AMBER WEST — An olive ruched square-neck top, cream tailored shorts, gold strappy heels, a sage green mini Lady Dior, Van Cleef-adjacent jewelry, and sunglasses perched on her head like she just stepped off a yacht and couldn't be bothered to put them away. Amber, this is polished. This is put-together. This is the kind of look that photographs beautifully and offends absolutely no one. And that, darling, is precisely the problem. There is not a single risk in this entire ensemble. The Dior bag is doing the most interesting thing here and it's a bag. You are clearly capable of more. Rating: 6.5/10 @amberwest

AURORA ASTOR — A bubblegum pink coordinated set — cropped blazer fastened with a single jeweled bow closure, matching micro mini skirt with a front slit, and crystal-embellished strappy heels. Aurora. The bow closure is either the most charming thing I've seen all evening or a cry for help, and I genuinely cannot decide which. The monochromatic pink is committed and confident, and those heels are the right amount of extra. What holds this back is the execution — the blazer sits slightly stiff and the overall look reads just a touch too pageant-ready for a party like this. The bones are there. The risk is there. The landing was slightly wobbly. Rating: 7/10 @auroraastor

DEAN DI LAURENTIS — Head to toe black. Collarless double-breasted jacket, black trousers, black shoes, thin chain at the neck. Dean showed up to this party dressed like he's been asked to identify a body and decided to look good doing it. And you know what? It works. The collarless jacket is a strong choice — it gives the all-black something to say beyond "I ran out of ideas." The chain is minimal and correct. This is clean, intentional, and quietly confident. Off Campus men, take note. Rating: 7.5/10 @deanxdilaurentis

SERENA VAN DER WOODSEN — A rose gold scalloped sequin halter mini dress with intricate fan-shaped embellishment from neckline to hem, crystal drop earrings, and barely-there strappy heels. Serena. Of course. She arrived looking like something that was hand-delivered from another dimension specifically to make everyone else feel underdressed. The scalloping on that dress is extraordinary — it catches the light like it was engineered to do exactly that — and the halter neckline gives it a sleekness that keeps it from tipping into costume. Serena Van der Woodsen does not try. She simply arrives. Rating: 9.5/10 @serenavxoxo

JASPER NOVAK — A colour-blocked denim jacket in white, tan, and black panels, black slim trousers, and grey canvas sneakers. Jasper, I appreciate the jacket. It has a point of view. The colour-blocking is bold enough to be interesting and the construction is clearly intentional. But the black trousers are too casual and the sneakers undercut everything the jacket was trying to say. This look needed either a sharper trouser or a better shoe — it had all the ingredients for something memorable and stopped just short of committing. Rating: 6/10 @jasperxnovakx

ELIJAH HAMILTON — A deep espresso brown open-collar shirt tucked into matching wide-leg pleated trousers, photographed in a marble-and-wood hallway like he's already the most interesting person in the building. Elijah. This is a masterclass in tonal dressing. The monochromatic brown could so easily read flat, but the relaxed silhouette of those trousers and the deliberate ease of that open collar elevate it into something genuinely considered. The setting helps — he clearly knew exactly where he was standing when this was taken. Intentional from head to toe. Rating: 8.5/10 @elijahxhamilton

MAX WOLFE — A sage green zip-up harrington-style jacket over a black open-knit mesh top, matching sage wide-leg trousers, and chunky black boots, photographed mid-stride on a Manhattan street like he simply does not have time for any of us. Max, the mesh top under the jacket is either very brave or very much a choice, and I'm landing on brave. The tonal sage co-ord is sharp, the boots ground the whole thing, and the energy of this photo — purposeful, unbothered, slightly chaotic — is doing as much work as the outfit itself. The reboot brought something interesting. Rating: 8/10 @maximusxwolfe

