The Curious Case of the 4th District
Do you ever get the urge to reread an old favorite? Do you ever get partway through and remember things that had stuck out to you as odd all those years ago? Ever fall down a rabbit hole of research, writing, and theorizing that leaves you looking like Charlie Day at conspiracy-theory-o'clock?
Well, let me tell you, it's a blast, and you should try it some time!
Let's talk about 07-Ghost, and how the geopolitical background of the Barsburg Empire is actually really interesting and strange.
Some spoilers ahead for most of the back half of 07-Ghost, so if you haven't read this 20 year old manga (ohgodohgodohgodwhat), now's your chance to go read it I guess?
Allow me to set the stage:
You are Fea Kreuz. You are the current vessel of the Ghost Vertrag. Your brother is the reigning monarch of the Raggs Kingdom. You have an adorable nephew, Tiashe, whom you love quite a lot.
Your lovely nephew has, in just the last week, been kidnapped, branded, and had Pandora's Box, the physical remains of a wholly malevolent god of death, implanted into his body by the Queen and the Pope. The Kingdom's southern neighbor, the Barsburg Empire, has been manipulated into believing that Raggs has stolen said cursed artifact bearing said death god's physical remains, and is using that as an excuse to wage a sudden, intense war against your home using a supernatural weapon of mass destruction.
As a last-ditch effort to save your nephew's soul and stop the conflict before the kingdom is obliterated, you plan to take Tiashe on the pilgrimage to Seele, using the opportunity to reveal the truth about Pandora's Box to each of the Houses of God along the way. You leave as soon as you can, no more than two days after the start of the conflict, heading toward the landmass' western port with the goal of making it into the Barsburg Empire's 3rd District.
What is your plan? Do you head into allied territory, the soon-to-be 4th District? Or do you leave the kingdom entirely for an allegedly neutral third party, the Principality of Raldo?
All we know is that Fea Kreuz planned to do the latter.
(Please forgive any differences in translation, the images are cropped from some ancient fan translations, while most of my references are from the official English publications.)
It's probably fair to say that there's far more we don't know about the wider world of 07-Ghost than we do, but that's part of what makes it fun to speculate about. Case and point, why on earth would Fea Kreuz have decided to abandon friendly ground during an active conflict? Sure, the answer could be that he decided the 4th's ports might be under siege by the time they needed to travel, or that at least he couldn't find passage into hostile territory. I probably would have assumed that, if it hadn't been for something that had been mentioned 20 chapters earlier, something that sparked a lot more theorizing about the 4th and why Fea Kreuz wanted to avoid it than is probably healthy. Bear with me!
Allow me to present Kapitel 31 (courtesy inmeliora).
In order to save themselves from extinction, the God Houses that fought with Raggs would present the Barsburg Empire the heads of the current master of the family.
Cool. So what does this have to do with the 4th District?
When Teito and Ouka begin uncovering the secrets of the 4th District's God House, we learn a lot of Labrador-née-Ilyusha Krat's backstory. For example, we learn that the Krat House is currently under the leadership of Ilyusha's paternal uncle, following the death of Ilyusha's father. We learn a great deal about the character of Ilyusha's uncle, too - namely, his willingness to manipulate and sacrifice others, including his own nephew, for personal and political gain. (Keep that one in mind, if you would!) (Also can I just say I really feel like the whole 'mansplain, manipulate, manwhore' adage fits Ilyusha's uncle. I shan't elaborate c:)
We also learn something crucial to my crackpot little theory: that Ilyusha passed in a way that was similar to his father. For argument's sake, I will mention that this may be a translation oddity, as I've seen this particular detail written two ways: "Poor young master. He died so soon after, as if following his father," or "Ilyusha-sama also followed the same fate as his father..." from Kapitel 54, Joker. If Ilyusha died soon after his father, then it's possible his father was decapitated like Xinglu Hausen, and this theory is bust (boo!). However, if Ilyusha died like his father, then what does that imply? Ilyusha was not decapitated; he sacrificed himself. If you'll allow me my indulgences, the majority of the translations I've read follow the interpretation of Ilyusha dying in a similar manner to his father, and the implications of that make it the more compelling read in my eyes, because...
If the 4th District was part of Raggs, and if the Krat House supported the Kingdom in the war, and the God Houses that participated opted to decapitate the heads of their houses to appease the Empire, then who of the Krat family was decapitated?
