The Guy Next Door Pt.2
Benjamin Poindexter x Cannibal! Mutant! Reader
๐ฆน๏ฝกโ Summary: Dex finds himself in your coffee shop and expects to be in and out. Instead, you awkwardly try to make convo. Your friend, Priscella, definitely sees something going on.
๐ฆน WC: 2.3k
๐ฆน๏ฝกโ Tags: Fluff. Neighborly talks. Coffee shop. Awkward interactions. Priscella trying to be your wingman. DDBA S2! Dex.
๐ฆน Warnings: none!
A/N: I feel like Iron Man with all that technology in front of him right now ngl. I hate writing filler plot for the life of me. This took like 20,000 rough drafts before I can get this one out straight. I want to pace this as nice as possible because I don't want to rush this. SOON, we'll get to the nitty gritty of her desires. lol
โฏโ masterlist ๐ฆ previous part ๐ฆ next part โฏโ
You could say routine was one of the last things Dex had that was true to himself. Everything else had been torn and taken from him until there was nothing left. All he could be grateful for was the fact he got out of that...place.
This apartment building was a new life. A beginning towards that balanced that he craved. To balance the scales. Why else would he have survived from falling four stories? Something else is keeping here for one specific reason.
Now, he was sitting in a coffee shop, in a back corner watching you serve customers with a smile just a little too wide for it to be comfortable. At first, it really was to stay for a half an hour, move on with the rest of his day, but it was like watching you put on a show for everyone. The way everything was so calculated, a steady rhythm to be seen normally.
Dex reached for the toothpicks placed in the middle of the table, shaking one out of its container. He placed the toothpick in his mouth before raising his head up towards the TV that was planted into the corner of the cafe.
"Police still are on the lookout for the vigilante, Bullseye, who had escaped prison a few months ago. Task Force claims that this individual still wreak havoc across New York, killing individuals with bizarre makeshift weapons," Dex could only smile at that. "If you see this individual, please call Task Force immediately and do not engage with him."
He dropped his head down from the TV with a smirk still present on his lips. He decided to take that as his sign to leave the cafe and start looking around for Task Force.
However, as he was about to push his chair out, a voice called out to him. Your voice. "Uh--Tony, right?"
Looking over to where your voice called out. Your face shifted into something more genuine. A genuine, amused face scattered across your face.
That was what made Dex stay.
He quickly pushed himself back into his seat, taking out the toothpick from his mouth.
He raised an eyebrow to act confused before calling out your name, "Hey, yeah that's me. What are you doing here?"
"I work here," You pointed to your clothes. "It's nice seeing you exploring what's around here."
Dex placed both of his hands onto his lap, taking in a deep breath, "Yeah, it seems quiet around here. Not much issue."
You nodded you head at him, letting out a soft chuckle. You felt that you could relate to him more as you continued to talk to him. He seemed to just fit into the middle of your puzzle piece after decades for trying to find someone who would.
"Yes. That's why I like this area. You know...quiet and peaceful, but still in the city around other people," You say as the words you've been trained to say spilled out.
Dex leaned into more towards you. His eyebrow flicking slightly at the wording of your statement. He nodded his head towards at you before asking, "Yes, well...now Task Force is on every corner. Soon this one."
You raised your hand from your sides to say, 'that's how it is'. "I don't approve of it as the next person. It's just...unnecessary."
Dex hummed at your answer, placing his hand on the bottom of his chin. Then you just sighed, shrugging your shoulders, "I just hope it all works out in the end."
"Of course..." Dex nodded his head, making a promise to you that you didn't even realize.
Taking in a deep breath, you placed your hands back at your side and then looked behind you. You could see Pris looking back at you with this all-knowing look. You quickly snapped out of your trance with him and opened your mouth to speak, stuttering as you try to form the words.
"I should...get back to work before I get a write up or fired," You pointed you thumb back towards the kitchen.
Dex immediately stood up from the table. "Oh, right. Your duty calls."
You nervously laughed, starstruck at how tall he really was in front of you. Not to mention how extremely buff he was. Jesus. "Yeah...uh. See you soon? Or, whenever we bump into each other again."
Dex placed his hands in front of him with a smirk, nodding down at you. "I'll see you soon."
"Yes, great," You answered back in a bad attempt to act normal. "Bye."
Then, as quick as you were there, you immediately walked away from him. From behind you, Dex placed the toothpick back into his mouth with an amused glint littered across his face. You were just so...abnormally normal. Just moments when your true emotions would come out, you snapped back into this routine.
That's what he was so interested in. What was wrong with your neighbor that you needed to behave a certain way in front of people? To perform for them to please society. What were you hiding under that personality?
Dex pushed open the cafe door to enter back into the street with that question filling his mind. However, he did know one thing about you. Task Force was much of a thorn at her side as it was for him. Of course, for different reasons.
In Dex's mind, it was the fact he was Bullseye. Wanted for multiple counts of murder and attempted assassinations. Not to mention his recent prison escape.
But for you...it was because they were disrupting the peace in your neighborhood. The peace that seemed to be routine for you to surround yourself with for years.
But Dex couldn't be more wrong than that.
For in your own mind, Task Force was two steps closer to finding out about you through a background check. You heard from pass of word about the conditions they were holding individuals with the status as "vigilantes". The idea being thrown into a cage, treated as something less than a human just broke you internally.
You started to make sure you were taking your medication more regularly with timers at the very second you needed to take it again. You couldn't be seen as yourself in public anymore. Not with Fisk as the mayor of New York.
"Who was that man you were talking to earlier?" Pris questioned with a teasing glint in her eyes.
