Oh, You’re Breaking My Heart
Warnings: SMUT! 18+ MINORS DNI! Fingering, squirting, profanities, mentions of death, eating out, handjob, inexperienced reader. Fluff, heart to heart.
Authors note: so sorry for the delay! I’ve been so caught up in school work… but beware there’s lots of smut involved in this so YEAAAAAAH… enjoy!!!
Chapter 4: Hope.
☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚☆˖°☾ ⋆˚
You couldn't stop thinking about that day, that feeling, and Billy Hargrove. These thoughts were on a constant loop in your mind, becoming all-consuming. They emerged while in the shower, in bed, and even during conversations with Steve. The characters in your novel even began to borrow his face. Was this an obsession? Had you gone mad?
You haven't seen him since that day. Now, his moans, groans, the taste of his lips, and that earth-shattering climax are overwhelming your thoughts in class, with him just two seats away.
The tension was evident.
He continually stole glances at you, causing an insatiable desire to stir between your thighs. You craved more and your mind wouldn't rest until you had it.
The bell rang, and everyone rushed out of class, including you, hastily packing your things in hopes of catching him. But you lost him in the sea of students. Huffing in frustration, you headed towards your locker. Before you could even process it, you were being pulled into the janitor’s closet. Panic overtook you until you saw who it was.
“Jesus Christ, Billy, you scared me!” you whisper-yelled, smacking his chest.
He grabbed your wrist tightly and pulled you closer to his chest. “I’ve missed you, sweet thing,” he murmured before smashing his lips into yours.
“Haven’t been able to stop thinking about you,” he said through the fervent kiss. “You’re driving me crazy.”
You’re so glad the feeling is mutual.
“Me either,” you breathed into his mouth. The two of you continued for a few minutes, losing yourselves in the kiss. The second bell rang, signaling that you were now late to sixth period.
His hands started to roam your body, squeezing your breasts and then your ass. The touch ignited a fire within you, and you let out a couple of moans, becoming even more hot and bothered than before.
The desire was evident. It felt as if you needed to breathe each other in, or you’d both die.
“You have to be quiet, sweetheart, or someone will hear us,” he whispered between the clashing of tongues.
Your heart started to beat in your chest, he’s right being caught means consequences and you’ve worked so hard to fix your record. Being friends with Tommy and Carol did a number on your school record. Suspensions, write-ups, and multiple detentions. Being caught was something you couldn’t afford.
“You’re right, I have to get to class” you said taking a deep breath trying to calm the pleasure that surged through your body.
It was addicting, he was addicting.
He kept kissing your neck, then licked a stripe from it to your ear, swirling your earlobe with his tongue causing you to shudder under his touch.
Maybe the consequences would be worth it?
“You’re already late honey, let me at least make it up to you,” he whispered in your ear.
“How’re you going to make it up to me?”
Billy swiftly turned you around so your backside was pressed to his chest, “Can I show you?” He whispered in your ear again.
Fuck it.
You closed your eyes and nodded yes and he unbuttoned your jeans sliding them just above your knees and then he shoved his hand in your underwear and touched you where you longed for him the most.
You were soaking for him, aching for him, for his touch, for his presence. He was intoxicating.
You started to moan loudly which then prompted him to use his free hand to cover your mouth. He gathered the slick from your entrance and used it to rub slow circles in your clit. “You’re soaking my fingers baby,” he said in your ear and you don’t know why but the warmth of his breath on your ear made you whimper.
“I’m gonna put my fingers in baby, it might sting a bit so let me know if I need to stop,” your heart rate started to pick up, you were nervous but the pleasure you felt overpowered it.
His fingers poked your entrance and you tightened your grip on his wrist letting, his fingers were thick, really thick.
“Ngh it hurts Billy,” you said removing his hand from your mouth, “They’re almost in honey but I can stop if you want?” You really didn’t want to stop so your nodded your head at him to keep going and he did. His fingers started to slip further and further in your tight sopping hole.
The pressure felt good, unlike anything you’ve felt before and you moaned when he pumped out then pushed back in.
“Youre doing so good,” he praised. He started to pick up his pace, everything was sloppy wet down there which made everything much more erotic. “Billy I can’t stay quiet, ah, it feels too good,” you moaned, he quickly put a hand over your mouth and pumped faster, your knees started to buck as the pleasure consumed you.
“Shes taking my fingers well, do you hear how wet you are hmm? Is this all because of me?” He groaned in your ear, he was right it was all because of him, but you couldn’t vocalize that at the moment, all you could do was moan into his hand blissed out from pleasure.
