He had been caught by her MOTHER. After a rather routinely LURE turned into a switch and bait with some hunters, her mother wasnβt one to go down easy. After snatching Dean away from his precious BROTHER Sam, the two women had him TIEDΒ up in the back room of the house they had made into a HOME for the last few months. It would take a while to track them down, so Evieβs mother decided to have a little bit of fun. But before that, she sent in her beautiful young daughter to set the room up with a few THINGS. A few TOYS. And thatβs what she was doing when the oldest Winchester came to. The room was DARK, lit only by a few candles flickering shadows across their faces, but Evie worked expertly despite all of that. Though she made sure to never let her eyes catch his own. Hunters were dangerous - her mother had taught her that.