Which Came First? Christopher Michael Langan Interview
John Harras: What came first, the chicken or the egg? Â Those are your choices...either the chicken or the egg. Â Any other answer is wrong.
Christopher Langan: Â Contrary to popular belief, this age-old dilemma actually has a very straightforward solution. First, you must specify what kind of egg you mean. If you mean âany kind of eggâ, then the egg came first (because chickens were preceded on the evolutionary timeline by, for example, egg-laying fish, insects and dinosaurs). If, on the other hand, you mean âa chicken eggâ, then you must specify whether this means (a) âan egg laid by a chickenâ, (b) âan egg containing a chickenâ, or (c) âan egg laid by and containing a chickenâ. In cases (a) and (c), the answer is by definition âthe chickenâ (if the answer were âthe eggâ, then the egg could not have been laid by a chicken).
In case (b), the usual and most interesting interpretation, the answer is âthe eggâ. This is because interspecies mutations separating a new species from its parent species occur in reproductive rather than somatic DNA, i.e. in germ cells rather than body cells. (Germ cells include the sperm and egg cells produced in the reproductive tracts of male and female animals respectively.) Since germ cells are merely produced, but not somatically expressed, by the parents of the organism(s) whose biological information they encode, their expression begins in the egg containing the offspring. Â So the egg contains a chicken, but was not laid by a chicken. (See how easy that was?)
Source:Â http://www.megafoundation.org/CTMU/Q&A/Archive.html#Chicken