The noises of your pussy were embarrassing, the squelching, your muffled moans, the hot of Billy’s breath in your ear was too much everything was too much.
It was becoming hard to stand with your knees almost giving out and the overwhelming sensation of you needing to pee hit you making you run away from his fingers.
You snatched his hand off your mouth. “Billy, I feel like I-I need to pee,” you cried breathlessly, trying to wiggle away from him. Confusion swept over you as he started to go faster, his fingers pumping in and out of you relentlessly, and your moans grew louder and louder. “Let go, just let go, baby, it’s okay,” he groaned once again in your ear.
Your eyes started to roll back and you felt like jello.
You let out the most pornographic moan out of your mouth and your first orgasm couldn’t compare to this one. No, not at all, your mind went blank, and your ears started to ring and your body convulsed Billy hunched over preventing you from collapsing as you came undone.
“That’s it, baby. Oh, fuck. You’re gonna be the death of me,” he chuckled, feeling like he was about to explode in his jeans.
God, he was so done for. You were it for him. There was nobody else he wanted in the world but you. As you squirted all over his fingers, all over yourself, he realized this was something he’d never experienced before. Sure, he’d made women feel good; it was his expertise. But with you, there was more to it. You actually felt something for him other than just wanting a quick fuck. There were feelings involved. Longing.
You were no longer on this planet; you were somewhere else entirely. When you opened your eyes, you were brought back to reality, out of breath. But the chuckle that came out of Billy’s mouth snapped you out of it.
“You’re gonna be really, really late to 6th period now,” you furrowed your eyes in confusion until you felt the wetness dripping down your legs—the wetness that soaked your underwear and seeped into the denim of Billy’s jeans.
“Oh my gosh…” you paused, looking at how soaked everything was. “Oh my fucking gosh! Billy, how the fuck am I supposed to clean this up?!” Your panic was evident, and it only made Billy laugh even more.
“What even was that?! Did you put some shit on your fingers to make me pee or something?” you asked, your eyes bulging out of your head.
God, you are so it for him, he thought, feeling both overwhelmed and amused by the situation.
“Y/n, baby, does this look like pee to you? Does it smell like pee?” No, it most certainly did not, you thought, but if it wasn’t pee, then what was it? “You squirted, I made you squirt,” he said proudly, as if he couldn’t believe it himself.
“Squirt?” You questioned, geez you were in desperate need of girl time with Nance and Rob.
“Yes, my fingers hit a spot in you that caused you to do that, your g-spot,” he explained.
You still didn’t know what you were going to do and him? He couldn’t go to class like that.
“And some shit on my fingers? To make you squirt?” He scoffed. “Baby, my fingers are the shit,” he said smugly, still infuriating, still such an infuriating bastard.
You rolled your eyes and used your pants to wipe the floor of your juices. When you tried to grab Billy’s hand to wipe his, he snatched it away from you.
“Aht aht” Billy tsked bringing up his fingers to his mouth to lick the juices off of them, he closed his eyes and savored your taste sucking on each finger, your stomach did somersaults.
“Mmm so sweet,” he groaned. “Wanna taste?” He asked.
“S’nothing left on your fingers,” you squeaked. He then brought you closer to him, like he did earlier, looking deep into your eyes, and reached his hand down to gather what was left of your taste from you. You hissed, still feeling extremely sensitive.
He then brought his fingers to your mouth prompting you to suck on his fingers and you obliged happily.
Billy hissed as you sucked his digits. He looked as if he was in pain.
“S’wrong?” You asked innocently, doe eyes starting into his seductive blue ones. “You okay?”
“Im about to explode sweetheart,” he chuckled motioning down to his pants, you looked into his eyes before reaching a hand to feel him.
He hissed and you gasped.
“It’s really hard,” you whispered, testing the waters.
“S’your fault” he croaked.
You started to palm him through his jeans, it relieved some pressure, but not enough. You were still naked from the waist down surprisingly not uncomfortable.
Suddenly, a humming whistle was coming from outside the door. It didn’t sound close, but it was getting closer.
Your eyes went wide. It sounded like the janitor was approaching.
“Shit!” You exclaimed, rushing to put on your panties but Billy snatched them from you before you can out them on and stuffed them in the back of his pockets.
“For safekeeping” he shrugged, you rolled your eyes. He was completely unfazed by the situation. Your heart was leaping out your chest right now.
Your jeans were drenched. Completely soaked.
