Aw, how cute 💕 they can write songs together :D

Sally Mckenna x reader who's a songwriter

Warnings: mentions of murder, mention of sex, swearing, think that's it

Writing is one of only Sally's passions other than killing people so she would love having someone she could share her ideas with

She'd often ask you for your thoughts on her latest songs or give you her thoughts on yours if you asked her to

Collaborations are a must. Sometimes she'd write a portion of a song and leave out a verse or two specifically so she could have you finish it

She likes writing songs about you mostly. That, and the pain she felt when she was still alive; but she also writes about the joy she felt when she found you

Sally doesn't share her songs with anyone, and I mean anyone, but she trusts you not to judge her work. You're one of the few people she lets see such a personal side of her

Sex while writing is very much possible. If you're going over songs together and one of them has a suggestive lyric, no matter how sexual or erotic it may or may not be you guys definitely end up fucking because of it

If she ever hears someone talking bad about one of your songs she'll murder them, just like that. She knows how important her music is to her, and if you feel only a fraction of that towards your music then she will do whatever it takes to make sure no one ever ends up hurting you by insulting something you love

~

Main masterlist || American Horror Story masterlist

39. Who initiated the relationship? Who kissed who first? When did they realize they were in love? 

Sally initiated the relationship, picking Cordelia out of a crowd immediately and hooking her dependency to her. 

There was something about Cordelia that Sally just couldn’t comprehend. Something so pure and bright and golden. 

And while she had wanted to kiss Cordelia almost from the moment she set eyes on her, she was afraid. 

She knew Cordelia was different, and she knew if she somehow screwed it up and lost her, she would never forgive herself. 

For Cordelia, it was a bit different. 

She didn’t really realize that Sally had initiated any kind of anything until two weeks in when she couldn’t stop thinking about her. 

She often dreamt about her, whispers in the night drawing her to a restless sleep. Something about her universe felt off when Sally wasn’t by her side, and Cordelia found herself going back to that hotel over and over again. 

Cordelia kissed Sally first. 

They had been at the bar, where they usually met, drinking just a bit too much and getting just a bit too handsy.

It was mostly Cordelia.

Cordelia couldn’t stop staring at the way Sally licked over her blood red lipstick when her tears fell, or the way her brow pushed up whenever Cordelia talked, like she needed to listen to her more than she needed to breathe. 

And before she knew what was happening Sally was practically in her lap, both of them laughing and biting their lips and looking at each other from lidded eyes.

But there were people there, everywhere. And so Cordelia — yes, Cordelia — had asked if they could go somewhere a bit quieter. 

Sally’s hand clamped down around hers as she dragged her back to her room. Almost too eager. Almost too fast. 

But they only made it halfway, Cordelia giggling and stumbling after her. Because no sooner had Cordelia’s hands skimmed over Sally’s hips and tugged at her dress, than Sally had her pinned against the wall, panting over her as Cordelia squirmed.

It only took Sally’s eyes flicking to Cordelia’s lips, teeth scraping over lipstick, and then Cordelia couldn’t help herself. 

That first kiss was rough. 

These are two very dominant women, as soft as they both are, and they were both drunk. So it was a lot of fighting with their mouths — sloppy, messy, biting kisses. 

But when they got interrupted by March and Cordelia brought her hand up to her mouth to find that the sting there was blood on her lip, she didn’t really mind. 

Maybe she wanted Sally dominating her and shoving herself at her and forcing Cordelia into submission until she couldn’t breathe. 

Maybe she wanted to hold Sally down and unravel her and show her who was boss. 

Even drunk, Cordelia didn’t miss the way Sally’s entire demeanor changed at March’s presence, the confident woman suddenly so submissive as she backed herself between him and Cordelia, fiery eyes downcast. 

So when March started picking on her and bossing her and raising his voice, Cordelia’s hands immediately found Sally’s waist. 

Sally grounded herself in the comfort there, reminding herself what she had, and what she refused to lose, and found strength in Cordelia’s presence, grabbing at her wrist and yanking her past March, down the hall, and into the safety of her room. 

And when Sally shut the door, tears falling against her will as her heart pounded, Cordelia was right there, pressing the softest kisses to her cheeks. Suddenly sober. Suddenly entirely too gentle as she walked Sally back to the bed and straddled her and kissed her like there was no tomorrow. 

