#bob rewatch

i love that we have an entire episode dedicated to how great eugene roe is.

the fact that it’s quiet enough at the beginning that we can hear the sound of walking over the snow.

winters trying to shave in that frozen hell + arresting that german soldier with shaving cream still on his face.

the episode is so devoid of colour that winter’s doesnt look ginger :( though we can always see the color of blood, of course.

sleepy and probably hungover nixon appears out of nowhere. classic.

gene almost spraining his ankle.

that shot of gene looking at the morphine!

“two medics in one hole?!” dude, they are friends.

seriously lost count over how many times eugene says “scissus” in the first twenty minutes of this get the guy some goDDAMNED SCISSORS.

the absolute fatigue in lipton’s face when he has to show lieutenant dike where his foxhole is + also, how the fuck does dike not know where his foxhole is that’s literally his nickname.

“the hell with the leg, i'm pissing needles” poor bill spends the whole episode with a peeing problem.

gordon’s “scissors? well, let's see, i'll have to check the sewing room. might be upstairs in the study. that skinny old drawer in the middle of the desk”.

gene i know it’s your job but how can you just be running around during a shelling.

roe literally falling on top of babe and julian (+ babe’s accent !!! i will never get tired of repeating it).

babe and spina’s conversation while trying to go for more supplies (“the replacement in my foxhole, julian. goddamn virgin. just a kid. the only virgin i know is the virgin mary” + babe falling into a german trench and chuckling, that little freak).

only two medics for the entire company is insane btw.

the fellas joking around in dinner time (“nothing you won't eat, malarkey” / “i won't eat malarkey” + “anybody seen lieutenant dike?” / “try battalion cp, sir” / “try paris” / “try hinkle” + the imitation of german accents) + gene watching from a safe distance.

the way dike is leaning with his arms crossed in his foxhole pffttt

the infamous “gene, what's with the heffron bullshit, huh? you know my name, why don’tcha use it?” / “it's edward, right?” / “edward, are you serious? only the goddamn nuns call me edward”

“toye, you missing something?” / “home” (and that nasty stare mcclung gets when he exposes him) + “where are your boots?” / “in washington, up general taylor’s ass”... joe toye i love you do you hear me?

“frank, you keep cleaning those teeth, the germans will see you from a mile away. shot him dead” i seriously never noticed how much perconte cleans his teeth (this scene is just the beginning) + perconte’s indignation when roe steals his scissors.

bill’s “marlene, is that you?”. are you okay, dude.

liebgott and alley singing a christmas song. in a foxhole. at night. in the middle of the battle of the ardenes.

bill not understanding gene when he uses a french word to refer to his thing.

eugene praying (specifically the st. francis prayer! + the fact that he repeats “with all my heart” twice).

that yell for medic when the screen is dark????? cinema.

skinny gets hit and perconte complains about getting blood all over his trousers (“i’m real sorry, frank!”). 

“i’m in heaven, doc”

roe and renee bonding in french (+ one of the few scenes where roe genuinely smiles). it’s so sweet but also so sad how they have to part ways so quickly. and the chocolate?????

“that’s it, guys, nothing more to worry about. we’re gonna die now, we’re gonna die in a state of grace” skip you will be missed.

george’s “that asshole couldn’t find a snowball in a blizzard” about peacock…

first instances of how the war is affecting gene (numbness and paralisis) when we see him sitting on that tree. always waiting for something…

the idea of babe, who was introduced as a replacement like two episodes ago (a few months in real time), having to mentor and lose an ever greener replacement like all the other veterans that had mentored him… a never ending cicle.

winters sitting with the guys when they are all down because of julian’s death.

that look babe sends to roe… #whatthatmean. does he resent him for not being able to save him? does he understand by he’s always so distant with them? a little bit of both?

also, gene thinks about giving him the chocolate immediately! he basically spends the rest of the day looking for babe to give it to him.

so he can’t find babe ‘cause he isn’t in his hole? we know he’s with spine, so does that mean babe went there looking for him too? much to think about.