“We’re gonna have to make a run for it sweets,” Billy said matter of factly, “You don’t wanna show up to 6th period like that do you?” He said looking down at your pants.
You didn’t wanna run out of school, you didn’t wanna risk getting caught, and you didn’t want to miss 6th period but…
"Whew okay, okay," you took deep breaths, rolled up your sleeves, and prepared to run. Billy's hand was on the doorknob, ready to swing the door open so you could run out first.
"Ready... set... go!" With the count of three, the closet door was flung wide open. You burst out, running as if chased by the very hounds of hell, your heartbeat thundering in your ears. Billy trailed close behind, his own flight spurred by the same wild measure of adrenaline that fueled your own.
“Hey! HEY! You damn kids, stay out of my closet!” The janitor's voice echoed through the empty school corridors, his futile attempts to catch up with you adding a sense of comedy to the situation. His words hung in the air, but they were no match for the sound of your laughter. Billy was already caught in a fit of uncontrollable laughter, his shoulders shaking with each chuckle. You could not help but join him, your laughter ringing out as pure and infectious as his.
With the janitor still trailing behind, you made a mad dash for the exit. The school doors, usually a symbol of routine and order, were now your gateway to freedom. You pushed them open with a force that echoed your adrenaline-fueled excitement.
The sight of Billy's car waiting just outside was a beacon of safety. With the taste of rebellion still fresh and the sound of your laughter still lingering, you ran towards it, leaving the echoing protests of the janitor behind you.
"Come on, we have to hurry! Unlock the car!" You called out to Billy, your voice laced with impatience. Billy, quickly fumbled with the keys and with a swift motion, he unlocked the doors and you both hurriedly clambered into the safety of the vehicle.
Billy stepped on the pedal and sped out of the school parking lot the sound of his tires were heard by everyone. You seen out the corner of your eye that the basketball team ran towards the gates in a commotion to see what was going on. You seen Steve too with a look on his face that you couldn’t read.
“Whew that was a close one huh?!” Billy whooped with laughter. He was still pressing on the gas, going well over the speed limit. Left hand was gripping the wheel and his other was resting on your thigh which never failed to make your stomach flutter.
Your cheeks hurt from smiling and laughing a feeling you hadn’t felt in a very long time. It almost felt foreign, like a dream.
Who knew a singular person, a boy, could bring you so much joy, so much excitement? It almost felt silly and you wanted so badly to scold yourself for this because it felt like you were setting yourself up for failure. Relying on someone for happiness or depending on someone for happiness was a set up for heartbreak.
But in the end, even if heartbreak did happen, it would all be worth it. Even if things didn’t work out, even if he broke your heart or you broke his, it would still be worth it. Yet, you didn’t want that to happen. You didn’t want this to end, and you didn’t want to hurt each other.
“You okay?” Billy asked, squeezing your thigh in the process, snapping you out of your thoughts.
You brought your doe eyes, which Billy thought were so full of light, up to meet his blue ones.
“Don’t break my heart Billy Hargrove,” you said almost in a whisper. Billy chuckled and looked back towards the road.
Billy’s thoughts had been consumed with you more than anyone else in his life. Like you, he couldn’t stop thinking about you. The childlike excitement you brought out in him, his inability to contain his smile and laughter around you—it all made you unforgettable. You reminded him of everything he always thought was beautiful. You were imperfect like him but constantly striving for perfection, to make things right, to fix things, and he admired that. You were hope, the light at the end of a very dark tunnel. His life was the dark tunnel, and you were the light.
Even if he didn’t handle things well with his father or even with you that night, you being there on the hood of his car, looking up at the stars, changed everything for him.
At times, he even chuckles at the absurdity of it all, hearing Neil’s voice in his head labeling these newfound feelings for you as pathetic and warning of eventual heartache. It made Billy struggle, torn between his emotions and “the voice of reason” echoing in his mind.
“Don’t break mine.” He replied softly
After that, you two rode in silence, music blaring through his radio, while he lightly tapped his fingers on the now semi-dry thigh of your pants.
A few moments later you arrived at the front of your house. Dad still wasn’t home, no surprise there, and you really didn’t want Billy to go home.
You gathered your things, hand on the handle of the car and you turned around with a smile on your face like you had the brightest idea ever before exiting his car completely.
“You wanna come in?”
.
The house was quiet and lonely—the first two things that came to Billy’s mind. It reminded him of the houses he had lived in with his father.