Sally fell in love almost immediately, after Cordelia came back for the third time and something lit within her at the mere sight of her. 

She hadn’t let herself feel it the second time Cordelia came back. 

Just in case it was just a coincidence. Just in case she wasn’t there to see Sally. 

But that third time, that third time... 

It felt different than the hollow hope and want and desperation that normally clawed at her. 

When she was around Cordelia, she felt light. She felt like she was good, like she had a purpose and was meant to exist. 

But she didn’t realize she was in love with her until maybe a month in, when they were having sex and she was grinding out all of her pleasure on Cordelia’s lap, and Cordelia was forcing her to go slow, to be soft about it, peppering feathery kisses across her face and chest and murmuring soft utterances of “good girl” and “my girl” and “beautiful”. 

The words had almost come out of Sally’s mouth as she orgasmed, and she had to dig her teeth into her bottom lip to hold them in, because the feeling hit her like a train, and the last thing she wanted was to ruin what she had and lose the one person that she finally, finally, realized actually meant something to her. 

It grew on Cordelia like a vine, harmless and flowering until it was choking her and squeezing her and she realized that she couldn’t live without Sally. That they were bound together forever. 

The thought crossed her mind for the first time one night when Sally had fallen asleep, tears dried and lipstick smeared off, the covers on the bed barely covering her waist and leaving her thin, freckled, pale arms completely exposed. 

Cordelia had kissed her then, just at the top of her shoulder, and realized that she didn’t want to be in a bed without Sally. She didn’t want to live in a world without Sally. 

And so she had said it. 

Whispered it right into the still night air because she knew herself. 

She barely said that to anyone, had barely said it to Hank on their wedding night. But she felt compelled to say it now, something about the atmosphere pushing it out of her and making her feel safe. 

Somehow she knew Sally wasn’t going to say no. 

Somehow she knew that Sally loved her, too. 

She pressed another kiss to her shoulder, murmuring the words into her skin. And Sally’s eyes fluttered open as her hand reached behind her and gripped Cordelia’s wrist. 

She turned slowly, eyes wide. “What did you say?” 

“I said I love you, darling.” 

“You don’t mean that. You don’t want to love me.” Tears dropped against Sally’s will. 

“Yes, I do.” 

“Cordelia—“ 

Cordelia silenced her with a kiss. “Yes, I do.” 

And then Sally was in her arms, and they were kissing so fervently that Cordelia couldn’t be sure if the wet on her face was from Sally’s teeth or tongue or tears. 

They had nice, soft, sensual sex that night, coming over and over and over to the soundtrack of “I love you”s. 

And every time Cordelia let the phrase drop from her heart, Sally was right here, sucking it out of her mouth with a desperate “say it again.”

-everyone but a few servants would be dead but you’d almost never see them

-hella lavish life style

-if you ever want or need anything, Michael gets it for you (somehow)

-baby boi just needs a domestic life

-baths together are totally a thing

-i feel like this boi would give pretty dope ass massages 

-if you look stressed or tired he just pulls you over to give you a massage

-cuddling in bed all the time

-talking for hours and hours about everything

-playing with his hair

-slow dancing together

-there’s honestly not much to do in the compound

-except sex

-or like reading 

-but mostly sex

-trying on his clothing and walking around and he just loves it

-him planning stuff cuz now that its totally canon that he defeated all the witches and the world is still fucked, maybe he’d wanna fuck it up just a bit more because why not

-maybe watching copious amounts of TV

-somehow he finds you DVD’s of shows?!

-he’d do rituals a lot and you could join or just take care of him after

-being so grateful that he defeated the witches

-he likes watching you sleep and he pets your hair while you do

-yeah just good times with all the witches dead

Nora Montgomery:

- honestly? she’s not a fan

- too much sand everywhere

- will literally just sit on you to avoid it getting all over her

- also too many almost naked people

- or actually naked; she thinks it’s honestly disgusting

- much more conservative with her own body and wears a modest swimsuit

- even though she knows she’d look amazing in something a lot skimpier

- she doesn’t mind so much that you show off your body

- but she gets kinda wound up when people stare

- "they’re just jealous because you’re mine"

- with the HOTTEST smirk omg

- definitely prefers sunbathing to swimming

- (she won’t admit that she’s sort of scared of all the fish swimming around her ankles in the shallows)

