One in The Same ⯠Tobias Eaton Headcanon
Pairings: Tobias Eaton x Reader Fandom: Divergent MASTERLIST Warnings: Cursing? SUMMARY: [see request] Request from anon: hiii- so um, if requests are open, could i please request a fic or a headcanon for tobias eaton?? if not thatâs totally fine! so- for a headcanon/fic i was thinking something along the lines of tobias slowly becoming comfortable with the reader? like, heâll start to share small things about him the more they hangout, and eventually he tells the reader his feelings for them?? ahh i hope this makes sense- thank you!! <3
A/N I think Iâve forgotten how to write headcanons yâall... this is deadass 1k words. Also this request is so cute, I hope this is suitable <3 Can we please normalize calling guys pretty đĽş
It started off with little things that made Four intrigued by you
Firstly, you being a transfer from Amity to Dauntless of all factions
Secondly, despite being raised to be kind, you were the most ruthless of initiates
And lastly, you had a way of drawing attention to yourself; either intentional or not that made you seem magnetic to Four
You two didnât really meet until after you were properly welcomed as a member of the Dauntless faction
The two of you both worked in security, you werenât a good leader and you enjoyed technology even if Amity wasnât the most âtechyâ faction
It was easy working beside Four, he wasnât annoying or arrogant which you found to be very refreshing
âAll of the others here think theyâre better than me, itâs crazy.â (You)
Small talk wasnât your forte but the silence in the room was deafening
âTell me about it,â (Four)
He knew a thing or two about arrogant assholes, one always came to mind; Eric Coulter
After that, you two began hanging out together
Sitting beside each other during meals became routine, it was convenient especially when you had to tell him something in regards to work
âI was thinking of getting a tattoo, want to join me?â (You)
You skipped out on tattoos when the other initiates got them, it didnât feel right at the time
âSure, whatâre you getting?â (Four)
âI dunno, itâll be my first.â (You)
After that, Four looks at you differently
He honestly expected you to dive headfirst into âDauntless lifeâ to prove you were worthy because you came from Amity
The trip to the tattoo parlor was one of many times you two spent time together outside of work
âBeing in Amity was so weird, Iâve always been sort of angry by nature so it was hell trying to be peaceful.â (You)
âYou donât seem angry,â (Four)
âOh 16 years of standing in the corner will do that to a person.â (You)
Things never got that personal, but when the conversation felt too close to home (for either of you) one of you quickly switched topics
Your friendship worked well in that way
âOne time I put a frog in my cousinâs bed and had to do like a hundred hours of community service. I was nine.â (You)
âMy old faction as a whole wasnât horrible. But I didnât fit in wellâŚâ (Four)
âSame here, least we got each other right?â (You)
It became obvious to Four that you two were more alike than he originally realized
Two people from similar factions with similar upbringings⌠both having grown up feeling out of place
Four realized his feelings for you were turning into something more when you made him a cake for his birthday
Your bright smile and messy apron made him stop in his tracks, surprised
âDauntless chocolate cake for my favorite personâs birthday!â (You)
âHowâd you know?â (Four)
âYou mentioned it when we first met, howâs it feel to be an old man, Four?â (You)
That night was something different, stargazing after watching a movie felt so intimate with Four, but so comfortable at the same time
âNo oneâs ever made me a cake before.â (Four)
âNot even your mom?â (You)
You found out she passed soon after and instead of asking more questions like usual, you just kept him company
âI never really considered leaving Amity until I got my aptitude test results,â (You)
âWhatâd you get?â (Four)
âDauntless, duh.â (You)
Four had laughed at that, you always surprised him with your random sarcastic outbursts or remarks
âBet it came as a surprise.â (Four)
âNot really, if anything I was thankful for a way out. Despite their appearance, Amity isnât as beautiful as they claim to be.â (You)
Four genuinely recognized his feelings when you and some initiates from your group invited him to some shenanigans, he hadnât done anything like that since he transferred, but you were adamant
âCome on, itâll be fun! I did this on like my third night here and nearly died but it was so worth it!â (You)
It actually turned out to be fun, the same game of capture the flag but in a different area of the city
Four was on your team (luckily) and you two were taking people out left and right
When you saved him by taking down one of the enemies, he watched in awe at how good you were (man is WHIPPED)
That was the first night you crashed at his place because you were so tired
âIâll pay you back tomorrow, mkay?â (You)
You made him breakfast in the morning, it wasnât anything spectacular just something to repay him for giving up his bed
âNobodyâs made me breakfast in like ten years.â (Four)
âThat sucks, but Iâm glad I could be that personâŚâ (You)
Neither of you spoke after that, it was like the energy in the air after the game of capture the flag completely changed
It wasnât uncomfortable, just⌠heavy⌠with things unsaid
I feel like Four would keep himself from being nice all of a sudden since it would be weird if he suddenly changed up on you
But he found it hard because your company made him happy
At one point he told you his real name, out of the blue, he just asked if youâd start calling him it when it was just you two
âCall me Tobias,â (Four)
âWhy would I call you that, your nameâs Four-- Oh... thatâs your real name isnât it? Hmm, itâs nice, serious just like you.â (You)
He would often catch himself staring at you as you spoke or enjoying the sound of your voice
âTobias? You there?â (You)
Youâd caught him staring and it made him get really embarrassed
It was weird seeing Four flustered and struggling to find the right words, you were usually the less composed one
âAre you okay? You look like youâre having an allergic reaction, staring is normal. I do it all the time.â (You)
This would confuse Four, you stared at him? No⌠that couldnât be true, could it?
âWhat I meant to say was--â (You)
âWhat?â (Four)
Now things felt awkward, those unsaid words were heavy in the air; both of you knew but didnât want to ruin a nice thing (your friendship)
âI stare at you⌠because youâre pretty.â (You)
âNever been called pretty before,â (Four)
âWell⌠you are, very pretty.â (You)
âYouâre prettier but Iâll take it.â (Four)
His sudden confidence came out of nowhere but he was definitely thankful for it
âYou think Iâm pretty?â (You)
âI think youâre great⌠in general⌠itâs weird but I feel comfortable to be myself around you,â (Four)
âThatâs not weird, I feel the same.â (You)
Things didnât change all too much after that, neither of you wanted to rush into things because your friendship was too beautiful to ruin by making a mistake