But it was tidy, with nothing out of place, and it smelled just like you—clean and rosy. He picked up a picture frame. In the photo, there were three people: a lady who looked a lot like you, a man, and a little girl with pigtails and missing front teeth, smiling as if life were the greatest gift. The lady and the man looked less lively, even tired, and their smiles seemed forced.
“You live alone or something?” Billy called out as you disappeared into the hallway of your house.
He had never seen anyone besides you going in and out of this house. No other cars, just Steve’s from time to time, Eddie’s, and Nancy’s.
“Come over here!” you yelled from your room. You quickly changed into a pair of shorts and threw your pants into the dirty hamper. You also scrambled to tidy up any noticeable mess in your room.
You heard Billy’s boots hit the wooden floor, and each step made your belly jump with excitement. Sure, having boys over was nothing new, but having a boy you actually liked over was something special.
Seeing him at the door of your room was, I don’t know, it was a feeling your couldn’t really gather into words. It was weird almost surreal.
“This is the only part of my house that matters,” you said with a smile and open arms, presenting your room to him.
There were a variety of posters everywhere—movie posters, to be exact. The Goonies, The Breakfast Club, Scarface, The Godfather, and Gremlins adorned the the tan walls.
The duvet of your bed was white. Funny, he thought, a wry smile playing on his lips as he glanced at it.
There were a few teddy bears on your bed and a full size mirror in front of your bed.
“I like it,” Billy said, his eyes roaming around your room. He sauntered over to your dresser, opened one of the drawers, and pulled out a pair of pink panties with a smug grin. “I like these too,” he added, twirling them around his finger with a smirk.
You stormed toward him, yanked the delicate fabric from his grasp, and shoved it back into your drawer with a sharp motion. “You already have a pair, asshole. Leave the rest of my panties alone,” you snapped, your voice tinged with embarrassment as a deep blush spread across your cheeks.
“You know,” Billy began, stepping closer toward you, his voice softening, “I really want to know why you get all shy around me.”
Was it not obvious, or did he just want to hear the words from your lips? You liked him, everything about him. You even adored him, but saying it out loud felt too embarrassing. So, you rolled your eyes and pushed his hand away and plopped down on your bed.
“I don’t live alone, by the way,” you began, answering the question he had asked earlier.
Billy chuckled at how you avoided his question and settled down beside you.
“My dad lives here, barely,” you said playing with your fingers.
“Is he working or somethin?” Billy asked.
“Yeah, he travels a lot for work. He’s gone for weeks, sometimes even months,” you sighed. “I don’t really see much of him.”
That shattered him. Billy was surrounded by people yet felt alone, but you, you were both.
“What about your mom?” Billy asked.
He didn’t want to pry but he wanted to know more about you, he wanted to know everything in fact.
You took a deep breath before answering, simply because you wanted to suppress the emotions that always surfaced when you were asked that question.
Billy noticed your uneasiness and reached over to grab your hand. “You don’t have to answer if you don’t want to. I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to pry,” he said softly as he rubbed circles into the back of your hand.
“No, it’s okay. I need to get past the uneasiness I feel every time she comes up in conversation. Maybe one day it won’t hurt as much anymore,” you admitted, a hint of hope in your voice.
Billy gave you a soft smile, his hand still in yours comfortably.
“Um, she passed a year back,”
Your mother was one of Vecna’s victims. You can still hear the snapping of her bones and see the life being sucked out of her eyes before they went dull, her body limp and lifeless.
Before Vecna, your relationship with your mother was strained. She drank wine almost every day, and your father was home more often before you had to downsize houses. Which meant lots of bickering, glasses being broken, slamming doors, and your dad’s car taking off almost every night.
Your mother was aggressive and verbally abusive, constantly criticizing your weight, clothes, hair, and even your choice of clothing. Not a single positive word ever came out of her mouth towards you. She was like your own personal bully.
“God you’re just like him. Always on my case, just worry about your fucking self.”
“That’s how you’re dressing to school? Jesus.”
“Try hanging around Carol more, maybe you’d look a little like her.”
“Leave, leave like your father you ungrateful little bitch!”
“Sorry! I’m so sorry I’m just a shitty mother!”
“It’s a miracle Steve even hangs around you looking like that.”
There was more, much more, but you think your brain blocked out most of the things she said and did while you were growing up. You didn’t know whether to be grateful or sad that you didn’t have many memories from your childhood.
Around the time Vecna’s murders were happening, you noticed a few changes in your mom’s behavior. She started drinking even more, but she wasn’t aggressive like before. Instead, she became quiet and withdrawn, spending a lot of time in bed. Things got progressively worse as she began waking up screaming in fear, afraid to leave the house, and became increasingly emotional. You remember the time she woke you up out of your sleep, blubbering with apologies, 3 day old mascara was runny, face full of tears and snot.