- the sun makes her rlly sleepy

- and sometimes she’ll just fall asleep with her head on your tummy

- she might snore very quietly and softly

- and it’s the cutest

- sometimes you’ll tease her about it later

- she gets kinda embarrassed and it’s very cute

- but you know she’ll do it again next time

Sister Mary Eunice:

- she’d never been to the beach before you took her

- she didn’t live near one as a kid and her family didn’t have a lot of money

- so it’s still a new experience for her

- loves how happy everyone is there

- especially the kids playing games with their parents

- she thinks it’s really cute

- it even makes her feel a little jealous because she never had that... but then she feels bad for feeling that way

- besides, she’s got you now

- constantly tells you how pretty you look in your swimsuit

- she loves when you compliment her back because she still feels really self conscious in hers

- loves making sand castles with you

- she’s so careful

- and it always looks like a masterpiece

- so you’re both kinda sad when you have to leave it

- she likes swimming, but she’s not very good because she was never taught

- you had to teach her

- that was an experience

- it made her trust you so much

- honestly? she loves cuddling in the water because of how safe she feels with you

- or just whenever you have your hands on her, to be honest

Mary Eunice (possessed):

- doesn’t love it tbh

- she’ll tolerate it for you

- but she will complain

- you just have to laugh

- hates how many children there are

- and especially how loud they are

- wears next to nothing

- and you love it

- lots of PDA

- her hands are literally all over you

- loves it when you sit straddling her

- slipping her hand in your swimsuit? um yes

- does she care if anyone’s watching? definitely not

- she refuses to go swimming if you ask her

- but sometimes she’ll join you

- just to splash you and literally almost drown you

- sometimes she pulls you under the water

- and it really scares you even though it’s a joke

- but then she kisses you and she’s forgiven

- sharing drinks

- she usually finishes yours

- but you don’t mind

- and sex on the beach? hell yeah

Misty Day:

- loves the beach!!

- literally always asks when you can go back

- always packs a picnic to take

- it’s a nice thought but she brings so!! much!! food!!

- looks adorable in a cute lil bikini with her shawl over her shoulders to stop her getting burnt

- that was your idea

- she doesn’t really like suncream

- because it makes all the sand stick to her

- but she’ll put it on if you ask her

- a lot of the time you actually end up putting it on her

- she loves that

- you bring two towels but you only ever put one out

- because she always wants to be so close to you

- literally lies on top of you

- she can’t keep her hands to herself, either

- kisses you so much

- literally begs you to go swimming with her

- water fights!!

- she always apologises profusely (and so many times) if water even goes near your eyes

- she always brings a lil inflatable beach ball and you play catch together

- you have to blow it up

- Misty literally doesn’t have the breath

Masterlist

I had a sleepover with my main b, @lilyfiremaster53​, the other night and at 3 a.m. she helped me come up with some thoughts on a wild au for Apocalypse

Somehow someway you are one of the chosen people to survive

When you meet Wilhemina Venable, she intimidates you, but also intrigues you

You definitely have a crush on the woman

There’s not much going on in Outpost 3 considering it’s ya know the apocalypse

So you find an interesting way to fill your time

Writing

You practically beg Venable and Mead to let you have a notebook or journal and a pen to let you write

“Please, it’ll help me keep the ‘chaos on the inside’“

Giving you the journal was probably the worst decision Venable has ever made

At first the journal is used like a diary, but then you get bored with that because there’s nothing going on for you to write about

So then you turn to writing stories

These stories happen to be inspired by your real life

As in your real life, I mean the life of your fellow Outpost-mates

Writing a backstory of sorts for Venable

Your own Venable fanfiction

You fill up your first journal with the first part of your Venable fanficiton and beg Venable for another one

Of course you don’t let her know what the contents of your journal hold

You also write down almost everything you can remember about life as it once was

This includes vines, songs, poems, movie plots, and even what you can remember of the Constitution 

The vines and movie plot journals gets passed around the most between the other members of the Outpost

Venable does not understand why a group of you are gathered around your journal laughing over something called a “free shavacado”

You fill an entire journal of what you can remember of the Constitution, complete with the Amendments, preamble, and whatever you’ve somehow managed to pull out of your brain

After you finish it you bring it to Venable

“I would to instate the Constitution into our Outpost. We need a founding document. I have made some additions to adapt to our circumstances”