JOHN LOGAN — A light grey plaid suit with subtle texture variation, a dark brown crewneck underneath, sleeves casually rolled, a delicate pendant necklace, and a watch. John. This is the quiet confidence of someone who understands that the details do the talking. The plaid suit has enough character to carry the look, and pairing it with a dark tee rather than a dress shirt was the right call — it keeps it from feeling like a job interview. The rolled sleeves and chain say "I dress like this on purpose and I always have." Off Campus, consider yourself redeemed from last month. Rating: 8/10 @thejohnlogan

AZRIEL — A black crewneck sweater, grey wide-leg trousers, white athletic socks, black loafers, and a silver chain. Photographed on a stool like he's posing for a magazine that doesn't exist yet but absolutely should. Azriel flew in from the Night Court and dressed like he's been lurking in the shadows of a very stylish Soho apartment. The socks-with-loafers combination is a deliberate choice and it lands — there's something almost deliberately anti-fashion about it that becomes, paradoxically, very fashion. The grey trouser is perfect. The chain is exactly the right weight. Quietly devastating. Rating: 8/10 @azrielxoxo

IMOGEN CARDULO — A black off-shoulder sheer mesh long-sleeve top, light wash wide-leg denim jeans, pink hair, and a city skyline backdrop at night with a cigarette in hand. Imogen arrived from Fourth Wing looking like she landed in New York and immediately adopted a personality. The mesh top is doing everything right — the off-shoulder gives it intention and the sheer texture adds dimension to what is otherwise a very pared-back look. The pink hair against the city lights is the real statement. She looks like trouble, and in this context, that is a compliment. Rating: 7.5/10 @imogencarduloxoxo

RYKER MADDOX — A striped cream and sage knit cardigan over a white thermal tank, loose grey-brown linen trousers, and photographed holding a piece of fruit in what appears to be a greenhouse. Ryker. I have questions. Not about the cardigan — the cardigan is actually lovely, relaxed and textured in exactly the right way. Not even about the trousers, which have a pleasing slouch to them. My questions are about the fruit. And the greenhouse. And what exactly you thought this event was. This is a Sunday morning look worn to what is emphatically not a Sunday morning occasion. Charming, but confused. Rating: 5.5/10 @rykermaddoxxo

KAI JORDAN — A white graphic muscle tank reading "YOUR FAVORITE BOY BAND," black leather trousers, a silver chain, and what appears to be a bathroom hallway as the backdrop. Kai. I will give you this: the leather trousers are doing significant work. They are the only thing standing between this look and a full disaster. The tank is either an incredibly self-aware joke or a complete lack of self-awareness, and the location of this photo suggests the latter. You have the leather trousers. Next time, build up from there. Rating: 4/10 @kaijordansxo

SAGE EDWARDS — A powder blue strapless floral midi dress with a full skirt, a delicate gold necklace, holding a glass of champagne in what looks like a garden at dusk. Sage, this is genuinely lovely. The blue is soft and the floral print is charming without being saccharine, and the strapless bodice keeps it from feeling too precious. It is, however, decidedly garden party rather than post-Met gala aftermath, and the champagne glass suggests she either knows this and doesn't care, or hasn't quite grasped the assignment. Either way, she looks beautiful, and sometimes that's enough. Rating: 7/10 @sageedwardsxo

RHIANNON MATTHIAS — A dark chocolate brown crochet halter top with cut-out detailing, matching wide-leg crochet trousers, photographed poolside with lush tropical greenery behind her. Rhiannon arrived from the battlefield and dressed like she's been somewhere significantly better. This is a strong, cohesive look — the matching crochet set is tactile and interesting, the cut-outs on the top are well-placed rather than gratuitous, and the setting she chose is doing the outfit every favor. She looks like someone who has very good instincts and even better taste. Fourth Wing is having a moment. Rating: 8.5/10 @hirhiannonmatthias