“I’m sorry baby, I’m so, so sorry please forgive me.”
You eventually shared your mother’s symptoms with the gang, and they matched up with what Vecna’s victims were experiencing. You had a heartfelt conversation with your mother about it, both of you crying together. You promised her to keep your father out of it, and you both tried your best. I think what hurt the most was having hope amidst the despair.
Hope for a new relationship, a clean slate. You all tried.
The next day, your mother ran into the woods, and you chased after her. There, you found her floating in the air.
Snap, snap, snap, and thud.
You were a pool of tears at this point, struggling to get the words out. God, you couldn’t tell Billy this. You hated lying, but him knowing the truth would put him in so much danger.
“Um, I’m sorry…” you said with shaky breaths. “It was, uh, some illness. Doctors didn’t really know what it was,” you explained, your heart skipping a beat. It felt wrong to lie to him.
“It was the worst because she finally apologized to me and we were on the brink of a clean slate…” you said taking a deep breath again, “Um, she was a lot Neil, and she put me through hell. But, I was willing to let all that go just to fix things between us, I wanted to know what it was like to have her like that fully. She was the sweetest, funniest woman on her deathbed, it was something new and it left me with so much hope,” you said, the tears were running down your face like a waterfall now. “But hope is for suckers..” you laughed bitterly, “She died a few days later.” You finished, looking into Billy’s now sad blue eyes.
His heart broke over and over again. You didn’t deserve that, he didn’t deserve that. What’s up with the universe putting us in fucked in broken homes? He thought.
“Don’t say that,” Billy said sternly. “Hope isn’t for suckers. You give me hope every day.” He took a deep breath, embracing vulnerability. “You remind me a lot of myself… and now I understand why. Hanging around the wrong crowd, being a bitch. I’m still those things…” he confessed, locking eyes with you. “But every day, I strive to be more like you because you’re the perfect example of how people can change, no matter what. I want to change. I don’t want to be like Neil. I want to be better, do better.” He smiled warmly, reaching over to wipe the tears from your eyes.
“I’m really trying so hard not to sob right now and you’re not making it any better,” you said with a wobbly voice.
“S’okay honey, you can cry,” he giggled. He brought you into a hug and you nuzzled your face into his neck letting out quiet sobs. He brushed the back of your head. You two stayed like that for a while and he didn’t mind it one bit.
A few moments went by and you finally took your head out of his embrace.
“Do you maybe want to sleep over?” You asked, wiping the remaining tears off your face. “It’s fine if you don’t want to, I-I just really like you being here and I wouldn’t mind sharing the bed-” you rambled, but Billy cut you off before you went any further, “I’d love to.”
.
Billy left to grab a few things from his house and you took a quick shower.
When you were done, you rubbed on your favorite strawberry lotion, a gift from Nancy because it reminded her of you.
You quickly changed into a band tee and some shorts, then plopped down on your bed, staring at the ceiling questioning if today was real.
Billy looked to you for hope. You were Billy’s hope. It was such a strange feeling. You felt important and seen, something you had never felt before. And he was coming over tonight.
Oh. My. God.
Billy was coming over tonight, and he was going to be sleeping in your bed. You took deep breaths, trying not to freak out over the fact that there was going to be a boy sleeping in your bed tonight.
Three knocks at your front door snapped you back to reality and the anxiety started to creep back in again. You scrambled out of bed and made your way towards the door.
You opened it and there he was. He was still in the same clothes from earlier.
“You think I can use your shower?” He asked. “Max was having a Madonna concert in ours, and she wasn’t getting out anytime soon,” he huffed, rolling his eyes.
You laughed, picturing her screaming her lungs out like she did that one time in Steve’s car.
“Yeah it’s fine follow me,” you said, “Oh! And lock the door behind you please!”
You walked towards the bathroom, which was right across your room, and stepped inside to turn on the shower and adjust the water for him.
“Not too hot, not too cold right?” You questioned as you played with the knobs, you remembered how he liked the water when you were helping him during his recovery.
“Yes, ma’am,” he said, settling his duffel on top of the sink and kicking off his shoes. When you turned around, he was already shirtless and in his boxers. You tried to keep your eyes from roaming, but it was hard.
“My eyes are up here, doll,” He said smugly. You cleared your throat. “Um, water should be good. If it isn’t right, hot; left, cold,” you said, trying to regain your composure.
