There’s this one detail that just keeps getting stuck in my head with your au,is that I just genuinely don’t think Lucifer likes sinners. I know it’s fanfiction, but I legitimately don’t think Lucifer would get over the bias he has over sinners especially if his family died fighting for them (I don’t fully remember what your lore was for that) so if Lucifer was being dlulu I feel like you would either latch onto a hellborn or a fallen angel. It actually had me thinking that the fallen angel idea could work since Charlie is dead technically reader could just replace vaggie and Lucifer found them instead of Charlie.

But what I wanted to write was that after the death of Lilith and Charlie Lucifer gets so depressed he conjures a person using magic (kinda like razzle and dazzle) to fill that hole in his heart only for his creation to be terrified of him because they know there just a replacement for his old family and is scared he’ll kill them when (more like if) he break out his delusion. So they’re trying to run away.

There are just so many angst possibilities with this Au. I’ll send it in once I finish writing it but I’m busy trying to deal with college stuff so it might take a while.

The only Mourningstar that has the knowledge that you are a sinner but glosses over and has a disconnect that doesn't necessarily make sense is the original who saved a Little from extermination. He sees them as above other sinners, or possibly sent over a small mistake they made just like him (in fact it's likely he uses this reasoning to justify himself if at any point he was reminded they were a sinner because they are NOT the same as every other filthy degenerate soul down here, they are like him not them). For the others, well True Daughter is completely delusional and is convinced they are his literal daughter, and Sacrifice Mourningstar is convinced that had they not made a deal with him they would be sent to the pearly gates, regardless of what may be true he is convinced their only real sin was making a deal with him.

Just a question for that then, would it kinda end up as a kidnap situation? Once stolas saves the reader from getting taken and sold by other hellborn would stolas just whisk them away to the palace?

Like, like am sorry, but the man wants to be my dad/believes that he is, and through the first five minutes of knowing me gives me more affection than my real dad showed me in the last 22 years. I'm in 100%.

In the scenario that my sibling that i love is there. "Daddy don't you remember them?", looks at the sibling with dramatic sadness when they try to argue "They may not remember much, but i also didn't, and you helped."

Like, no one was killed by a little gaslightig, gaslight him back!

Ngl this made me laugh because it's just so valid XD It would totally work with True Daughter Mourningstar too lol. He'd be legitimately devastated because how could he forget his babygirl was a twin?! Because regardless of what your sibling looks like or if they're clearly younger or older they're your twin that was also separated at birth.

He'd apologize profusely and assure you that he would help you help them remember. Would like to have one of his clones paint a new family portrait of you all with matching outfits (because twinsies!) and would probably dress you both alike unless either of you objects because of course both of your comforts come first. Also, if your sibling uses anything other than she/her pronouns, you're probably gonna have to have a talk because Lucifer is also going to call them his babygirl and such.

Ultimately the feeding into his delusions might not be the "healthy" thing to do, buuut who's it hurting when you're gaining the most loving and devoted Daddy in the entire universe who would do almost anything (anything but letting you out of his direct vicinity for longer than a few minutes, like if you asked for some privacy he's going to make it like three minutes maximum if he can't even leave a clone with you) and he gets the one thing he desires most in the entire cosmos just by your acceptance of him as your Daddy?

I don't actually have any works written for any of my AUs, as of yet, but I do have tagged asks on here. Anything underneath the Mourningstar AU (Original, True Daughter, or Sacrifice) is tagged with Lucifer Mourningstar and yandere. Anything in the 2p verse is tagged with the corresponding character like Alastor 2p, Vox 2p, Val 2p, or staticmoth 2p.