These additions include but are not limited to:

Movie night on Monday where people take turns reenacting movies from before the apocalypse. A one person show if you will

Tuesday is game night

Wednesday is crafts during the afternoon

Afternoon therapy circle on Thursday

Debate night after dinner on Friday. Each week there is a new topic that the group votes on the week before. (Venable is allowed one veto per week)

Karaoke being held after dinner on Saturday nights

Sunday is another therapy circle in the afternoon

Another addition is that once the cubes are cut in half they must be referred to as rectangular prisms

Venable doesn’t outright tell you no

But she does give you a look that says “are you fucking kidding me”

Ultimately she just says “I’ll consider it”

When she doesn’t give you a solid answer you go ahead with your plans anyways

Planning all of the events yourself

People generally go along with it because what else do they have to do

Your journals become quite the success among everyone too

You loan certain ones out to people

You always have to be careful that you don’t hand out your Venable one though

Venable has gotten to the point that as long as you’re not disturbing her, she’ll let you do whatever you want

She does find you endearing, but she’ll never admit it

You are the person keeping morale high in the Outpost

Without you, everyone would be bored to tears

-

Masterlist

I’m really sorry if this isn’t good! I really like the request so I hope this is alright!

anonymous said: HC’s for taking care of a jet lagged Audrey, please?

Picking her up from the airport and instantly knowing how she’s feeling from the expression on her face

Sometimes she’s ready to conquer the day when she gets in at 2 am and other times it’s noon and she could fall asleep standing up if you’d let her

Jet lag is something Audrey experiences a lot with her job, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t her her pretty hard sometimes

After coming back home from filming in some far off location, Audrey gets extremely tired

But she has to go right back to working in a couple of days so you have to do your best to help her get back on track

You help her relax as much as possible but try to keep from ruining her sleep schedule / internal clock even more

So this means sometimes you have to keep her awake when your darling would much rather sleep, cuddling you

“Come on baby. Stay awake for me”

Her scrunching her face and shaking her head

“Please” you say giving her puppy dog eyes “you can tell me about what your trip was like”

Giving her lots of kisses all over

Bribing her with her favorite foods she couldn’t get while she was away

Her being clingier than normal but you don’t mind

She also gets quite cranky when she has to stay awake

Audrey can occasionally be the equivalent of a toddler when she’s sleepy

Making her cups of tea just how she likes 

Unrelated, but Audrey doesn’t strike me as an energy drink drinker

After she can finally go to sleep, you hold her tight and wake her up in the morning with breakfast in bed

And even more kisses

“Darling, how did I get so lucky?”

“Says the woman who was pouting about me keeping you up yesterday.”

Sometimes trips have the opposite of sleepy Audrey which is overly energetic, restless Audrey

While keeping her awake calls for showers, getting the blonde to go to sleep calls for warm baths

Sometimes the two of you pull an all nighter together because Audrey refuses to sleep

Audrey has ideas on how to keep you awake with her

Some of them being her showing you how much she missed you

-

Thank you for these :) I’ll do a little bit of exploring for these lovely ladies

Also, I wrote so much for this that this is today’s post 😂 

3. - Are they open about their relationship? How do they feel about public displays of affection?

Fiona does not care what people think. They’re the type of couple that isn’t going to make a big deal that they’re together, but they’re not going to keep it a secret either.

With that being said, they don’t do a lot of big public displays of affection. Drunk Fiona wraps her arms around Mina more than usual in public. She also gets really close and will whisper in her ear. Sober PDA is more a hand placed on a shoulder or arm. Light kisses. Occasionally a handhold, but they don’t hold hands much in public. They’re both reserved people in public so this is also seen when it comes to their PDA. 

4. - First impression of each other? Was it love at first sight?

There was no love at first sight with these two. If anything, it was lust or intrigue at first sight. The thing that attracted them to each other was their confidence in a room full of idiots. They like how each other held themselves, not taking shit from anyone. This caused Fiona to ask Mina out because Mina does not seem like the one to make the first move.

16. - Do they keep secrets? Lie? Cheat?

Let’s get this clear. Fiona and Mina would never cheat on each other. They have way too much respect for each other to do it. Fiona might flirt with someone else to make Mina jealous (she loves how red the woman gets), but she would never cheat on her.