“I trust you, thank you. I won’t be long,” he said, leaning over to kiss your cheek.
“You’re welcome,” you smiled and left closing the door behind you.
Billy took a deep breath inhaling the air which smelled like you. He loved it.
He loved it so much it made his dick half hard. He stepped into the warm shower and thought about today.
He had never done anything like today, and he had never willingly slept over at a girl’s house before. He was used to sneaking out and sneaking in, leaving at the brink of dawn. But today he was going to sleep next to you, feel the heat of your body right next to him, smell you.
His dick was now fully hard.
“You need to behave,” he scolded himself, looking down at his hard-on.
He turned the shower knob to the left and prepared himself for the cold water that was about to hit him.
He hissed at that feeling but his dick was soft again. He decided to just leave it on for the remainder of the shower to keep it from happening again.
Once he was done, he dried off and grabbed his duffel to get his lotion. He rummaged through his things but couldn’t find it. He moved his belongings around, hoping it was at the bottom of the bag, but still found nothing.
“Shit,” he muttered, disappointed. He put his things away and noticed a pink bottle of lotion on your counter labeled, “Sweet, Sweet Strawberry.”
He rolled his eyes and grabbed the bottle, squirting a few pumps into his hand. He needed to moisturize; he had no other choice.
He smelled just like you, your body wash, your lotion.
He pushed his thoughts away and threw on his boxers and black sweats that hung low on his hips. Gathering his belongings, he made his way to your room, switching off the bathroom light as he exited.
Your nose was in a book, and he admired you from the doorway of your room. You wore glasses, your legs crossed, shorts hiking up the curve of your butt as you leaned back against the bed frame. He could get used to this be thought.
You felt eyes on you and glanced away from your book for a moment, seeing Billy at your doorframe. Your eyes met his. He was shirtless, sweats hanging from his hips, his happy trail on full display, and his curls damp.
You shut the book completely with wide eyes, silently praying, “Please don’t ask me what it’s about,” in your head. You were reading a very inappropriate passage of your book, which made it look like you were caught doing something you weren’t supposed to be doing, and you didn’t want him to know what you were reading.
“What you reading that’s got you so stuck?” He asked, his curiosity clear.
Shit.
“It’s uh, a-a romance,” you stuttered. It was hard to keep your composure around him, especially with him being shirtless, looking like walking sex leaning on your doorframe.
He left his duffel bag beside your dresser and closed the door behind him.
“You don’t mind if I close the door do you?” He asked before he joined you on the bed. “No it’s fine, I hate sleeping with the door open.” You replied.
He jumped into bed with you and got underneath the covers and you so did you. Your stomach was dancing with butterflies.
"So?" He asked, with raised eyebrows and a smirk, nodding towards the book in your hands.
Your eyes went wide. You can’t tell him what you were just reading. Geez absolutely not, it was filthy.
“It’s, um, about a girl and a boy,” you said, foolishly. Billy let out a loud laugh. “Obviously, dork, but what else?” You looked down at the book in your hands, searching for something more to say, but your mind went blank.
“Fine, if you’re not going to tell me, let me see where you left off so I can get an idea,” he said, attempting to grab the book from your hands. You immediately snatched the book from his grasp and hid it under the covers.
“No!” You yelped, feeling a surge of panic. Oh, now Billy absolutely had to know what was in this so-called romance.
He yanked the blanket off of you, and you held the book to your chest tightly. Billy was now hovering over you, your waist between his legs, attempting to pry the book from your grasp.
“Come on, let me see!” he said, eagerly reaching for the book.
He began to tickle your sides, and you erupted in laughter, but you weren’t budging. In a quick attempt to distract him, you threw the book to the wall by your dresser, hoping to catch him off guard.
He turned his head slightly, and you seized the opportunity to pull his neck down so he could face you. Now, you were both staring deeply into each other’s eyes. You looked down at his lips and leaned in slowly. But he couldn’t wait, so he pressed his lips into yours harshly.
So much for controlling himself tonight. He thought.
The kiss was fervent, like it always was. You let out the slightest moans that went straight to his dick. His arms were caging your head and he was pressing into you slowly.
You decided to experiment and brought your hand down to rub the outline of his dick through his sweats. It made everything so much hotter.
Billy moaned into your mouth as you your hands explored the outline of him. You pulled back from his lips and he groaned at the loss of contact.
“Billy c-can I see it?” You asked innocently, looking at his now dark blue eyes.
He nodded and leaned back on your bed stand. He lifted his butt from off the bed slightly and slid his boxers and sweats down at the same time.