the soft “got ya” when he finally finds him + “i promised him, if he got hit, i'd get his stuff and bring it to his ma, you know? now the fucking krauts'll strip him” / “it’s okay” / “it’s not! it’s not okay”

gene smiling softly when talking about traiteurs and his grandmother + spina’s “i’ve had enough of playing doctor”.... spina asks him about it but he doesn’t answer (it’s amazing how little he lets us see inside his mind!).

the smiles when the supplies arrive.

how much of a nerd am i when i recognize that they also filmed a scene from les mis in that chappel?

roe and renee talking after they couldn’t save that guy (the chocolate, the hands, “i never want to treat another wounded man again. i'd rather work in a butcher's shop”, “no, it’s not a gift. god would never give such a painful thing”).

buck talking about legionaries and visigoths to gonorrea and babe (“so, what's college like, buck? you can study with all the cheerleaders running fingers through your hair?” / “hell, babe, i can't even remember”).

babe being amused that gene called him “edward” (+ the idea that doc refuses to use nicknames as a way of distancing himself from the men).

that rushed breath when smokey gets hit? + the fact that it takes a while for gene to react and help smokey (spina almost has to shake him out of it).

“he's paralyzed. can't feel a thing”... something about only being able to understand a bit of what gene’s feeling through his diagnosis of a patient (his numbness = smokey’s “can’t feel a thing)...

renée appearing in the light like an angel. understanding gene without him having to say a word.

babe getting some food for eugene.

winters looking out for gene.

“to the german commander: nuts!”, which everyone but gene finds funny.

malark’s “merry christmas, fellas. you gotta thank jolly old saint luz” + penkala’s “i’m shaking so goddamn much, i feel like i’m dancing!”

“a dell? like where fairies and gnomes live?”

“okay, get up. not okay, lie down”.

the m gene marks in welsh’ forehead (to indicate he’s had morphine) resembles the gesture of that priest from a previous scene! simbolism. whatever.

gene leaning over harry’s body to protect him from the shelling (an apparent improvisation from the actor!).

finding renée’s head piece in the ruins.

the final scene (the best scene in the whole episode? yes): “you called me ‘babe’!”, babe imitating roe’s lousiana accent, “heffron, watch the goddamn line”, the sun is finally out, the camera pans towards the blood covered snow ahead… masterpiece !

are they… you know… foxhole buddies?

no because what i love about this episode is thats so structurally sound: gene’s arch towards numbness interrupted by renée (a sort of angel-like figure), who offers him a tentative contact with human connection in the middle of the war (which gene has been depriving himself of because he doesn’t want to get too attached to his potential patiens) that ends up culminating with babe (gene literaly uses renée’s hanky to heal babe! and it’s the use of his nickname that gets babe out of his own small numbness!). perhaps it was precisely renée’s death that made gene take a step towards babe. 

BUT WHO CARES. I DON'T. I’M NOT CRYING.

anyway gene and babe and renée as a golden trio is one for the ages.

“no memeber of the 101st has ever agreed that the division needed to be rescued”

Ron Livingston's Video Diary take away- Lewis Nixon did NOT want him to record that phone call with Dick Winters about him. Sure, blah blah, recording device, backfeed, ghosts? come on, etc....me: Sir, that man is fine with Dick and Grace talking about him but he knew Dick Winters was going to impress upon you the importance of immortalizing his best friend and that shit did not need to be recorded. Especially when it got this reaction:

gene is the first closeup!!! the star of the show!!! and of my heart.

i like those shots of soldiers looking directly at the camera, as if imitating some found footage of the actual days before the big jump.

winters and nix conversation (“civilized place for civilized men” / “should’ve been born earlier, nix.” / “what, and give up all this? we'll go to chicago. I'll take you there”… are you kiDDING me how can you not interpret this as they are in love).

private bullshit.

you can see fucking gonorrea’s penguin walk during one of their marches jsajshah (apparently a philly thing, to avoid falling when the floor is icy! details!).

“sobel does not hate easy company, private randleman. he just hates you” and luz's smirk.

“it’s a can of peaches, sir” and winters trying not to smirk.

“i like spaghetti :)”

perconte shitting on said spaghetti (or “army noodle with ketchup”, as he calls it).

sobel telling hoobler to pack up his ears and go home.

