I see it a lot, many times when it comes to adopting cats.
āWell the girl cat is an alpha so I canāt adopt another cat.āĀ
āMy one cat is the alpha so they beat up the other cats.ā
And I just wanted to say,
I understand what you mean, but please stop using the term alpha.
That term came from a dated canine training theory, so Iāll link yāall a few articles, since Iām not actually a canine behaviorist.Ā
https://www.whole-dog-journal.com/behavior/debunking-the-alpha-dog-theory/
http://content.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,2007250,00.html
https://www.animalhealthfoundation.net/blog/2017/10/the-myth-of-the-alpha-dog/
Essentially this theory cropped up as a behavior modificationĀ ātechniqueā (heavy use of the quotation marks there), when some wolves were observed in what was assumed to be a pack exhibiting pack behavior. The observation and theory was later debunked in wolves, for several reasons (lack of sample size, relation of wolves to each other), but also the very important addition that dogs are not wolves.
So Iām gonna kinda drop a truth load on yāall.
If dogs are not wolves, cats are definitely not wolves.
I know. Itās shocking. But Iāve checked. Trust me.Ā
That is to say, felines behaving in an aggressive manner towards other cats is absolutely still -a thing-, but identifying it asĀ āalphaā behavior is 1) incorrect and 2) allowing you to let a behavioral problem slide by simply by dismissing the behavior as something that just exists, when in reality it shouldnāt.
Donāt get me wrong, cats get upset at other cats. Anxiety and tension can get high for various reasons, from fighting over food resources when cats lack options of feeding, to literallyĀ āI saw a bird out the window and I canāt get it so now Iām HECKINā U P S E T and I WANT TO KILL IT but I CANāT. So I guess Iāll give the other cat in the house a mean right-hook.ā
There are a MILLION and a half reasons for your cats to fight, or not get along, but literally none of them are because your cat is an alpha.
In theĀ āwildā (heavy quotes here considering Felis catus is an invasive species literally almost everywhere), cats do a LOT of stuff together. They will share food, they will communally raise kittens, they will protect what they deem as their territory, but itās more akin to cats living in a communal building with some shared living space, but with a ton of extra rooms so you and your fellow housemates only HAVE to interact when you WANT to (like communal din-din). You know your roommate likes to read from 12-4 PM, so you stay out of the reading room during that time, because you have like three other rooms to choose from to do the thing you wanted to do. You can go use that room later when your roommate isnāt there.
So yeah, catĀ āterritoryā functions more as a time-share instead of like a hard black-and-white concept.
What happens when a new roommate comes into the house, though? Maybe that roommate doesnāt know the 12-4 reading room rule, so they barge in with something that roommate REALLY doesnāt want to deal with.
āWhatās up, dude? I was thinking we could listen to some heavy metal! You like Dimmu Borgir?ā
āHey, Iām reading right now. Itās my reading time. I always use the room at this time.ā
āPfft, thatās boring. I want you to listen to Progenies of the Great Apocalypse. Itās my favorite.ā
You can see why Reading Room Cat would be upset, right? Reading Room Cat might decide to lay down the law with aĀ āHey, youāre new here, you donāt make the rules for the reading room, take your heavy metal into the music room where it belongsā.
And yeah, cats can be pretty compartmental about what they allow in what area. Like play time should not happen near where they go to the bathroom, for instance. Thatās weird. Cats donāt like the idea of getting through this level of Angry Birds while relieving themselves. The fact that they donāt like eating where they go is a little more obvious, but even playtime should be separate.Ā
This is just a single example, though. Like I said, there are MANY reasons why cats may not get along with another cat.
-They may not have the option to avoid the other cat in the house for whatever reason. They donāt have the choice to get up and away from them, they donāt have the choice to hide from them due to lack of ways around a room. Only so much we can do about that aside from knocking holes in the wall, but there is a lot we can do to help. Shelving, hides, tunnels, things like that.
-One cat may want to play when the other one REALLY WOULD RATHER NOT, THANKS.
-Cats may be fighting for a resource, such as food, water, or a litter box. Not having the option to get to choose where they can pee when all of the litter boxes are being used can definitely cause some inter-cat aggression.
-Cats may be introduced too quickly to each other, or may be experiencing just a general issue sharing their space. Itās why I advocate for INCREDIBLY long socialization periods, and even re-introducing cats that have known each other for years should their relationships start to come into question.
-One cat may be getting increased anxiety from an external source and may not have the adequate blow-off tool required. This is when increased play, puzzle feeders, and monitoring window-watching is important.
Those are only a few things, though. Things like illness, injury, sudden changes, a specific occurrence, and more can change how a cat interacts with another cat.
And yes, there are aggressive cats. There are cats that become aggressive more easily than others, and yes, those cats may live a happier and more fulfilling life without other cats in the home, or with limited interaction with other cats. They may need medication to help you figure out the best way to get them to live their best lives. There are definitely things you need to consider with cats, and some cats may just be more aggressive by nature, or by upbringing.
But itās not because theyāre an alpha.
So chose your words wisely! Try not to perpetuate a debunked theory for a different species by also tacking it onto feline-kind.
Unless youāre writing some fanfiction, maybe keep the alpha talk to discussing some Greek letters.