You gasped at what you were now seeing. His thick member slapped his stomach and his tip that resembled a mushroom was an angry red.
Billy kept his eyes on you mesmerized with how star stuck you were over his cock.
You reached your over hand to grab at his length curiously and he groaned bucking his hips slightly at the contact.
It was warm and harder than it was earlier, feeling it bare was different from feeling it through his jeans.
You didn’t like the position you were in; sitting on your knees had become uncomfortable. So, you lay on his chest, keeping your hand on his length.
"Tell me what to do to you," you whispered, your hand weakly gripping the base of his cock.
Billy could see everything reflected in the full-length mirror in front of your bed.
Your cheek rested on his bare chest, your warmth almost making him burst. His cock captured your full attention as your fingers gently squeezed and released it, your eyes curiously examining the length of it. The scene was intimate, but he didn’t mind it at all.
“Spit on your hand,” he commanded, and you obliged. In any other situation, this would have been disgusting, but right now it was far from it.
“Now move it in an up and down like this,” Billy grabbed your hand and guided it to his throbbing member in an up and down motion.
Your hand was sliding up and down his cock now, slimy and hot with the slick of your saliva. “Yeah, fuck, yeah just like that baby,” He eventually moved his hand and let you take control, you found a steady motion but excited about the moans Billy was letting out you played around with it a little and went slow when you reached the tip of him.
He watched you through the mirror, mouth agape, with shock and pleasure.
“Ah, shit y/n,” he groaned, mouth hung open. He was so ready to spill but was holding out as long for as long as he could.
Your eyes drifted to the front of the mirror. The view was incredible. Billy Hargrove was a mess under your fingers, beneath your inexperienced hands. His mouth hung open, groans and moans spilling from his soft pink lips, beads of sweat forming on his forehead.
You both now locked eyes in the mirror. You began to pick up the pace, your movements becoming faster and less steady, as you tightened your grip on him.
Billy’s hand gripped your thigh harshly, the pain intensifying the ache in your core. Your mouth fell open just from watching him come undone. You focused your pace on the tip of his cock, “Shit, I’m coming, it’s gonna shoot out, It-“ before he could finish you quickly wrapped your mouth around the tip of him catching him completely by surprise.
He sat up and lifted his hips into your mouth shooting sticky hot ropes of cum into it as he gripped your hair a moaning and groaning mess.
The taste wasn’t good or bad, it was tolerable enough for you to swallow. You hallowed your cheeks a bit and wrapped your tongue around him savoring how he felt in your mouth and let go with a pop.
No words were exchanged as you pulled back; just Billy shoving his tongue into your mouth and you moaning at the roughness of it.
Your face was hot, your body was hot, and the heat of his and your mouths made everything even hotter.
“I feel like I’m going to explode,” you whispered against his lips, now understanding how he felt earlier.
Billy broke the lip lock you two were entranced in and pulled his sweats back up. As gently as he could, he dragged you to the edge of your bed by the back of your thighs.
“Do you trust me?” he asked, getting on his knees and locking his deep blue eyes with yours.
You did. In the short time you had known each other, you trusted him with your life. Silly, isn’t it? Vulnerability, intimacy.
“Yes,” you breathed, a little too desperately. He smiled and grabbed the waistband of your shorts, slowly pulling them down your legs. You lifted your butt slightly to help him get them off completely.
You were now completely bare from the waist down again, but this time he had a full view of your pretty cunt.
Billy licked his lips like a hungry animal about to devour its prey, his gaze intense and focused on your sopping wet cunt.
“So pretty,” he whispered, mesmerized by the sight before him.
“And she’s soaking wet honey, what was it?” He asked caressing her with his thumb causing you to gasp loudly.
“T-the mirror,” you stuttered, your eyes taking in the sight of Billy on his knees before you.
“Hmmm just the mirror?” He questioned like his words had a double meaning behind them.
It wasn’t just the mirror; it was him. Having him at your fingertips, your crush on him, how much you liked him—all of it intensified everything for you. This wasn’t purely sexual; this wasn’t just him helping you with your lack of experience. It was more. You had feelings for him.
He made you nervous, made your stomach dance with butterflies, and infuriated you in the best way possible.
You now knew what he was doing. He was trying to get you to admit there was something more, which is why he asked you why he made you so nervous earlier.
You kept quiet, your pride keeping you from admitting your liking towards him. He knew you did; he just wanted to hear the words from your mouth.
You kept quiet, your moans and gasps getting harder to contain as he kept gliding up and down your pussy. You were getting closer and closer to the edge.
