Serafina and the Black Cloak Reread Thoughts
I forgot that the book takes place in 1899 for some reason, but regardless I'm very eager to see how that's handled (since I read it when I was much younger, I doubt I would have picked up on that). but I mean that's just fascinating given the history of the civil war (Cornelius Vanderbilt was a union man--not in it himself, but donated a giant steamship worth about 1 million USD). Also fun fact: George Vanderbilt paid his staff New York wages, which were higher than Asheville wages-- up to the equivalent of $73-ish dollars for the highest working members.
sera and her pa are adorable! little serafina not wanting to eat her veggies is my favorite thing & in a modern au he would definitely be the kinda guy to mix spinach into her brownies to try and trick her into eating vegetables
also serafina first line: "Did." do with that what you will
can serafina get rabies? she says she's been bitten by rats before...
love the sprinkling of 1890s southern dialect lmao
SHE'S THE CRC!
I forgot how good the imagery in this book is!! the descriptions of sounds and nature are incredible!!
mr Vanderbilt has over 22 THOUSAND BOOKS that's the kinda life goal I aspire to
serafina made up stories after reading she's just like me for
au where serafina is a PI & part-time novelist perchance?? (Braeden is a vet ofc)
Sera's pa: if anybody ever asks you who you are or where you're from, you don't answer, got it?
Sera: got it
Sera, the second she meets Braeden: hi I'm serafina here's my social security number
OH BRAEDEN FIRST DESCRIPTION WHAT "... or she'd see their twelve-year-old nephew riding his horse across the grounds, with his sleek black dog running alongside." (p. 12)
"Sometimes she dreamed of wearing fancy dresses and ribbons in her hair and shiny shoes on her feet" props to Robert Beatty for not making her have internalized misogyny and hating "girlie" things. the main fight scene is done in a dress if I recall and I'm so ready to read it
she mentions Braeden a lot (calls him "the young master" or "the nephew" but still, good foreshadowing)
awww poor sera wants a real family but also loves her pa *sigh* EMOTIONAL CONFLICT
sera describing the basement as "hers"!!!
the butler's 11 year old assistant gobbling cookies in the middle of the night is so real im sorry. but also sera standing in the shadow watching him & pretending they're friends chatting is gonna make me cry
oooh the rats and bugs all fleeing from cracks in the walls when the man in the black cloak arrives!!!
mr Thorne first line: "Don't worry. We're going right in here..." creepy lil shit
"her legs felt like explosions of speed" idk why but that line made me laugh. the book is so well-written but for some reason that line just feels very, idk, childish? it kinda took me out of the experience but maybe that's just me
"friends had to help friends. she didn't know much about life, but she knew that." she doesn't even know the girl but considers them friends and wants to help her. serafina seems to think Braeden is kinder than she is, but honestly I don't think that's true. I think Braeden is more willing to trust people, but serafina is more willing to sympathize with them, & I think she has preconceptions of people in power being bad (mr v, mr Thorne-- though the latter turned out to be true--rowena, etc) which turns out false
"A tall man in a black cloak and hood, his hands stained with blood" we have our first Mr Thorne description folks!!
"Just stay still, and this will all be over," he said, pulling her toward him. Serafina suddenly realized she'd made a dreadful mistake. This was far more than she could handle." oh god the places my mind instantly went to? dark, awful places. this book is disturbing and I'm inly 19 pages in-- how did I read this so gleefully as a kid?
"...as if the man wasn't of his own mind but possessed by a demented, ravenous demon" I don't quite remember but isn't it true that the cloak can speak to the wearer? so did it take over mr Thorne at some point? did hearing that voice all the time affect him and further corrupt him? did he ever get confused when he took the cloak off, maybe in the beginning, and think perhaps he didn't want to put it back on again, but in the end the urge for power and youth was too great? oooh angsty fanfic ideas.....
