Why The Phrase âMan Up!â is Completely Fine.
The phrase âMan up!â is said to someone - typically a boy - who is expressing non-masculine traits (such as crying, or another kind of âfeminineâ emotional outburst). In this way, the expression is used to say âStop crying and be more masculine!â. This is not a problem, and saying that itâs a problem is to completely misunderstand the sentiment.
There are very few men who will sincerely say that one should âNever express emotionâ. Very few. Not even most wrestlers or marines would say that. Those few men who do are usually insecure, and themselves express emotion much more than they deem to be ideal for themselves (which is something actually related to the phrase âMan up!â).
Nevertheless, expressing lots of emotions is not inherently a bad thing.
What is meant by âMan up!â, then, is NOT âNever express emotion! Ever!â. Thatâs a simple and flawed view of the phrase. âMan up!â actually means âNow is not the time to just sit there and cry!â.
It is a phrase used to spur one to put oneâs emotions to one side and focus on the job at hand. It is used to instil discipline. It is used to encourage the recipient to stop being childish, to be mature, and to realise that breaking down in tears isnât going to solve whatever problem they are facing.
In effect, it is a phrase used to encourage pragmatism in a situation which demands it. Any debilitating emotions can be processed after the problem has passed, but not before.
To dismiss the use of the phrase âMan up!â is to dismiss the value it has in maintaining personal morale in tough situations, and in getting shit done. The alternative is to encourage whining and ineffectual displays of emotion instead of gritting oneâs teeth and getting on with it.
This latter sentiment is what is truly awful, and is something âMan up!â is used to avoid.
Sorry, this has been eating at me. Can people please stop ripping into the concept of masculinity? Just... in general? Itâs completely fine the way it is.
P.S. The use of the phrase âWoman up!â to the same effect is also something i approve of. Go nuts with that, too.