I think the only AU I have that I don't have any questions for is the Stolas AU I made but never utilized beyond a poll where Blitzo and him remain friends and Blitzo becomes a ring master for his own circus which Stolas provides the financial backing and deals with the paperwork and such for everything else is pretty much the same Moxxie, Millie, and Loona are still there and the M&Ms have their own acts (Millie = Muscle Woman, Moxxie = Trick shooting and knife throwing) Loona works the ticket booth. Stella and Stolas end up getting divorced after Octavia moves out of the house and Stolas can no longer justify his suffering for her sake. The AU would begin with Stolas meeting a hellborn (imp or any other ring demon, like the Sloth goats, or Lust Succubi and Incubi) Little as he goes on a stroll one lonely evening and manages to prevent them from being kidnapped, and likely sold, by other hellborns thus making them, subconsciouslyor not, see him as their Caregiver and seek him for comfort. However he meets them, he's over the moon at the prospect of being needed again. If I wrote for this one, it might have a few choices, but Reader's personality would be shy and have issues with self worth.

Like they notice that reader never does anything with their wings, and their feathers start looking dull and feel brittle. So, as a good caretakers that they are, they scold them for neglecting their wings, before showing them how to do it.

With Mourningstar i feel like he would do it right from the very start. Regular preening sessions.

Considering the ask, I'm adding another character here with Husk since he has feathered wings and would likely have to help Alastor's little in this situation.

Adam- is practically obsessed with looking his best as far as his wings go. He can get away with stubble or a bit of relaxed hygiene and general appearance upkeep since his mask and robes cover pretty much everything, but his wings are out there for anyone and everyone to see and they're almost a source of pride for him. After all, the first man has to have the most beautiful and pristine wings out of all the Winners, of course he isn't so vain that he would compare himself to say someone like Sera, buuuut he definitely spent more of his time ensuring that not a single feather was out of place.

So naturally his winged Litttle would need to follow his shining example. If they're Winners he's probably helping them from the get go if they struggle themselves because he can't be seen dead, or well, double dead, with anyone less than perfect and Winner Little goes wherever he goes, equal parts because of his trust issues and jealous/possessive nature. Will likely tease them at first when they struggle, and will scold them if they show absolutely no interest in the upkeep of their wings.

Now, Sinner Little would probably suffer for a bit. He's still very much pissed that he was saddled with a fucking Sinner of all people and hates that his Caregiver won't let him let you get exterminated by his girls. Plus, it's not like they're leaving the mansion so why the fuck should he care how they look? Only, the longer he's around them the more he does care, and eventually, maybe, he thinks they look pathetic enough, failing miserably to preen their undoubtedly itchy and uncomfortable wings that he takes pity upon them and takes mercy upon them and helps them out. Will likely insult their intelligence at first and say mean things along the lines of "you know the term filthy Sinner isn't meant to be literal right dipshit?" When he cares about them he might say sorry in varying ways and only ever apologizing sincerely when their asleep or farther into the future.

Lucifer, while not as clingy as Mourningstar, would likely still leap at the chance to help his Little. His scolding is mild at best if the Little shows no interest in preening themselves. He honestly would be secretly happy to be able to do this for them while also trying to help them do it on their own if that makes sense. Like he does want them to learn and grow as any Caregiver or parent would, but also if they never do in this aspect he is more than happy to continue doing these Daddy/ Duckling bonding sessions with them.

Mourningstar, however is actively infantilizing the everloving hell out of them as always. Preening was a regular part of their schedule from day one, if they attempt to learn to do it themselves he will merely chuckle and remind them with a soft smile that it's Daddy's job to take care of his babygirl and that he very much loves getting to do this for them, and they wouldnt want to make him feel sad and unwanted would they? As an added note, True Daughter would definitely use their wings as evidence they were related even if they looked nothing alike.

Husk, while not a Caregiver himself, I could see helping out Alastor's Little in the event they had wings and were unable to care for them properly. Honestly, if he noticed them struggling with preening or their wings were bothering them I could see him helping them learn on his own without Alastor using his soul contract to force him to. He's a surly alcoholic, but I imagine he has a soft spot for Littles and Pets especially.

Very accurate, man wants to lovingly and gently mold you into his babygirl. He would never raise his voice at you or take the violent route with you. However, will he gaslight, manipulate, and possibly trick you into feeling or thinking a certain way? Oh yes, very much so, but he doesn't see it as doing those things. He's just trying to help you.