"Death was so near that she could see its blackness and hear the screams of the children who had gone before." this book is so dark how is it for children???? it's incredible I love it
ik she's looking for a place to hide from a guy trying to pull our her soul but her thought process when searching for a hiding spot reminds me of playing hide n seek
"She was the CRC. No trap or weapon or evil man was going to catch her." hELL YEAH
ahhhh description of serafina. collar bones that don't connect to other bones --> cats have a detached collar bone. four toes not five--> cats again. (also as a kid who was tiny and short and having been thought practically dead at birth, serafina was always inspiring to me)
"Mice are timid and prone to panic-induced mistakes at key moments. Just stay still little mouse, [she thought]." oooh nice callback to this exact thought about mice when she's hunting rats earlier
Also did I mention how much I love the chapter titles being encircled in brambles that form the shape of her face or a panther?? that's just cool. if I can actually write something good enough to be published, I'd love to have something like that
Babe wake up new slang just dropped: âgnawinâ on leatherâÂ
Her pa doesnât like mr poe gives âmy dad wonât let us watch horror movies so you have to sneak them over in a different dvd cover if weâre gonna watch a horror movie when you sleep over later tonightâ omg rowena & serafina girltime au?? (Lol sorry)
Oooooh the dynamoâs busted I wonder what thaaat meeeaannnssss (hehehe)
Biltmore being one of the few homes to have electricity is a nice reminder of the time period
âsheâd been trying to follow [her paâs] rules at least some of the timeâ lol
âSpotting an upholstered chair she felt an overwhelming desire to run her fingernails over the plush fabricâ REAL
Her being shocked at flower vases & the idea of flowers INSIDE the house is so funny
Awwww poor sera, looking for her momma and siblings everywhereâŚ
Serafina is super smart. just putting that out there. Sheâs brilliant and I love her
Oop the first description of Edith Vanderbilt kinda gives chatgpt-generated ngl (obviously it wasnât bc it predates chatgpt & shitty ai writing generators, & this book is SO MUCH BETTER than anything an AI could generate regardless)Â
âA refined and attractive woman, Mrs. Vanderbilt had a pale complexion and a full head of dark hair, and she seemed at ease in her role of hostess as she moved through the room.â Idk what about this makes me think âAI generatedâ but it just DOES
âSerafina loved to climb the tapestries at night and run her fingernails down through the soft fabricâ AGAIN SHES SO REAL FOR THIS
OHOHOHO MR THORNE NAMEDROP:
âIâm sure that most of you already know Mr. Montgomery Thorne,â⌠Mrs. Vanderbilt said with a gentle sweep of her arm toward a gentleman. âHe has graciously offered to play [the violin] for us today.â
âThank you, Mrs. Vanderbilt,â Mr. Thorne said with a smile as he stepped forward. ... To Serafina, whoâd been listening to Biltmoreâs visitors her entire life, he didnât sound like he came from the mountains of North Carolina, or from New York like the Vanderbilts. He spoke with the accent of a southern gentleman, maybe from Georgia or South Carolina.â
Serafina having an eye for fashion was NOT what I was expecting from this reread lol (she describes mr tâs outfit then says âall of which she thought went nicely with his silvery-black hair and perfectly trimmed sideburnsâ)
Hmmm interesting she actually sympathizes with/likes mr Thorne at first?? I did nOT recall that
Lol serafina liking to watch mr Thorneâs fingers move as he plays and wanting to pounce on them is so Cat of her
OMG BRAEDEN BRAEDEN BRAEDEN BRAEDEN
Apparently he looks âsickly, a little frail evenâ which I do not recall, but hes also got âwatchful, sensitive brown eyesâ and âa rather fetching tussle of wavy brown hairâ
âAre you lost?â WE GOT IT WE GOT THE LINE but more importantly we got the NEXT LINE which is âMay I help you find your way?â And hes described as not timid or shy but also not overly confident which I LOVE (fun fact this line is very similar to one of the characters of my other favorite kidâs book series, Keefe Sencenâs âyou must be lostâ line)
Lol Braeden always sharing his food with Gideon annoys the chefs i LOVE him
OMG HE BOWS TO HER WHEN SHE GIVES HIM HIS NAME LIKE SHEâS A PROPER LADY!!!!! MEN!!!! TAKE NOTES!!!!!! THIS IS HOW ITâS DONE!!!