“we fall upon the risers, we fall upon the grass, / we never land upon our feet, we always hit our ass. / highty, tighty, christ almighty, who the hell are we? / zim zam, goddamn, we're airborne infantry!”

toye and luz homoerotic exchange, setting the tone for the rest of the series (if nixon and winters weren’t enough).

whenever sobel is behaving pathetically incompetent i just see ross from friends. it’s hilarious. also: toye’s, lip’s and eugene’s disappointing stares HSAJSJ.

“no flaws, no vices, no sense of humor” (the eyes…).

liebgott “jokingly” threatening to kill sobel with a hand grenade jesus christ this guy. + “‘cause the army wouldn’t make a mistake, right, shift?”

“going my way?” (the whole conversation... are you kiDDING me, pt. 2). “since when do i drink?” and that stare… winters, control yourself.

that scene in the ship (“really, its hot in africa?” / “shad ap”) which i know by heart for no reason.

george pretending to be major horton and messing with sobel (+ tipper’s knowing smirk!).

that post that said that only ones playing basketball were american actors because all the british ones sucked at it.

you just gotta love lip. he’s just so lip from he beginning: caring about his soldiers, teaching them stuff, organizing a mutiny... typical lip stuff.

anyway it’s also so heartwarming how everyone is immediately loyal to winters from the very start.

british people causaly committing a war crime (wearing the enemy’s uniform).

hoobs and the tommie not understanding each other, and him almost stealing the lugger (and the foreshadowing…. shut up im fine).

“are you ticked because they LIKE me?!”

nixon using every chance he gets to show off everything he learned at yale (read: correct pronuntiation of french towns). 

toye spitting fire for 40 seconds (“i could use some brass knuckles”).

it’s hilarious that talbert’s birthplace is kokomo, because he would absolutely be the sort of guy to rock to kokomo by the beach boys.

it’s devastating whenever luz stops joking around to be serious (we see more of that starting from episode seven but still!).

the way martin choses to tell guarnere about his brother without actually having to speak with him, my brother in christ, dude. like, where's the tact.

that passive aggressive cunt that shushes guarnere while watching the movie. love him.

again with those found footage shots! love them.

guarnere praying with the rosary beads and looking straight to the camera ????

winters trying to make little hot priest laugh cause he is scared + “we are not lost, private. we’re in normandy”.

“what's that guy's problem?” / “gonorrhea.” / “really?” / “his name, dummy, guarnere, gonorrhea, get it?”.

the winters and guarnere beef + toye killing the horse cause he's a good guy (sort of).

malarkey’s such a nice guy he can become best friends with a pow.

first thing spiers ever does in the series is steal a pack of cigs from buck, second thing he does is comit a war crime. because of course.

popeye getting hit in the ass thus starting the tradition of easy company gi’s getting hit on the ass (+ buck’s “in the ass!?” in that fucking transatlantic accent).

toye survives TWO fucking granades (“fucking twice”).

someone give compton some brown lenses jesus christ almighty.

toye got some brass knuckles in the end !!! what a guy.

malark risks his fucking life like an idiot for a luger for his kid brother (+ lieb cursing in the background, “now you stop firing? beautiful”).

“shut your f*cking guinea trap, gonorrhea.” / “he's all right, that kid”... im going to cry.

poor lipton (whose job was to tnt the shit out of the machine guns) gets there late every single time.

spiers appears out of nowhere and takes the third and last machine like a madman (foreshadowing for what he does in foy, if you think about it).

“going my way?” pt. 2 + nix and winters glad of seeing each other i will pass out.

soldiers smoking and leaning on a world war one memorial…

the guys cooking inside the car-thing (buck doesn’t trust malark cause he’s irish + “sir, if you have a reservation someplace else, i’ll be glad to join ya” + winters and guarnere make up like men (read: without talking) + winters drinking for the first time + “oh, and sargent? i’m not a quaker” and guarnere’s laugh).

nix opens the can for winters after he struggles to open it up, and winters gives it back to him cause he’s “not hungry” + nix watches him walk away. like, #whatthatmean.