Why CGD Always Wins: Visibility Wins Subsidies, Industrial Consumption Does Not
When government relief is handed out in India’s gas sector, city gas distributors (CGDs) are always first in line. The latest round of concessions again shows how this segment — positioned at the crossroads of clean-air politics and corporate lobbying — secures benefits that power plants and fertiliser companies can only observe from the sidelines.
1. The disguised subsidy chain
The APM gas pool — once designed to favour all priority sectors — has slowly narrowed. APM allocations for CGDs have dropped from 70% last year to 57% in Q2 FY26, yet the gap is filled by New Well Gas, a slightly costlier but still domestically priced substitute.
This ensures CNG and home-PNG remain insulated from LNG volatility, while power and fertiliser users continue relying on pooled imports and subsidies that only neutralise cost, not margins.
2. A tax cut that works better for some
The new tax shift — replacing 15% interstate VAT with 2% CST — appears universal. But the biggest gainers are again CGD companies, who move large volumes across states.
Fertiliser and captive power units often receive intra-state gas under fixed contracts. Their benefit is minimal. For CGDs, however, the 13-percentage-point reduction directly boosts EBITDA or enables CNG/PNG-D price cuts that capture more consumers.
3. PNGRB’s Zone-1 miracle
India’s map effectively becomes a single-zone tariff regime — but only for CNG and domestic PNG. Every urban consumer pays the lowest-distance pipeline tariff, irrespective of location.
Industrial and power consumers still pay zone-based tariffs. This is a regulatory privilege built for visibility: politically popular, economically selective.
4. The lobbying advantage
CGDs include Adani Total Gas, GAIL, IOAGPL, MGL and IGL — companies with public-sector access, private capital, and ESG appeal.
For a government seeking urban approval and clean-air headlines, the CGD lobby offers the perfect exchange: gas for cities, optics for policymakers.
By contrast, industrial gas consumption is invisible — there are no ribbon-cuttings for captive boilers or ammonia reformers.
5. The politics of perception
Gas used in fertiliser plants feeds subsidy burdens; gas used in a city bus or domestic burner signals progress. That difference shapes modern gas policy.
APM reforms, tax restructuring, and Zone-1 pricing—though framed as efficiency measures—collectively shield the retail gas ecosystem rather than the industrial backbone that drives gas demand.
Bottom line
CGD firms don’t just bargain better. They sit at the intersection of policy visibility and political capital.
As long as clean-air metrics dominate policymaking, the most visible users — urban households and vehicles — will keep receiving the least visible subsidies. Everything else in the gas economy will simply… pay the distance. For more https://energylineindia.com/
