No Honor Amongst Thieves | Ch. 3
Nerves, rejection, and hurt. That's what was circling through Casey's body after he mentioned wanting to tell Arthur something, who was still looking at him expectantly, but patiently all the same. Letting out a deep, shaky breath, Casey closed his eyes for a moment before opening them again and focusing on Arthur. "Okay...here goes...I, uh...I happen to have different, unconventional views..." he finally blurted out, biting his bottom lip as he looked at the burly man riding next to him, who seemed momentarily shocked. Which was fair. Casey wasn't expecting any other reaction. Well...maybe rejection, too. "Um, as in what, Casey?" Arthur had drawled out, recovering from his shocked expression. Casey shrugged and shook his head, giving Beau an affectionate pat. "Nevermind, Arthur. It's just something stupid, anyway. No need to concern yourself with it," the brunette had responded, sighing as he looked out ahead of them, doing his best not to let his emotions get the best of him like they so often did. Arthur had shaken his head as well and reached over to gently tap the man's shoulder to grab his attention. "You can tell me, Case. You know this. I'm the last person that would think differently of you." After hearing these words, Casey had nodded his head and decided he'd fess up. Arthur did happen to be correct, though. He knew the man would be the last person to judge him for who he was, for who he liked. "I...I like men. I don't know if it was particularly obvious before hand, but...I prefer the company of men. I hope that doesn't change anything between us," Casey had finally said, a weight seeming to lift from his shoulders after confessing this to his best friend.
Not surprisingly, Arthur did happen to be a little taken aback by the news. He always had his suspicions about this, but of course he never wanted to assume anything that he wasn't sure about. But to hear Casey admit this made his feelings even more surreal. That meant...there could be a chance between the two of them. This thought made Arthur's heart beat a little faster, ultimately excited at the mere prospect of being more than friends with a man like Casey. Clearing his throat, Arthur Morgan flashed a smile towards Casey. "'s nothing wrong with that, Case. You know I care about you no matter what. No matter who or what you like," the burly man spoke, his hand grasping Casey's shoulder, smiling at the other male with a warm, loving smile. This made Casey blush and smile back, ducking his head a little bit before then doing his best not to lean into Arthur's touch. "Thanks, Arthur. That really means a lot to me," the male had responded, chuckling softly as he then looked at Arthur, thinking he had noticed a certain look in his eyes, but brushed it off.
'So...into men? How have I not noticed it before?' Arthur thought to himself, taking his bottom lip in between his teeth as he got lost into his thoughts, which soon turned a bit naughty...he hadn't realized that Casey was still looking at him, but eventually he stopped his thoughts and cleared his throat, walking away and getting onto his horse to try and hide his growing erection from where his thoughts took him about Casey. Casey was confused when Arthur did this, but decided not to dwell on it too much as he got onto his horse as well and sighed softly as he looked over at the burly man and noticed something. Now what he noticed really had Casey confused. Arthur had an erection. Arthur. The man who barely even thought of things like that. He had never seen Arthur this way before. He wondered what caused this, but he didn't want to be weird and ask. So instead, Casey cleared his throat as they rode on and smiled over at Arthur. "So, where we going next, Arthur?" The brunette had asked the male riding next to him, biting hsi bottom lip as he had waited for Arthur to answer him back. Arthur looked over at Casey and shrugged his shoulders. "Not sure. I was planning on just riding around for a bit. Maybe staying at a hotel for the night. Give us a bit of a break from the group. How's that sound, Case?" Arthur asked, doing his best not to think about what might happen at the hotel later that night.
Casey smiled when he heard Arthur's suggestion and couldn't help but to laugh some and nod his head. "Yeah. That sounds good. I could use a break from Micah trying to stir up trouble again," he said and shrugged his shoulders some as they continued riding through the plains. "Where were we staying at? In Valentine, Saint Denis?" He asked Arthur so he could get an idea ahead of time where they would be staying for the night. Arthur hummed some in thought, thinking about it first. "I say we stay in Valentine tonight. Maybe even Rhodes. I don't like to go into Saint Denis unless I've got to," the outlaw had said, to which Casey chuckled and nodded his head, completely understanding what Arthur meant. He also hated going into Saint Denis if he didn't have to. "Okay. I say we stay in Rhodes tonight. Unless you wanna go with Valentine. I'm fine with whatever you want," Casey had spoken, a pink tint spreading across his cheeks as Arthur noticed and laughed a little bit. "I'm fine with Rhodes, Case," the male spoke, shrugging his shoulders and sending a wink towards Casey without even thinking about it, or realizing it, for that matter.














