I know you talked about Youthful Exuberance in another post, but Iâm going to ask again for The Comprehensive History, specifically about Cornwellâs role in the story and her relationship with Una, along with anything else you want to share.
Oh my goodness, Iâm so excited to talk more about Youthful Exuberance (Some Kind of Love) and Cornwellâs key role within the narrative. Thank you for this ask, @cornwells-couch! â¤ď¸
Okay, so with this wonderful gifset as a reminder, letâs remember Una and Katâs last canon interaction ⌠that âwaitâ ⌠that look ⌠that lingering elbow hold.
I choose to believe that these two have history.
Letâs also remember Una saying in âAd Astra Per Aspera:â
When I was five or six, I remember a Starfleet crew visited. They were all so different from one another. So many crew members from so many planets.
And, finally, letâs also remember that Laâanâafter being hunted by the Gorn that killed her family and anyone else on the SS Puget Sound, then being sent into space alone on a life raft to be eventually rescued by Una as an ensign on the Martin Luther King Jr.âwas able to get into Starfleet Academy despite what must have been extreme psychological distress.
So ⌠what if a certain person was a member of that Starfleet crew and helped a little Illyrian girl?
What if that same person noticed when that no-longer-little girl managed to join Starfleet?
What if that same person decided to protect that no-longer-little girl by becoming her first captainâthe trained psychologist captain of the Martin Luther King Jr. who was able to not only help another little girl who needed guidance but also encourage the two to form an important bond of friendship?
Writing Kat as the embodiment of what Starfleet should be: grit, wisdom, care for others, thinking ahead, pivoting as needed, and always striving to be better ⌠it was my love and appreciation for her character with every word. When the King Jr. was mapping the sector and Kat got to lead treaties, soothe planetary infighting, allocate resources, and more? That was me reveling in seeing Kat captain a ship, yes as a model for Una of what a great officer can be, but also for me, me, me, and my admiration for what Kat becomes as a leader and how she may have gotten there.
I have this theory in writing: I believe that every story should have the capacity to be compelling if told from any main characterâs point of view.
This story from Katâs point of view compels me:
Kat felt guilty for not doing more to help the little Illyrian girl. (I think that guilt is somewhat misplaced, but people are people.)
Kat kept her cards close to her chest and didnât want to overwhelm or scare Una once Una arrived on the King Jr., a caution that speaks to Katâs care and respect for Una.
Kat approached Laâan absolutely beautifully (imo) both to help Laâan and to get the information Starfleet needed about the Gorn as a new enemy.
Kat had a plan waiting for the if/when of Una getting caught by Starfleet.
Kat stuck up for Chris and Una as captain and first officer, yet also knew when to tell Una to recognize that not everything was about Una and to step back and follow orders.
I love her, your honor, and I love the idea that Una could have her as a mentor and role model who was fiercely protective but also knew when to let go (e.g., agreeing to Unaâs transfer to the Antares).
If the story had been written from Katâs point of view, there would have been all of the above plus more about Gabriel Lorca, Katâs âfriendâ (they be banginâ) who became unusually reedy yet flinty at the end of the story (when Chris couldnât have known that Gabriel had returned from time spent in the Mirror Universe). There also would have been a lot more interaction between Kat and Laâan thatâs suggested but wasnât possible to detail given the third-person limited point of view on Una and Chris. But it would have been made clear that:
Kat continued to comfort Laâan in the King Jr. sickbay. (Of course.)
Kat accepted the promotion to commodore in part to be nearby while Laâan was at the academy. (Parentsâ Weekend? Kat and Chrisâ mom would be Laâanâs âparents,â most definitely.)
Kat helped Laâan process the kindness and understanding Neera showed Laâan at Unaâs hearing. Yes, people had been kind to Laâan in the past. But immediate, clear, unapologetic understanding for the depths of Laâanâs self-doubt? Laâan hadnât gotten that in a long, long time.
One more thing: Maybe it was obvious, but Katâs conclusion to Chris and Unaâs wedding ceremony:
Lieutenants Christopher Pike and Una Chin-Riley. With the power vested in me by Starfleet Command and the United Federation of Planets, I now pronounce you husband and wife. You can kiss, high-five, shake hands â whatever you want. Youâre married!
was an homage to Janewayâs conclusion to Tom and BâElannaâs wedding ceremony in âCourse: Oblivion:â
Lieutenant Thomas Eugene Paris. Lieutenant B'Elanna Torres. With the power vested in me by Starfleet Command and the United Federation of Planets, I now pronounce you husband and wife. Now, Tom.
because Kat is part of the pantheon of awesome, badass, soulful, wonderful Trek women, and it was an absolute honor for me to write her as an integral part of that story.
Thank you, thank you, thank you for asking about this, @cornwells-couch! â¤ď¸ Iâm always happy to talk about Youthful Exuberance (Some Kind of Love) ⌠or any of my stories ⌠and our beloved Katrina Cornwell.