Name drop at last, missing girlâs name is Clara Brahms. Honestly Iâm a little sad Clara isnt a recurring character later on. Braeden, Serafina, and Clara couldâve been a good trioÂ
OOOOHH âShe had heard the servants in the kitchen joke that their master must have secretly found the Fountain of Youthâ what a NICE SET UP for how the black cloak keeps people young & serafinaâs suspicion of mr Vanderbilt
Mr Vanderbilt: *wears dress shoes to go riding*
serafina: criminal activity right there. Lock him up
Least accurate part of this book is the implication that serafina uses a hairbrush lmao
New slang: spit nails (means be really mad)
âIâm twelve years old. Iâm grown up.â Mmmm not quite, but I agree with the spirit!
âJust tell me whatâs wrong with me. I want to know. Why are you ashamed of me?â scuse me, Iâll just be over here⌠crying⌠in the corner
Ohhhh serafina back story⌠she couldâve had 3 siblings (AU where all of her siblings survive, but theyâre humans too & her pa raises them all???)
The midwives wouldnât even help a baby??? And the nuns were so mean for what? Like at least consolidate the man, heâs trying to keep a child alive, donât just tell him âitâs going to die. You should kill it nowâ who DOES THAT??
Itâs so funny to me that serafina didnât realize she was the baby in the story until after it was over. i get that itâs a kids book but still!
Oooooh nature v nurture very nice very nice
Oh wow I forgot serafina was almost kidnapped when she was probably around 2-3ish (her pa says she was walking/wandering around, so I assume itâs around that time?)
âItâs plain to see that youâre not like other girlsâ WOW seraâs pa just went there lmao
Ok so when I was first reading this, I remember shipping Leandra and serafinaâs pa SO HARD and wanting her to have a proper mother-daughter-father type family, yknow?Â
The implication that bright/stereotypically âgoodâ things can ensnare your soul too is so fascinating. That good things can be bad for you too⌠fascinating
âHer pa had told her to leave them to it, that it wasnât any of her business, that they werenât her kin, but who was he to say who was kin and who wasnât? He stole babies out of the woods!â Help why is this so funny đÂ
Ooohhh she wants to find Braeden! And she keeps thinking of Clara as her friend. Iâm so annoyed Clara wasnât brought back now ugh
Awwww sheâs wondering if she can think of Braeden as a friend
Awww poor serafinaÂ
Serafina: *sees dress shoes* THE DEVILâS APPAREL!!!
Huh apparently thereâs a concealed door to the right of the fireplace in the billiard room? Wonder if thatâs true
Oooh and it leads to the smoking room, with a similar one leading to the gun room. VERY curious if this was made up for the sake of the story or not
Haha serafina spitting on the back of her hand and using it to wipe her face and hair is so Cat
Serafina loves closets lolÂ
HES ARRIVED!!!!!!!! BRAEDEN!!!!!
Help why is this whole page so funny đ
Serafina canonically climbing up a tree to get away from a dog and staying there until her pa got a ladder to get her down is so Cat I canât
â[ShadowsâŚ] [which] reminded her of griffins, chimeras, and other twisted creatures of the night which were half one thing and half another.â OOOOH good foreshadowing!!!
I like this part
when he asks why heâs never seen her and she says âmaybe youâve seen me before and youâve just forgottenâ and he says âI WOULD HAVE REMEMBERED YOUâ!!!!
hearinf him say her name has tremendous power over her!!!! Iâm going to be sick đ
smolandweirdwriter reblogged trialserrors Pinned Postsilversickles-deactivated202101 This blog is a safe space.Nazis, TERFs, pedophiles, bigots, Tr*mp supporters, Islamophobes, exclusionists, queerphobes, and anyone who canât reblog this post, etc, do not interact. I will block you.emo-bunny-1317 FollowHell yeah!#safe space
smolandweirdwriter reblogged smolandweirdwriter Serafina and the Black Cloak Reread Thoughts: chapter Nine and TenMr Vanderbilt: youâve got to be a man, BraedenSerafina, in the corner, under her breath: yOUâvE gOT tO bE A MaN, bRAeDeNMr Vanderbilt: *gives Braeden some well intentioned, albeit slightly sexist, advice* Serafina: MURDERERNice allusion to Mr thorneâs skill at everything being suspicious Chapter 10 was creepy af (I mean it does take place in a graveyard soo)Cloven Smith has a creepy gravestone, & google told me nothing about him, so I doubt he was realSerafina: *sees a grave to two women* oh these must be sisters me: WIVESAnyway now I wanna write an au about Mary and Margaret being witches or catamounts or something WE FOUND THE GLADEscarred-serafina-fan Djffjjfjvjgnng I'm gonna assume sisters since they were nine but that's freaking funny lolsmolandweirdwriter oh my god I didnât even read the dates đ Iâm so stupid
smolandweirdwriter Serafina and the Black Cloak Reread Thoughts: chapter Nine and TenMr Vanderbilt: youâve got to be a man, BraedenSerafina, in the corner, under her breath: yOUâvE gOT tO bE A MaN, bRAeDeNMr Vanderbilt: *gives Braeden some well intentioned, albeit slightly sexist, advice* Serafina: MURDERERNice allusion to Mr thorneâs skill at everything being suspicious Chapter 10 was creepy af (I mean it does take place in a graveyard soo)Cloven Smith has a creepy gravestone, & google told me nothing about him, so I doubt he was realSerafina: *sees a grave to two women* oh these must be sisters me: WIVESAnyway now I wanna write an au about Mary and Margaret being witches or catamounts or something WE FOUND THE GLADE#serafina and the black cloak#serafina and the black cloak reread
smolandweirdwriter
Serafina and The Black Cloak Reread Thoughts: Chapter Seven and Eight
I got bored so my thoughts will be on two chapters at once now (so this goes faster)
Braeden is canonically a horse girl
lol serafina is scared of horses
mr crankshod is a lil sus (I say like Iâve never read the book before)
still. I donât like him
me personally I would not walk into the forest at night but đ¤ˇ
no bc lowkey I hate bugs. Iâd be thinking about them walking all over me the whole time (UNFORTUNATELY, I do love camping and nature. Just not the bugs. Which yes yes I know biodiversity theyâre good for the environment et cetera et cetera. I wish I loved themâ I never kill them in the house or anything, I take them outside, but I just donât like them
Sera and Gidean trusting each other!!
oooh when Braeden freezes when he gets scared, nice allusion to how the rats/scared creatures freeze
Theyâre allies!!!
something I find very interesting is that to serafina EVERYONE can be separated into Friend or Foe. Clara and Nolan, whom she barely knows? Friends.
Braeden is such a horse girl
ooooh heâs helping her into the carriage like a GENTLEMAN
âIâm sorry there arenât any blankets,â Braeden said. âNot even a good cloak to sleep under.â
âIâll pass on the cloak, thank you,â Serafina said with a smile, and Braeden laughed.
theyâre so 12 year old coded lol
Braeden backstory!! & emotions
Mr Vanderbilt: youâve got to be a man, Braeden
Serafina, in the corner, under her breath: yOUâvE gOT tO bE A MaN, bRAeDeN
Mr Vanderbilt: *gives Braeden some well intentioned, albeit slightly sexist, advice* Serafina: MURDERER
Nice allusion to Mr thorneâs skill at everything being suspicious
Chapter 10 was creepy af (I mean it does take place in a graveyard soo)
Cloven Smith has a creepy gravestone, & google told me nothing about him, so I doubt he was real
Serafina: *sees a grave to two women* oh these must be sisters
me: WIVES
me, realizing theyâre nine: ⌠Childhood lovers who could never fall in love properly because they never grew up?
me, sighing: sisters
Anyway now I wanna write an au about Mary and Margaret being witches or catamounts or something
WE FOUND THE GLADE
WE MET SERAFINAS SIBLINGS!!!!
AND LEANDRA!!!!!!!!! OMG!!!!!!!!!!
oooh is a creature of the night good or bad? Or is right/wrong/good/bad something we need to decide for ourselves?? Fascinating implications & queries for a kids book
âwhy do I deserve a present?â âBecause weâre friends, right?â SO CUTE!!!!!!
braeden being loud af in the tunnels lol
braeden hanging 30 feet in the air lol
serafina wanting to knock the pieces of the chess set over to watch them fall is so Cat (yes that is what I dub the term)
lmaoooo Mr Thorne calling Mr Rostanov âdaddyâ aged SO WELL
serafina: letâs go through peoples stuff
braeden: letâs not
Braeden as they go through every room: I like this guy! He canât be evil! I like this guy too! And this guy!
Serafina: you like too many people
Raphael Room, Van Dyck Room, Sheraton Room, Old English Room, Morland Room
Love knowing this is actually true!!
âThe pumpkin pie, like all pumpkin pie, looked like something a dog would eatâ UH! I beg your pardon?? Pumpkin pie is DELICIOUS
Serafina softening to Mr Vanderbilt and seeing how much he cares for his staff and guests!!
Ooooh Mr Thorne is getting sick!!!
Haha Braeden saving serafina from getting her eardrums ruptured
ohhhhh heâs playing the piano because clara is good with the piano
Braeden somehow knowing what kind of food serafina likes and bringing it to her is friend goals
GUYS Braeden says that Mr Thorne owned an estate âbefore the war between the states.â Thatâs the civil war, in 1861. Itâs been almost 38 years since then. But Mr Thorne isnât described as an old man at all. But he couldnât be a fully grown adult and own property 38 years ago but still appear as if heâs in his 40s. Right??
but also Mr Thorneâs death is sooooo overdue. Child murdering evil plantation-owning racist piece of shit got what he deserved
UGH all the descriptions of the night and the stars and nature make me SO MAD I live in a giant polluted city
A good couple pages:
âThe time for sneaking and hiding was over. She was going to make sure one man in particular saw her. And tonight was the night. The Chief Rat Catcher had a job to do.â (Ch 19, p225) YES SERAFINA!!!!!
âShe⌠kept lacing her dress up her back with shaky fingers, but she was having a terrible go of it. Normal girls must have extremely long and bendy arms to do this every night, she thought. Help sheâs so funny đ
âShe hated walking straight. And she hated walking slow.â REAL
âShe was a China doll, and she was a wraith, in and out of shadows, a girl in between.â Very nice
oooohhhhhh sheâs hoping the mountain Lion will show up to kill him. I didnât realize that the first time i read this
âCome out, my dear child, before I become angry with you.â Thanks to @secretly-a-catamount for telling me Thorne was meant to be a warning to children about child predators because now I SEE IT even more clearly than I did earlier
âAt that moment, all the power and ferocity of closed motherhood came ripping out of the woods.â YESSIR
GIDEAN TO THE RESCUE!!!
âshe was mightily perturbed he hadnât stayed deadâ đ đ
yesyesyesyes die rat bastard!!!!! Mr Thorne is dead!!!!! Letâs go!!!!!
LEANDRA!!!!!
Braeden putting together a search party for serafina and sending gidean out ahead is so perfect and wonderful
Am I the only one somewhat perplexed that all Mrs&Mr Vanderbilt did was send down some beds? Like why not give them a proper room even in the servantâs floor or something? Idk
âThere are few skills more important than picking good friends.â â Mr Vanderbilt, the man who befriended Mr Thorne đ
ahhhh I loved this book. I canât WAIT to reread the rest!