He saw this too. You were now bucking your hips up to feel more, and he pulled back, teasingly withholding what you craved.
You groaned, annoyed at the loss of contact. He planted a kiss right on your clit, causing you to jolt up a little. The feeling was foreign and new, and you wanted more.
“Just tell me, baby, and I’ll keep going without stopping, I promise,” he said, looking back up into your eyes.
“It wasn’t just the mirror,” you gasped.
“No?” Billy asked in a teasing manner, focusing his attention back on your desperate cunt. He licked a stripe from your entrance to the top of your clit, stopping just short, causing you to whimper.
“Fuck! It was you, you! I have feelings for you. So many feelings that it makes it hard to even breathe sometimes!” You confessed, slightly frustrated at the on and off teasing.
“Wasn’t that hard was it?” He cheekily replied, now putting his entire mouth over your pussy eating you out like it was his dying wish. The warmth of his mouth was overwhelming, the way he moved his tongue to lap your clit was making your eyes roll back.
He was literally making out with the most sacred part of you.
Your grip tightened on your sheets and your toes curled in pleasure. “Oh-oh my gosh Billy please,” you moaned struggling to keep your composure.
He started to swirl his tongue right on your pearl and entered two fingers into your tight sopping hole, causing you to let out the most guttural moan. Your toes curled and drool started to creep outside the corners of your mouth.
The pressure started building up in your belly, feeling as if you were about to explode. He started to pump his fingers faster and faster, causing you to scream profanities in ecstasy.
“Ah! Fuck! Billy, I’m coming, I’m coming!” You screamed, and he kept his eyes on you the entire time, multitasking with his mouth still on you and his fingers pumping in a fast manner.
The feeling of release washed over you, and you finally let go, stopping fighting it.
You lifted a hand and gripped the mess of curls on his head, pushing him further into you, riding out your orgasm. You felt the vibrations of his groans on your pussy, making everything spin around you in a euphoric haze.
Your elbows gave out, and you were now flat on the bed, stuck in a haze. Everything was blurry, and you felt limp, completely spent from the intensity of the experience.
“Y/n? Y/n?” He sing-songed, tapping the inside of your thigh. “Hmm?” you asked, completely out of it, lost in the aftermath of pleasure.
“You okay?” He giggled, his head now resting on your thigh looking up at you in admiration.
“Mhmmm,” you responded weakly, with a hazy smile.
“You got anything I can clean this up with?” He asked, removing his head from your thigh. You lifted yourself up slightly, and your eyes widened at the mess you made.
His face was dripping with slick, his chest wet with the juices that squirted out of you, and the duvet underneath you was soaked.
“Again?” You groaned, rolling your eyes and facepalming. “There’s towels in my closet,” you said, plopping back on your bed and weakly pointing to the closet to the left of you.
He grabbed the towels and wiped his face and chest first, he then walked over to you and wiped below your thighs, then the inside of your legs and thighs carefully.
He slipped your panties back up and tapped your butt twice, signaling for you to lift yourself up so he could slide them all the way up and you obliged.
“I need to take the duvet off, we could sleep with the blanket that’s under it,” he said tapping your thigh again, “Come on get up,” he commanded.
“UGH! I can’t move. I feel like jello,” you complained, not wanting to move, causing Billy to laugh. “Too bad move,” he said.
You rolled over, groaning dramatically, and slipped under the blanket beneath your duvet, which Billy had just snatched off and tossed into your dirty hamper.
Billy joined you on the bed, the mattress sinking slightly as he settled in. You were facing away from him, unintentionally, simply exhausted but content and happy.
“Come here,” he said gruffly. You turned around and cuddled up next to him, finding comfort in his embrace.
You smelled something familiar radiating off of him.
“Are you wearing my strawberry lotion?” you asked, a playful smile tugging at the corners of your lips.
“I forgot mine at home,” he gruffed grumpily, rolling his eyes.
You laughed and kissed his chest, closing your eyes, ready to sleep in his comforting embrace.
He caressed the crown of your head with his hand and kissed the top of your forehead.
“I like you too,” he whispered, his voice soft and sincere. “You’re the first thing on my mind when I wake up and when I go to sleep.”
You both drifted off into a deep sleep feeling safer than you’ve ever felt in each others embarace.
Taglist: @jennapancake @writethrough @callsignwidow @strlightfilms @empathyroad @moneyy-21 @fossface @t3n1 @kpoppunk18-blog
Tags:













