#dreamx

Going on the theory Eret used to be some kind of powerful being before the SMP, maybe they first came to the SMP because they've been hearing all these stories about loved ones visiting the SMP and then never returning, as figures that as a demigod/god/whatever they are it's probably something they should check out themselves. So they go, and at first nothing seems amiss, and before they know it they too are falling into the trap. The thing that snaps them out of it is Foolish bringing up their past together (he also came to the SMP because he wanted to know what happened to his friend).

Since the In-Between has also been known to cause memory fuckery, maybe XD is the guardian or ruler of it. Maybe Karl became aware of what's going on and started time-travelling to try and put a stop to it, causing XD to panic and frantically try to cover his tracks.

And finally, maybe once DreamXD has been taken care of and everybody's got their memory and is hopefully far away from the SMP, we can get some SBI just breaking down in one big family cuddle pile and making sure each of them know they're loved because God knows they need it.

Eret was going to go and try and get his friends and the others back only for his own memories to get completely deleted as well. Whoops.

Inbetween and XD being the guardian of it? Yeah that checks. That checks a lot.