Keeping secrets and lying is something that Fiona has to work on. She finds herself lying about little things here and there such as where she was and things like that. Fiona doesn’t lie about anything too serious though. 

After Fiona dismissed why she was out late a few too many times (doing witchy things), Mina gets pissed about how Fiona is always keeping things from her. This is when Fiona finally tells her about her being a witch.

19. - What do they fight about? What are their arguments like? How do they make up?

These two bicker back and forth so much. Most of their arguments are over little things like who’s turn it is to make dinner or do the dishes. Serious arguments are when one of them is becoming self-conscious or hurt over something the other does (like Fiona not telling her something big happening within the Coven and instead she brushes it off like it’s nothing). Mina and Fiona have personalities where they retreat when they’re hurt. This is where their communication is sometimes lacking. Once the other realizes that this is why they are lashing out, the argument is quickly resolved with reaffirmations of love.

Side note, Mina and Fiona totally bicker all the time about Mina wanting Fiona to stop smoking.

23. - How do they hug? Kiss? Tease? Flirt? Comfort?

Fiona is taller Mina so Mina finds herself resting her chin on Fiona’s shoulder. Most hugs start with Fiona kisses Mina’s forehead first. They don’t hug much and especially not in public, but sometimes one of them is having an awful day and they just want to be close to each other. 

There are the occasional forehead and cheek kisses but not as often as kisses on the mouth. Pecks before one of them leaves the house. Fiery intense kisses when they’re alone. Loving tender kisses when things are gentler. (Kind of feel like these two would get into some pretty intense make-out sessions quite frequently).

Fiona loves to tease Mina, especially when she’s had a couple of drinks. Fiona just has this effect on Mina that gets her so flustered and at first Mina hates that Fiona can do this to her. Fiona smirks as she whispers dirty things into Mina’s ear and Mina is trying to keep her stoic facade.

Their way of flirting is so much smirking and sly remarks. I’m telling you, there’s a fire in their eyes. Wandering hands. Touches on the arm that last a little too long to be considered merely friendly.

Sometimes they don’t need to be too cuddly to be comforting each other. They could sit on the couch together, touching in some small way, and be comfortable. Other times more is necessary. Hugs and some cuddling. Fiona may not seem like a cuddler, but her and Mina definitely spoon. Fiona is the bigger spoon.

24. - Any doubts about the relationship?

Sometimes Mina doesn’t understand why Fiona in all her Supremely glory would want to be with her. Fiona doubts that’s able to be loved and love people in return sometimes because she feels like she has failed in all her past relationships (especially with her daughter). Mina and Fiona always reassure each other and push away these doubts though.

29. - How do the handle disasters or emergencies? Minor injuries? Sickness?

These two get angry when something happens. If someone does something to hurt one of them, the other is ready to murder them. They are very protective of each other.

This also applies to minor injuries and sickness. They take everything seriously, not letting the other brush them off even though they hate feeling weak. Making sure the other takes care of themself. Mina makes Fiona soup when she’s sick and Fiona orders soup when Mina is sick because Fiona can’t cook, but she wants to do anything she can to help her.

If you ask either of them if the above paragraph is true, they will deny everything. 

37. - How much would they be willing to sacrifice for the other? Any lines they refuse to cross?

These two would risk it all for the other. They would do this even before they realize they’re in love. Fiona realizes she’s fallen for Mina when she finds herself thinking that she would give up the Supremacy if it meant she could be with her lover forever. 

I’m picturing Fiona thinking about or staring at Mina while Myrtle and the Council chastise her for not doing something as Supreme and that they could punish her for whatever it is. Fiona finally snapping saying she doesn’t care and they can do whatever. Myrtle puts two and two together, realizing that Fiona’s only weakness is Mina. Fiona

On the other side, Mina expresses this in the way that she will fight anyone and everyone even though Fiona can kill whoever is bothering her with the flick of her wrist.

44. - Are they comfortable with each other? Anything they have to have their privacy for?

At the beginning of the relationship, Mina is self-conscious about her back and doesn’t want Fiona to see it. Even when Fiona stays the night she tries to hide this part of herself, making sure that the lights were dim to where maybe Fiona wouldn’t see her and little things like this. After the second or third night this happens, Fiona asks Mina what’s wrong and why she’s acting strange. This conversation ends with Fiona being hella gentle and loving and just expressing all of the love she has for Mina.

Fiona is very soft for Mina.

-