on gender. A father can seek custody, joint parenting, interim visitation, overnight access, vacation access, video calls and school participation rights.

Important remedies:

petition under Guardians and Wards Act;

custody petition under personal law;

interim visitation application;

application for school access;

application against parental alienation;

contempt/enforcement if visitation order is violated.

If the mother is poisoning the child against the father, denying access, changing school without consent, or using the child as a litigation weapon, the father must document everything and move court quickly.

Delay kills custody cases.

6. REMEDIES AGAINST FALSE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CASES

The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 is women-centric. A man cannot file a DV case as an aggrieved husband under this Act. But he can defend himself strongly.

He can contest:

false residence claims;

inflated maintenance;

false allegations of violence;

property misuse;

attempt to convert matrimonial dispute into property grab;

overlapping claims in multiple courts.

If the husband’s parents are senior citizens and the daughter-in-law is illegally occupying their self-acquired property, remedies may also be available under senior citizen welfare law and civil property law, depending on facts.

7. PERJURY, FALSE EVIDENCE AND FALSE AFFIDAVITS

If a wife files false income affidavit, hides job, hides property, gives false statement on oath, creates forged documents or suppresses material facts, legal action may be possible.

Remedies include:

application for dismissal or adverse inference;

application for production of documents;

cross-examination;

perjury proceedings where legally maintainable;

complaint for forgery if forged documents are used;

use of contradictions in trial.

Falsehood in court is not “strategy”. It is abuse of judicial process.

8. DEFAMATION AND MALICIOUS PROSECUTION

If a man is falsely accused publicly, defamed in society, workplace or social media, he may consider civil or criminal defamation, depending on facts.

If he is acquitted in a false criminal case, he may explore malicious prosecution, compensation or damages. These remedies are difficult but not impossible. They require strong proof that the case was false, malicious and caused real damage.

A man should preserve:

certified copies of complaints;

acquittal order;

messages showing threats;

public posts;

employer notices;

medical records of mental trauma;

financial loss records;

travel and litigation expenses.

9. POLICE COMPLAINT AND COUNTER FIR

Men can also file criminal complaints where they are victims of assault, threats, extortion, criminal intimidation, theft, trespass, blackmail, stalking, cheating, forgery or data misuse.

Being a husband does not mean losing the right to complain.

If the wife or her relatives threaten false cases for money, property or custody leverage, the man should preserve recordings where legally permissible, WhatsApp chats, emails, bank trails and witness details.

10. RESTITUTION OF CONJUGAL RIGHTS

A husband may file restitution of conjugal rights if the wife has withdrawn from society without reasonable cause. This remedy is not suitable in every case, but it may be strategically relevant in desertion, maintenance and divorce disputes.

However, it must not be filed mechanically. A wrong RCR case can later harm the husband’s divorce strategy.

11. PROTECTION OF PARENTS AND FAMILY MEMBERS

False matrimonial cases often do not stop at the husband. Parents, sisters, brothers, distant relatives and even people living abroad are dragged into litigation.

Remedies for family members include:

anticipatory bail;

quashing;

discharge;

exemption from personal appearance;

separate defence showing separate residence;

proof of no involvement;

travel records;

medical records;

employment proof;

passport/immigration records.

The law does not permit punishment by relationship. Being mother, sister or brother of the husband is not a crime.

12. THE REAL STRATEGY FOR MEN

Men lose cases not only because law is biased. Many lose because they react emotionally and act late.

A man facing matrimonial litigation should immediately:

collect documents;

stop verbal fights;

avoid threats;

avoid emotional WhatsApp essays;

preserve chats, emails and call records;

maintain financial discipline;

avoid illegal recordings in private spaces;

file replies on time;

attend proceedings;

keep certified copies;

build a chronology;

consult before signing settlement.

The system may be slow. It may be painful. It may be biased in practice. But law still gives remedies to the man who fights with evidence, not emotion.

CONCLUSION

Indian men have legal remedies. They have constitutional rights. They have arrest safeguards. They have divorce remedies. They have custody remedies. They have remedies against false complaints, false evidence and malicious prosecution.

But remedies work only when men stop behaving like victims and start behaving like litigants.

Sympathy does not win cases. Evidence does.

FAQs

1. Can a man be arrested immediately in a 498A or Section 85 BNS case?

Not automatically. Police must follow arrest safeguards and record reasons. Arrest cannot be mechanical merely because allegations are made.

2. Can a husband file divorce if wife files false cases?

Yes. False criminal complaints can amount to mental cruelty and may become a ground for divorce, depending on proof and facts.

3. Can husband’s parents get a false 498A case quashed?

Yes, especially where allegations are vague, general, omnibus or there is no specific role attributed to them.

4. Can a father get child custody in India?

Yes. Courts decide custody on welfare of the child, not gender alone. Fathers can seek custody, visitation, overnight access and parenting rights.

5. Can a man take action after acquittal in a false case?

Yes. Depending on facts, he may explore defamation, perjury, malicious prosecution, compensation or other civil/criminal remedies.

Protect your rights with informed legal strategy and dedicated support in sensitive family and custody disputes. For expert guidance and strong representation, get in touch today.

Visit: ShoneeKapoor.com

Contact No.: +91–8010850498