NATASHA HARRINGTON — A black strapless structured corset top, light wash denim cutoff shorts, black patent over-the-knee boots, and a black puffer jacket sliding off one shoulder. Natasha showed up to this event like she came directly from somewhere else and didn't have time to fully commit to either location. The corset and the OTK boots are doing their absolute best — they're confident and they're sharp — but the denim cutoffs introduce a casualness that the rest of the outfit doesn't know what to do with. The puffer jacket is an accessory at this point, not a garment. Interesting, unresolved, but not without potential. Rating: 6.5/10 @hinatashaharrington

ADRIANNA BARNES — A sheer nude long-sleeve crop top with delicate square neckline, a voluminous champagne satin midi skirt, nude pointed heels, and a blush pink shoulder bag. Adrianna floated into this party looking like the human embodiment of a sigh — and I mean that in the best possible way. The contrast between the barely-there top and the dramatic, full skirt is exactly the kind of tension a good outfit needs. The champagne satin catches the light beautifully and the nude tones head-to-toe create a seamless, elongated silhouette. This is quietly spectacular. Rating: 9/10 @hiadriannabarnes

SARAH ROUTLEDGE — An ivory ribbed zip-front structured corset top with an asymmetric hem, black wide-leg leather trousers, and a mini crystal-embellished clutch. Sarah from the Outer Banks walked in and dressed like she's been quietly watching everyone else and decided to do them all one better. The corset-to-leather trouser pairing is a strong combination — the ivory against the black is graphic and clean, and the asymmetric hem on the corset adds just enough edge to keep it from being too polished. The clutch is a perfect finish. This is a statement made with precision. Rating: 8.5/10 @hisarahroutledge

NESTA ARCHERON — A black off-shoulder cropped cami top with long black knit gloves, a high-slit black patent vinyl maxi skirt, and strappy black heels, holding a geometric clutch. Nesta came from Prythian, walked into this party, and looked at everyone like they were already beneath her — and the outfit is entirely consistent with that energy. The patent vinyl skirt is aggressive in the best possible way, the gloves add a theatricality that most people couldn't pull off, and the overall effect is someone who dressed specifically to be the most intimidating person in the room. She succeeded. Rating: 9/10 @nestaarcheronxoxo

VIOLET SORRENGAIL — A white lace-up knit corset top with delicate tie detailing, ivory wide-leg linen trousers with a braided rope belt detail, photographed outdoors in warm light. Violet. This is airy, considered, and genuinely beautiful. The lace-up corset top in that ivory knit is the kind of piece that looks effortless but absolutely isn't, and the matching linen trousers with the rope belt detail bring in just enough texture to keep it interesting. The overall effect is someone who dressed with intention and didn't need anyone's approval to do it. Understated excellence from Basgiath's finest. Rating: 8.5/10 @violetsorrengailxoxo

EMMELINE MADDOX — A periwinkle blue semi-sheer ribbed button-down blouse, black Valentino logo mini shorts with gold V-hardware, dark burgundy ankle-strap block heels, and her auburn hair pulled back in a sleek high ponytail with a black ribbon. Unlike her brother Ryker — who arrived with a piece of fruit and no explanation — Emmeline came to play. The blue and black combination is sharp, the Valentino shorts are doing precisely the right amount of showing off, and those burgundy heels are the kind of unexpected color choice that separates the good outfits from the great ones. Ryker, take notes. Rating: 8.5/10 @emmelinemaddoxxoxo

EVERLEIGH SMITH — A full-length shimmering silver-white textured gown with a deep plunge neckline, long sleeves, and a dramatic black satin bow at the waist, paired with a black satin clutch, bold red hair, and a diamond necklace. Everleigh arrived last and dressed like she knew exactly what she was doing. The textured fabric catches every available light source and turns it into something extraordinary, and that black bow — which should by all rights be too much — is somehow the precisely correct amount of too much. The red hair against the silver is a color pairing that demanded confidence to execute and got it. This is how you close a post. Rating: 9.5/10 @everleighsmithxoxo

The math has been done, darlings. Some of you proved that getting dressed is an art form. Some of you proved that it is, in fact, possible to be wrong about an outfit. Either way — I saw everything.