...was a member of the Krat family decapitated?
Did the 4th District support Raggs once war erupted?
Eh? Ehh???
Here we go: when tensions spiked between Raggs and Barsburg over Fea Kreuz allegedly stealing Pandora's Box, each House of God was faced with a decision - support their nation, take a neutral stance, or switch sides. We know that the Hausen family upheld their alliance with Raggs, but we hear no such confirmation regarding the Krats.
My theory is as such - Ilyusha's uncle was the acting head of the Krat House when the war broke out, and he faced with the decision of whether or not to support the Raggs Kingdom. Now, his position as the head of the house may or may not be the most stable at this time - his brother, the previous head, was widely adored, and his nephew presented a major obstacle to cementing himself as the legitimate master of the Krat House, whether Ilyusha realized it or not. Per Kapitel 54, Ilyusha even seemed to have the favor of at least the household staff, based on their comments about the two of them as the greenhouse burns. So, Ilyusha's uncle is looking for a way to legitimize his claim on his position, and along comes a little war to rock the world.
Well, one great way to give yourself legitimacy is always to ingratiate yourself to the leadership.
I imagine that, within a day or so of the war starting, Ilyusha's uncle curried favor with the Empire by flipping sides. When Fea Kreuz and Tiashe were beginning to seek passage south, they didn't face the prospect of crossing the 4th as friendly territory, but as part of an enemy nation explicitly hunting for them. They had to divert to Raldo, as the 4th was an actively hostile war zone.
There is one more bit of 'proof' I'm going to share, but it happens to rely on a timeline that's only loosely given. It could prop up my crackpot little theory, or it could just be a sign that Ilyusha getting way too down-to-earth happened a good stretch after the Raggs War had actually concluded. Who's to say? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
(Yeah, I've got another theory/analysis about the timeline of the Raggs War, based on what information we've got - I can talk about that another time if anyone really cares c:)
Perhaps one of the first things that tipped me over to this whole theory is what we see in the immediate aftermath of Ilyusha allowing the Flower of Eden to bloom.
Imagine it: there I was, late 2009, waiting eagerly for the next fan translation for my favorite manga to drop, for an arc about my favorite character, and I get a heartbreak bomb dropped right on my head, because boom, Labrador turned himself into a damn plant to try to save his sister. Bless my little 15 year old heart. So many tears. Baby sanjikuu was a mess, I tell you. I finished reading the chapter and started it again, and again, and again. And on one of those many rereads, I noticed something a bit odd.
The military force that responds to the threat of what is essentially an uncontained bio-weapon smack-dab in the middle of the 4th is the Barsburg Empire's Imperial Guard. Not an internal group, not anyone from the defunct Raggs, but some of the Barsburg Empire's best. No one in the crowd even seems that surprised that the Imperial Guards are the ones who responded to the whole carnivorous plant-child thing going on back there.
Depending on when exactly Ilyusha decides to take his love of plants to the next level, it seems likely the Krat family had already been pledged to the Barsburg Empire, not Raggs, and I can't imagine people being okay with that overnight.
And that's it, really.
Based on the context clues left for us in the manga, there's a chance that something really, really wonky happening in the 4th as the Raggs War is kicking off. Of course, it's always possible that all these points are coincidental and meaningless in this context, or that the timeline floating around in my noggin doesn't align well with the series, but isn't it fun to imagine some grand coup happening in the shadows while the plot is happening?
That's always been a large part of why I enjoy 07-Ghost so much: there's a level of detail to the worldbuilding that allows for both satisfying background and imaginative speculation.
Anyway, thanks for reading? This was, like, entirely for my entertainment, and for all three of you who maybe check up on the 07-Ghost tag once a year. Feel free to tear this whole thing down in a scathing rebuttal, or just start throwing your own tinfoil hat 07-Ghost ideas at me, I don't know, go wild! I'm just nostalgic for one of the defining works of my youth, and I want to see more of it out there. I've got some fanfiction brewing, but that's always an ordeal for me, and sometime just talking stuff out on tumblr is more accessible. I have a few other weird theories floating around upstairs, like I said, so if anyone's interested, just give a shout, I don't have anything else going on right now!
Cheers!









