I have a problem with writing dialogue and that is I write too much of it, in other words my dialogues are too long. How do i make them seem long and good and important without it lasting through 20,pages? Also, how do i say, rather than show, some of the dialogues,but in a way my readers dont feel like they missed out?
hi! been following for a year or so and iâm so grateful for this blog. youâve helped me and others out a ton. i find that when i write, my first draft is very dialogue-heavy. when i go back and edit itâs mostly to fill in the spaces between spoken word, but i always feel like i donât have enough detail for others to see what i see. what are some ways i can improve on adding more detail? iâve been practicing by journaling/freewriting, but this style doesnât really find its way into my WIP. thx!
Hello! Iâm writing a novel and I feel like I have a lot of dialogue. Is that okay? (Itâs in 1st person POV).
Wow, a lot of synchronicity here!Â
Nothing makes me close a page of fanfic faster than Wall OâDialogue. And itâs not just fanfic: I have actually photocopied pages from a professionally edited and published book so that I could go through and write down (it was a library book) who was talking.Â
Thank you all for realizing itâs an issue and looking to deal with it.Â
Relentless dialogue is just as frustrating to your readers as an unparagraphed wall of text or reams of irrelevant infodump.Â
tl;dr: You donât have to kill your darlings. You do, however, have to stuff a sock in them sometimes.Â
Dialogue should be like any other part of your story â essential to plot and characterization.Â
If youâre writing a story in novel format, you donât want it dominated by dialogue. Thatâs called a screenplay. But youâre writing a narrative; youâre struggling with things like plot and point of view. Too much dialogue can mean too little action.
Then again, your characters reveal themselves to the reader through conversation. And you might just need to slow the action down for a minute, so you have them talk. How do you sort it all out?Â
Ask yourself: Is it necessary?Â
Your first task: Make sure your dialogue is advancing the story or revealing character. If itâs not necessary, cut it out. Save the file ⌠it might be useful later, but remove it from your working draft.Â
Next: Break up the dialogue you still need if you havenât already. Your four main tools for breaking up (necessary) dialogue are:
1. dialogue tags: he said, she asked, they replied. Be specific, use the characterâs name if you have to, try to avoid fancy words like âhe articulated.âÂ
2. action beats: âIâm not going,â he said, dropping the book on the floor; orÂ
            Xander tossed the book on the bed. âIâm not going.â
3. inner monologue:Â âI donât care what you think,â Tamsyn said.Â
               Juno was tired of her bullshit. She knew T cared. Juno was tired of her own anger. This was no way to have a relationship. But T wasnât in a place to listen, and Juno had no other way to explain it.
              âOK, if thatâs how you feel, Iâve got nothing else,â Juno said as she turned to leave.Â
Inner monologue is an excellent device for replacing dialogue that you cut out. Instead of having your characters go back and forth, put the reactions into the inner, real-time thoughts and reactions of your POV character. Sometimes, what your character does NOT say out loud is far more revealing and interesting.
 4. actual action: Nothing wrong with interrupting your blathering lovelies with plot- or character-revealing action. Someone bursts into the room with news ⌠something is happening on the TV news thatâs relevant ⌠one of your characters gets a phone call or text that is disturbing, etcâŚÂ
Underwriting/Under-describing
Another reason we resort to too much dialogue is that we are covering for a lack of description, also known as underwriting. We donât want to insult our readers by being obvious, because part of the fun of reading is connecting the dots. Itâs up to you, the writer, to make sure there are just enough dots.Â
Donât jump to conclusions without presenting the evidence first. Nobody changes their life simply because of one conversation â although one conversation can spark a series of interim changes that will have life-altering and story-altering effects. Â
Maybe you need to do more research on the setting. Maybe you need to interview your characters to find out more about them â do a questionnaire or other character building exercises.Â
Ask your beta readers what they think is lacking. Remember, your first draft is going to need work, so donât get too bogged down trying to make everything perfect on the first pass.Â
You can find more help here. An author shares her struggles with description here.Â
There are additional tips in these articles here and here.Â
If you want to learn good dialogue, read good dialogue, as recommended here and here.
â Aliya, currently feeling your pain with a dialogue-heavy section of her fanfic