Honestly, I don’t think the idea of a washed-up middle-aged Peter Pan is necessarily a bad idea in of itself. The problem is that they made him a VILLAIN.
Imagine if CnDRR had portrayed Sweet Pete in a more sympathetic light, and at the end he was given a second chance at an acting career, allowing him to recover and finally become happy again. It would’ve been really poignant and heartwarming, and it would feel like Disney is apologizing for ruining Bobby Driscoll’s life all those decades ago, and saying that this is the life he SHOULD’VE gotten.
But no. Disney instead portrays Peter Pan as an irredeemably evil sociopath who rejects all attempts at a second chance, and at the end he gets horribly mutated and locked up Hannibal Lecter-style, with no attempt to fix or rehabilitate him. What kind of commentary are they trying to make THERE?
It feels like the movie is saying Bobby was a piece of shit who deserved to be thrown out into the streets and die of a drug overdose when he was only 31. Intentional or not, it’s fucked up.