You were sitting at an empty table with most of the cafe now being empty during your slow hours. You raised your head that was resting on your fist to look at her.
You blinked as you were trying to register what she was saying to you. "Hm?"
"That guy that came in during the rush in the morning. He was really tall with scruffy, blonde hair," Pris explained while placing her hand above her hair to mimic messy hair.
"Oh, you mean Tony," You responded back, your posture immediately straightened and turned to fully look at her.
Pris immediately noticed your behavior and smiled, "Oh, yes 'I mean Tony'. Who is he?"
"My neighbor. He just moved in next door," You explained.
She let out a little coo at your words. "And you find him attractive too, huh?"
"What? Pris, I just met the man yesterday," You shook your head, immediately denying it.
"And now he was here in the coffee shop! That's your literal sign it's meant to be!" Pris responded back to you with a bright smile.
Your eyes slightly dropped at her words, your shoulders dropping down and heart settling in your chest. Meant to be. It was fate he came in here. There are millions of other places that he could have chosen to enjoy coffee, and yet, he chose here.
Your eyes squinted with your mouth mimicking a smile. "Maybe it is."
Pris pointed at you. "Now that's the attitude we need! You should get to know this guy more. You know, more than his name is Tony and lives next door."
You raised an eyebrow at her in confusion. "Isn't that enough?"
"You need to get out of your shell," Pris sighed out your name. "He looks totally into you."
"Into me?" You questioned.
"Attracted to you." Pris elaborated.
You blinked at her, thinking you heard her wrong. "Attracted? From one interaction."
"Call it a blooming love," Pris giggled while wiggling her fingers for the added effect.
She started to go off more on a tangent about how you were looking at him and how he was looking at you. However, your mind was just hooked on the idea that it wasn't just all in your mind. That someone, you believed to be a close friend, was saying something was there.
An alignment of the cosmos to bring you together.
Another chance to be able to be yourself with someone you wanted to cherish.
You placed a hand on your heart. Feeling something wrapping in your mind. Something twisting reason into pure logic. Something set in stone on what you had to do.
What was destined for you.
When you did get off your shift, you were traveling up the flight of stairs, paying no mind to your surroundings. Somehow, even with the bare minimum of social skills, you were still mentally drained from having to deal with customers all day.
And yet, you still need a way to make a steady living in order to keep your apartment.
You got to do what you've got to do.
Climbing up the last steps, you walked out into the hallway leading towards your apartment. This time, you were actually paying attention to where you were walking, but he wasn't out in the hall as you expected.
You were a little disappointed at the idea of him not being there, but it was five o'clock. He must be working or something about this hour. Letting out a sigh, you grab your keys from your back pocket as you approach your door.
Just as you slotting your key in the keyhole, you heard someone turning the locks on their door. Your heart skipped a beat at the sound before seeing Tony walking out of his apartment. He looked like he was in a rush to leave, mindlessly walking out to wherever he was going, but when he caught your eyes, he stopped.
He called out your name, causing you to smile, before he said, "I'm starting to think you're stalking me with how many times we run into each other."
For a second, you were trying to stutter out how you were just coming back from work and you weren't, but he just stared back at you with a teasing smile.
Seeing that teasing looks on his face, it registered to you that he was just joking. You snapped your lips shut at the realization before a small chuckle escaped from your mouth.
You shook your head and shrugged your shoulders to play along with him, answering back with, "It might just be fate."
He stared at you for a few seconds, observing your words as they were uttered out. He squinted his eyes and nodded before saying in a scruffy voice, "Yeah...it might be."
You placed your hands in your back pocket, feeling your keys there, and crossed your legs. "Ah, so are you heading out for tonight?"
"Yeah, just on my way to work actually," Dex responded back, making you widen your eyes.
"I must be making you late. I'm sorry," You immediately placed a hand on your chest and began to walk away, so he wasn't obligated to stay.
He placed his hand out to make you stop and said, "Oh, don't worry. My boss is very lenient."
In actuality, his boss was just himself. Under his coat was his Bullseye costume as he was just about to head out to scout out Task Force agents that were close by. However, he spotted you before even making out the door. It didn't matter to him, anyways, he had all night to look for agents.
"Still, you don't have to listen to me rant for hours," You answered back.
"I don't mind your talking. Haven't had a lot of people to talk to in my last building," Dex explained, knowing the real reason was because he was in a prison cell.
You smiled at his words, feeling something fluttering in your chest. You couldn't believe that someone like him wanted to listen to you. You looked down to avoid eye contact with him, causing your hair to come in front of your face.
You looked back at him while flipping your hair back to say, "Well, I guess that makes two of us. Not many friendly faces around this building either."
"Glad we share a wall together then," Dex answered back with a smile appearing softly on his lips.
"Yes, it's very good," You answered back to him. "You make good conversation."
He dipped his own head down to avoid eye contact with a soft chuckle. He brought his hands together while you waited for him to reply.
"You do too," Dex answered back with a huff coming out as a soft chuckle. "But, as much as I hate saying it, I should probably head to work."
Your eyes widened at his words and took a step back again. "Right. Work. Important."
Dex just listened as you spoke like what you said was the most complex and fascinating thing to ever grace his ears.
He nodded, echoing you, "Important."
"I'll see you soon, then?" You pointed a finger at him with a raised eyebrow.
"Soon," Dex nodded his head before backing away from you. "Enjoy your evening."
"You too, Tony," You replied back before he turned around to head out.
For Dex, it hurt for him to hear you utter a fake name that didn't belong to him. He knew what he was doing was just for now. He still needed to make sure you couldn't be a loose end. He needed to make sure you weren't to have the same path of Julie.
You were very interesting to say the least.













