I have been waiting for SO LONG to tell someone this idea: What if Sally was the one to end up raising Fundy instead of Wilbur?
So Wilbur leaves the SMP because he and Sally get into a big fight and the next morning he’s just gone. Turns out that very same night he disappeared a certain god *Cough* XD *Cough* turned him into a sheep (unknowingly, he was just releasing some energy), and had basically got run out of the SMP by the others who kept trying to kill him for food.
Anyway, Sally is deeply heartbroken and decides, dammit, if Wilbur isn’t going to be a good dad, then she’ll be the best mom to her little Fundy as humanely possible.
No drug empire. Sally decides to make L'manburg to be a place free of the constant conflict of the SMP, and a safe place for her little Fundy to call home. Her talks of freedom gather Tommy and Tubbo to her side, and peace interested Eret. She is a peaceful general and hates the fighting with a passion, something her and Tommy clash heads on constantly. Once when Tommy was being especially agressive and rude, she threatened to kick him from L'manburg right there, for the safety of her people and her child. Luckily he stayed and gave up his discs, telling Sally what he learned from her: “The only way to end a war is through peaceful sacrifice.”
Fundy grows up and since Sally never kept anything from him, he comes to believe that maybe his father was right for leaving since Sally can be overly controlling with him - she doesn’t let him leave L'manburg walls without someone with him. (She’s just terrified of losing him like she lost Wilbur.) He even comes across his original beanie, which he begins to wear instead of his usual hat, to feel closer to him and believing that one day, someday, he’ll come home again.
Eventually after Sally dies in the war to take everything back, she as a ghost finds Wilbur in sheep form - blue wooled sheep - and calls him Friend. When Phil tries to bring Sally back for Fundy - upset at his son’s actions and believing he deserves to have one parent - this ends up lifting the curse on Wilbur as he transforms back into his old self, the only remnant being horns from the event - and finally he ‘wakes up’ to see his infant son grown, his wife dead, and his father looking at him with tears in his eyes, unbelieving. (Wilbur finally came home after 18 years of getting the milk)
Just… awkward times as Fundy and Wilbur get to know each other really for the first time, Wilbur upset that he missed so much important stuff, babying him sometimes to make up for time lost, which only serves to annoy Fundy to no end. Phil and Wilbur bonding and Phil giving him advice and stuffs. Wilbur angst times with Ghost Sally who doesn’t like to go near him, since he makes her feel bad and upset.
Also, maybe at one point he turns back into the blue sheep and everyone freaks out (Dream stealing him for his collection of attachments to the server?)
Thoughts?
